Y Cyfarfod Llawn

Plenary

25/10/2022

Yn y fersiwn ddwyieithog, mae’r golofn chwith yn cynnwys yr iaith a lefarwyd yn y cyfarfod. Mae’r golofn dde yn cynnwys cyfieithiad o’r areithiau hynny.

In the bilingual version, the left-hand column includes the language used during the meeting. The right-hand column includes a translation of those speeches.

Cyfarfu'r Senedd yn y Siambr a thrwy gynhadledd fideo am 13:30 gyda'r Llywydd (Elin Jones) yn y Gadair. 

The Senedd met in the Chamber and by video-conference at 13:30 with the Llywydd (Elin Jones) in the Chair.

1. Cwestiynau i'r Prif Weinidog
1. Questions to the First Minister

Prynhawn da, a dyma gychwyn ar ein cyfarfod ni y prynhawn yma. Yr eitem gyntaf y prynhawn yma yw'r cwestiynau i'r Prif Weinidog, ac mae'r cwestiwn cyntaf gan Sioned Williams.1

Good afternoon. We begin our meeting this afternoon. The first item this afternoon is questions to the First Minister, and the first question is from Sioned Williams. 

Tlodi Plant
Child Poverty

1. A wnaiff y Prif Weinidog ddatganiad am fesurau Llywodraeth Cymru i drechu tlodi plant yng Ngorllewin De Cymru? OQ58632

1. Will the First Minister make a statement on Welsh Government measures to tackle child poverty in South Wales West? OQ58632

Llywydd, diolch i Sioned Williams am y cwestiwn. Rydyn ni yng nghanol argyfwng tlodi, ac yn gwneud popeth y gallwn ni ar gyfer y rhai sydd fwyaf agored i niwed, gan gynnwys plant. Eleni, drwy raglenni sy’n amddiffyn cartrefi sydd dan anfantais, a chynlluniau sy’n rhoi arian nôl ym mhocedi pobl, rydyn ni wedi darparu gwerth £1.6 biliwn o gymorth.2

I thank Sioned Williams for the question. We are in the midst of a poverty crisis, and we are doing everything within our powers for those who are most vulnerable, including children. This year, through programmes that protect disadvantaged households, and schemes that put money back in people’s pockets, we have provided support worth £1.6 billion. 

Diolch, Brif Weinidog. The latest research by the Bevan Foundation revealed that the number of people in households with one or two children who are having to cut back on food has nearly doubled since this time last year, with one in 10 families with one child, and one in five families with two children cutting back on food for children. So, that staggering number of 6,300 children who've been recorded as living in poverty in my home county of Neath Port Talbot, in the region I represent, has surely risen even higher over past weeks as everyday costs have soared. And we know this poverty causes health inequalities in our communities, something that 114 members of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health have highlighted in their recent open letter to you, which warns that Wales lacks a focused and prominent strategy, setting specific targets to reduce child poverty and unequal health outcomes. Plaid Cymru have announced a people's plan which would make the pay packet go further, extend free school meals in secondary schools and increase education maintenance allowance. Brif Weinidog, will you heed the words of the Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health, and will you work with Plaid Cymru to protect Welsh children from poverty?3

Diolch, Prif Weinidog. Datgelodd y gwaith ymchwil diweddaraf gan Sefydliad Bevan bod nifer y bobl ar aelwydydd ag un neu ddau o blant sy'n gorfod lleihau faint o fwyd maen nhw'n eu bwyta bron wedi dyblu ers yr adeg yma y llynedd, gydag un o bob 10 teulu ag un plentyn, ac un o bob pum teulu â dau blentyn yn lleihau'r bwyd y maen nhw'n ei roi i'w plant. Felly, mae'r nifer syfrdanol yna o 6,300 o blant y cofnodwyd eu bod yn byw mewn tlodi yn fy sir enedigol, Castell-nedd Port Talbot, yn y rhanbarth rwy'n ei gynrychioli, wedi codi hyd yn oed yn uwch dros yr wythnosau diwethaf wrth i gostau bob dydd saethu i fyny. Ac rydym ni'n gwybod bod y tlodi hwn yn achosi anghydraddoldebau iechyd yn ein cymunedau, rhywbeth y mae 114 aelod o'r Coleg Brenhinol Pediatreg ac Iechyd Plant wedi tynnu sylw ato yn eu llythyr agored diweddar atoch chi, sy'n rhybuddio nad oes gan Gymru strategaeth wedi'i chanolbwyntio ac amlwg, sy'n pennu targedau penodol i leihau tlodi plant a chanlyniadau iechyd anghyfartal. Mae Plaid Cymru wedi cyhoeddi cynllun y bobl a fyddai'n gwneud i'r pecyn cyflog fynd ymhellach, yn ymestyn prydau ysgol am ddim mewn ysgolion uwchradd ac yn cynyddu'r lwfans cynhaliaeth addysg. Prif Weinidog, a wnewch chi wrando ar eiriau'r Coleg Brenhinol Pediatreg ac Iechyd Plant, ac a wnewch chi weithio gyda Phlaid Cymru i ddiogelu plant Cymru rhag tlodi?

Well, Llywydd, I thank Sioned Williams for some of those very important facts. I think I've reported previously to the Senedd that the Cabinet's cost-of-living committee is meeting weekly, and, at the start of each meeting, we are currently hearing from expert groups who are able to give us the most up-to-date information and ideas as to how we can do more to help people in Wales. The Cabinet committee met yesterday, and yesterday the expert evidence was indeed from the Bevan Foundation. The chief executive of the foundation went through a number of the points that Sioned Williams has raised this afternoon, and went through with us the things that the foundation believes are having a positive impact here in Wales, both the things that we have done jointly with Plaid Cymru in extending free school meals—and there are over 4,000 children additionally in the Member's region receiving a free school meal as a result of the work that we have done together—and looking at the impact of the help that we give with the cost of the school day, and with the discretionary assistance fund, with over 4,500 awards in the Member's region alone in September. All of those practical things that we are able to do, and it is the practicalities that this Government is focused on. There is work going on, led by my colleague Jane Hutt, on a child poverty strategy, but, for the moment, we are focused less on strategising than we are on identifying those practical actions that we can assist with that will help those families and those children through this winter.4

I'm very pleased, Llywydd, to see more local authorities setting out the ways in which they will use the discretionary fund that we've provided to them to help families through this winter, and I know that Sioned Williams will be pleased to see that, in Bridgend for example, in her region, the local authority has decided to use the money that they now have to provide families with £50 for every child in every family who is receiving free school meals, and £150 to all those families with children who are living in temporary accommodation. Where there are further ideas, and further things that we can work on together, then, of course, the Welsh Government will always be keen to explore ideas that are practical, and which, from a financial perspective, are within the bounds of the possible. 5

Wel, Llywydd, diolch i Sioned Williams am rai o'r ffeithiau pwysig iawn hynny. Rwy'n credu fy mod i wedi adrodd yn flaenorol i'r Senedd bod pwyllgor costau byw'r Cabinet yn cyfarfod yn wythnosol, ac, ar ddechrau pob cyfarfod, rydym ni'n clywed ar hyn o bryd gan grwpiau arbenigol sy'n gallu rhoi'r wybodaeth a'r syniadau diweddaraf i ni ynglŷn â sut y gallwn ni wneud mwy i helpu pobl yng Nghymru. Fe wnaeth pwyllgor y Cabinet gyfarfod ddoe, a ddoe roedd y dystiolaeth arbenigol yn wir gan Sefydliad Bevan. Aeth prif weithredwr y sefydliad drwy nifer o'r pwyntiau y mae Sioned Williams wedi eu codi y prynhawn yma, ac aeth drwy'r pethau y mae'r sefydliad yn credu sy'n cael effaith gadarnhaol yma yng Nghymru gyda ni, y pethau rydym ni wedi eu gwneud ar y cyd â Phlaid Cymru i ymestyn prydau ysgol am ddim—ac mae dros 4,000 o blant ychwanegol yn rhanbarth yr Aelod yn derbyn pryd ysgol am ddim o ganlyniad i'r gwaith rydym ni wedi ei wneud gyda'n gilydd—ac edrych ar effaith y cymorth rydym ni'n ei roi gyda chost y diwrnod ysgol, a gyda'r gronfa cymorth dewisol, gyda dros 4,500 o ddyfarniadau yn rhanbarth yr Aelod yn unig ym mis Medi. Yr holl bethau ymarferol hynny yr ydym ni'n gallu eu gwneud, a'r agweddau ymarferol y mae'r Llywodraeth hon yn canolbwyntio arnyn nhw. Mae gwaith yn cael ei wneud, dan arweiniad fy nghyd-Weinidog Jane Hutt, ar strategaeth tlodi plant ond, ar hyn o bryd, rydym ni'n canolbwyntio llai ar strategeiddio nag yr ydym ni ar nodi'r camau ymarferol hynny y gallwn ni gynorthwyo â nhw a fydd yn helpu'r teuluoedd hynny a'r plant hynny drwy'r gaeaf hwn.

Rwy'n falch iawn, Llywydd, o weld mwy o awdurdodau lleol yn nodi'r ffyrdd y byddan nhw'n defnyddio'r gronfa ddewisol yr ydym ni wedi ei darparu iddyn nhw i helpu teuluoedd drwy'r gaeaf hwn, a gwn y bydd Sioned Williams yn falch o weld, ym Mhen-y-bont ar Ogwr, er enghraifft, yn ei rhanbarth hi, bod yr awdurdod lleol wedi penderfynu defnyddio'r arian sydd ganddyn nhw nawr i ddarparu £50 i deuluoedd ar gyfer pob plentyn ym mhob teulu sy'n derbyn prydau ysgol am ddim, a £150 i'r holl deuluoedd hynny sydd â phlant sy'n byw mewn llety dros dro. Lle mae syniadau pellach, a phethau pellach y gallwn ni weithio arnyn nhw gyda'n gilydd, yna, wrth gwrs, bydd Llywodraeth Cymru bob amser yn awyddus i ymchwilio i syniadau sy'n ymarferol, ac sydd, o safbwynt ariannol, o fewn ffiniau'r posibl. 

First Minister, you'll be aware of the recent report by Loughborough University that showed that, in 2020-21, child poverty across the UK went down by 4 per cent, but, in Wales, it had gone up by 5 per cent. So, can you tell us, First Minister, why the statistics are telling us that your Welsh Labour Government is failing to tackle child poverty?6

Prif Weinidog, byddwch yn ymwybodol o'r adroddiad diweddar gan Brifysgol Loughborough a ddangosodd bod tlodi plant ledled y DU, yn 2020-21, wedi gostwng 4 y cant, ond, yng Nghymru, roedd wedi cynyddu 5 y cant. Felly, a allwch chi ddweud wrthym ni, Prif Weinidog, pam mae'r ystadegau yn dweud wrthym ni fod eich Llywodraeth Lafur Cymru yn methu â mynd i'r afael â thlodi plant?

13:35

Llywydd, the figures show no such thing. What the figures demonstrate is the impact of cuts to benefits by the UK Government. And if you live in a part of the country where more families depend upon benefits, then the cuts to those benefits, of course, have a greater effect. Let me tell him what the latest research is saying to us about the actions of his Government. The Resolution Foundation finds that if benefits are not raised in line with inflation, then a further 300,000 children across the United Kingdom will find themselves in absolute poverty. I think this is probably the fourth week in a row in which I've invited the Welsh Conservatives to say that they believe that benefits should be uprated—[Interruption.] Well, if you said it last week, then I'm very glad—[Interruption.] If you said it last week, I'm very glad indeed to acknowledge it, because I think the more that we can speak together on that matter, the more influence that we will have. And given that, as a party, you have a direct ability to influence a Conservative Government at Westminster to know that you too believe that benefits should be uprated in line with inflation, that would be good news for those poor families in Wales. Even if benefits are uprated in line with inflation, then the Resolution Foundation says that child poverty across the United Kingdom will rise to 34 per cent—the highest for over 20 years. And for people reliant on basic out-of-work support, the real value of that support will be lower than it was at the time when Mrs Thatcher was Prime Minister. That's why you see the figures that you quote—because of the impact of the last 12 years on the incomes of the very poorest families across Wales and the United Kingdom.7

Llywydd, nid yw'r ffigyrau'n dangos y fath beth. Yr hyn mae'r ffigyrau'n ei ddangos yw effaith toriadau i fudd-daliadau gan Lywodraeth y DU. Ac os ydych chi'n byw mewn rhan o'r wlad lle mae mwy o deuluoedd yn dibynnu ar fudd-daliadau, yna mae'r toriadau i'r budd-daliadau hynny, wrth gwrs, yn cael mwy o effaith. Gadewch i mi ddweud wrtho beth mae'r gwaith ymchwil ddiweddaraf yn ei ddweud wrthym ni am weithredoedd ei Lywodraeth. Mae'r Resolution Foundation yn canfod, os nad yw budd-daliadau'n cael eu codi yn unol â chwyddiant, yna bydd 300,000 o blant eraill ar draws y Deyrnas Unedig yn canfod eu hunain mewn tlodi llwyr. Mae'n debyg mai dyma'r bedwaredd wythnos yn olynol yr wyf i wedi gwahodd y Ceidwadwyr Cymreig i ddweud eu bod nhw'n credu y dylid cynyddu budd-daliadau—[Torri ar draws.] Wel, os gwnaethoch chi ddweud hynny wythnos diwethaf, yna rwy'n falch iawn—[Torri ar draws.] Os gwnaethoch chi ei ddweud yr wythnos diwethaf, rwy'n falch dros ben o'i gydnabod, oherwydd rwy'n meddwl po fwyaf y gallwn ni siarad gyda'n gilydd ar y mater hwnnw, y mwyaf o ddylanwad fydd gennym ni. Ac o ystyried hynny, fel plaid, mae gennych chi allu uniongyrchol i ddylanwadu ar Lywodraeth Geidwadol yn San Steffan i wybod eich bod chithau hefyd yn credu y dylid cynyddu budd-daliadau yn unol â chwyddiant, byddai hynny'n newyddion da i'r teuluoedd tlawd hynny yng Nghymru. Hyd yn oed os yw budd-daliadau'n cael eu cynyddu yn unol â chwyddiant, yna mae'r Resolution Foundation yn dweud y bydd tlodi plant ar draws y Deyrnas Unedig yn codi i 34 y cant—yr uchaf ers dros 20 mlynedd. Ac i bobl sy'n ddibynnol ar gymorth di-waith sylfaenol, bydd gwir werth y cymorth hwnnw yn is nag yr oedd ar yr adeg pan oedd Mrs Thatcher yn Brif Weinidog y DU. Dyna pam rydych chi'n gweld y ffigurau rydych chi'n eu dyfynnu—oherwydd effaith y 12 mlynedd diwethaf ar incwm y teuluoedd tlotaf ar draws Cymru a'r Deyrnas Unedig.

Many children are living in poverty not caused by parental indolence or wastefulness; many parents are working two or three jobs, but at minimum wage, on irregular hours. The expansion of free school meals to a universal provision of meals is very welcome. What further help can the Welsh Government give to support foodbanks, and will the Welsh Government make representation to end the fixed charge by energy companies, which means people are paying for energy on days they do not use any? This is the cruellest charge you've got—you don't use any energy for five days, and you then heat a bowl of soup, which costs you somewhere around £2.50 or £3.00.8

Mae llawer o blant yn byw mewn tlodi nad yw wedi'i achosi gan ddiogi neu afradlondeb rhieni; mae llawer o rieni yn gweithio dwy neu dair swydd, ond am isafswm cyflog, ar oriau afreolaidd. Mae ehangu prydau ysgol am ddim i ddarpariaeth gyffredinol o brydau bwyd i'w groesawu'n fawr. Pa gymorth pellach all Llywodraeth Cymru ei roi i gynorthwyo banciau bwyd, ac a fydd Llywodraeth Cymru yn gwneud dadl i roi terfyn ar y tâl sefydlog gan gwmnïau ynni, sy'n golygu bod pobl yn talu am ynni ar ddiwrnodau nad ydyn nhw'n defnyddio unrhyw ynni? Dyma'r tâl mwyaf creulon sydd gennych chi—dydych chi ddim yn defnyddio unrhyw ynni am bum diwrnod, ac yna rydych chi'n cynhesu powlen o gawl, sy'n costio tua £2.50 neu £3.00 i chi.

Mike Hedges makes some really important points, Llywydd. I think it's one of the most pernicious myths of poverty that poverty is somehow caused by the people who are in poverty. I've never met people who could manage money better than those people who have the least of all to manage by—they have to. And the idea that it's parental indolence or neglect is absolutely to be rejected. The Welsh Government announced a further £1 million to support anti-poverty work at community level in Wales only a couple of weeks ago. That comes now to £5 million in this financial year. And much of that goes directly to foodbanks, who now find that the donations that they were able to rely on previously are drying up as families even further up the income level are unable to manage the impact of energy price and food inflation. Sioned Williams drew attention to the work of the Bevan Foundation, Llywydd, and she will now that, in that work, it isn't just families who are on the very lowest incomes who report that they cannot now afford the basics; it's families further up the income range as well, as people find that the things that they've made commitments to while they were in better times are now beyond their reach.9

And the point that Mike Hedges makes about standing charges and pre-payment meters, Llywydd, is, I think, one of the great injustices of our time. I raised this directly with UK Ministers at the British-Irish Council when it met in July, and I wrote immediately afterwards to the UK Government Minister who attended, asking him to take action at a UK level to cancel standing charges for people who rely on pre-payment meters. There can be nothing worse, Llywydd, can there, than to find, having not had access to energy for many days and scraping the money together to be able to charge the pre-payment meter again, that the money you've put into it is nothing like the money that you have found because it has already been taken away from you? In many cases, you will have been put on a pre-payment meter because of debt. There are 60,000 new pre-payment meter customers in the United Kingdom so far this year. Their meters are calibrated so that the first thing they have to do is pay back the money they owe. Then they find that, in all the days where they had no electricity at all, they have to pay a standing charge for a time when they weren't able to access the service. Imagine how galling that must be. The point that Mike Hedges makes about the action that could be taken, at very little cost, I believe, to the Government or to the companies, to put that injustice right is a really important call we've heard this afternoon.
 
 10

Mae Mike Hedges yn gwneud rhai pwyntiau pwysig iawn, Llywydd. Rwy'n meddwl mai un o gelwyddau mwyaf niweidiol tlodi yw bod tlodi yn cael ei achosi rywsut gan y bobl sydd mewn tlodi. Nid wyf i erioed wedi cwrdd â phobl a allai reoli arian yn well na'r bobl hynny sydd â'r lleiaf i ymdopi ag ef—mae'n rhaid iddyn nhw. Ac mae'r syniad mai diogi neu afradlondeb rhieni sy'n gyfrifol i'w wrthod yn llwyr. Cyhoeddodd Llywodraeth Cymru £1 miliwn arall i gynorthwyo gwaith gwrth-dlodi ar lefel gymunedol yng Nghymru dim ond wythnos neu ddwy yn ôl. Mae hynny bellach yn £5 miliwn yn y flwyddyn ariannol hon. Ac mae llawer o hynny'n mynd yn uniongyrchol i fanciau bwyd, sydd bellach yn gweld bod y rhoddion yr oedden nhw'n gallu dibynnu arnyn nhw cynt yn lleihau wrth i deuluoedd hyd yn oed ymhellach i fyny'r lefel incwm fethu â rheoli effaith prisiau ynni a chwyddiant bwyd. Tynnodd Sioned Williams sylw at waith Sefydliad Bevan, Llywydd, a bydd yn gwybod nawr, yn y gwaith hwnnw, nad teuluoedd sydd ar yr incwm isaf oll yn unig sy'n dweud na allan nhw fforddio'r pethau sylfaenol erbyn hyn; mae teuluoedd ymhellach i fyny'r raddfa incwm yn dweud hynny hefyd, wrth i bobl ganfod bod y pethau y maen nhw wedi gwneud ymrwymiadau iddyn nhw pan oedden nhw mewn cyfnod gwell bellach y tu hwnt i'w cyrraedd.

Ac mae'r pwynt y mae Mike Hedges yn ei wneud am daliadau sefydlog a'r mesuryddion talu ymlaen llaw, Llywydd, yn fy marn i, yn un o anghyfiawnderau mawr ein hoes. Codais hyn yn uniongyrchol gyda Gweinidogion y DU yng Nghyngor Prydain-Iwerddon pan gyfarfu ym mis Gorffennaf, ac ysgrifennais yn syth wedyn at Weinidog Llywodraeth y DU a oedd yn bresennol, gan ofyn iddo weithredu ar lefel y DU i ganslo taliadau sefydlog i bobl sy'n dibynnu ar fesuryddion talu ymlaen llaw. Ni all fod dim gwaeth, Llywydd, a all yna, na chanfod, ar ôl methu â chael mynediad at ynni ers llawer o ddiwrnodau a chrafu'r arian at ei gilydd er mwyn gallu llenwi'r mesurydd talu ymlaen llaw eto, nad yw'r arian rydych chi wedi ei roi ynddo yn ddim byd tebyg i'r arian yr ydych chi wedi ei ganfod gan ei fod eisoes wedi cael ei gymryd oddi arnoch? Mewn llawer o achosion, byddwch wedi cael eich rhoi ar fesurydd talu ymlaen llaw oherwydd dyled. Mae 60,000 o gwsmeriaid mesuryddion talu ymlaen llaw newydd yn y Deyrnas Unedig hyd yma eleni. Mae eu mesuryddion yn cael eu graddnodi fel mai'r peth cyntaf y mae'n rhaid iddyn nhw ei wneud yw talu'r arian sy'n ddyledus ganddyn nhw yn ôl. Wedyn maen nhw'n canfod, yn yr holl ddiwrnodau pan nad oedd ganddyn nhw unrhyw drydan o gwbl, bod yn rhaid iddyn nhw dalu tâl sefydlog am gyfnod pan nad oedden nhw'n gallu cael mynediad at y gwasanaeth. Dychmygwch faint y mae'n rhaid bod hynny'n brifo. Mae'r pwynt y mae Mike Hedges yn ei wneud am y camau y gellid eu cymryd, am gost isel iawn, rwy'n credu, i'r Llywodraeth neu i'r cwmnïau, i unioni'r anghyfiawnder hwnnw yn alwad hynod bwysig rydym ni wedi ei chlywed y prynhawn yma.
 
 

13:40
Twf Economaidd
Economic Growth

2. A wnaiff y Prif Weinidog nodi strategaeth Llywodraeth Cymru ar gyfer twf economaidd? OQ58597

2. Will the First Minister set out the Welsh Government’s strategy for economic growth? OQ58597

Llywydd, good afternoon to Dr Hussain. The Welsh Government strategy is diametrically different to the disastrous approach of the latest Conservative Government. Alongside and in partnership with businesses, we invest in the physical infrastructure that promotes investment and the human capital that improves productivity.11

Llywydd, prynhawn da i Dr Hussain. Mae strategaeth Llywodraeth Cymru yn gwbl groes i ddull trychinebus y Llywodraeth Geidwadol ddiweddaraf. Ochr yn ochr â busnesau ac mewn partneriaeth â nhw, rydym ni'n buddsoddi yn y seilwaith ffisegol sy'n hyrwyddo buddsoddiad a'r cyfalaf dynol sy'n gwella cynhyrchiant.

In March last year, your Government published its 'Wales Infrastructure Investment Plan—Project Pipeline', setting out a range of investments in communities in Wales, including those which local authorities had committed to. Whilst I welcome the attempt to capture these activities, it is clear that there is a range of major challenges now facing the south of the country that are not being addressed, not least the continued M4 congestion at the Brynglas tunnels in Newport. CBI Wales has long argued for this to be tackled for our prosperity and employment in south and west Wales. This week also marks the Road Haulage Association's National Lorry Week, which they launched in my region yesterday. Hauliers told me at the launch that hold-ups around Newport often push drivers over their allotted hours and that the lack of lorry parks was also taking a toll. First Minister, in the absence of doing the right thing and building a relief road, what alternative solutions do you now have up your sleeve to unblock this vital link into Wales and improve the situation for Wales's road hauliers? Thank you.12

Ym mis Mawrth y llynedd, cyhoeddodd eich Llywodraeth ei 'Chynllun Buddsoddi yn Seilwaith Cymru—Llif Prosiectau', yn cyflwyno amrywiaeth o fuddsoddiadau mewn cymunedau yng Nghymru, gan gynnwys y rhai yr oedd awdurdodau lleol wedi ymrwymo iddyn nhw. Er fy mod i'n croesawu'r ymgais i nodi'r gweithgareddau hyn, mae'n amlwg bod amrywiaeth o heriau mawr bellach yn wynebu de'r wlad nad ydyn nhw'n cael sylw, ac nid lleiaf y tagfeydd parhaus ar yr M4 yn nhwneli Brynglas yng Nghasnewydd. Mae CBI Cymru wedi dadlau ers amser maith dros roi sylw i hyn er budd ein ffyniant a'n cyflogaeth yn ne a gorllewin Cymru. Yr wythnos hon hefyd yw Wythnos Genedlaethol Lorïau y Gymdeithas Cludo ar y Ffyrdd, a lansiwyd ganddyn nhw yn fy rhanbarth i ddoe. Dywedodd cludwyr ar y ffyrdd wrthyf i yn y lansiad bod oedi o amgylch Casnewydd yn aml yn gwthio gyrwyr dros eu horiau penodedig a bod y diffyg parciau lorïau hefyd yn cael effaith. Prif Weinidog, yn absenoldeb gwneud y peth iawn ac adeiladu ffordd liniaru, pa atebion amgen sydd gennych chi ar y gweill i ddatgloi'r cysylltiad hanfodol hwn i Gymru a gwella'r sefyllfa i gludwyr ar y ffyrdd Cymru? Diolch.

Llywydd, I don't plan to relitigate an issue that has long been settled here in Wales. The Conservative Party put their case to the people in Wales at the last Senedd election. The building of the M4 relief road was a prominent promise that the Welsh Conservative Party made, and your party failed to win a single seat—a single seat—along the whole length of the M4 in south Wales. So, if you believe that your case is a sound one, you can continue to put it to people in Wales, and you'll continue to get the same answer.13

What we are doing is we are pressing ahead with the proposals of the Burns commission—a series of practical actions that can be taken to address congestion at the M4. We will complete the dualling of the Heads of the Valleys road, which will mean that heavy traffic coming from the midlands will be able to go directly to south-west Wales without having to come down and pass through Newport. There is, as I've said before, Llywydd, a major challenge now facing the UK Government. The Johnson Government launched the UK connectivity review. We put evidence to the Sir Peter Hendy review—I don't believe the Welsh Conservatives did—and we promoted there the investment that is needed to improve the second railway line, the second main line, down from south Wales, in order to be able to draw traffic away from the M4 and so that people have better public transport alternatives. The Hendy review endorsed the case that we have made, and, to be fair, the UK Government has provided a small amount of money to develop the ideas that the Hendy review endorsed. Now there will be a major decision. Shall we see whether the latest UK Prime Minister will take up the promises that were made in the UK connectivity review and demonstrate that they are prepared to invest in Wales, so that some of the issues that Dr Hussain has mentioned can be properly addressed? 14

Llywydd, nid wyf yn bwriadu ail-fyw mater sydd wedi ei hen setlo yma yng Nghymru. Fe wnaeth y Blaid Geidwadol gyflwyno eu hachos i'r bobl yng Nghymru yn etholiad diwethaf y Senedd. Roedd adeiladu ffordd liniaru'r M4 yn addewid blaenllaw a wnaeth Plaid Geidwadol Cymru, a methodd eich plaid ag ennill yr un sedd—yr un sedd—ar hyd yr M4 gyfan yn ne Cymru. Felly, os ydych chi'n credu bod eich dadl yn un gadarn, gallwch chi barhau i'w chyflwyno i bobl yng Nghymru, a byddwch yn parhau i gael yr un ateb.

Yr hyn rydym ni'n ei wneud yw bwrw ymlaen â chynigion comisiwn Burns—cyfres o gamau ymarferol y gellir eu cymryd i fynd i'r afael â thagfeydd wrth yr M4. Byddwn yn cwblhau'r gwaith o ddeuoli ffordd Blaenau'r Cymoedd, fydd yn golygu y bydd traffig trwm sy'n dod o ganolbarth Lloegr yn gallu mynd yn uniongyrchol i dde-orllewin Cymru heb orfod dod i lawr a mynd trwy Gasnewydd. Fel yr wyf i wedi ei ddweud o'r blaen, Llywydd, ceir her fawr sy'n wynebu Llywodraeth y DU nawr. Lansiodd Llywodraeth Johnson adolygiad cysylltedd y DU. Fe wnaethon ni roi tystiolaeth i adolygiad Syr Peter Hendy—nid wyf i'n credu bod y Ceidwadwyr Cymreig wedi gwneud hynny—ac fe wnaethon ni hyrwyddo yno'r buddsoddiad sydd ei angen i wella'r ail reilffordd, yr ail brif linell, i lawr o dde Cymru, er mwyn gallu tynnu traffig oddi wrth yr M4 ac fel bod gan bobl well dewisiadau trafnidiaeth gyhoeddus amgen. Fe wnaeth adolygiad Hendy gymeradwyo'r ddadl yr ydym ni wedi ei gwneud, ac, i fod yn deg, mae Llywodraeth y DU wedi darparu swm bach o arian i ddatblygu'r syniadau a gymeradwywyd gan adolygiad Hendy. Nawr fe fydd penderfyniad mawr. Fe gawn ni weld a fydd Prif Weinidog diweddaraf y DU yn bwrw ymlaen â'r addewidion a wnaed yn adolygiad cysylltedd y DU a dangos eu bod nhw'n barod i fuddsoddi yng Nghymru, fel y gellir mynd i'r afael yn briodol â rhai o'r materion y mae Dr Hussain wedi'u crybwyll.

13:45

I'm sure that the First Minister meant to say 'a single constituency seat along the M4'. 15

Rwy'n siŵr bod y Prif Weinidog yn bwriadu dweud 'yr un sedd etholaeth ar hyd yr M4'. 

You said 'single seat'. 17

Fe ddywedoch chi 'yr un sedd'. 

A single constituency seat—I beg your pardon. 18

Yr un sedd etholaeth—mae'n ddrwg gen i. 

Diolch, Llywydd. I'm afraid that efforts to promote growth have been fatally undermined by what the Tories have done to our economy, and I'm concerned about the prospect of job losses and the damage that that will mean not only to our economy, but to people's lives. Businesses across my region are under pressure with rising energy bills and inflation. The Federation of Small Businesses' small business index recently found that business confidence has plummeted, as they face rising costs and decreasing revenue, and public sector employees also face the prospect of a new wave of hyper austerity, with council leaders and Ministers warning that the financial situation is serious. So will you assure the Senedd, Prif Weinidog, that you'll do everything you can to protect jobs in Wales over the coming period, and explain what discussions you'll be having with representatives of businesses and public services to try to avoid job losses? 20

Diolch, Llywydd. Rwy'n ofni bod ymdrechion i hybu twf wedi cael eu tanseilio'n angheuol gan yr hyn mae'r Torïaid wedi ei wneud i'n heconomi, ac rwy'n pryderu am y posibilrwydd o golli swyddi a'r niwed y bydd hynny'n ei olygu nid yn unig i'n heconomi, ond i fywydau pobl. Mae busnesau ar draws fy rhanbarth dan bwysau gyda biliau ynni cynyddol a chwyddiant. Canfu mynegai busnesau bach Ffederasiwn y Busnesau Bach yn ddiweddar bod hyder busnesau wedi plymio, wrth iddyn nhw wynebu costau cynyddol a refeniw gostyngol, ac mae cyflogeion sector cyhoeddus hefyd yn wynebu'r posibilrwydd o don newydd o hyper-gyni, gydag arweinwyr cynghorau a Gweinidogion yn rhybuddio bod y sefyllfa ariannol yn ddifrifol. Felly a wnewch chi sicrhau'r Senedd, Prif Weinidog, y byddwch chi'n gwneud popeth o fewn eich gallu i ddiogelu swyddi yng Nghymru dros y cyfnod sydd i ddod, ac egluro pa drafodaethau y byddwch chi'n eu cael gyda chynrychiolwyr busnesau a gwasanaethau cyhoeddus i geisio osgoi colli swyddi?

I thank Delyth Jewell for that question, Llywydd, because she is right: on any reasonable reading of the current prospectus, job losses are coming to Wales and to the United Kingdom. I think I said on the floor of the Senedd in the last couple of weeks that, if we were to see cuts in public expenditure of the eye-watering variety promised by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, then that will result in hundreds, if not thousands, of jobs being lost in public services in Wales. It is absolutely unavoidable. Somewhere around 50 per cent to 56 per cent of all the money spent in public services in Wales is spent on people; employing people to do the jobs that other people then rely on. If there are to be cuts in those budgets, then those jobs will be lost. It's simply unavoidable, and it will be a direct consequence of having to deal with the catastrophic results of the briefest Prime Minister in UK history.21

Again, Delyth Jewell is right to point to the fact that those pressures appear in the private sector as well as in the public sector. The Bank of England says that the UK economy is already in recession and it will raise interest rates again in November despite the fact that, in any other circumstances, it will be cutting interest rates in order to support a shrinking economy, and that will put great pressure on employment in the private sector as well.22

The Welsh Government, of course, works with our colleagues in local authorities and in the NHS to minimise, as best we can, whatever impact there will be from the statement on 31 October. And we work with our major employers as well, many of whom have plans to expand employment here in Wales, because of the approach that the Welsh Government takes to these matters. They understand that we are partners with them, in the business of helping them. Think, Llywydd, for a moment, of the Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre Cymru in north Wales, built with £20 million of Welsh Government money, and the reason why the Wing of Tomorrow is being built by Airbus in north Wales; the reason why, with the food and drink sector in north Wales, we now have the Factory of the Future project based in the AMRC—because we understand, in a way that the Tories never do, that public investment used properly crowds in private investment, and doesn't crowd it out, and that it is a responsibility of Government to invest in the skills of a workforce that brings employment to Wales in the future. That's the story of Airbus; that's the story of the cyber security cluster in south Wales. They are examples of the way in which a sensible approach to economic growth can make things happen, just as we have seen what a disastrous approach to economic growth can do to the future prospects of the country.23

Diolch i Delyth Jewell am y cwestiwn yna, Llywydd, oherwydd mae'n iawn: ar unrhyw ddarlleniad rhesymol o'r prosbectws presennol, mae colledion swyddi yn dod i Gymru ac i'r Deyrnas Unedig. Rwy'n credu i mi ddweud ar lawr y Senedd yn yr wythnos neu ddwy ddiwethaf, pe baem ni'n gweld toriadau i wariant cyhoeddus o'r math sy'n tynnu dŵr i'r llygaid a addawyd gan Ganghellor y Trysorlys, yna bydd hynny'n arwain at golli cannoedd, os nad miloedd, o swyddi mewn gwasanaethau cyhoeddus yng Nghymru. Mae'n gwbl anochel. Mae tua 50 y cant i 56 y cant o'r holl arian sy'n cael ei wario yn y gwasanaethau cyhoeddus yng Nghymru yn cael ei wario ar bobl; cyflogi pobl i wneud y swyddi y mae pobl eraill wedyn yn dibynnu arnyn nhw. Os bydd toriadau i'r cyllidebau hynny, yna bydd y swyddi hynny'n cael eu colli. Mae'n gwbl anochel, a bydd yn ganlyniad uniongyrchol o orfod ymdrin â chanlyniadau trychinebus y Prif Weinidog mwyaf byrhoedlog yn hanes y DU.

Eto, mae Delyth Jewell yn iawn i gyfeirio at y ffaith bod y pwysau hynny'n ymddangos yn y sector preifat yn ogystal ag yn y sector cyhoeddus. Mae Banc Lloegr yn dweud bod economi'r DU eisoes mewn dirwasgiad a bydd yn codi cyfraddau llog eto ym mis Tachwedd er gwaethaf y ffaith y bydd, o dan unrhyw amgylchiadau eraill, yn torri cyfraddau llog er mwyn cefnogi economi sy'n crebachu, a bydd hynny'n rhoi pwysau mawr ar gyflogaeth yn y sector preifat hefyd.

Wrth gwrs, mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn gweithio gyda'n cydweithwyr mewn awdurdodau lleol ac yn y GIG i sicrhau, y gorau gallwn ni, bod pa bynnag effaith a ddaw o'r datganiad ar 31 Hydref cyn lleied â phosibl. Ac rydym ni'n gweithio gyda'n cyflogwyr mawr hefyd, y mae gan lawer ohonyn nhw gynlluniau i ehangu cyflogaeth yma yng Nghymru, oherwydd yr agwedd y mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn ei chymryd i'r materion hyn. Maen nhw'n deall ein bod ni'n bartneriaid gyda nhw, yn y busnes o'u helpu. Meddyliwch, Llywydd, am eiliad, am Ganolfan Ymchwil Gweithgynhyrchu Uwch Cymru yn y gogledd, a adeiladwyd gyda £20 miliwn o arian Llywodraeth Cymru, a'r rheswm pam mae Wing of Tomorrow yn cael ei adeiladu gan Airbus yn y gogledd; y rheswm pam, gyda'r sector bwyd a diod yn y gogledd, mae gennym ni brosiect Ffatri'r Dyfodol wedi'i leoli yn yr AMRC—oherwydd ein bod ni'n deall, mewn ffordd nad yw'r Torïaid byth yn ei ddeall, fod buddsoddiad cyhoeddus sy'n cael ei ddefnyddio'n briodol yn denu buddsoddiad preifat, ac ddim yn ei gau allan, a'i bod yn gyfrifoldeb ar Lywodraeth i fuddsoddi mewn sgiliau gweithlu sy'n dod â chyflogaeth i Gymru yn y dyfodol. Dyna hanes Airbus; dyna hanes y clwstwr seiberddiogelwch yn y de. Maen nhw'n enghreifftiau o'r ffordd y gall agwedd synhwyrol at dwf economaidd wneud i bethau ddigwydd, yn union fel rydym ni wedi gweld beth all agwedd drychinebus tuag at dwf economaidd ei wneud i ragolygon y wlad ar gyfer y dyfodol.

13:50

Of course, the last time we met, First Minister, the Tories were telling us that Liz Truss was the best Prime Minister that we've ever had and that Conservative economic policy was unchallengeable. We've seen some change in that in the last few days. But, what we haven't seen, of course, is any change in the reality of Tory economic incompetence, which means that Wales doesn't get the investment that should come to us. The people of Blaenau Gwent want to see investment in the Ebbw valley line, but they don't get it because rail isn't devolved and the Tories will not invest in Wales.24

First Minister, do you agree with me that what we need to see is not only a change of Government, but we need to see a change in attitude from the UK Treasury that means that countries like Wales and Scotland, and the north of England, get the same priority and investment as London and the south-east of England?25

Wrth gwrs, y tro diwethaf i ni gyfarfod, Prif Weinidog, roedd y Torïaid yn dweud wrthym ni mai Liz Truss oedd y Prif Weinidog gorau i ni ei gael erioed ac nad oedd hi'n bosibl herio polisi economaidd y Ceidwadwyr. Rydym ni wedi gweld rhywfaint o newid i hynny yn ystod y dyddiau diwethaf. Ond, yr hyn nad ydym wedi ei weld, wrth gwrs, yw unrhyw newid yn realiti anallu economaidd y Torïaid, sy'n golygu nad yw Cymru'n cael y buddsoddiad a ddylai ddod i ni. Mae pobl Blaenau Gwent eisiau gweld buddsoddiad yn rheilffordd Glynebwy, ond dydyn nhw ddim yn ei gael gan nad yw'r rheilffyrdd wedi'u datganoli, ac ni wnaiff y Torïaid fuddsoddi yng Nghymru.

Prif Weinidog, a ydych chi'n cytuno â mi mai'r hyn sydd angen i ni ei weld yw nid yn unig newid Llywodraeth, ond mae angen i ni weld newid agwedd gan Drysorlys y DU sy'n golygu bod gwledydd fel Cymru a'r Alban, a gogledd Lloegr, yn cael yr un flaenoriaeth a buddsoddiad â Llundain a de-ddwyrain Lloegr?

Well, Llywydd, of course I agree with Alun Davies that what this country needs is a general election—an opportunity for all parties to make their case to people and for the people to decide how they believe the crisis that we face should best be tackled. That general election is a democratic necessity, but it's also an economic necessity because you need a Government with a mandate and with the stability to take the difficult decisions that undoubtedly are there to be made. If we had that opportunity, I believe not only would Wales be better off, but the United Kingdom, of course, would be better off as well.26

As to the point that the Member has made about the Treasury, I'm afraid I've long believed that the Treasury, driven by the Barnett formula, is essentially a Treasury for England, and that other parts of the United Kingdom simply get the consequences of decisions that are made in that way. We need a Treasury that is prepared to make the decisions that recognise the different needs of the United Kingdom and is prepared to invest in that way. Let's give one example of just how differently things are thought of in London and by the Conservative party: the now-discredited package of tax cuts made by Liz Truss would have resulted in three times—[Interruption.]27

Wel, Llywydd, wrth gwrs rwy'n cytuno ag Alun Davies mai'r hyn sydd ei angen ar y wlad hon yw etholiad cyffredinol—cyfle i bob plaid wneud eu dadleuon i bobl ac i'r bobl benderfynu beth maen nhw'n ei gredu yw'r ffordd orau o fynd i'r afael â'r argyfwng sy'n ein hwynebu. Mae'r etholiad cyffredinol hwnnw'n anghenraid democrataidd, ond mae hefyd yn anghenraid economaidd oherwydd mae angen Llywodraeth arnoch chi sydd â mandad ac â'r sefydlogrwydd i wneud y penderfyniadau anodd sydd yn ddiamheuaeth yno i'w gwneud. Pe bai gennym ni'r cyfle hwnnw, rwy'n credu nid yn unig y byddai Cymru ar ei hennill, ond byddai'r Deyrnas Unedig, wrth gwrs, ar ei hennill hefyd.

O ran y pwynt y mae'r Aelod wedi ei wneud am y Trysorlys, mae gen i ofn fy mod i wedi credu ers tro bod y Trysorlys, wedi'i yrru gan fformiwla Barnett, yn Drysorlys i Loegr yn ei hanfod, a bod rhannau eraill o'r Deyrnas Unedig, yn syml, yn cael canlyniadau penderfyniadau sy'n cael eu gwneud yn y ffordd honno. Mae angen Trysorlys arnom ni sy'n barod i wneud y penderfyniadau sy'n cydnabod gwahanol anghenion y Deyrnas Unedig ac sy'n barod i fuddsoddi yn y ffordd honno. Gadewch i ni roi un enghraifft o ba mor wahanol yr ystyrir pethau yn Llundain a chan y blaid Geidwadol: byddai'r pecyn o doriadau treth a wnaed gan Liz Truss, sydd bellach wedi cael eu tanseilio, wedi arwain at dair gwaith—[Torri ar draws.]

Okay, let's hear the First Minister finish his answer to the question.28

Iawn, gadewch i ni glywed y Prif Weinidog yn gorffen ei ateb i'r cwestiwn.

Thank you, Llywydd. I'm just explaining the importance of the point that Alun Davies made. Had the Liz Truss Government had their way, those tax cuts would have provided three times as much to London and the south-east than they would have provided to Wales or to northern England. They, of course, were very pleased to support all of that only two weeks ago, just as today, they're no doubt pleased to turn their back on it all as though it had never happened. But, the point that Alun Davies makes is exactly that: we need a Treasury prepared to think of the needs of the country as a whole, not just London and the south-east of England.29

Diolch, Llywydd. Y cwbl rwy'n ei wneud yw egluro pwysigrwydd y pwynt a wnaeth Alun Davies. Pe bai Llywodraeth Liz Truss wedi cael eu ffordd, byddai'r toriadau treth hynny wedi darparu tair gwaith cymaint i Lundain a'r de-ddwyrain nag y bydden nhw wedi ei ddarparu i Gymru neu i ogledd Lloegr. Roedden nhw, wrth gwrs, yn falch iawn o gefnogi hynny i gyd dim ond pythefnos yn ôl, yn union fel heddiw, mae'n siŵr eu bod nhw'n falch o droi eu cefnau ar y cyfan fel pe na bai erioed wedi digwydd. Ond, y pwynt y mae Alun Davies yn ei wneud yw hynny'n union: mae angen Trysorlys arnom ni sy'n barod i feddwl am anghenion y wlad yn ei chyfanrwydd, nid Llundain a de-ddwyrain Lloegr yn unig.

Cwestiynau Heb Rybudd gan Arweinwyr y Pleidiau
Questions Without Notice from the Party Leaders

Cwestiynau nawr gan arweinwyr y pleidiau. Arweinydd y Ceidwadwyr, Andrew R.T. Davies.30

Questions now from the party leaders. Leader of the Conservatives, Andrew R.T. Davies.

Thank you, Presiding Officer. First Minister, I would just like to inform you that we do have six regional Members and one constituency Member who do run in parallel with the M4, so we do have a vested interest, and that's an increase in the number of Members who came back after the 2021 elections.31

What I would like to ask you, First Minister, is: after the waiting time figures that came out last Thursday, one of the big issues that many people struggle with is to get a general practitioner appointment. I've seen that, in other parts of the UK, commitments have been made that if someone requires a GP appointment, they will get it within two days. Are you prepared to make a similar commitment here in Wales?32

Diolch, Llywydd. Prif Weinidog, hoffwn eich hysbysu bod gennym ni chwe Aelod rhanbarthol ac un Aelod etholaeth sy'n rhedeg ochr yn ochr â'r M4, felly mae gennym ni fudd personol, ac mae hynny'n gynnydd i nifer yr Aelodau a ddaeth yn ôl ar ôl etholiadau 2021.

Yr hyn yr hoffwn ei ofyn i chi, Prif Weinidog, yw: ar ôl y ffigurau amseroedd aros a gyhoeddwyd ddydd Iau diwethaf, un o'r materion mawr y mae llawer o bobl yn cael trafferth ag ef yw cael apwyntiad gyda meddyg teulu. Rwyf i wedi gweld, mewn rhannau eraill o'r DU, bod ymrwymiadau wedi cael eu gwneud, os bydd rhywun angen apwyntiad gyda meddyg teulu, y bydd yn ei gael o fewn deuddydd. A ydych chi'n barod i wneud ymrwymiad tebyg yma yng Nghymru?

Llywydd, it's important to get the facts right, and I'm happy to correct the fact that the Welsh Conservative Party did win one constituency seat across the whole length of the M4 in south Wales.33

As far as GP appointments are concerned, let us be clear that there is no guarantee whatsoever that that promise will be delivered. I've heard it made by Conservative health Ministers repeatedly over more than a decade. They've never managed to make it happen so far; they're certainly not going to make it happen this time either.34

The Member will be aware that only last week, the Care Quality Commission published its report on the state of healthcare and adult social care in England. It described a system, as they say, in gridlock: only two people in five able to leave hospital when they are ready to do so because the state of social care and primary care in England means that those people cannot leave hospital. People in England in the health service and social care, Llywydd, are working as hard as they possibly can. I make absolutely no criticism of them. It's just that they are facing, as we do, very, very significant headwinds in being able to provide the service to everybody in the way that we would wish to do so. I spent Friday morning in a GP practice here in Wales, hearing from GPs and the wider primary care team about all the extraordinary efforts they make to be able to provide appointments for the population that they serve, and they know that every day, they're not able to do the job in the way that they would like that job to be done, but it's absolutely not because they are not doing everything they can to make that happen, and they have the full support of the Welsh Government in doing so. 35

Llywydd, mae'n bwysig cael y ffeithiau'n iawn, ac rwy'n hapus i gywiro'r ffaith bod Plaid Geidwadol Cymru wedi ennill un sedd etholaethol ar hyd cyfan yr M4 yn ne Cymru.

O ran apwyntiadau meddyg teulu, gadewch i ni fod yn eglur nad oes unrhyw sicrwydd o gwbl y bydd yr addewid hwnnw'n cael ei gyflawni. Rwyf i wedi ei glywed yn cael ei wneud gan Weinidogion iechyd Ceidwadol dro ar ôl tro dros fwy na degawd. Dydyn nhw erioed wedi llwyddo i wneud iddo ddigwydd hyd yma; yn sicr dydyn nhw ddim yn mynd i wneud iddo ddigwydd y tro hwn chwaith.

Bydd yr Aelod yn ymwybodol mai bod y Comisiwn Ansawdd gofal, dim ond yr wythnos diwethaf, wedi cyhoeddi ei adroddiad ar gyflwr gofal iechyd a gofal cymdeithasol i oedolion yn Lloegr. Disgrifiodd system, fel maen nhw'n dweud, sy'n sefyll yn stond: dim ond dau berson o bob pump sy'n gallu gadael yr ysbyty pan fyddan nhw'n barod i wneud hynny oherwydd bod cyflwr gofal cymdeithasol a gofal sylfaenol yn Lloegr yn golygu na all y bobl hynny adael yr ysbyty. Mae pobl yn Lloegr yn y gwasanaeth iechyd a gofal cymdeithasol, Llywydd, yn gweithio mor galed ag y gallan nhw. Nid wyf i'n gwneud dim beirniadaeth ohonyn nhw o gwbl. Dim ond eu bod nhw'n wynebu, fel yr ydym ni, rwystrau sylweddol dros ben o ran gallu darparu'r gwasanaeth i bawb yn y ffordd y byddem ni'n dymuno gwneud hynny. Treuliais fore dydd Gwener mewn meddygfa deulu yma yng Nghymru, yn clywed gan feddygon teulu a'r tîm gofal sylfaenol ehangach am yr holl ymdrechion rhyfeddol y maen nhw'n eu gwneud i allu darparu apwyntiadau ar gyfer y boblogaeth y maen nhw'n ei gwasanaethu, ac maen nhw'n gwybod bob dydd, nad ydyn nhw'n gallu gwneud y swydd yn y ffordd y bydden nhw'n hoffi i'r swydd honno gael ei gwneud, ond yn sicr nid yw hynny oherwydd nad ydyn nhw'n gwneud popeth o fewn eu gallu i wneud i hynny ddigwydd, ac mae ganddyn nhw gefnogaeth lawn Llywodraeth Cymru i wneud hynny.

13:55

Well, it's interesting that that commitment was made by the Labour health spokesperson at the Labour Party conference in Liverpool, so I'm sure that you'll pick up the phone and tell him that that commitment can't be made, considering that they're looking to Wales each time to see what can be delivered at a Westminster level. That was an interesting comment that you made, First Minister, there.36

What about two-year waits? In particular, here in Wales we have just under 60,000 people waiting two years or more to have their procedure undertaken on the NHS. In other parts of the United Kingdom, in England, those two-year waits have been wiped out, and in Scotland, they've virtually been wiped out. Will you give us a timeline when that will happen here in Wales, and when the 59,000 that are two years or more on a waiting list can expect the same level of service here in Wales?37

Wel, mae'n ddiddorol mai llefarydd iechyd y Blaid Lafur wnaeth yr ymrwymiad hwnnw yng nghynhadledd y Blaid Lafur yn Lerpwl, felly rwy'n siŵr y byddwch chi'n codi'r ffôn ac yn dweud wrtho nad oes modd cyflawni'r ymrwymiad hwnnw, o gofio eu bod nhw'n edrych at Gymru bob tro i weld yr hyn y gellir ei gyflawni ar lefel San Steffan. Roedd hwnna'n sylw diddorol i chi ei wneud yn y fan yna, Prif Weinidog.

Beth am arosiadau o ddwy flynedd? Yn benodol, yma yng Nghymru mae gennym ni ychydig yn llai na 60,000 o bobl yn aros dwy flynedd neu fwy i gael cwblhau eu triniaeth ar y GIG. Mewn rhannau eraill o'r Deyrnas Unedig, yn Lloegr, mae'r arosiadau dwy flynedd hynny wedi cael eu dileu, ac yn yr Alban, maen nhw bron wedi cael eu dileu. A wnewch chi roi amserlen i ni o ran pryd fydd hynny'n digwydd yma yng Nghymru, a phryd y gall y 59,000 sydd wedi bod ar restr aros am ddwy flynedd neu fwy ddisgwyl yr un lefel o wasanaeth yma yng Nghymru?

Llywydd, in the figures to which the Member referred last week, it showed that those long waits continue to fall. They've now fallen for five months in a row. They fell again in July, and provided that the system is able to continue in that way, then of course those long waits will be eliminated. 38

What the figures also showed is the extent to which the health service in Wales, despite the huge pressures that it faces, has now been able to recover activity levels. Out-patient activity in July was at 102 per cent of pre-pandemic levels. In other words, not only is the system delivering everything it did before the pandemic hit, but still operating in a condition where over 500 patients are occupying a bed in the Welsh NHS today with COVID, where over 1,000 are not in work because of COVID—the system is delivering out-patient appointments over and above what it was able to do before the pandemic hit. And operations, elective in-patient care, have recovered to 92 per cent of the level that they were at before the pandemic. That's the highest level we've seen since the pandemic struck, and all of this while the system continues to do everything else we asked of it. This week, we have gone above 500,000 COVID vaccinations carried out over this autumn period. Who is involved in doing all of that? Well, it's the GPs that the Member mentioned in his first question, and all those other staff who turn up at weekends and run the clinics that mean that we've seen that extraordinary success.39

So, while the health service works hard every day to recover the ground that was lost during COVID, to respond to the emergencies that people present, to do the other things we ask of them in vaccination not only for COVID, but for flu as well, we are seeing those long waits continuing to fall.40

Llywydd, yn y ffigurau y cyfeiriodd yr Aelod atyn nhw yr wythnos diwethaf, dangoswyd bod yr arosiadau hir hynny yn parhau i leihau. Maen nhw bellach wedi lleihau bum mis yn olynol. Fe wnaethon nhw leihau eto ym mis Gorffennaf, a chyn belled ag y bo'r system yn gallu parhau yn y ffordd honno, yna wrth gwrs bydd yr arosiadau hir hynny'n cael eu dileu.

Yr hyn yr oedd y ffigurau yn ei ddangos hefyd yw i ba raddau y mae'r gwasanaeth iechyd yng Nghymru, er gwaethaf y pwysau aruthrol sy'n ei wynebu, wedi gallu adfer lefelau gweithgarwch bellach. Roedd gweithgarwch cleifion allanol ym mis Gorffennaf ar 102 y cant o'r lefelau cyn y pandemig. Mewn geiriau eraill, nid yn unig y mae'r system yn darparu popeth yr oedd cyn i'r pandemig daro, ond mae'n dal i weithredu mewn cyflwr lle mae dros 500 o gleifion yn meddiannu gwely yn GIG Cymru heddiw gyda COVID, lle nad yw dros 1,000 mewn gwaith oherwydd COVID—mae'r system yn darparu apwyntiadau cleifion allanol i lefelau uwch na'r hyn yr oedd yn gallu ei wneud cyn i'r pandemig daro. Ac mae llawdriniaethau, gofal cleifion mewnol dewisol, wedi gwella i 92 y cant o'r lefel yr oedden nhw arni cyn y pandemig. Dyna'r lefel uchaf yr ydym ni wedi ei gweld ers i'r pandemig daro, a hyn oll tra bod y system yn parhau i wneud popeth arall y gwnaethom ni ofyn ganddi. Yr wythnos hon, rydym ni wedi mynd dros 500,000 o frechiadau COVID a roddwyd dros gyfnod yr hydref hwn. Pwy sy'n rhan o wneud hynny i gyd? Wel, y meddygon teulu y soniodd yr Aelod amdanyn nhw yn ei gwestiwn cyntaf, a'r holl staff eraill hynny sy'n troi i fyny ar benwythnosau ac yn rhedeg y clinigau sy'n golygu ein bod ni wedi gweld y llwyddiant rhyfeddol hwnnw.

Felly, er bod y gwasanaeth iechyd yn gweithio'n galed bob dydd i adennill y tir a gollwyd yn ystod COVID, i ymateb i'r argyfyngau y mae pobl yn eu cyflwyno, i wneud y pethau eraill rydym ni'n eu gofyn ganddyn nhw o ran brechu nid yn unig ar gyfer COVID, ond ar gyfer y ffliw hefyd, rydym ni'n gweld yr arosiadau hir hynny yn parhau i leihau.

In my first question, First Minister, I asked you to support a commitment that the Labour health spokesperson in Westminster said that Labour would deliver, and you said that was undeliverable. In the second question, I asked you to give a commitment and a road map to wiping out the two-year waits here in the NHS. I've been contacted by a constituent this week, Richard Cooper, who got told that, to have his hip operations on the NHS here in Wales—because he required both hips to be done—he could expect a four to five-year wait for those procedures to be undertaken. He had to access his own private savings to go to a clinic in Poland to have the procedure undertaken. Now, I can't get a commitment out on GP response times, I can't get a commitment on two-year waits out of you; what is the advice I should tell my constituents, like Richard Cooper, who are having to access their own savings, their pension pots, because you can't deliver a health service that can meet the needs of the people of Wales?41

Yn fy nghwestiwn cyntaf, Prif Weinidog, gofynnais i chi gefnogi ymrwymiad y dywedodd llefarydd iechyd y blaid Lafur yn San Steffan y byddai Llafur yn ei gyflawni, ac fe ddywedoch chi nad oedd modd ei gyflawni. Yn yr ail gwestiwn, gofynnais i chi roi ymrwymiad a map ffordd i ddileu'r arosiadau dwy flynedd yma yn y GIG. Mae etholwr wedi cysylltu â mi yr wythnos hon, Richard Cooper, a gafodd ei hysbysu, i gael ei lawdriniaethau clun ar y GIG yma yng Nghymru—oherwydd roedd angen llawdriniaeth ar y ddwy glun—gallai ddisgwyl arhosiad o bedair i bum mlynedd i'r llawdriniaethau hynny gael eu cyflawni. Bu'n rhaid iddo ddefnyddio ei gynilion preifat ei hun i fynd i glinig yng Ngwlad Pwyl i gael y llawdriniaeth. Nawr, ni allaf gael ymrwymiad ar amseroedd ymateb meddygon teulu, ni allaf gael ymrwymiad ar arosiadau dwy flynedd gennych chi; beth yw'r cyngor y dylwn i ei roi i'm hetholwyr, fel Richard Cooper, sy'n gorfod defnyddio eu cynilion eu hunain, eu potiau pensiwn, oherwydd na allwch chi ddarparu gwasanaeth iechyd sy'n gallu diwallu anghenion pobl Cymru?

14:00

On those three points, Llywydd, first of all, as soon as there is a Labour Government, we will be able to implement the Labour promises. I've explained to you—[Interruption.] I've explained to you why, under your Government, with budgets falling year by year, and now another era of austerity facing us all, the promises that your health Secretary made in England will not be met. With a Labour Government, then those things will be different and then of course we will see things improve, as we did under the last Labour Government. And I explained to you that long waits in the NHS continue to fall, despite everything else that the health service is doing, and everything else the health service is doing extends to trying to make sure that we have a sustainable orthopaedic service here in Wales. That is a challenge, Llywydd. We have an ageing population. We have more work that needs to be done. We have operating theatres still not able to complete the volume of activity that they were before the pandemic, and yet, as I said, in August alone there were 24,000 operations carried out in the Welsh NHS, and 230,000 out-patient appointments. While I regret anybody who is waiting too long for the operation they need, what I say to them is the system is working as hard as it can, it is gaining ground not losing ground, and we will continue to invest both financially but also in the staff that we need to make sure that our NHS continues to provide the treatment it does at that industrial volume that I've just described to you from the month of August alone. 42

Ar y tri phwynt hynny, Llywydd, yn gyntaf oll, cyn gynted ag y bydd Llywodraeth Lafur, byddwn yn gallu gweithredu addewidion y Blaid Lafur. Rwyf i wedi esbonio i chi—[Torri ar draws.] Rwyf i wedi esbonio i chi pam, o dan eich Llywodraeth chi, gyda chyllidebau'n gostwng o un flwyddyn i'r llall, a nawr cyfnod arall o gyni cyllidol yn ein hwynebu ni i gyd, ni fydd yr addewidion a wnaed gan eich Ysgrifennydd iechyd yn Lloegr yn cael eu cyflawni. Gyda Llywodraeth Lafur, yna bydd y pethau hynny'n wahanol ac yna wrth gwrs byddwn ni'n gweld pethau'n gwella, fel y gwnaethom ni o dan y Llywodraeth Lafur ddiwethaf. Ac esboniais i chi bod arosiadau hir yn y GIG yn parhau i leihau, er gwaethaf popeth arall y mae'r gwasanaeth iechyd yn ei wneud, ac mae popeth arall y mae'r gwasanaeth iechyd yn ei wneud yn ymestyn i geisio gwneud yn siŵr bod gennym ni wasanaeth orthopedig cynaliadwy yma yng Nghymru. Mae hynny'n her, Llywydd. Mae gennym ni boblogaeth sy'n heneiddio. Mae gennym ni fwy o waith y mae angen ei wneud. Mae gennym ni theatrau llawdriniaeth nad ydyn nhw'n gallu  cwblhau lefel y gweithgarwch yr oedden nhw'n gallu ei gwblhau cyn y pandemig o hyd, ac eto, fel y dywedais i, ym mis Awst yn unig cyflawnwyd 24,000 o lawdriniaethau yn y GIG yng Nghymru, a 230,000 o apwyntiadau cleifion allanol. Er fy mod i'n gresynu unrhyw un sy'n aros yn rhy hir am y llawdriniaeth sydd ei hangen arnyn nhw, yr hyn rwy'n ei ddweud wrthyn nhw yw bod y system yn gweithio mor galed ag y gall, mae'n ennill tir nid colli tir, a byddwn yn parhau i fuddsoddi yn ariannol ond hefyd yn y staff sydd ei angen arnom ni i wneud yn siŵr bod ein GIG yn parhau i ddarparu'r driniaeth y mae'n ei darparu ar y lefel ddiwydiannol honno yr wyf i newydd ei disgrifio i chi o fis Awst yn unig.

Diolch, Llywydd. First Minister, you quite rightly complained that the last Tory Prime Minister failed to pick up the phone to you, and indeed treated yours and the other devolved Governments with contempt. How do you intend to approach relations with the latest Prime Minister? Will you perhaps decide to change tack and try and pick up the phone to him, as leaders of other national Governments are set to do over the next few days? If you do speak, you will no doubt want to congratulate him on being the first British Asian to be elected as Prime Minister, which is indeed a historic event and all the more fitting that it's on Diwali. But will you also want to underline that the one thing he must not do in his Halloween budget is to usher in a new era of austerity and plunge the economy into recession, people into poverty and our public services, including the NHS, into yet a deeper crisis? 44

Diolch, Llywydd. Prif Weinidog, fe wnaethoch chi gwyno'n gwbl briodol bod Prif Weinidog Torïaidd diwethaf y DU wedi methu â chodi'r ffôn i chi, ac yn wir yn trin eich Llywodraeth chi a'r Llywodraethau datganoledig eraill â dirmyg. Sut ydych chi'n bwriadu mynd i'r afael â'r berthynas gyda Phrif Weinidog diweddaraf y DU? A wnewch chi benderfynu newid tac efallai a cheisio codi'r ffôn iddo ef, fel y mae arweinwyr Llywodraethau cenedlaethol eraill ar fin ei wneud dros y dyddiau nesaf? Os byddwch chi'n sgwrsio, mae'n siŵr y byddwch chi eisiau ei longyfarch ar fod yr unigolyn Asiaidd Prydeinig cyntaf i gael ei ethol yn Brif Weinidog y DU, sydd wir yn ddigwyddiad hanesyddol ac yn fwy addas fyth ei fod yn ystod Diwali. Ond a fyddwch chi hefyd eisiau tanlinellu mai'r un peth y mae'n rhaid iddo beidio â'i wneud yn ei gyllideb Calan Gaeaf yw cychwyn cyfnod newydd o gyni cyllidol a phlymio'r economi i ddirwasgiad, pobl i dlodi a'n gwasanaethau cyhoeddus, gan gynnwys y GIG, i argyfwng mwy dwys fyth? 

Llywydd, I hope of course that the new Prime Minister will take a different approach to relations with the devolved Governments across the United Kingdom. I see a series of Welsh Conservative MPs today calling on the new Prime Minister to take that initiative, and it is the initiative for the Prime Minister to take. So, I hope very much that there will be early contact from the latest administration, and, if there is, then you can be sure that I will want to have a constructive relationship with the new Prime Minister. If I have an opportunity, there will be a series of things that I will want to put early on his list of priorities. The future of the United Kingdom itself—I'll remind him, no doubt, that the Welsh Government is the only other unambiguously unionist Government with which he will have contact, and I would want to work with him to make sure that there is a successful future for the United Kingdom. 45

I want to talk to him about some very important individual issues that are important here in Wales—the future of Tata Steel, for example. When I wrote to the Prime Minister but one ago earlier in the summer, he replied to me acknowledging the seriousness of the position of Tata Steel, but saying that it would be for the next Prime Minister to make the decisions about the level of support that could be offered to the company; well, that latest Prime Minister came and went and no decision of that sort was made. So, if I have the opportunity, I will certainly be saying to the new Prime Minister that attending to that very important issue, as far as Wales is concerned, should be high on his list of priorities. And, of course, Llywydd, I will say as well that the very last thing people in Wales or across the United Kingdom need is a further dose of Tory austerity.46

Llywydd, rwy'n gobeithio wrth gwrs y bydd Prif Weinidog newydd y DU yn mabwysiadu agwedd wahanol o ran y berthynas â'r Llywodraethau datganoledig ar draws y Deyrnas Unedig. Rwy'n gweld cyfres o Aelodau Seneddol Ceidwadol o Gymru heddiw yn galw ar Brif Weinidog newydd y DU i achub y blaen yn hynny o beth, ac mae'n gam i Brif Weinidog y DU ei gymryd. Felly, rwy'n gobeithio'n fawr iawn y bydd yna gyswllt cynnar gan y weinyddiaeth ddiweddaraf, ac, os oes, yna gallwch fod yn sicr y byddaf eisiau cael perthynas adeiladol gyda Phrif Weinidog newydd y DU. Os caf gyfle, bydd cyfres o bethau y byddaf i eisiau eu rhoi'n gynnar ar ei restr o flaenoriaethau. Dyfodol y Deyrnas Unedig ei hun—byddaf yn ei atgoffa, rwy'n siŵr, mai Llywodraeth Cymru yw'r unig Lywodraeth unoliaethol ddiamwys arall y bydd ganddo gysylltiad â hi, a byddwn eisiau gweithio gydag ef i wneud yn siŵr bod dyfodol llwyddiannus i'r Deyrnas Unedig. 

Rwyf i eisiau siarad ag ef am faterion unigol pwysig iawn sy'n bwysig yma yng Nghymru—dyfodol Tata Steel, er enghraifft. Pan ysgrifennais at y Prif Weinidog ond un yn ôl yn gynharach yn yr haf, fe wnaeth fy ateb gan gydnabod difrifoldeb sefyllfa Tata Steel, ond gan ddweud mai mater i Brif Weinidog nesaf y DU fyddai gwneud y penderfyniadau am lefel y cymorth y gellid ei chynnig i'r cwmni; wel, mae'r Prif Weinidog diweddaraf hwnnw wedi mynd a dod ac ni wnaed penderfyniad o'r math hwnnw. Felly, os caf gyfle, byddaf yn sicr yn dweud wrth Brif Weinidog newydd y DU y dylai rhoi sylw i'r mater pwysig iawn hwnnw, cyn belled ag y mae Cymru yn y cwestiwn, fod yn uchel ar ei restr o flaenoriaethau. Ac, wrth gwrs, Llywydd, dywedaf hefyd mai'r peth olaf un sydd ei angen ar bobl yng Nghymru neu ar draws y Deyrnas Unedig yw dos pellach o gyni cyllidol Torïaidd.

14:05

You've been calling for a general election, and there is an unanswerable case for having one, given now we've had two Prime Ministers without a democratic mandate. The truth is that Prime Minister Sunak is free to ignore that, as he is free to ignore you. The UK's unwritten constitution concentrates huge power in the hands of the PM, which explains the mess we're in. Now, the doctrine of Westminster supremacy means the new Prime Minister is free to repeal any Act of this Senedd and revoke any power, even though he has no mandate to do so, certainly not here in Wales. Now, the political pendulum may swing at the next election, whenever it comes, but how can we stop being in exactly the same position in years to come, when the pendulum swings back? How do you propose an incoming Labour Government would entrench our Welsh democracy in a political system where Westminster reigns supreme?47

Rydych chi wedi bod yn galw am etholiad cyffredinol, ac mae dadl na ellir ei hateb dros gael un, o ystyried ein bod ni bellach wedi cael dau Brif Weinidog y DU heb fandad democrataidd. Y gwir amdani yw bod y Prif Weinidog Sunak yn rhydd i anwybyddu hynny, fel y mae'n rhydd i'ch anwybyddu chi. Mae cyfansoddiad anysgrifenedig y DU yn canolbwyntio grym enfawr yn nwylo Prif Weinidog y DU, sy'n esbonio'r llanast rydym ni ynddo. Nawr, mae athrawiaeth goruchafiaeth San Steffan yn golygu bod Prif Weinidog newydd y DU yn rhydd i ddiddymu unrhyw Ddeddf y Senedd hon a diddymu unrhyw rym, er nad oes ganddo unrhyw fandad i wneud hynny, yn sicr nid yma yng Nghymru. Nawr, efallai y bydd y pendil gwleidyddol yn troi yn yr etholiad nesaf, pryd bynnag y daw, ond sut gallwn ni roi'r gorau i fod yn union yr un sefyllfa mewn blynyddoedd i ddod, pan fydd y pendil yn troi'n ôl? Sut ydych chi'n cynnig y byddai Llywodraeth Lafur newydd yn gwreiddio ein democratiaeth yng Nghymru mewn system wleidyddol lle mae San Steffan yn oruchaf?

Llywydd, I agree that there is an unanswerable case for an election, and I don't think that the Prime Minister is in quite the unassailable position that the leader of Plaid Cymru has suggested. The deep divisions inside the Conservative Party may be papered over for a few weeks yet. We may see Conservative Members of Parliament playing football against one another on the green outside Parliament in some form of Christmas truce, but, once Christmas is out of the way, then I'm afraid the incoming Prime Minister will face the very, very deep divisions inside the Conservative Party, as the last four predecessors have done as well. And I'm not in quite the same position as the leader of Plaid Cymru in thinking that a general election won't be coming our way sooner rather than later. After that election, there will be an opportunity, I hope, for an incoming Labour Government to do exactly what Adam Price has said: to entrench devolution, so that it cannot be rolled back in the way that we have seen since 2019. I think there are a series of practical ways in which that can be done, and, when the Gordon Brown report into the future arrangements of the United Kingdom is published, I think we will see a number of those practical ideas. I'm not going to rehearse them this afternoon necessarily, Llywydd, but they are there. They are there in ways that would guarantee that the things that have been endorsed in two referendums by people in Wales can be organised in a way that those preferences can be delivered without the risk that they're always under pressure of being rolled back.48

Llywydd, rwy'n cytuno bod dadl na ellir ei hateb dros etholiad, ac nid wyf i'n credu bod Prif Weinidog y DU yn y sefyllfa anorchfygol y mae arweinydd Plaid Cymru wedi'i awgrymu. Efallai y bydd y rhaniadau dwfn y tu mewn i'r Blaid Geidwadol yn cael eu cuddio am ychydig wythnosau eto. Efallai y byddwn ni'n gweld Aelodau Seneddol Ceidwadol yn chwarae pêl-droed yn erbyn ei gilydd ar y lawnt y tu allan i Senedd San Steffan mewn rhyw fath o gadoediad Nadolig, ond, unwaith y bydd y Nadolig allan o'r ffordd, yna mae gen i ofn y bydd y Prif Weinidog newydd yn wynebu'r rhaniadau dwfn iawn, iawn y tu mewn i'r Blaid Geidwadol, fel y mae'r pedwar rhagflaenydd diwethaf wedi ei wneud hefyd. Ac nid wyf i o'r un farn yn union ag arweinydd Plaid Cymru o feddwl na fydd etholiad cyffredinol ar ei ffordd i ni yn gynt yn hytrach nag yn hwyrach. Ar ôl yr etholiad hwnnw, bydd cyfle, rwy'n gobeithio, i Lywodraeth Lafur newydd wneud yr union beth y mae Adam Price wedi ei ddweud: gwreiddio datganoli, fel na ellir ei erydu yn y modd rydym ni wedi ei weld ers 2019. Rwy'n credu bod cyfres o ffyrdd ymarferol y gellir gwneud hynny, a phan fydd adroddiad Gordon Brown ar drefniadau'r Deyrnas Unedig yn y dyfodol yn cael ei gyhoeddi, rwy'n credu y byddwn ni'n gweld nifer o'r syniadau ymarferol hynny. Nid wyf i'n mynd i'w trafod nhw y prynhawn yma o reidrwydd, Llywydd, ond maen nhw yna. Maen nhw yna mewn ffyrdd a fyddai'n sicrhau y gellir trefnu'r pethau a gymeradwywyd mewn dau refferendwm gan bobl yng Nghymru mewn ffordd y gellir darparu'r dewisiadau hynny heb y risg eu bod nhw bob amser o dan bwysau o gael eu herydu.

When you were in Ireland recently, you reiterated your view that the United Kingdom represents, for Wales, a great insurance policy, but how is that policy working for us when the contract can constantly be changed over our heads, against our wishes and against our interests? You talked about the pooling of risk through the union, but surely the events of the last few weeks have demonstrated that the union actually exposes us in Wales to risk, to uncertainty and to avoidable harm. Now, you've said you would never ever support an independent Wales, but would you accept that there are some circumstances at least—another Tory Government elected against our wishes in Wales, or a Scottish 'yes' vote in an independence referendum—where independence might become, for Wales, and even for your party, the more progressive option? I understand that you prefer a continuing union, but isn't saying 'never' to independence simply wedding ourselves to a future that will be never our own to decide?49

Pan oeddech chi yn Iwerddon yn ddiweddar, fe wnaethoch chi ail-bwysleisio eich barn bod y Deyrnas Unedig, i Gymru, yn bolisi yswiriant gwych, ond sut mae'r polisi hwnnw'n gweithio i ni pan fo modd newid y contract yn gyson dros ein pennau, yn erbyn ein dymuniadau ac yn erbyn ein buddiannau? Fe wnaethoch chi sôn am gyfuno risg drwy'r undeb, ond siawns nad yw digwyddiadau'r wythnosau diwethaf wedi dangos bod yr undeb mewn gwirionedd yn ein hamlygu ni yng Nghymru i risg, i ansicrwydd ac i niwed y gellir ei osgoi. Nawr, rydych chi wedi dweud na fyddech chi byth yn cefnogi Cymru annibynnol, ond a fyddech chi'n derbyn bod rhai amgylchiadau o leiaf—Llywodraeth Dorïaidd arall yn cael ei hethol yn erbyn ein dymuniadau yng Nghymru, neu bleidlais dros annibyniaeth i'r Alban mewn refferendwm—lle gallai annibyniaeth ddod, i Gymru, a hyd yn oed i'ch plaid, yr opsiwn mwy blaengar? Rwy'n deall bod yn well gennych chi undeb barhaus, ond onid yw dweud 'byth' i annibyniaeth yn gwneud dim ond clymu ein hunain i ddyfodol na fydd byth yn eiddo i ni ei benderfynu?

Llywydd, the issue of whether Wales should be independent is a matter for people in Wales, and I've always said that if a party were to put that as a prospect in a manifesto and they were to win a majority of seats here in the Senedd, then, of course, if people choose that course of action, then that is the democratic will of people in Wales. Their voice is the important one—not mine, whether I think it's right or wrong. Where I will agree with the leader of Plaid Cymru is this: that if the political geometry of the United Kingdom were to alter, if one of its constituent parts were to choose a different future, that doesn't leave what remains untouched. You would have to have a very serious set of discussions about how Wales's future could best be designed in those different circumstances, and it's why, as the leader of Plaid Cymru knows, we have established our own constitutional commission to help us to think about what choices there would be available to Wales in those circumstances. Independence could be one of them, as it has been ever since his party was established and ever since it's put that prospect in front of the people of Wales. So far, people have not been persuaded of that, and there will be alternative futures that others of us would rather advocate. But that's the right place for these decisions to be debated; they're not for me as First Minister or even for political parties here to make that determination. Just as the leader of Plaid Cymru said there was an unanswerable case for a general election to determine the future economic direction of the United Kingdom, so it would be an unanswerable need for such decisions of the sort that he's outlined this afternoon to be made by the people who put us here.50

Llywydd, mae'r cwestiwn a ddylai Cymru fod yn annibynnol yn gwestiwn i bobl yng Nghymru, ac rwyf i wedi dweud erioed pe bai plaid yn cynnig hynny fel dewis mewn maniffesto ac y bydden nhw'n ennill mwyafrif y seddi yma yn y Senedd, yna, wrth gwrs, os yw pobl yn dewis y cam hwnnw, yna dyna ewyllys ddemocrataidd pobl yng Nghymru. Eu llais nhw yw'r un pwysig—nid fy un i, pa un a ydw i'n meddwl ei fod yn iawn neu'n anghywir. Lle byddaf yn cytuno ag arweinydd Plaid Cymru yw hyn: pe bai geometreg wleidyddol y Deyrnas Unedig yn newid, pe bai un o'i rhannau cyfansoddol yn dewis gwahanol ddyfodol, nid yw hynny'n gadael yr hyn sy'n weddill heb ei gyffwrdd. Byddai'n rhaid i chi gael cyfres ddifrifol iawn o drafodaethau ynglŷn â'r ffordd orau y gellid cynllunio dyfodol Cymru o dan yr amgylchiadau gwahanol hynny, a dyna pam, fel y mae arweinydd Plaid Cymru yn gwybod, rydym ni wedi sefydlu ein comisiwn cyfansoddiadol ein hunain i'n helpu i feddwl pa ddewisiadau fyddai ar gael i Gymru o dan yr amgylchiadau hynny. Gallai annibyniaeth fod yn un ohonyn nhw, fel y bu ers sefydlu ei blaid ac ers iddi roi'r dewis hwnnw gerbron pobl Cymru. Hyd yn hyn, nid yw pobl wedi cael eu perswadio o hynny, a bydd gwahanol fathau o ddyfodol y byddai'n well gan eraill ohonom ni eu hyrwyddo. Ond dyna'r lle iawn i'r penderfyniadau hyn gael eu trafod; dydyn nhw ddim yn fater i mi fel Prif Weinidog na hyd yn oed i bleidiau gwleidyddol yma wneud y penderfyniad hwnnw. Yn union fel y dywedodd arweinydd Plaid Cymru bod dadl na ellir ei hateb dros etholiad cyffredinol i benderfynu cyfeiriad economaidd y Deyrnas Unedig yn y dyfodol, felly hefyd y byddai'n angen na ellir ei ateb am benderfyniadau o'r fath y mae wedi'u hamlinellu y prynhawn yma i gael eu gwneud gan y bobl sy'n ein rhoi ni yma.

14:10
Prentisiaethau Gradd
Degree Apprenticeships

3. Pa asesiad mae'r Prif Weinidog wedi'i wneud o effaith rhaglen prentisiaethau gradd Llywodraeth Cymru ar niferoedd mynediad am brentisiaethau gradd? OQ58629

3. What assessment has the First Minister made of the impact of the Welsh Government's degree apprenticeships programme on admission numbers for degree apprenticeships? OQ58629

Llywydd, since the degree apprenticeship programme began in Wales in 2018, we have achieved more than a fivefold increase in enrolments. In the current academic year, 780 apprenticeships are working to achieve degree-level qualifications in digital, energy and advanced manufacturing.51

Llywydd, ers i'r rhaglen prentisiaeth gradd ddechrau yng Nghymru yn 2018, rydym ni wedi sicrhau cynnydd o fwy na phum gwaith i gofrestriadau. Yn y flwyddyn academaidd bresennol, mae 780 o brentisiaethau yn gweithio i ennill cymwysterau lefel gradd ym meysydd digidol, ynni a gweithgynhyrchu uwch.

Thank you, First Minister. It's interesting, what you said, and I just want to note that the Welsh Conservatives fully support degree apprenticeships, and, in fact, we go further than the current policy. But, First Minister, a few weeks ago, I stood here and raised some concerning statistics highlighting that white working-class males are the least likely to attend university across the UK, but the picture is worse in Wales. You implied the problem wasn't as bad as I said, trying to excuse the figures. You said, and I quote:52

'Our degree apprenticeship programme will not be counted in the figures that the Member has suggested this afternoon',53

as if that would somehow make the situation look better. For the academic year 2019-20, there were 380 new and continuing apprentices in the degree apprenticeship programme. In the very same cohort, 83,800 Welsh students went to university—453 per cent more than the amount taking degree apprenticeships; 380 is just 0.45 per cent of 83,800. First Minister, it's quite clear from the statistics that degree apprenticeships, even if included in the figures, and your new figures that you outlined just now, would make very little difference to those overall numbers that I outlined. So, First Minister, the problem still remains: we are seeing low numbers of university admissions for white working-class males. How exactly are you trying to rectify the situation, and, again, what practical solutions are you going to put in place to ensure that that trend doesn't continue?54

Diolch, Prif Weinidog. Mae'n ddiddorol, yr hyn a ddywedoch chi, a hoffwn nodi bod y Ceidwadwyr Cymreig yn cefnogi prentisiaethau gradd yn llawn, ac, a dweud y gwir, rydym ni'n mynd ymhellach na'r polisi presennol. Ond, Prif Weinidog, ychydig wythnosau yn ôl, sefais yma a chodais rai ystadegau pryderus yn amlygu mai gwrywod dosbarth gweithiol gwyn yw'r rhai lleiaf tebygol o fynd i'r brifysgol ar draws y DU, ond mae'r darlun yn waeth yng Nghymru. Fe wnaethoch chi awgrymu nad oedd y broblem cynddrwg ag y dywedais i, gan geisio esgusodi'r ffigurau. Fe ddywedoch chi, ac rwy'n dyfynnu:

'Ni fydd ein rhaglen prentisiaethau gradd yn cael ei chyfri yn y ffigurau y mae'r Aelod wedi'u hawgrymu y prynhawn yma',

fel pe bai hynny rhywsut yn gwneud i'r sefyllfa edrych yn well. Ar gyfer blwyddyn academaidd 2019-20, roedd 380 o brentisiaid newydd a pharhaus yn y rhaglen prentisiaeth gradd. Yn yr un cohort, aeth 83,800 o fyfyrwyr o Gymru i'r brifysgol—453 y cant yn fwy na'r nifer sy'n dilyn prentisiaethau gradd; dim ond 0.45 y cant o 83,800 yw 380. Prif Weinidog, mae'n gwbl eglur o'r ystadegau y byddai prentisiaethau gradd, hyd yn oed pe baen nhw'n cael eu cynnwys yn y ffigurau, a'ch ffigurau newydd a amlinellwyd gennych chi nawr, yn gwneud ychydig iawn o wahaniaeth i'r niferoedd cyffredinol hynny a amlinellais. Felly, Prif Weinidog, mae'r broblem yn parhau: rydym ni'n gweld niferoedd isel o dderbyniadau prifysgol ymhlith dynion dosbarth gweithiol gwyn. Sut yn union ydych chi'n ceisio unioni'r sefyllfa, ac, eto, pa atebion ymarferol ydych chi'n mynd i'w rhoi ar waith i sicrhau nad yw'r duedd honno'n parhau?

Well, Llywydd, I've enjoyed Laura Anne Jones's latest contribution to her leadership campaign, but I have to say this to her: that she will need to slow down on the numbers to allow people to follow the points that she is making. I look forward to reading the transcript so I'm better able to follow the argument that she was making.55

The apprenticeship programme—degree apprenticeship programme—Llywydd, is designed to focus on, as I said in my answer, those areas where we have particular needs in the Welsh economy—digital, energy and advanced manufacturing being amongst them—areas where, historically, women have been under-represented but white young men are very much in the majority and, despite our efforts to attract young women into those areas through the degree apprenticeship programme, that remains the case.56

What is more important in terms of the question put to me, though, Llywydd, is whether we are attracting through the degree apprenticeship route young people who otherwise wouldn't be in higher education. I am encouraged that over 57 per cent of those young people who come to take up degree apprenticeships in Wales come from families where there is no parent who has ever been to higher education. In other words, we are recruiting through that route people who would not be as likely to have higher education experience by the conventional routes. And in that sense, I'm glad that the Member has welcomed the degree apprenticeship programme, because I think—I don't think I followed her completely here, but I think, when I study her figures, I will find that, actually, it is doing what she wants it to do; it is reaching into those parts of the community that more conventional routes into higher education fail to achieve the penetration that we would like to see.57

Wel, Llywydd, rwyf i wedi mwynhau cyfraniad diweddaraf Laura Anne Jones at ei hymgyrch arweinyddol, ond mae'n rhaid i mi ddweud hyn wrthi: y bydd angen iddi arafu ar y niferoedd er mwyn caniatáu i bobl ddilyn y pwyntiau y mae hi'n eu gwneud. Rwy'n edrych ymlaen at ddarllen y trawsgrifiad fel y gallaf ddilyn y ddadl yr oedd hi'n ei gwneud yn well.

Mae'r rhaglen brentisiaeth—y rhaglen prentisiaeth gradd—Llywydd, wedi ei chynllunio i ganolbwyntio, fel y dywedais i yn fy ateb, ar y meysydd hynny lle mae gennym ni anghenion arbennig yn economi Cymru—digidol, ynni a gweithgynhyrchu uwch yn eu plith—meysydd lle, yn hanesyddol, y mae menywod wedi cael eu tangynrychioli ond mae dynion ifanc gwyn yn sicr yn y mwyafrif ac, er gwaethaf ein hymdrechion i ddenu menywod ifanc i'r meysydd hynny drwy'r rhaglen prentisiaeth gradd, mae hynny'n parhau i fod yn wir.

Ond yr hyn sy'n bwysicach o ran y cwestiwn a ofynnwyd i mi, Llywydd, yw a ydym ni'n denu drwy'r llwybr prentisiaeth gradd pobl ifanc na fyddai fel arall mewn addysg uwch. Rwy'n cael fy nghalonogi bod dros 57 y cant o'r bobl ifanc hynny sy'n dod i ddilyn prentisiaethau gradd yng Nghymru yn dod o deuluoedd lle nad oes rhiant erioed wedi bod mewn addysg uwch. Mewn geiriau eraill, rydym ni'n recriwtio drwy'r llwybr hwnnw pobl na fyddai mor debygol o gael profiad addysg uwch drwy'r llwybrau confensiynol. Ac yn yr ystyr hwnnw, rwy'n falch bod yr Aelod wedi croesawu'r rhaglen prentisiaeth gradd, oherwydd rwy'n meddwl—nid wyf i'n credu fy mod i wedi ei dilyn hi'n llwyr yma, ond rwy'n meddwl, pan fyddaf yn astudio ei ffigurau, y byddaf yn gweld, mewn gwirionedd, ei bod yn gwneud yr hyn y mae hi eisiau iddi ei wneud; mae'n cyrraedd y rhannau hynny o'r gymuned y mae llwybrau mwy confensiynol i addysg uwch yn methu â sicrhau'r treiddiad yr hoffem ni ei weld.

14:15

This Friday, I'll be visiting DRB Group in my own constituency of Alyn and Deeside, and I'm proud to have completed my apprenticeship in advanced manufacturing at DRB, with the help of the Welsh Labour Government. I'm also extremely grateful to the company for funding my part-time degree whilst I was there. Before I visit and return to my former workplace, I will be speaking at a skills-shortage conference, organised by Deeside Business Forum. What message can I send from you, as First Minister of Wales, to the conference, to companies like DRB Group in Alyn and Deeside, about the Welsh Government's commitment to equipping the next workforce with the skills to develop the next generation of green industrial products in north-east Wales?58

Ddydd Gwener yma, byddaf yn ymweld â Grŵp DRB yn fy etholaeth fy hun, sef Alun a Glannau Dyfrdwy, ac rwy'n falch o fod wedi cwblhau fy mhrentisiaeth mewn gweithgynhyrchu uwch yn DRB, gyda chymorth Llywodraeth Lafur Cymru. Rwyf i hefyd yn hynod ddiolchgar i'r cwmni am ariannu fy ngradd rhan amser tra'r oeddwn i yno. Cyn i mi ymweld a dychwelyd i fy hen weithle, byddaf yn siarad mewn cynhadledd prinder sgiliau, a drefnwyd gan Fforwm Busnes Glannau Dyfrdwy. Pa neges gaf i ei hanfon gennych chi, fel Prif Weinidog Cymru, i'r gynhadledd, i gwmnïau fel Grŵp DRB yn Alun a Glannau Dyfrdwy, am ymrwymiad Llywodraeth Cymru i roi'r sgiliau i'r gweithlu nesaf i ddatblygu'r genhedlaeth nesaf o gynhyrchion diwydiannol gwyrdd yn y gogledd-ddwyrain?

I thank Jack Sargeant for that and congratulate him, of course, on the way that he himself came through that apprenticeship system and did so so successfully. What you can quite certainly say to the business forum is that, in Wales, they have a Government that fully understands the responsibility that we have to invest in the skills that will allow businesses in that part of Wales to continue to thrive. Unemployment, Llywydd, in Wales is at its very lowest in the north-east of Wales. I met companies in the Deeside area when I was in north Wales only a couple of weeks ago. They know it's a competitive market to attract, particularly, young people to take up the job opportunities that are there for them, and they were very appreciative of the work that the Welsh Government does and particularly those on-the-ground providers—Coleg Cambria and others—the things that they do to align the programmes that they provide with the needs of that great green industrial future that we want to create here in Wales. And I'd be really grateful to Jack Sargeant if, on our behalf, on behalf of the Welsh Government, he can reinforce, with that business forum, our determination to go on working alongside them and the education system to make sure that we turn out young people who have the skills that they will need to create successful futures for themselves, and to contribute to those great employers that we have in the north-east of Wales.59

Diolchaf i Jack Sargeant am hynny a'i longyfarch, wrth gwrs, ar y ffordd y daeth ef ei hun drwy'r system brentisiaeth honno a gwneud hynny'n llwyddiannus. Yr hyn y gallwch chi ei ddweud yn eithaf sicr wrth y fforwm busnes yw bod ganddyn nhw, yng Nghymru, Lywodraeth sy'n deall yn iawn y cyfrifoldeb sydd gennym ni i fuddsoddi yn y sgiliau a fydd yn caniatáu i fusnesau yn y rhan honno o Gymru i barhau i ffynnu. Mae diweithdra, Llywydd, yng Nghymru ar ei isaf yn y gogledd-ddwyrain. Fe wnes i gyfarfod â chwmnïau yn ardal Glannau Dyfrdwy pan oeddwn i yn y gogledd dim ond cwpwl o wythnosau yn ôl. Maen nhw'n gwybod ei bod hi'n farchnad gystadleuol i ddenu, yn enwedig, pobl ifanc i fanteisio ar y cyfleoedd gwaith sydd ar gael iddyn nhw, ac roedden nhw'n gwerthfawrogi'n fawr y gwaith y mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn ei wneud ac yn enwedig y darparwyr llawr gwlad hynny—Coleg Cambria ac eraill—y pethau y maen nhw'n eu gwneud i alinio'r rhaglenni y maen nhw'n eu darparu gydag anghenion y dyfodol diwydiannol gwyrdd gwych hwnnw rydym ni eisiau ei greu yma yng Nghymru. A byddwn yn ddiolchgar iawn i Jack Sargeant pe gallai, ar ein rhan ni, ar ran Llywodraeth Cymru, atgyfnerthu, gyda'r fforwm busnes hwnnw, ein penderfyniad i barhau i weithio ochr yn ochr â nhw a'r system addysg i wneud yn siŵr ein bod ni'n cynhyrchu pobl ifanc sydd â'r sgiliau y bydd eu hangen arnyn nhw i greu dyfodol llwyddiannus iddyn nhw eu hunain, ac i gyfrannu at y cyflogwyr gwych hynny sydd gennym ni yng ngogledd-ddwyrain Cymru.

Dolydd Blodau Gwyllt
Wildflower Meadows

4. Pa asesiad y mae'r Gweinidog wedi'i wneud o effaith dolydd blodau gwyllt ar fywyd gwyllt yn Sir Ddinbych? OQ58599

4. What assessment has the Minister made of the impact of wildflower meadows on wildlife in Denbighshire? OQ58599

Llywydd, the Denbighshire wildflower project recorded 268 wildflower species on their sites in 2021. One-hundred-and-thirty-six of those species had not been found there before, and the site network of the project is growing every year, supported by Welsh Government's Local Places for Nature initiative.60

Llywydd, cofnododd prosiect blodau gwyllt sir Ddinbych 268 o rywogaethau blodau gwyllt ar eu safleoedd yn 2021. Nid oedd 136 o'r rhywogaethau hynny wedi cael eu canfod yno o'r blaen, ac mae rhwydwaith safleoedd y prosiect yn tyfu bob blwyddyn, wedi'i gefnogi gan fenter Lleoedd Lleol ar gyfer Natur Llywodraeth Cymru.

Thank you for that response, First Minister, and the reason I ask the question this afternoon is that I've been contacted by many residents from the Nant Close area of Rhuddlan, and from the coastal areas of Rhyl and Prestatyn over the summer, who are very concerned about some of the uses of wildflower meadows in built-up residential areas. Now, I can certainly see the benefit of wildflower meadows and the positive effects these have on promoting biodiversity and wildlife in Denbighshire, but would you join me, First Minister, in calling on Denbighshire and local authorities to adopt a more common-sense approach to such projects? So, where there is good evidence of effectiveness, then by all means keep them, but when there is little evidence of this, then to cut them down and restore some horticultural order, so that we can dispel the myth that the council can't be bothered to cut the lawn and give my constituents assurances that—[Interruption.]61

Diolch am yr ymateb yna, Prif Weinidog, a'r rheswm rwy'n gofyn y cwestiwn y prynhawn yma yw bod nifer o drigolion ardal Nant Close yn Rhuddlan wedi cysylltu â mi, ac o ardaloedd arfordirol y Rhyl a Phrestatyn dros yr haf, sy'n bryderus iawn am rai o ddefnyddiau dolydd blodau gwyllt mewn ardaloedd preswyl adeiledig. Nawr, gallaf yn sicr weld budd dolydd blodau gwyllt a'r effeithiau cadarnhaol y mae'r rhain yn eu cael ar hybu bioamrywiaeth a bywyd gwyllt yn sir Ddinbych, ond a fyddech chi'n ymuno â mi, Prif Weinidog, i alw ar sir Ddinbych ac awdurdodau lleol i fabwysiadu agwedd fwy synnwyr cyffredin at brosiectau o'r fath? Felly, lle ceir tystiolaeth dda o effeithiolrwydd, yna cadwch nhw ar bob cyfrif, ond pan nad oes llawer o dystiolaeth o hyn, yna torrwch nhw i lawr ac adfer rhywfaint o drefn arddwriaethol, fel y gallwn ni chwalu'r myth bod y cyngor yn rhy ddiog i dorri'r lawnt a rhoi sicrwydd i'm hetholwyr bod—[Torri ar draws.]

Let the Member finish his question. Let the Member finish his question, please.62

Gadewch i'r Aelod orffen ei gwestiwn. Gadewch i'r Aelod orffen ei gwestiwn, os gwelwch yn dda.

Thank you. So that we can dispel the myth that the council can't be bothered to cut the lawn and give my constituents assurances that next summer will be more effective than this one.63

Diolch. Fel y gallwn ni chwalu'r myth bod y cyngor yn rhy ddiog i dorri'r lawnt a rhoi sicrwydd i'm hetholwyr y bydd yr haf nesaf yn fwy effeithiol na'r un yma.

Well, Llywydd, I genuinely didn't imagine this afternoon that we would hear that the Welsh Conservative party is against flowers. [Laughter.] They're against almost everything else, but I hadn't expected to see wildflower meadows added to their list of things that they don't support in modern Wales. Of course, I do not support what he said this afternoon. In fact, I absolutely congratulate Denbighshire council.64

And by the way, Llywydd, these would have been the actions of Denbighshire council at a time when the Conservative Party was part of the administration of Denbighshire council, because you don't create a wildflower meadow in five minutes. It can take a number of years to achieve what his colleagues managed to achieve in Denbighshire.65

I think it's a matter of genuine congratulation to the Denbighshire wildflower project, working with the local authority, that they have been able to create nearly 50 acres of native local-provenance meadows across the county. That is a really significant achievement. It is a proper contribution to sustaining biodiversity, to doing the things that we can do that make a difference. I congratulate them, and I think their local Member would be far better off supporting those efforts rather than carping from the sidelines about them.66

Wel, Llywydd, wnes i wir ddim dychmygu'r prynhawn yma y byddem ni'n clywed bod plaid Geidwadol Cymru yn erbyn blodau. [Chwerthin.] Maen nhw yn erbyn bron popeth arall, ond doeddwn i ddim wedi disgwyl gweld dolydd blodau gwyllt yn cael eu hychwanegu at eu rhestr o bethau nad ydyn nhw'n eu cefnogi yn y Gymru fodern. Wrth gwrs, nid wyf i'n cefnogi'r hyn a ddywedodd y prynhawn yma. A dweud y gwir, rwy'n llongyfarch Cyngor Sir Ddinbych yn llwyr.

A gyda llaw, Llywydd, dyma fyddai gweithredoedd Cyngor Sir Ddinbych wedi bod ar adeg pan oedd y Blaid Geidwadol yn rhan o weinyddiaeth Cyngor Sir Ddinbych, oherwydd nid ydych chi'n creu dôl blodau gwyllt mewn pum munud. Gall hi gymryd nifer o flynyddoedd i gyflawni'r hyn y llwyddodd ei gydweithwyr i'w gyflawni yn sir Ddinbych.

Rwy'n credu ei fod yn fater o glod gwirioneddol i brosiect blodau gwyllt sir Ddinbych, yn gweithio gyda'r awdurdod lleol, eu bod nhw wedi gallu creu bron i 50 erw o ddolydd brodorol lleol ar draws y sir. Mae honno'n gamp sylweddol iawn. Mae'n gyfraniad go iawn at gynnal bioamrywiaeth, i wneud y pethau y gallwn ni eu gwneud sy'n gwneud gwahaniaeth. Rwy'n eu llongyfarch, ac rwy'n credu y byddai'n llawer gwell i'w Haelod lleol gefnogi'r ymdrechion hynny yn hytrach na lladd arnyn nhw o'r ymylon.

14:20

Can I just declare an interest? I'm a member of the North Wales Wildlife Trust. Thank you. I attended the wildlife trust annual general meeting on Saturday. They do great work with landowners regarding managing them for nature, and the chief executive officer spoke of significant concerns about UK Government policies weakening environmental protections on leaving the EU, and also deregulation under investment zones. She spoke about how Wales is leading the way regarding policies for nature, and one great project is the 'It's for Them' Welsh Government nature project, working with councils and local nature partnerships, managing verges and amenity grasslands for biodiversity, taking the residents along with them. North Wales Conservative MPs have been writing to council leaders, including Denbighshire's, encouraging them to show an interest in these investment deregulation zones, and I know that two bordering English council leaders were not consulted before being added to the list.67

So, First Minister, will you write to north Wales council leaders, sharing your concerns regarding the pressure put on them regarding the natural environment under the deregulated investment zones? And could you also write in support of the good work they're doing in the 'It's for Them' project, managing our wildlife areas and grass verges for biodiversity, so we can bring our residents along with them? I'm worried that it might fall lower down the list under austerity 2. Thank you.68

A gaf i ddatgan diddordeb yn gyflym? Rwy'n aelod o Ymddiriedolaeth Natur Gogledd Cymru. Diolch. Fe es i gyfarfod cyffredinol blynyddol yr ymddiriedolaeth natur ddydd Sadwrn. Maen nhw'n gwneud gwaith gwych gyda thirfeddianwyr o ran eu rheoli nhw ar gyfer natur, a siaradodd y prif swyddog gweithredol am bryderon sylweddol am bolisïau Llywodraeth y DU yn gwanhau amddiffyniadau amgylcheddol o adael yr UE, a hefyd dadreoleiddio o dan barthau buddsoddi. Siaradodd am y ffordd y mae Cymru'n arwain y ffordd o ran polisïau natur, ac un prosiect gwych yw prosiect natur 'Iddyn Nhw' Llywodraeth Cymru, yn gweithio gyda chynghorau a phartneriaethau natur lleol, gan reoli lleiniau ymyl ffordd a glaswelltiroedd amwynder ar gyfer bioamrywiaeth, gan sicrhau cefnogaeth y trigolion. Mae Aelodau Seneddol Ceidwadol y gogledd wedi bod yn ysgrifennu at arweinwyr cynghorau, gan gynnwys rhai sir Ddinbych, yn eu hannog i ddangos diddordeb yn y parthau dadreoleiddio buddsoddi hyn, a gwn na ymgynghorwyd â dau arweinydd cynghorau yn Lloegr sydd ar y ffin cyn iddyn nhw gael eu hychwanegu at y rhestr.

Felly, Prif Weinidog, a wnewch chi ysgrifennu at arweinwyr cynghorau gogledd Cymru, i rannu eich pryderon ynglŷn â'r pwysau sydd arnyn nhw o ran yr amgylchedd naturiol o dan y parthau buddsoddi wedi'u dadreoleiddio? Ac a allech chi hefyd ysgrifennu i gefnogi'r gwaith da y maen nhw'n ei wneud yn y prosiect 'Iddyn Nhw', yn rheoli ein hardaloedd bywyd gwyllt a'n lleiniau glaswellt ar gyfer bioamrywiaeth, fel y gallwn sicrhau cefnogaeth ein trigolion ynghyd â nhw? Rwy'n poeni y gallai ddisgyn ymhellach i lawr y rhestr o dan gyni cyllidol 2. Diolch.

Well, Llywydd, first of all, can I thank Carolyn Thomas for all the work that she has done, commissioned by the Deputy Minister for Climate Change, to champion better management of our road verges and grasslands across north Wales? Carolyn Thomas is absolutely right, Llywydd. This is what deregulation means. In practice, what it means is stripping away the protections that you and I have so that we can preserve our environment, so that we can make sure that the rights we enjoy are there for us for the future. This is a real issue for us here in Wales, because we have cross-border designated sites where we will want to make sure that the highest standards are maintained, and we will not take kindly to the idea that those standards should be lowered in pursuit of some sort of ideological commitment to removing the protections that exist at the moment.69

I'm very happy to write, in the way that the Member has suggested, to congratulate those north Wales authorities who are doing great work in this area and to make sure that they understand that in the Welsh Government they have a Government that is on their side.[1]70

Wel, Llywydd, yn gyntaf oll, a gaf i ddiolch i Carolyn Thomas am yr holl waith y mae hi wedi ei wneud, a gomisiynwyd gan y Dirprwy Weinidog Newid Hinsawdd, i hyrwyddo gwell rheolaeth o'n lleiniau ffyrdd a'n glaswelltiroedd ar draws y gogledd? Mae Carolyn Thomas yn llygad ei lle, Llywydd. Dyma beth mae dadreoleiddio yn ei olygu. Yn ymarferol, yr hyn y mae'n ei olygu yw diddymu'r amddiffyniadau sydd gennych chi a minnau fel y gallwn ni warchod ein hamgylchedd, fel y gallwn ni wneud yn siŵr bod yr hawliau rydym ni'n eu mwynhau yno ar ein cyfer ni ar gyfer y dyfodol. Mae hon yn broblem wirioneddol i ni yma yng Nghymru, oherwydd mae gennym ni safleoedd dynodedig trawsffiniol lle byddwn ni eisiau gwneud yn siŵr bod y safonau uchaf yn cael eu cynnal, ac ni fyddwn yn hapus iawn â'r syniad y dylid gostwng y safonau hynny i fynd ar drywydd rhyw fath o ymrwymiad ideolegol i ddileu'r amddiffyniadau sy'n bodoli ar hyn o bryd.

Rwy'n hapus iawn i ysgrifennu, yn y ffordd y mae'r Aelod wedi awgrymu, i longyfarch yr awdurdodau hynny yn y gogledd sy'n gwneud gwaith gwych yn y maes hwn a gwneud yn siŵr eu bod nhw'n deall bod ganddyn nhw yn Llywodraeth Cymru Lywodraeth sydd ar eu hochr nhw.[1]

Gofal Cymdeithasol
Social Care

5. Pa gefnogaeth y mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn ei darparu i weithlu gofal cymdeithasol Cymru? OQ58637

5. What support is the Welsh Government providing to Wales's social care workforce? OQ58637

Wel, Llywydd, diolch i Hefin David am y cwestiwn. Rydyn ni'n gweithio'n agos gyda'n partneriaid gofal cymdeithasol i wella telerau ac amodau cyflogaeth y gweithlu. Mae £43 miliwn wedi cael ei ddarparu i'r sector i'w helpu i gynyddu cyflogau i'r cyflog byw gwirioneddol. Yn ogystal â hynny, mae £45 miliwn wedi cael ei roi ar ffurf grant y gweithlu i awdurdodau lleol eleni.71

Well, Llywydd, I thank Hefin David for the question. We are working closely with our social care partners to improve the employment terms and conditions of the workforce. Forty-three million pounds has been provided to the sector to help it increase wages to the real living wage. In addition to that, £45 million has been distributed as a workforce grant to local authorities this year.

Diolch am yr ateb.72

Thank you for that answer.

This question follows on, in many ways, from my question last week about the ambulance service. This is the other end of the scale, where delays further down the way with the ambulance service might be caused by delayed transfers of care, which of course rely hugely on the social care workforce. I took a call this week and last week as well from Neville Southall, who is working for Unison, trying to get care homes to recognise the value of their workforce, and working with care homes and Unison to do that, and he said there are a few things that could happen to help things improve. First of all, pay, and the First Minister has recognised that the real living wage is vital; there is also recruitment, as those people who are working in the care sector are finding that they are overburdened with work; there is working conditions, which lack parity with the NHS; there is trade union recognition, which is vitally important; and overall that amounts to parity of esteem with their fellow NHS workers. And what Neville Southall told me was that he was finding that people in the care sector were feeling less recognised than their NHS counterparts during the pandemic. So, all of these things together are important. Would the First Minister be willing to allow officials to meet with me and with Neville Southall, and the Minister, to discuss some of these issues and try to find a way through that would be helpful to him in his work?73

Mae'r cwestiwn yma'n dilyn ymlaen, mewn sawl ffordd, o fy nghwestiwn yr wythnos diwethaf am y gwasanaeth ambiwlans. Pen arall y raddfa yw hon, lle gallai oedi ymhellach i lawr y ffordd gyda'r gwasanaeth ambiwlans gael ei achosi drwy oedi wrth drosglwyddo gofal, sydd wrth gwrs yn dibynnu'n enfawr ar y gweithlu gofal cymdeithasol. Cefais alwad yr wythnos hon a'r wythnos ddiwethaf hefyd gan Neville Southall, sy'n gweithio i Unsain, yn ceisio cael cartrefi gofal i gydnabod gwerth eu gweithlu, a gweithio gyda chartrefi gofal ac Unsain i wneud hynny, a dywedodd bod ychydig o bethau a allai ddigwydd i helpu pethau i wella. Yn gyntaf oll, cyflog, ac mae'r Prif Weinidog wedi cydnabod bod y cyflog byw gwirioneddol yn hanfodol; ceir recriwtio hefyd, gan fod y bobl hynny sy'n gweithio yn y sector gofal yn gweld eu bod nhw'n cael eu gorlwytho â gwaith; ceir amodau gwaith, nad ydyn nhw'n gyfartal â'r GIG; ceir cydnabyddiaeth undebau llafur, sy'n hanfodol bwysig; ac ar y cyfan mae hynny'n gyfystyr â chyd-barch â'u cydweithwyr yn y GIG. A'r hyn a ddywedodd Neville Southall wrthyf i oedd ei fod yn canfod bod pobl yn y sector gofal yn teimlo eu bod nhw'n cael eu cydnabod llai na'u cymheiriaid yn y GIG yn ystod y pandemig. Felly, mae'r pethau hyn i gyd gyda'i gilydd yn bwysig. A fyddai'r Prif Weinidog yn barod i ganiatáu i swyddogion gyfarfod gyda mi a gyda Neville Southall, a'r Gweinidog, i drafod rhai o'r materion hyn a cheisio dod o hyd i ffordd drwy hynny a fyddai o gymorth iddo yn ei waith?

14:25

Well, Llywydd, Hefin David made a series of important points there, all of which I think the Welsh Government would agree with and all of which are areas in which we continue to make our efforts. I mentioned the £43 million we're investing in securing the real living wage for our social care workforce, the additional investment that we have made—£10 million in fact, on top of the £45 million we normally provide in the annual workforce grant, to help local authorities in their efforts to recruit and then to retain social care workers, and raising the status of the profession is really important in doing that. It's why this Senedd passed legislation to require the registration of the workforce. More than 40,000 workers in social care are already registered or are about to be registered here in Wales. We began with the registration of domiciliary care workers, we moved on to the registration of adult care homes as well, and that is important because it's through registration that you open the door to career progression, training, opportunities, leadership training. The social care fair work forum, which we've established as part of the social partnership forum, has just concluded the first iteration of a model that they are going to promote for progression by workers in social care. So, if you become a social care worker, you can see how a career could lie in front of you, as you would, indeed, if you joined the NHS. I'm very happy to look to see whether a conversation between the forum and Mr Southall would be a good way of taking forward some of the points he has made, relayed by the Member for Caerphilly this afternoon.[2]74

Wel, Llywydd, fe wnaeth Hefin David gyfres o bwyntiau pwysig yn y fan yna, yr wyf i'n credu y byddai Llywodraeth Cymru yn cytuno â phob un ohonyn nhw ac sydd i gyd yn feysydd yr ydym ni'n parhau i wneud ein hymdrechion ynddyn nhw. Soniais am y £43 miliwn yr ydym ni'n ei fuddsoddi mewn sicrhau'r cyflog byw gwirioneddol i'n gweithlu gofal cymdeithasol, y buddsoddiad ychwanegol rydym ni wedi ei wneud—£10 miliwn a dweud y gwir, ar ben y £45 miliwn rydym ni'n ei ddarparu fel rheol yn y grant gweithlu blynyddol, i helpu awdurdodau lleol yn eu hymdrechion i recriwtio ac yna chadw gweithwyr gofal cymdeithasol, ac mae codi statws y proffesiwn yn bwysig iawn i wneud hynny. Dyna pam y pasiodd y Senedd hon ddeddfwriaeth i'w gwneud yn ofynnol cofrestru'r gweithlu. Mae dros 40,000 o weithwyr ym maes gofal cymdeithasol eisoes wedi'u cofrestru neu ar fin cael eu cofrestru yma yng Nghymru. Fe wnaethon ni ddechrau trwy gofrestru gweithwyr gofal cartref, fe wnaethon ni symud ymlaen i gofrestru cartrefi gofal i oedolion hefyd, ac mae hynny'n bwysig gan mai trwy gofrestru rydych chi'n agor y drws i ddatblygiad gyrfaol, hyfforddiant, cyfleoedd, hyfforddiant arweinyddiaeth. Mae'r fforwm gwaith teg gofal cymdeithasol, yr ydym ni wedi ei sefydlu yn rhan o'r fforwm partneriaeth gymdeithasol, newydd gwblhau'r fersiwn gyntaf o fodel y maen nhw'n mynd i'w hyrwyddo ar gyfer datblygiad gan weithwyr ym maes gofal cymdeithasol. Felly, os byddwch chi'n dod yn weithiwr gofal cymdeithasol, gallwch weld sut y gallai gyrfa ddatblygu o'ch blaen, fel y byddech chi, yn wir, pe byddech chi'n ymuno â'r GIG. Rwy'n hapus iawn i edrych i weld a fyddai sgwrs rhwng y fforwm a Mr Southall yn ffordd dda o fwrw ymlaen â rhai o'r pwyntiau y mae wedi eu gwneud, a gyflëwyd gan yr Aelod dros Gaerffili y prynhawn yma.[2]

My own local authority, Conwy County Borough Council, currently commissions around 790 beds supporting individuals in residential and/or nursing care. The gross spend within Conwy on residential and nursing services was £23 million in the last financial year, with only a potential uplift going forward of around 7 to 9 per cent—that's 7 to 9 per cent, not 79 per cent. Yet, in some other local authorities, where year on year they hold back in reserve, in some local authorities, a couple of hundred million in reserves, providers are indicating to the local authority that the combination of unpredicted high levels of inflation, increasing care levels, complex services and current workforce pressures are resulting in a financial shortfall relating to residential and nursing care—and I saw this first-hand when I visited a care home recently. First Minister, do you agree with me that the rates paid by any local authority to care homes should increase by at least inflation? And what steps are you taking to ensure that there's a fairer funding settlement and one that better reflects the true cost of social care need within our local authorities? Diolch.75

Ar hyn o bryd mae fy awdurdod lleol fy hun, Cyngor Bwrdeistref Sirol Conwy, yn comisiynu tua 790 o welyau sy'n cefnogi unigolion mewn gofal preswyl a/neu nyrsio. £23 miliwn oedd y gwariant gros yng Nghonwy ar wasanaethau preswyl a nyrsio yn y flwyddyn ariannol ddiwethaf, gyda chynnydd posibl yn y dyfodol o ddim ond tua 7 i 9 y cant—7 i 9 y cant, nid 79 y cant. Ac eto, mewn rhai awdurdodau lleol eraill, lle maen nhw'n cadw cronfa wrth gefn flwyddyn ar ôl blwyddyn, mewn rhai awdurdodau lleol, cwpl o gannoedd o filiynau wrth gefn, mae darparwyr yn hysbysu'r awdurdod lleol bod y cyfuniad o lefelau uchel na ragwelwyd o chwyddiant, lefelau gofal cynyddol, gwasanaethau cymhleth a phwysau gweithlu cyfredol yn arwain at ddiffyg ariannol yn ymwneud â gofal preswyl a nyrsio—ac fe welais hyn yn bersonol pan ymwelais â chartref gofal yn ddiweddar. Prif Weinidog, a ydych chi'n cytuno â mi y dylai'r cyfraddau a delir gan unrhyw awdurdod lleol i gartrefi gofal gynyddu yn unol â chwyddiant o leiaf? A pha gamau ydych chi'n eu cymryd i sicrhau bod setliad ariannu tecach ac un sy'n adlewyrchu'n well gwir gost yr angen gofal cymdeithasol yn ein hawdurdodau lleol? Diolch.

Llywydd, we've rehearsed many times here the calls that come from different parts of Wales to reform the funding formula, and we have always said, as a Government, that when local authorities come forward with a proposal for reform, of course we will be prepared to discuss it with them. What we cannot possibly do, as the Member will understand, is negotiate a separate formula for each of the 22 local authorities. There is a single formula, as there is in England, as there is in Scotland. It's unavoidable that you have a single system. The system can be reformed, but it can only be reformed with the agreement of local authorities themselves. And, as to the point that she makes about guaranteeing an in-line-with-inflation rise in the funding of those services, I hope she is relaying that point to the new Government at Westminster, because if they will give us that uplift, we will definitely give it to the services that she has spoken about this afternoon.76

Llywydd, rydym wedi trafod droeon yma y galwadau a ddaw o wahanol rannau o Gymru i ddiwygio'r fformiwla ariannu, ac rydym ni bob amser wedi dweud, fel Llywodraeth, y byddwn ni, wrth gwrs, yn barod i drafod y peth gydag awdurdodau lleol pan fyddan nhw'n cyflwyno cynnig ar gyfer diwygio. Yr hyn na allwn ei wneud o bosibl, fel y bydd yr Aelod yn ei ddeall, yw cytuno ar fformiwla ar wahân ar gyfer pob un o'r 22 awdurdod lleol. Ceir un fformiwla, fel sydd yn Lloegr, fel sydd yn yr Alban. Nid oes modd osgoi bod gennych chi un system. Gellir diwygio'r system, ond dim ond gyda chytundeb awdurdodau lleol eu hunain y gellir ei diwygio. Ac, o ran y pwynt y mae hi'n ei wneud ynglŷn â sicrhau cynnydd yn unol â chwyddiant i gyllid ar gyfer y gwasanaethau hynny, rwy'n gobeithio ei bod hi'n cyfleu'r pwynt hwnnw i'r Llywodraeth newydd yn San Steffan, oherwydd os byddan nhw'n rhoi'r cynnydd hwnnw i ni, byddwn yn bendant yn ei roi i'r gwasanaethau y mae hi wedi siarad amdanyn nhw y prynhawn yma.

14:30
Amseroedd Aros Canser
Cancer Waiting Times

6. Pa gamau y mae Llywodraeth Cymru'n eu cymryd i wella amseroedd aros canser y GIG? OQ58607

6. What action is the Welsh Government taking to improve NHS cancer waiting times? OQ58607

Innovation, additional investment and recruitment of specialist staff are amongst the actions being taken alongside clinical leaders to reduce cancer waiting times.77

Mae arloesedd, buddsoddiad ychwanegol a recriwtio staff arbenigol ymhlith y camau sy'n cael eu cymryd ochr yn ochr ag arweinwyr clinigol i leihau amseroedd aros canser.

Thank you, First Minister. The latest data released on cancer cases showed that, in August, only 52.5 per cent reached the Government's 62-day target of starting treatment—the lowest number since records were collected. One of my constituents has been waiting over seven months for cancer treatment. In previous years, he had mouth cancer and had accessed Hereford hospital, where he was successfully treated within three months following referral for both mouth cancer and subsequent nose cancer. Upon moving to my constituency, he developed a small cancer on his ear, requiring a relatively small procedure. However, as a direct result of being stuck on the Welsh NHS waiting list, he is likely now to lose his hearing and his ear. What started as a small cancerous growth, which could have been removed with early intervention, has now grown into something absolutely horrendous for the individual. 78

I thank the health Minister for her correspondence in relation to this, but, First Minister, whilst it's welcome news that Wales is rolling out rapid diagnosis centres, unfortunately, it's too late for my constituent. Do you agree that more action is needed to tackle lagging treatment in Wales to stop people going through such an ordeal, and what hope can the Government provide to people who are suffering like my constituent?79

Diolch. Dangosodd y data ddiweddaraf a gafodd ei ryddhau ar achosion canser, mai dim ond 52.5 y cant ym mis Awst a gyrhaeddodd nod y Llywodraeth o ddechrau triniaeth o fewn 62 diwrnod—y nifer lleiaf ers i gofnodion gael eu casglu. Mae un o fy etholwyr i wedi bod yn aros dros saith mis am driniaeth canser. Yn y blynyddoedd blaenorol, roedd wedi cael canser y geg ac roedd wedi cael mynediad i ysbyty Henffordd, lle cafodd driniaeth lwyddiannus o fewn tri mis ar ôl cael ei gyfeirio am ganser y geg a chanser y trwyn wedi hynny. Ar ôl symud i fy etholaeth i, datblygodd ganser bach ar ei glust, a oedd yn gofyn am driniaeth gymharol fach. Ond o ganlyniad uniongyrchol i fod yn sownd ar restr aros GIG Cymru, mae'n debygol nawr o golli ei glyw a'i glust. Mae'r hyn a ddechreuodd fel twf bach canseraidd, a allai fod wedi'i dynnu gydag ymyrraeth gynnar, nawr wedi tyfu'n rhywbeth cwbl erchyll i'r unigolyn. 

Diolch i'r Gweinidog iechyd am ei gohebiaeth o ran hyn, ond, yn gyntaf Prif Weinidog, er ei fod yn newyddion i'w groesawu bod Cymru'n cyflwyno canolfannau diagnosis cyflym, yn anffodus, mae'n rhy hwyr i fy etholwr i. Ydych chi'n cytuno bod angen mwy o weithredu i ymdrin â thriniaeth ar ei hôl hi yng Nghymru i atal pobl rhag mynd drwy ddioddefaint o'r fath, a pha obaith y gall y Llywodraeth ei ddarparu i bobl sy'n dioddef fel fy etholwr i?

I thank Peter Fox for that question. I've been able to read his letter to the health Minister and I've seen her reply. I hope that it will provide some information that is useful for his constituent in what are clearly very distressing individual circumstances. 80

The system works hard every month to deal with the increased volume of cases that come through the door. And it's a good thing that more cases come through the door, because we want to ensure that people are referred into the system as early as possible. August saw the highest number of patients treated in this financial year, and it saw the highest ever number of patients told that they did not have cancer—13,500 patients in Wales in August went through the system and were told that they didn't have that awful disease hanging over them. When you count up the people who were treated, and the people who were told they didn't need treatment, that comes to over 14,500 people, which are the highest numbers we've ever managed. And yet 16,000 people were referred into the system in the same month. As I say, Llywydd, that is good news, because that means we are seeing more people, and earlier, and hopefully more of those people will find out that they don't have to face a cancer diagnosis.81

But you will see, and the Member for Monmouth will see, that even if you are managing record numbers of people coming through the system, if you've got record numbers of people coming into the system, the system is still flat out. That's why we do have the new rapid diagnostic centres, that's why we have the new one-stop clinics, that's why we are developing the straight-to-test diagnostics system. All of these are efforts being made by clinicians to find a way of both responding to the new referrals and dealing with people who have been in the system too long already. 82

Diolch i Peter Fox am y cwestiwn yna. Rydw i wedi gallu darllen ei lythyr at y Gweinidog iechyd ac rydw i wedi gweld ei hateb. Gobeithio y bydd yn rhoi rhywfaint o wybodaeth sy'n ddefnyddiol i'w etholwr yn yr hyn sy'n amlwg yn amgylchiadau unigol sy'n peri gofid mawr. 

Mae'r system yn gweithio'n galed bob mis i ymdrin â'r cynnydd yn nifer yr achosion sy'n dod drwy'r drws. Ac mae'n beth da bod mwy o achosion yn dod drwy'r drws, oherwydd rydym ni eisiau sicrhau bod pobl yn cael eu cyfeirio i'r system mor gynnar â phosibl. Ym mis Awst, cafodd y nifer uchaf o gleifion eu trin yn y flwyddyn ariannol hon, a chafodd y nifer uchaf erioed o gleifion wybod nad oedd ganddyn nhw ganser—aeth 13,500 o gleifion yng Nghymru ym mis Awst drwy'r system a chael gwybod nad oedd ganddyn nhw'r clefyd ofnadwy hwnnw'n pwyso arnyn nhw. Pan ydych chi'n cyfri'r bobl a gafodd eu trin, a'r bobl a gafodd wybod nad oedden nhw angen triniaeth, mae hynny'n dod i dros 14,500 o bobl, sef y niferoedd uchaf yr ydym ni erioed wedi ymdopi ag ef. Ac eto cafodd 16,000 o bobl eu cyfeirio at y system yn yr un mis. Fel yr wyf i'n ei ddweud, Llywydd, mae hynny'n newyddion da, oherwydd mae hynny'n golygu ein bod ni'n gweld mwy o bobl, ac yn gynharach, a gobeithio bydd mwy o'r bobl yna'n darganfod nad oed angen iddyn nhw wynebu diagnosis o ganser.

Ond fe welwch chi, a bydd yr Aelod dros Fynwy yn gweld, hyd yn oed os ydych chi'n ymdopi â nifer uchaf erioed o bobl sy'n dod trwy'r system, os oes gennych chi'r niferoedd uchaf erioed o bobl yn dod i mewn i'r system, mae'r system yn dal i fod wedi'i hymestyn i'r eithaf. Dyna pam mae gennym ni'r canolfannau diagnostig cyflym newydd, dyna pam mae gennym ni'r clinigau un stop newydd, dyna pam ein bod ni'n datblygu'r system diagnosteg symud yn syth at brofion. Mae'r rhain i gyd yn ymdrechion sy'n cael eu gwneud gan glinigwyr i ddod o hyd i ffordd o ymateb i'r cyfeiriadau newydd ac ymdrin â phobl sydd wedi bod yn y system yn rhy hir yn barod. 

Good afternoon, First Minister. As well as paying tribute to the health workers and those in our health professions who deal with cancer, there is also a range of charities who meet the needs of everybody suffering from cancer, and that includes the families of those suffering from cancer. Many of those have mental health issues, and people want to talk, not just the cancer sufferer, but those within the family and extended family. It's a very difficult time, and I thank my colleague Peter Fox for raising the issue and talking about that very sad situation. I do hope that the family of that person, as well as that sufferer, get the support that they need. 83

As well as the bigger charities like Macmillan and the Marie Curie trust, we also have, in Mid and West Wales, the wonderful Bracken Trust, based in Llandrindod Wells, which meets the needs of families and their carers. They have a drop-in service, a wig exchange service, and they just offer that support for families affected. I wonder if I could ask you, First Minister, what support can the Welsh Government give to those wonderful charities operating in the field with both the sufferer and the wider family? Thank you. Diolch yn fawr iawn.84

Prynhawn da, Prif Weinidog. Yn ogystal â thalu teyrnged i'r gweithwyr iechyd a'r rhai yn ein proffesiynau iechyd sy'n ymdrin â chanser, mae amrywiaeth o elusennau hefyd sy'n diwallu anghenion pawb sy'n dioddef o ganser, ac mae hynny'n cynnwys teuluoedd y rhai sy'n dioddef o ganser. Mae gan nifer o'r rheiny broblemau iechyd meddwl, ac mae pobl eisiau siarad, nid yn unig y dioddefwr canser, ond y rhai o fewn y teulu a'r teulu estynedig. Mae'n gyfnod anodd iawn, a diolch i fy nghydweithiwr Peter Fox am godi'r mater a siarad am y sefyllfa drist iawn honno. Rwy'n gobeithio y bydd teulu'r person hwnnw, yn ogystal â'r dioddefwr hwnnw, yn cael y gefnogaeth sydd ei angen arnyn nhw. 

Yn ogystal â'r elusennau mwy fel Macmillan ac ymddiriedolaeth Marie Curie, mae gennym ni hefyd, yn y canolbarth a'r gorllewin, y Bracken Trust wych yn Llandrindod, sy'n cwrdd ag anghenion teuluoedd a'u gofalwyr. Mae ganddyn nhw wasanaeth galw heibio, gwasanaeth cyfnewid wig, ac maen nhw yn cynnig y gefnogaeth yna i deuluoedd sy'n cael eu heffeithio. Tybed a gaf i ofyn i chi, Prif Weinidog, pa gefnogaeth y gall Llywodraeth Cymru ei rhoi i'r elusennau gwych hynny sy'n gweithredu yn y maes gyda'r dioddefwr a'r teulu ehangach? Diolch. Diolch yn fawr iawn.

14:35

I thank Jane Dodds; those are all very important points. She's absolutely right—it isn't just the individual, it's the family of the individual that gets caught up in a cancer diagnosis. And the physical impact of a cancer diagnosis is only one of the difficulties that families face. There is fantastic work done by third sector organisations in Wales, simply on trying to make sure that people get the financial help that they need. To be ill with cancer often means that people aren't able to earn in a way that they would have previously, and the benefits system is not sympathetic, in the way that it ought to be, to people who face those difficulties. So, there are practical issues, there are the wider health issues, including mental health impacts, of a diagnosis of that sort. The very many small and local organisations that exist throughout Wales are a sign of the strength of Welsh civic society—that people give their time, raise those moneys, provide those services. And there's the work that the Welsh Government does with the third sector partnership council, a part of our landscape since the very foundation of devolution. We recognise and work with that wider group of people in our society, who want to make sure that the core public services that are provided can be supported and augmented, particularly for people whose needs are greatest.85

Diolch i Jane Dodds; mae'r rheiny i gyd yn bwyntiau pwysig iawn. Mae hi'n hollol gywir—nid yr unigolyn yn unig sydd yma, teulu'r unigolyn sy'n cael ei ddal mewn diagnosis canser. A dim ond un o'r anawsterau mae teuluoedd yn ei wynebu yw effaith gorfforol diagnosis canser. Mae gwaith gwych yn cael ei wneud gan sefydliadau'r trydydd sector yng Nghymru, dim ond ar geisio sicrhau bod pobl yn cael yr help ariannol sydd ei angen arnyn nhw. Mae bod yn sâl gyda chanser yn aml yn golygu nad yw pobl yn gallu ennill arian mewn ffordd y byddai ganddyn nhw o'r blaen, ac nid yw'r system fudd-daliadau yn cydymdeimlo, yn y ffordd y dylai, â phobl sy'n wynebu'r anawsterau hynny. Felly, mae yna broblemau ymarferol, mae'r problemau iechyd ehangach, gan gynnwys effeithiau iechyd meddwl, o ddiagnosis o'r math yna. Mae'r llawer iawn o sefydliadau bach a lleol sy'n bodoli ledled Cymru yn arwydd o gryfder cymdeithas ddinesig Cymru—bod pobl yn rhoi o'u hamser, yn codi'r arian hynny, yn darparu'r gwasanaethau hynny. Ac mae'r gwaith mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn ei wneud gyda chyngor partneriaeth y trydydd sector, rhan o'n tirwedd ers sefydlu datganoli gyntaf. Rydym ni'n cydnabod ac yn gweithio gyda'r grŵp ehangach hwnnw o bobl yn ein cymdeithas, sydd eisiau sicrhau bod y gwasanaethau cyhoeddus craidd a ddarperir yn cael eu cefnogi a'u hymestyn, yn enwedig i bobl â'r anghenion mwyaf.

Bwrdd Iechyd Prifysgol Hywel Dda
Hywel Dda University Health Board

7. A wnaiff y Prif Weinidog ddatganiad am ddarparu gwasanaethau iechyd yn ardal Bwrdd Iechyd Prifysgol Hywel Dda? OQ58598

7. Will the First Minister make a statement on the delivery of health services in the Hywel Dda University Health Board area? OQ58598

Hywel Dda University Health Board is responsible for the provision of safe, sustainable, high-quality healthcare services for its local population, based on the most up-to-date clinical evidence and advice.86

Bwrdd Iechyd Prifysgol Hywel Dda sy'n gyfrifol am ddarparu gwasanaethau gofal iechyd diogel, cynaliadwy o ansawdd uchel i'w phoblogaeth leol, wedi'i seilio ar y dystiolaeth a'r cyngor clinigol diweddaraf.

First Minister, as I'm sure you're aware, on Saturday, it's World Stroke Day, and I hope Members all took the opportunity to meet with the Stroke Association outside on the Senedd steps earlier to learn more about stroke care and the positive impact that thrombectomy can have on stroke patients. In my health board area, the rate of thrombectomy in 2020-21 was 0.15 per cent, meaning that far too few stroke patients were able to have one. And yet we know that this treatment can make a life-changing difference and significantly reduce the chance of disabilities like paralysis, blindness or communication difficulties. So, First Minister, what work is being done to urgently increase the thrombectomy rate in the Hywel Dda University Health Board area, so that more and more people in my constituency can have access to this very vital treatment?87

Prif Weinidog, fel yr wyf i'n siŵr eich bod chi'n ymwybodol, ddydd Sadwrn, mae'n Ddiwrnod Strôc y Byd, ac rwy'n gobeithio y bydd yr Aelodau i gyd wedi manteisio ar y cyfle i gwrdd â'r Gymdeithas Strôc y tu allan ar risiau'r Senedd yn gynharach i ddysgu mwy am ofal strôc a'r effaith gadarnhaol y gall thrombectomy ei gael ar gleifion strôc. Yn ardal fy mwrdd iechyd i, roedd y gyfradd thrombectomy yn 2020-21 yn 0.15 y cant, sy'n golygu nad oedd yn bosibl i ddigon o gleifion strôc gael un. Ac eto, rydym ni'n gwybod y gall y driniaeth hon wneud gwahaniaeth sy'n newid bywydau a lleihau'r siawns o anableddau fel parlys, dallineb neu anawsterau cyfathrebu yn sylweddol. Felly, Prif Weinidog, pa waith sy'n cael ei wneud i gynyddu'r gyfradd thrombectomy ar frys yn ardal Bwrdd Iechyd Prifysgol Hywel Dda, fel bod mwy a mwy o bobl yn fy etholaeth i'n gallu cael gafael ar y driniaeth hanfodol iawn hon?

I'm sure that Members across the Chamber will want to mark World Stroke Day, and to recognise the very significant advances that there have been in recent times in treatments available for stroke patients and the way in which the NHS has been able to respond to that. I'm not familiar enough with the specifics of the Member's question to give him a direct answer on those points this afternoon, but the health Minister is in her place, and I'm sure that she will have things that she can say tomorrow, I believe, when she is contributing on the floor of the Senedd, that will help to answer the important points that Paul Davies has made this afternoon.88

Rwy'n siŵr y bydd aelodau ar draws y Siambr eisiau nodi Diwrnod Strôc y Byd, ac i gydnabod y datblygiadau sylweddol iawn sydd wedi bod yn ddiweddar mewn triniaethau sydd ar gael i gleifion strôc a'r ffordd y mae'r GIG wedi gallu ymateb i hynny. Nid ydw i'n ddigon cyfarwydd â manylion cwestiwn yr Aelod i roi ateb uniongyrchol iddo ar y pwyntiau hynny y prynhawn yma, ond mae'r Gweinidog iechyd yn ei lle, ac rwy'n siŵr y bydd ganddi hi bethau y gall hi eu dweud yfory, rwy'n credu, pan fydd hi'n cyfrannu ar lawr y Senedd, bydd hynny'n help i ateb y pwyntiau pwysig mae Paul Davies wedi'u gwneud y prynhawn yma.

Datgarboneiddio Digidol
Digital Decarbonisation

8. Pa asesiad y mae Llywodraeth Cymru wedi'i wneud o'r angen am ddatgarboneiddio digidol? OQ58620

8. What assessment has the Welsh Government made of the need for digital decarbonisation? OQ58620

Digital technologies can materially assist the necessary effort to decarbonise Wales. However, deployment can, of itself, create a carbon footprint. Sustainable digital decarbonisation is therefore the ambition of the digital strategy for Wales.90

Gall technolegau digidol gynorthwyo'r ymdrech angenrheidiol i ddatgarboneiddio Cymru yn sylweddol. Fodd bynnag, gall y weithred o ddefnyddio, ei hun, greu ôl troed carbon. Datgarboneiddio digidol cynaliadwy felly yw uchelgais strategaeth ddigidol Cymru.

First Minister, more than 60 per cent of the digital data that firms generate is collected, processed and stored for single-use purposes only. This could include outdated spreadsheets, multiple near-identical images, or the thousands upon thousands of unread or stored e-mails that will never, ever be looked at again. This type of data is known as 'dark data' or 'unstructured data'. It currently produces 2.5 per cent of all global human-induced carbon dioxide emissions, which is more than the total aviation sector combined at 2.1 per cent. Worryingly, the volume of dark data is growing at a rate of 62 per cent a year, and the subsequent carbon dioxide that is produced is predicted to account for more than the aviation, automotive and energy sectors combined in only just a few years. Government policy and technological innovations focus primarily on tackling traditional carbon emissions and carbon sequestration without addressing the growing problem of dark data, but part of this Government's digital vision is to drive economic prosperity and resilience by embracing and exploiting digital innovation. With this in mind, First Minister, what steps are the Welsh Government taking to ensure that public bodies and private companies in Wales are putting mechanisms in place to address the carbon dioxide from dark data? Thank you.91

Prif Weinidog, mae mwy na 60 y cant o'r data digidol y mae cwmnïau'n ei gynhyrchu yn cael ei gasglu, ei brosesu a'i storio at ddibenion untro yn unig. Gallai hyn gynnwys hen daenlenni, nifer o ddelweddau bron yr un fath, neu'r miloedd ar filoedd o e-byst heb eu darllen neu wedi'u storio na fydd byth, byth yn cael eu hystyried eto. Caiff y math hwn o ddata ei alw'n 'ddata tywyll' neu 'ddata anstrwythuredig'. Ar hyn o bryd mae'n cynhyrchu 2.5 y cant o'r holl allyriadau carbon deuocsid byd-eang sy'n cael eu hachosi gan bobl, sy'n fwy na chyfanswm y sector hedfan at ei gilydd ar 2.1 y cant. Yn bryderus, mae maint y data tywyll yn tyfu ar gyfradd o 62 y cant y flwyddyn, a rhagwelir y bydd y carbon deuocsid dilynol sy'n cael ei gynhyrchu yn cyfrif am fwy na'r sectorau hedfan, modurol ac ynni gyda'i gilydd mewn dim ond ychydig flynyddoedd. Mae polisi'r Llywodraeth ac arloesi technolegol yn canolbwyntio'n bennaf ar ymdrin ag allyriadau carbon traddodiadol a dal a storio carbon heb ymdrin â phroblem gynyddol data tywyll, ond rhan o weledigaeth ddigidol y Llywodraeth hon yw hyrwyddo ffyniant a chadernid economaidd drwy groesawu a manteisio ar arloesi digidol. Gyda hyn mewn golwg, Prif Weinidog, pa gamau mae Llywodraeth Cymru'n eu cymryd i sicrhau bod cyrff cyhoeddus a chwmnïau preifat yng Nghymru yn rhoi dulliau ar waith i ymdrin â'r carbon deuocsid o ddata tywyll? Diolch.

14:40

I thank Joel James for that question. As it happens, because I make no claims to be an expert in this field, I was discussing that very issue with the chief digital officer for Wales very recently. I think it's an important question because it exposes an issue that in some ways has only come to the fore in public debate very recently. From the discussion I had, my understanding is there are two possible solutions to the point that the Member has made. First of all, there is a responsibility on those major companies that store data, including data stored in the cloud, to put into place actions that they could take already to reduce the storage of dark data and therefore to reduce its carbon imprint. In future, now that this is an issue that has come to greater prominence and greater understanding, when contracts are struck between public bodies and other businesses with the data provider, part of those new contract arrangements ought to be a way in which the fruitless storage of data that will never be used or seen again can become part of the contract you have with the provider, so that that data is disposed of in a way that does not lead to the adverse impacts that Joel James has highlighted this afternoon.92

Diolch i Joel James am y cwestiwn yna. Fel mae'n digwydd, oherwydd nid wyf i'n gwneud unrhyw honiadau fy mod i'n arbenigwr yn y maes hwn, roeddwn i'n trafod yr union fater yna gyda phrif swyddog digidol Cymru yn ddiweddar iawn. Rwy'n credu ei fod yn gwestiwn pwysig oherwydd mae'n amlygu mater sydd mewn rhai ffyrdd ond wedi dod i'r fei mewn dadl gyhoeddus yn ddiweddar iawn. O'r drafodaeth a gefais, fy nealltwriaeth i yw bod dau ateb posibl i'r pwynt y mae'r Aelod wedi'i wneud. Yn gyntaf oll, mae cyfrifoldeb ar y cwmnïau mawr hynny sy'n storio data, gan gynnwys data sy'n cael ei storio yn y cwmwl, i roi camau ar waith y gallen nhw eu cymryd eisoes i leihau storio data tywyll ac felly i leihau ei ôl carbon. Yn y dyfodol, nawr bod hwn yn fater sydd wedi dod i fwy o amlygrwydd a mwy o ddealltwriaeth, pan fydd contractau'n cael eu taro rhwng cyrff cyhoeddus a busnesau eraill gyda'r darparwr data, dylai rhan o'r trefniadau contract newydd hynny fod yn ffordd y gall storio data yn ofer na fydd byth yn cael ei ddefnyddio na'i weld eto ddod yn rhan o'r cytundeb sydd gennych chi gyda'r darparwr, fel bod y data hwnnw'n cael ei waredu mewn ffordd nad yw'n arwain at yr effeithiau niweidiol y mae Joel James wedi'u hamlygu y prynhawn yma.

2. Datganiad a Chyhoeddiad Busnes
2. Business Statement and Announcement

Yr eitem nesaf yw'r datganiad a chyhoeddiad busnes. Fe gaiff y Trefnydd wneud y datganiad hwnnw—Lesley Griffiths.94

The next item is the business statement and announcement. The Trefnydd will make that statement—Lesley Griffiths.

Diolch, Llywydd. There are three changes to this week's business. The statement on the national contemporary art gallery has been withdrawn. Additionally, the debate on the Welsh Language Commissioner's annual report has been postponed until 15 November. Finally, an oral statement on the closure of the Menai bridge has been added as the last item on today's agenda. Draft business for the next three weeks is set out on the business statement and announcement, which can be found amongst the meeting papers available to Members electronically.95

Diolch, Llywydd. Mae tri newid i'r busnes yr wythnos hon. Mae'r datganiad ar yr oriel gelf gyfoes genedlaethol wedi ei dynnu'n ôl. Hefyd, mae'r drafodaeth ar adroddiad blynyddol Comisiynydd y Gymraeg wedi'i gohirio tan 15 Tachwedd. Yn olaf, mae datganiad llafar ar gau pont Menai wedi'i ychwanegu fel yr eitem olaf ar agenda heddiw. Mae busnes drafft ar gyfer y tair wythnos nesaf wedi'i nodi ar y datganiad busnes a'r cyhoeddiad, sydd i'w weld ymhlith y papurau cyfarfod sydd ar gael i Aelodau yn electronig.

Trefnydd, last week, I had the pleasure of meeting with Diabetes UK and Member of Parliament Sir James Duddridge to discuss the lesser know type 3c diabetes, something that both James and my father suffer with. For those in the Chamber that aren't aware, type 3c is diagnosed when the pancreas not only stops producing insulin for the body but inhibits the production of digestive enzymes as well. This is often brought on by a host of other conditions, such an pancreatitis, pancreatic cancer, cystic fibrosis and haemochromatosis. However, despite its causes, it's frequently misdiagnosed, most often as type 2 diabetes. So, given its rarity and the importance of accurate diagnosis, can I ask that the health Minister, either orally or in a written statement, make a statement about the steps that the Welsh Government are taking to raise clinical awareness about type 3c diabetes and how individuals living with the condition can be supported? Diolch, Llywydd.96

Trefnydd, yr wythnos diwethaf, cefais i'r pleser o gyfarfod â Diabetes UK a'r Aelod Seneddol Syr James Duddridge i drafod y clefyd llai adnabyddus diabetes math 3c, rhywbeth y mae James a fy nhad yn dioddef ohono. I'r rhai yn y Siambr nad ydyn nhw'n ymwybodol, mae diagnosis math 3c yn digwydd pan fydd y pancreas nid yn unig yn stopio cynhyrchu inswlin ar gyfer y corff ond yn rhwystro cynhyrchu ensymau treuliol hefyd. Mae llu o gyflyrau eraill yn achosi hyn yn aml, fel pancreatitis, canser y pancreas, ffibrosis systig a haemochromatosis. Fodd bynnag, er gwaethaf ei achosion, yn aml mae'n cael camddiagnosis, gan amlaf fel diabetes math 2. Felly, o ystyried ei brinder a phwysigrwydd cael diagnosis cywir, a gaf i ofyn i'r Gweinidog iechyd, naill ai ar lafar neu mewn datganiad ysgrifenedig, wneud datganiad am y camau y mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn eu cymryd i godi ymwybyddiaeth glinigol am ddiabetes math 3c a sut y mae modd cefnogi unigolion sy'n byw gyda'r cyflwr? Diolch, Llywydd.

Thank you. I certainly think you've done a very good job in raising awareness of a very unknown, I think, type of diabetes. The Minister for Health and Social Services is in her place and has agreed to write to you on it.97

Diolch. Yn sicr, rwy'n credu eich bod chi wedi gwneud gwaith da iawn o ran codi ymwybyddiaeth o fath o ddiabetes anhysbys iawn. Mae'r Gweinidog Iechyd a Gwasanaethau Cymdeithasol yn ei lle ac wedi cytuno i ysgrifennu atoch chi am hyn.

Trefnydd, figures supplied to my office lay bare the capacity problems within the Welsh NHS. The Welsh ambulance trust is routinely losing more than 2,000 hours per month due to ambulances waiting outside just one hospital in my region. The fact that this hospital is the flagship Grange hospital is even more problematic, as this was meant to herald an improvement in health services for constituents. Can this Government therefore order a review into capacity issues within the NHS and the knock-on effect that this is having on other services and patient well-being? The status quo is failing patients, it's failing hospitals and it's failing ambulance staff. I hope you agree things are unacceptable and things cannot go on like this. 98

Trefnydd, roedd y ffigyrau a gafodd eu rhoi i fy swyddfa yn amlygu'r problemau capasiti o fewn GIG Cymru. Mae ymddiriedolaeth ambiwlansys Cymru yn colli mwy na 2,000 awr y mis yn rheolaidd oherwydd ambiwlansys yn aros y tu allan i un ysbyty yn unig yn fy rhanbarth i. Mae'r ffaith mai'r ysbyty hwn yw ysbyty blaenllaw y Faenor hyd yn oed yn fwy problematig, gan fod hyn i fod i gyflwyno gwelliant mewn gwasanaethau iechyd i etholwyr. A all y Llywodraeth hon felly orchymyn adolygiad i faterion capasiti o fewn y GIG a'r sgil-effaith y mae hyn yn ei gael ar wasanaethau eraill a lles cleifion? Mae'r drefn bresennol yn methu cleifion, mae'n methu ysbytai ac mae'n methu staff ambiwlans. Gobeithio eich bod chi'n cytuno bod pethau'n annerbyniol ac na all pethau fynd ymlaen fel hyn. 

14:45

Thank you. Well, the Member does raise a very important point, and it's certainly something that I think we've seen outside many of our hospitals in Wales, which is something that we don't want to see, and I know the Minister's been working very hard with all the health boards to try and improve the times that ambulances are waiting outside. Obviously, this is an issue with capacity in our emergency departments, and, again, I know the Minister's been working very hard to recruit more emergency consultants. I know, certainly, Betsi Cadwaladr, which I appreciate is not in your area, is an area where they've had a real focus. 99

Diolch. Wel, mae'r Aelod yn codi pwynt pwysig iawn, ac yn sicr mae'n rhywbeth rwy'n meddwl ein bod ni wedi'i weld y tu allan i lawer o'n hysbytai yng Nghymru, sy'n rhywbeth nad ydym ni eisiau'i weld, ac rwy'n gwybod bod y Gweinidog wedi bod yn gweithio'n galed iawn gyda'r holl fyrddau iechyd i geisio gwella'r amseroedd y mae ambiwlansys yn aros y tu allan. Yn amlwg, mae hwn yn broblem gyda gallu yn ein hadrannau brys, ac, unwaith eto, rwy'n gwybod bod y Gweinidog wedi bod yn gweithio'n galed iawn i recriwtio mwy o ymgynghorwyr meddygol brys. Rwy'n gwybod, yn sicr, bod Betsi Cadwaladr, nad yw, rwy'n gwerthfawrogi, yn eich ardal chi, yn faes lle maen nhw wir wedi bod â phwyslais gwirioneddol. 

I ask for only one statement and it's by way of update. There was a real sense of optimism a year ago, when the Welsh Government stepped into the breach in terms of the Caerau Arbed community energy saving programme issues, with over 100 householders—not all through the Welsh scheme, in fact, the majority through the English CESP programme—deeply affected, with their homes and their standard of life as well, I have to say. It's a real issue. But the Welsh Government stepped up and it said it would work with Bridgend County Borough Council to bring forward a business case that would then be signed off and we could get on with remedying the homes of all those people. But time has gone by; I think it's eight months since the business case was being presented. I know there's been to-ing and fro-ing between the council and Welsh Government finessing it, because I've written before. Other Members in the Senedd have raised this issue as well. But we need a statement, so that we can give the reassurance to people that this is progressing, despite delays, despite refining, despite having to get all the bureaucracy signed off, because it's a heck of a lot of money we're talking about, but we want to see it progress. So, is there any chance that we could have a statement of update so that all those householders—over 100 in Caerau—will know that this work is finally going to be done, and sooner rather than later? 100

Rwy'n gofyn am un datganiad yn unig fel cyfrwng ar gyfer yr wybodaeth diweddaraf. Roedd gwir deimlad o optimistiaeth flwyddyn yn ôl, pan gamodd Llywodraeth Cymru i'r adwy o ran materion rhaglen arbed ynni cymunedol Caerau Arbed, gyda dros 100 o ddeiliaid tai—nid pob un drwy gynllun Cymru, mewn gwirionedd, y mwyafrif drwy raglen CESP Lloegr—wedi'u heffeithio'n ddwfn, a'u cartrefi a'u safon byw hefyd, mae'n rhaid i mi ddweud. Mae hi wir yn broblem. Ond fe gamodd Llywodraeth Cymru i'r adwy a dywedodd y byddai'n gweithio gyda Chyngor Bwrdeistref Sirol Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr i gyflwyno achos busnes a fyddai wedyn yn cael ei gymeradwyo a gallen ni fynd ati i wella cartrefi'r holl bobl hynny. Ond mae amser wedi mynd heibio; rwy'n credu ei bod hi'n wyth mis ers i'r achos busnes gael ei gyflwyno. Rwy'n gwybod bod yna 'nôl a blaen' wedi bod rhwng y cyngor a Llywodraeth Cymru yn mireinio'r peth, oherwydd yr wyf i wedi ysgrifennu o'r blaen. Mae Aelodau eraill yn y Senedd wedi codi'r mater yma hefyd. Ond mae angen datganiad, fel y gallwn ni roi'r sicrwydd i bobl bod hyn yn mynd yn ei flaen, er gwaethaf yr oedi, er gwaethaf mireinio, er gwaethaf gorfod cael yr holl fiwrocratiaeth wedi'i chymeradwyo, oherwydd mae'n swm anferth o arian yr ydym ni'n sôn amdano, ond rydym ni eisiau'i weld yn symud ymlaen. Felly, a oes unrhyw obaith y gallem ni gael datganiad o'r wybodaeth ddiweddaraf fel y bydd yr holl ddeiliaid tai hynny—dros 100 yng Nghaerau—yn gwybod y bydd y gwaith hwn yn cael ei wneud o'r diwedd, ac yn gynt yn hytrach nag yn hwyrach? 

Thank you. I know the Minister for Climate Change, who obviously has responsibility for this scheme, has recently written to Councillor Huw David, the leader of Bridgend County Borough Council, thanking his officers, particularly, for their ongoing engagement with her officials in developing the detailed business case. As you said, the Minister approved the scheme in principle, back in last November, so it has been nearly a year, and obviously there's been a subsequent submission of the detailed business case, and I know the Minister's officials are working on advice, which will be given to the Minister imminently.  101

Diolch. Rwy'n gwybod bod y Gweinidog Newid Hinsawdd, sydd yn amlwg â chyfrifoldeb am y cynllun hwn, wedi ysgrifennu at y Cynghorydd Huw David, arweinydd Cyngor Bwrdeistref Sirol Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr, gan ddiolch i'w swyddogion, yn enwedig, am eu hymgysylltiad parhaus gyda'i swyddogion wrth ddatblygu'r achos busnes manwl. Fel y dywedoch chi, cymeradwyodd y Gweinidog y cynllun mewn egwyddor, nôl ym mis Tachwedd diwethaf, felly mae bron i flwyddyn wedi bod, ac yn amlwg mae cyflwyniad wedi bod ers hynny o'r achos busnes manwl, ac rwy'n gwybod bod swyddogion y Gweinidog yn gweithio ar gyngor, a fydd yn cael ei roi i'r Gweinidog a hynny ar fin digwydd.  

Could I ask for an urgent statement from the health Minister this afternoon on waiting times in Glan Clwyd hospital in Bodelwyddan, as I have been contacted overnight by Chelsea Clark from Meliden, whose grandmother has been sat in A&E for 35 hours—35 hours in a dirty corridor with a blood clot in her leg, pneumonia, and has previously had sepsis and meningitis, which has caused kidney disease? This is a live case, Trefnydd, which is causing much distress to the patient and her family, and something needs to be done, as we see all too often cases such as this. So, I'd like an urgent statement from the Welsh Government this afternoon detailing what mechanisms they're going to use to bring the health board to account on these problems. And, failing this, will the Welsh Government accept that they've completely lost control of health services in north Wales? My constituents need answers and they need them now. 102

A gaf i ofyn am ddatganiad brys gan y Gweinidog iechyd y prynhawn yma ar amseroedd aros yn ysbyty Glan Clwyd ym Modelwyddan, gan fod Chelsea Clark o Meliden wedi cysylltu â mi dros nos, y mae ei nain wedi bod yn eistedd yn yr adran damweiniau ac achosion brys am 35 awr—35 awr mewn coridor budr gyda chlot gwaed yn ei choes, niwmonia, ac mae hi eisoes wedi cael sepsis a llid yr ymennydd, sydd wedi achosi clefyd yr arennau? Mae hwn yn achos byw, Trefnydd, sydd yn achosi llawer o drallod i'r claf a'i theulu, ac mae angen gwneud rhywbeth, gan ein bod ni'n gweld o achosion fel hyn yn rhy aml. Felly, hoffwn i gael datganiad brys gan Lywodraeth Cymru prynhawn yma yn manylu ar ba ddulliau maen nhw'n mynd i'w defnyddio i ddod â'r bwrdd iechyd i gyfrif ar y problemau hyn. A gan fethu hyn, a fydd Llywodraeth Cymru'n derbyn eu bod nhw wedi colli rheolaeth dros wasanaethau iechyd yn y gogledd yn llwyr? Mae angen atebion ar fy etholwyr i ac maen nhw eu hangen nhw arnyn nhw nawr. 

Well, the Member knows that we can't possibly do an urgent statement this afternoon on a very distressing individual case, and I'm sorry the Minister isn't in the Chamber, but I will make sure she hears about the individual case. While she can't obviously comment on a specific case, you will be very well aware of the significant work that the Minister is doing with Betsi Cadwaldar University Health Board particularly around A&E. I mentioned in my earlier answer to Peredur the work she has been doing to make sure that we can get—[Interruption.103

Wel, mae'r Aelod yn gwybod nad oes modd i ni wneud datganiad brys y prynhawn yma ar achos unigol gofidus iawn, ac mae'n ddrwg gennyf i nad yw'r Gweinidog yn y Siambr, ond byddaf i'n sicrhau ei bod hi'n clywed am yr achos unigol. Er na all hi wneud sylwadau ar achos penodol yn amlwg, byddwch chi'n ymwybodol iawn o'r gwaith arwyddocaol y mae'r Gweinidog yn ei wneud gyda Bwrdd Iechyd Prifysgol Betsi Cadwaladr yn enwedig ynghylch yr adran damweiniau ac achosion brys. Gwnes i sôn yn fy ateb cynharach i Peredur am y gwaith y mae hi wedi bod yn ei wneud i sicrhau ein bod ni'n gallu cael—[Torri ar draws.]  

Allow the Minister—[Inaudible.] 104

Gadewch i'r Gweinidog—[Anghlywadwy.]  

What's happening to my microphone? Allow the Trefnydd to carry on. I think she heard me.  106

Beth sy'n digwydd i fy meicroffon? Gadwch i'r Trefnydd fynd yn ei blaen. Rwy'n credu ei bod hi wedi fy nghlywed i.  

—to make sure that our major hospitals in north Wales do have the emergency care consultants that are required. 107

—i wneud yn siŵr bod gan ein prif ysbytai yn y gogledd yr ymgynghorwyr gofal brys sy'n ofynnol. 

Minister, as a clinician, I appreciate the enormous pressure on the NHS, on our patients waiting for treatment, and on our staff, who have shown such professionalism in the face of unprecedented challenges. Whilst I know we have to resolve the short-term crisis, we also need to look to the longer term strategically and with purpose. In the field of cancer care, this is vitally important. Both England and Scotland have a national cancer plan, and Northern Ireland consulted on this last November. Wales, by contrast, is now the only nation of the UK that does not have a cancer plan. I know that you owe it to those needing care and treatment and to those delivering our services for there to be a strategy to set out the outcomes that are needed. Will the Minister schedule a debate in the Government's time to allow the Minister to set out her thinking? Thank you.108

Gweinidog, fel clinigwr, rwy'n gwerthfawrogi'r pwysau enfawr ar y GIG, ar ein cleifion sy'n aros am driniaeth, ac ar ein staff, sydd wedi dangos y fath broffesiynoldeb yn wyneb heriau digynsail. Er fy mod i'n gwybod bod yn rhaid i ni ddatrys yr argyfwng tymor byr, mae angen i ni hefyd edrych i'r tymor hwy yn strategol a gyda phwrpas. Ym maes gofal canser, mae hyn yn hanfodol bwysig. Mae gan Loegr a'r Alban gynllun canser cenedlaethol, ac fe wnaeth Gogledd Iwerddon ymgynghori ar hyn fis Tachwedd diwethaf. Ar y llaw arall, Cymru yw'r unig genedl o'r DU nawr sydd heb gynllun canser. Rwy'n gwybod ei bod yn ddyletswydd arnoch, i'r rhai sydd angen gofal a thriniaeth ac i'r rhai sy'n darparu ein gwasanaethau, sefydlu strategaeth i nodi'r canlyniadau sydd eu hangen. A wnaiff y Gweinidog drefnu dadl yn amser y Llywodraeth i ganiatáu i'r Gweinidog nodi ei syniadau? Diolch.

14:50

I will certainly ask the Minister for Health and Social Services to consider making a statement on cancer services in Wales. I think she does do so most years, but I'm not quite sure in the cycle where we are, but I will certainly ask the Minister—who's just heard your question—if she's prepared to do so.109

Yn sicr, fe wnaf i ofyn i'r Gweinidog Iechyd a Gwasanaethau Cymdeithasol ystyried gwneud datganiad ar wasanaethau canser yng Nghymru. Rwy'n credu ei bod hi'n gwneud hynny bron bob blwyddyn, ond nid ydw i'n hollol siŵr lle yr ydym ni yn y cylch, ond yn sicr, fe wnaf i ofyn i'r Gweinidog—sydd newydd glywed eich cwestiwn—os yw hi'n barod i wneud hynny.

Good afternoon, Trefnydd. The particular financial situation at the moment means that those who are the poorest in our society are going to be particularly hard hit and those who are currently in debt are going to suffer particular problems. This was highlighted in an online story by the BBC that focused on the terrible case of a single mother who worked as a carer. Julie spoke of the shame she felt. She spoke of the terror her young daughter experienced when bailiffs in full body armour were banging on the door. I'm sure you would agree that no-one should have to live like this. We know that Wales has the highest proportion of financial exclusion in the UK and we need to be willing to consider radical solutions to address the effects of debt on our residents here.110

So, this is also by way of a follow-up. I was very pleased to be part of the social justice committee gthat recommended that Wales consider a debt bonfire. Therefore, could I ask for a statement from the Minister for Social Justice on this topic and an update on the situation? Diolch yn fawr iawn.111

Prynhawn da, Trefnydd. Mae'r sefyllfa ariannol benodol ar hyn o bryd yn golygu bod y rhai tlotaf yn ein cymdeithas yn mynd i ddioddef ergyd arbennig o galed ac mae'r rheiny sydd mewn dyled ar hyn o bryd yn mynd i ddioddef problemau penodol. Cafodd hyn ei amlygu mewn stori ar-lein gan y BBC a ganolbwyntiodd ar achos ofnadwy mam sengl a oedd yn gweithio fel gofalwr. Soniodd Julie am y cywilydd roedd hi'n ei deimlo. Soniodd hi am braw a wynebodd ei merch ifanc pan oedd beilïaid mewn arfwisg corff llawn yn curo ar y drws. Rwy'n siŵr y byddech chi'n cytuno na ddylai neb orfod byw fel hyn. Rydym yn gwybod mai Cymru sydd â'r gyfran uchaf o waharddiadau ariannol yn y DU ac mae angen i ni fod yn barod i ystyried atebion radical i ymdrin ag effeithiau dyled ar ein trigolion yma.

Felly, mae hyn hefyd drwy ddilyniant. Roeddwn i'n falch iawn o fod yn rhan o'r pwyllgor cyfiawnder cymdeithasol a wnaeth argymell y dylai Cymru ystyried coelcerth ddyled. Felly, a gaf i ofyn am ddatganiad gan y Gweinidog Cyfiawnder Cymdeithasol ar y pwnc hwn a'r wybodaeth ddiweddaraf ar y sefyllfa? Diolch yn fawr iawn.

Thank you. Well, we certainly know that, for many people, this cost-of-living crisis will absolutely tip them over the edge, unfortunately, in relation to their finances, and I know the Minister for Social Justice considered the report very carefully, and that she is looking—. I know one area where she is doing some work is debt owed to the public sector creditors, for instance, and that includes local authority, which is becoming a growing concern as people are faced with the cost-of-living crisis, and officials continue to research the proposal for a debt bonfire.112

As a Government, we are certainly doing all we can to support our residents in relation to being able to access financial support, and doing what we can to help people with debt and with the cost-of-living crisis, and you will have heard the First Minister say in his answer during his question session how, as a Cabinet, every week we have a cost-of-living sub-committee of Cabinet, where we have experts coming in to give us advice as to how we can be more radical and what more we can do to help people.113

Diolch. Wel, rydym ni'n sicr yn gwybod, i lawer o bobl, y bydd yr argyfwng costau byw hwn yn eu gwthio dros y diben, yn anffodus, o ran eu cyllid, ac rwy'n gwybod bod y Gweinidog Cyfiawnder Cymdeithasol wedi ystyried yr adroddiad yn ofalus iawn, a'i bod hi'n edrych—. Rwy'n gwybod mai un maes lle mae hi'n gwneud rhywfaint o waith yw dyled sy'n ddyledus i gredydwyr y sector cyhoeddus, er enghraifft, ac mae hynny'n cynnwys awdurdodau lleol, sy'n dod yn bryder cynyddol wrth i bobl wynebu'r argyfwng costau byw, ac mae swyddogion yn parhau i ymchwilio i'r cynnig am goelcerth ddyled.

Fel Llywodraeth, rydym ni'n sicr yn gwneud popeth o fewn ein gallu ni i gefnogi ein trigolion o ran gallu manteisio ar gefnogaeth ariannol, a gwneud yr hyn y gallwn ni i helpu pobl gyda dyled a gyda'r argyfwng costau byw, a byddwch chi wedi clywed y Prif Weinidog yn dweud yn ei ateb yn ystod ei sesiwn holi sut, fel Cabinet, bob wythnos mae gennym ni is-bwyllgor costau byw o'r Cabinet, lle mae gennym ni arbenigwyr yn dod i mewn i roi cyngor i ni ynglŷn â sut y gallwn ni fod yn fwy radical a beth arall y gallwn ni ei wneud i helpu pobl.

Please can I ask for a statement from the Minister for Economy about what work the Welsh Government is doing to boost pre-Christmas trade for our hard-working town-centre businesses? I'm a firm believer that we should be doing all we can to help businesses thrive, not just survive, across Wales, and they face rising cost-of-living pressures and continue to deal with the aftermath of the coronavirus pandemic. In my region of south-east Wales, I've launched a new initiative to give businesses a much-needed boost in the run-up to the festive period and increase footfall in our town centres. I've written to all the leaders of all the local authorities across south-east Wales, asking them to back my proposals and work with me to make this a reality. My plan is to see car parking fees scrapped in all council-controlled car parks throughout December in a bid to encourage more people to get out and about as the festive period approaches. Not only will businesses benefit as a result of free car parking, but it would also go a long way in helping families who are feeling the financial squeeze. Many town centres across the UK have rolled out similar schemes, which have been incredibly successful, and I do appreciate that Monmouth council has indeed embarked upon this as well. So, any support the Welsh Government can give to my initiative would be greatly appreciated, and I'd also appreciate if the economy Minister could outline how exactly he is working with local authorities and other stakeholders to help Welsh business in the run-up to Christmas.114

A gaf i ofyn am ddatganiad gan Weinidog yr Economi am ba waith y mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn ei wneud i hybu masnach cyn y Nadolig i'n busnesau canol trefi sy'n gweithio'n galed? Rwy'n credu'n gryf y dylem ni fod yn gwneud popeth o fewn ein gallu i helpu busnesau i ffynnu, nid dim ond goroesi, ledled Cymru, ac maen nhw'n wynebu pwysau costau byw cynyddol a pharhau i ymdrin â chanlyniadau'r pandemig coronafeirws. Yn fy rhanbarth i yn y de-ddwyrain, rwyf i wedi lansio menter newydd i roi hwb angenrheidiol i fusnesau yn ystod cyfnod yr ŵyl a chynyddu nifer yr ymwelwyr yng nghanol ein trefi. Rwyf i wedi ysgrifennu at holl arweinwyr yr holl awdurdodau lleol ar draws y de-ddwyrain, yn gofyn iddyn nhw gefnogi fy nghynigion a gweithio gyda mi i wireddu hyn. Fy nghynllun i yw gweld ffioedd parcio ceir yn cael eu dileu ym mhob maes parcio sy'n cael eu rheoli gan y cyngor drwy gydol mis Rhagfyr mewn ymgais i annog mwy o bobl i fynd allan wrth i gyfnod yr ŵyl agosáu. Bydd busnesau nid yn unig yn elwa o ganlyniad i barcio am ddim, ond byddai hefyd yn cyfrannu'n helaeth at helpu teuluoedd sy'n teimlo'r wasgfa ariannol. Mae llawer o ganol trefi ledled y DU wedi cyflwyno cynlluniau tebyg, sydd wedi bod yn hynod lwyddiannus, ac rwy'n gwerthfawrogi bod cyngor Mynwy yn wir wedi dechrau ar hyn hefyd. Felly, byddai unrhyw gefnogaeth y gall Llywodraeth Cymru ei roi i fy menter i'n cael ei werthfawrogi'n fawr, a byddwn i hefyd yn gwerthfawrogi pe bai Gweinidog yr economi yn gallu amlinellu sut yn union y mae'n gweithio gydag awdurdodau lleol a rhanddeiliaid eraill i helpu busnesau Cymru yn y cyfnod cyn y Nadolig.

Thank you. I certainly think it would be worth you writing to the Minister for Economy, outlining the proposals that you suggested, and I know we have undertaken quite a lot of work as part of town-centre regeneration, particularly in the run-up to Christmas over previous years, to highlight how they can get more footfall into our town centres, and, clearly, free car parking is one area.115

Diolch. Yn sicr, rwy'n credu y byddai'n werth i chi ysgrifennu at Weinidog yr Economi, gan amlinellu'r cynigion sydd wedi'u hawgrymu gennych chi, ac rwy'n gwybod ein bod ni wedi gwneud cryn dipyn o waith fel rhan o adfywio canol tref, yn enwedig yn y cyfnod cyn y Nadolig yn ystod y blynyddoedd blaenorol, i dynnu sylw at sut y gallan nhw gael mwy o ymwelwyr i ganol ein trefi, ac, yn amlwg, mae parcio am ddim yn un maes.

Good afternoon, Trefnydd. I would like a statement from the Minister for education on the fact that some primary schools now are in urgent need of support to extend their kitchens and employ more staff to manage the free school meal policy. Indeed, in a response to a written question, the Minister for education advised me, and I quote,116

'further work will take place during October to understand whether any additional kitchen upgrade works are required to deliver the next stages of universal primary free school meals.'117

He was then, however, unable118

'to confirm the number of primary schools in Wales requiring upgrades to their kitchens.'119

Without the staff that are employed to work in our school kitchens in Aberconwy and across Wales, the delivery of this universal offer is not going to be possible. I met one of those teams—a school kitchen team, the other day—and they were working incredibly hard, but they themselves now are beginning to panic about how they're going to take this policy and do it properly, with the number of pupils in various schools. So, could we have a statement from the Minister? Will he update the Chamber on the outcome of the work this month so that school kitchen teams themselves can find out whether they're going to be receiving this help? And, in the main, it's finances as well they're looking for. Thank you.120

Prynhawn da, Trefnydd. Hoffwn ddatganiad gan y Gweinidog Addysg am y ffaith bod angen cefnogaeth frys ar rai ysgolion cynradd i ymestyn eu ceginau a chyflogi mwy o staff i reoli'r polisi prydau ysgol am ddim. Yn wir, mewn ymateb i gwestiwn ysgrifenedig, gwnaeth y Gweinidog addysg fy nghyngori i, ac rwy'n dyfynnu,

'Bydd gwaith arall yn cael ei wneud yn ystod mis Hydref i ddeall a oes angen unrhyw waith uwchraddio ceginau ychwanegol i gyflawni camau nesaf prydau ysgol cynradd cyffredinol.'

Yr oedd bryd hynny, fodd bynnag, yn methu

'cadarnhau nifer yr ysgolion cynradd yng Nghymru y mae angen uwchraddio eu ceginau.'

Heb y staff sy'n cael eu cyflogi i weithio yng ngheginau ein hysgolion yn Aberconwy ac ar draws Cymru, nid yw darparu'r cynnig cyffredinol hwn yn mynd i fod yn bosibl. Gwnes i gyfarfod ag un o'r timau hynny—tîm cegin ysgol, y diwrnod o'r blaen—ac roedden nhw'n gweithio'n anhygoel o galed, ond maen nhw eu hunain nawr yn dechrau mynd i banig ynghylch sut maen nhw'n mynd i gymryd y polisi hwn a'i gyflawni'n gywir, gyda nifer y disgyblion mewn gwahanol ysgolion. Felly, a gawn ni ddatganiad gan y Gweinidog? A wnaiff e' roi'r wybodaeth ddiweddaraf i'r Siambr ar ganlyniad y gwaith y mis hwn fel bod timau cegin ysgol eu hunain yn gallu darganfod a ydyn nhw'n mynd i fod yn derbyn yr help hwn? Ac, yn bennaf, cyllid hefyd maen nhw'n chwilio amdano. Diolch.

14:55

Thank you. Obviously, as we roll out this policy, more work will be done and has been done with our schools. You mentioned that you'd had a response from the Minister for Education and the Welsh Language in relation to further work that was being undertaken during the month of October. Obviously, we're still in the month of October, so I would hope that when he has that information to hand, if he feels he needs to do an update, he will do so.121

Diolch. Yn amlwg, wrth i ni gyflwyno'r polisi hwn, bydd mwy o waith yn cael ei wneud gyda'n hysgolion, ac mae hynny eisoes yn digwydd. Fe wnaethoch chi sôn eich bod wedi cael ymateb gan Weinidog y Gymraeg ac Addysg mewn perthynas â gwaith pellach oedd yn cael ei wneud yn ystod mis Hydref. Yn amlwg, rydym ni'n dal ym mis Hydref, felly byddwn yn gobeithio pan fydd ganddo'r wybodaeth honno wrth law, os yw'n teimlo bod angen iddo wneud diweddariad, y bydd yn gwneud hynny.

Thank you, business Minister. I would like to request a statement, as well, from the Minister for education stating the Government's position on the charity Mermaids and their influence on educational material in Wales. There is currently an investigation under way by the Charity Commission surrounding the compliance of the charity, and, just this month, the Department for Education has removed Mermaids as a mental health and well-being resource for schools as a result of an ongoing investigation, the seriousness of the allegations and the need to protect our children and young people. Could I therefore ask the education Minister for an oral or written statement outlining this Welsh Government's stance on Mermaids and the concerns that I outlined? Thank you.122

Diolch, Gweinidog busnes. Hoffwn ofyn am ddatganiad, hefyd, gan y Gweinidog addysg yn datgan safbwynt y Llywodraeth ar yr elusen Mermaids a'u dylanwad ar ddeunydd addysgol yng Nghymru. Ar hyn o bryd mae ymchwiliad ar y gweill gan y Comisiwn Elusennau ynghylch cydymffurfiaeth yr elusen, ac, y mis yma, mae'r Adran Addysg wedi dileu Mermaids fel adnodd iechyd meddwl a lles i ysgolion o ganlyniad i ymchwiliad sy'n parhau, difrifoldeb yr honiadau a'r angen i amddiffyn ein plant a'n pobl ifanc. A gaf i ofyn felly i'r Gweinidog Addysg am ddatganiad llafar neu ysgrifenedig yn amlinellu safbwynt Llywodraeth Cymru ynghylch Mermaids a'r pryderon yr amlinellais i? Diolch.

I'm not aware of any work being undertaken by the organisation that you refer to, but if that is the case, I will ask the Minister to write to the Member.123

Dydw i ddim yn ymwybodol o unrhyw waith sy'n cael ei wneud gan y sefydliad rydych chi'n cyfeirio ato, ond os yw hynny'n wir, fe wnaf ofyn i'r Gweinidog ysgrifennu at yr Aelod.

3. Datganiad gan y Gweinidog Iechyd a Gwasanaethau Cymdeithasol: Fframwaith Imiwneiddio Cenedlaethol i Gymru
3. Statement by the Minister for Health and Social Services: National Immunisation Framework for Wales

Yr eitem nesaf, felly, yw datganiad gan y Gweinidog Iechyd a Gwasanaethau Cymdeithasol ar y fframwaith imiwneiddio cenedlaethol, a dwi'n galw ar y Gweinidog i wneud ei datganiad—Eluned Morgan.125

The next item is a statement by the Minister for Health and Social Services on the national immunisation framework for Wales, and I call on the Minister to make the statement—Eluned Morgan.

Diolch yn fawr. Today, I am publishing our new national immunisation framework. Vaccination has long been a critical part of NHS Wales's delivery to protect our citizens and our communities. The pandemic required us to think differently about the deployment of vaccination, in particular the need to maximise uptake and to ensure equity. We must learn these lessons and apply them to our future arrangements, and it is through this national immunisation framework that we will do that. I want this framework to enable positive changes to deliver and improve vaccination arrangements and to increase uptake across all our vaccination programmes.126

The vaccination transformation programme was established earlier this year to look at the provision of vaccination services to ensure arrangements are fit for the future. In July, I published the winter respiratory vaccination strategy, which paved the way for an integrated COVID-19 and influenza vaccination programme that launched on 1 September. The programme is progressing well, with both the COVID-19 and flu campaigns now in full swing. All those eligible for a COVID-19 booster will have their invites by the end of November, and those eligible for flu vaccination will have theirs by the end of December. It’s so important that we maximise the uptake of both vaccines, and I encourage everyone to take up their appointments this autumn to protect themselves and their families.127

As important as they are, especially at this time of year, this framework is about much more than vaccination against respiratory viruses; it covers all our vaccination programmes, including childhood immunisations. And it is the success and good practice of these programmes that has been the foundation for the transformation process. Indeed, they provided the basis for our world-leading COVID-19 vaccination programme.128

Our vision for the future of immunisation in Wales is high uptake of a sustainably delivered, effective vaccine at the right time to reduce severe illness and death. We want to see vaccination services that are clear, where people know what vaccinations they are eligible for and how to receive them, with high levels of uptake and equity of access at the heart of service design and provision. This is the first national immunisation framework to be issued for Wales and its development has been on a co-production basis, with the Welsh Government and the NHS working as one team to identify and use lessons from the pandemic to transition to a position of improved business as usual for all vaccination programmes.129

Health board accountability will remain unchanged, with boards assessing local need, commissioning, performance managing and evaluating provision in line with the national strategic direction. Our intention is to support that, to enable improvements and to maximise uptake to protect everyone in Wales. The NHS executive will have a key role in planning and performance managing vaccination programmes in the future.130

So, the framework identifies six key areas of focus, within which our strategic priorities and expectations are set, and these are vaccination equity, digitally enabled vaccination, eligibility, public vaccination literacy, deployment and governance. The majority of commitments outlined in the framework build on practices that have worked well from our experience and flexibility of the COVID-19 programme or best practice from existing, long-standing programmes. All have been identified by key partners, including those delivering services on the ground. We know that health harms from COVID-19 have not affected people in Wales equally. Tailored support has been needed to enable and encourage underserved groups to take up the offer of vaccination. People from harder-to-reach communities will come forward for vaccination, which points to accessibility rather than acceptability being a key barrier. That is something that we must tackle, and it is why we have put vaccination equity at the core of Wales’s vaccination approach and this framework.131

Public understanding and engagement are critical in supporting people to come forward for vaccination, so the framework focuses in on this. It includes priorities on the co-production of patient materials, robust communications and engagement strategies, and training to increase awareness of vaccination among the health and care workforce, and community and trusted figures, so that they can advocate for vaccination and make every contact count.132

Diolch yn fawr. Heddiw, rydw i'n cyhoeddi ein fframwaith imiwneiddio cenedlaethol newydd. Mae brechu wedi bod yn rhan hanfodol o ddarpariaeth GIG Cymru i ddiogelu ein dinasyddion a'n cymunedau ers amser maith. Roedd y pandemig yn gofyn i ni feddwl yn wahanol am ddefnyddio brechiadau, yn enwedig yr angen i gael cynifer â phosib i'w cymryd ac i sicrhau tegwch. Mae'n rhaid i ni ddysgu'r gwersi hyn a'u cynnwys yn ein trefniadau yn y dyfodol, a thrwy'r fframwaith imiwneiddio cenedlaethol hwn y byddwn yn gwneud hynny. Mae arna i eisiau i'r fframwaith hwn alluogi newidiadau cadarnhaol i gyflawni a gwella trefniadau brechu a chynyddu'r niferoedd sy'n cael eu brechu ar draws ein holl raglenni brechu.

Cafodd y rhaglen trawsnewid brechiadau ei sefydlu yn gynharach eleni i edrych ar ddarparu gwasanaethau brechu er mwyn sicrhau bod y trefniadau'n addas i'r dyfodol. Ym mis Gorffennaf, cyhoeddais strategaeth frechu'r gaeaf yn erbyn feirysau anadlol, a fraenarodd y tir ar gyfer rhaglen gyfunol i frechu yn erbyn COVID-19 a'r ffliw a lansiwyd ar 1 Medi. Mae'r rhaglen yn bwrw ymlaen yn dda, gyda'r ymgyrchoedd COVID-19 a'r ffliw bellach ar eu hanterth. Bydd pawb sy'n gymwys i gael pigiad atgyfnerthu COVID-19 yn cael gwahoddiad erbyn diwedd Tachwedd, a bydd y rhai sy'n gymwys i gael brechiad ffliw yn cael gwahoddiad erbyn diwedd Rhagfyr. Mae mor bwysig ein bod yn sicrhau bod cynifer â phosib yn cael y ddau frechlyn, ac rwy'n annog pawb i fynd i'w hapwyntiadau yr hydref hwn i amddiffyn eu hunain a'u teuluoedd.

Er mor bwysig ydynt, yn enwedig yr adeg hon o'r flwyddyn, mae'r fframwaith hwn yn ymwneud â llawer mwy na brechu yn erbyn firysau anadlol; mae'n cynnwys ein holl raglenni brechu, gan gynnwys brechiadau plentyndod. A llwyddiant ac arfer da'r rhaglenni yma sydd wedi bod yn sylfaen i'r broses drawsnewid. Yn wir, fe wnaethant ddarparu sail i'n rhaglen frechu COVID-19 sy'n arwain y byd.

Ein gweledigaeth ar gyfer dyfodol imiwneiddio yng Nghymru yw bod cynifer â phosib yn cael brechlyn effeithiol mewn ffordd gynaliadwy ar yr adeg gywir i leihau salwch difrifol a marwolaeth. Mae arnom ni eisiau gweld gwasanaethau brechu sydd yn glir, lle mae pobl yn gwybod pa frechiadau y maent yn gymwys i'w cael, a sut i'w derbyn, gyda chynifer â phosib yn eu cael a thegwch yn y ffordd y gwneir hynny wrth galon dylunio a darparu gwasanaethau. Dyma'r fframwaith imiwneiddio cenedlaethol cyntaf i'w gyhoeddi ar gyfer Cymru, ac fe'i datblygwyd ar y cyd, gyda Llywodraeth Cymru a'r GIG yn gweithio fel un tîm i adnabod a defnyddio gwersi o'r pandemig i drosglwyddo i sefyllfa o well gweithredu rheolaidd ar gyfer pob rhaglen frechu.

Bydd atebolrwydd y byrddau iechyd yn parhau heb newid, gyda byrddau yn asesu angen lleol, comisiynu, rheoli perfformiad a gwerthuso'r ddarpariaeth yn unol â'r cyfeiriad strategol cenedlaethol. Ein bwriad yw cefnogi hynny, galluogi gwelliannau ac i sicrhau bod cymaint â phosib o bobl yn manteisio i'r eithaf ar ddiogelu pawb yng Nghymru. Bydd gan fwrdd gweithredu'r GIG ran allweddol yn y gwaith o gynllunio a rheoli perfformiad rhaglenni brechu yn y dyfodol.

Felly, mae'r fframwaith yn nodi chwe maes pwyslais allweddol, lle mae ein blaenoriaethau a'n disgwyliadau strategol yn cael eu gosod, a'r rhain yw tegwch brechu, brechu digidol, cymhwysedd, llythrennedd brechu cyhoeddus, rhoi a llywodraethu. Mae mwyafrif yr ymrwymiadau a amlinellir yn y fframwaith yn adeiladu ar arferion sydd wedi gweithio'n dda o'n profiad o raglen COVID-19 ac o hyblygrwydd hynny neu ar yr arferion gorau o raglenni presennol, hirsefydlog. Mae'r cyfan wedi'u nodi gan bartneriaid allweddol, gan gynnwys y rhai sy'n darparu gwasanaethau ar lawr gwlad. Rydym ni'n gwybod nad yw niwed iechyd yn sgil COVID-19 wedi effeithio ar bobl yng Nghymru yn yr un modd. Roedd angen cefnogaeth benodol i alluogi ac annog grwpiau sydd wedi'u hesgeuluso i fanteisio ar y cynnig o frechu. Bydd pobl o gymunedau anoddach eu cyrraedd yn dod ymlaen i gael eu brechu, sy'n awgrymu bod hygyrchedd yn hytrach nac argaeledd yn rhwystr allweddol. Mae hynny'n rhywbeth y mae'n rhaid i ni fynd i'r afael ag ef, a dyna pam rydym ni wedi rhoi tegwch o ran brechu wrth wraidd dull brechu Cymru a'r fframwaith hwn.

Mae dealltwriaeth a diddordeb y cyhoedd yn hanfodol wrth gefnogi pobl i gael eu brechu, felly mae'r fframwaith yn canolbwyntio ar hyn. Mae'n cynnwys blaenoriaethau ar gyd-gynhyrchu deunyddiau i gleifion, strategaethau cyfathrebu ac ymgysylltu cadarn, a hyfforddiant i gynyddu ymwybyddiaeth o frechu ymhlith y gweithlu iechyd a gofal, a ffigyrau cymunedol a dibynadwy, fel y gallant eirioli dros frechu a gwneud i bob cyswllt gyfrif.

Daeth Joyce Watson i’r Gadair.

Joyce Watson took the Chair.

15:00

Mae'r fframwaith yn ymrwymo i greu adnodd imiwneiddio craidd mewn byrddau iechyd. Mae'n newid strwythurau llywodraethu i sicrhau goruchwyliaeth a rheolaeth briodol ac integredig i'r holl raglenni brechu a llifoedd gwaith i drawsnewid y seilwaith digidol ar gyfer brechu, sy'n cynnig cyfleoedd enfawr i wasanaethau a dinasyddion.133

Ymrwymiad arall o bwys yn y fframwaith yw symud i broses gaffael ganolog ar gyfer brechlyn y ffliw. Rŷn ni wedi gweld lefelau digynsail yn manteisio ar y brechlyn yn ein rhaglen COVID-19. Dwi'n derbyn bod hyn yn rhannol oherwydd y cyd-destun, ond mae peth o'r diolch hefyd i'r ffordd y mae'r system wedi meithrin cysylltiadau a chynnwys grwpiau sydd wedi bod yn anodd eu cynnwys yn y gorffennol. Dwi am i'r pwyslais hwn ar ddiogelu iechyd gael ei ddefnyddio yn y rhaglen ffliw yn y dyfodol hefyd. Gallwn ni ddim disgwyl i ddarparwyr gofal sylfaenol ysgwyddo'r risg o archebu mwy o'r brechlyn. Rŷn ni'n cydnabod bod yn rhaid cadw'r risg hon ar lefel genedlaethol, felly rŷn ni'n archwilio sut allwn ni symud at fodel caffael cenedlaethol o 2024 ymlaen.134

Bydd darparwyr gofal sylfaenol, gan gynnwys fferyllfeydd cymunedol, yn dal i chwarae rhan bwysig iawn wrth ddarparu brechlyn y ffliw a rhaglenni brechu eraill ar ôl 2024. Maen nhw'n elfen hollbwysig o'r opsiynau y dylid eu rhoi i ddinasyddion er mwyn sicrhau bod y nifer mwyaf posibl o bobl yn manteisio ar y brechlynnau. Rŷn ni'n gweithio'n agos gyda phawb sy'n rhan o'r gwaith hwn i roi'r newidiadau ar waith.135

Mae cyhoeddi’r fframwaith imiwneiddio cenedlaethol yn garreg filltir allweddol sy'n dangos ein bod wedi symud i gyfnod gweithredu'r rhaglen drawsnewid frechu. Rŷn ni'n disgwyl y bydd y broses o bontio i'r trefniadau newydd yn digwydd yn ystod 2023 a 2024. Drwy gydol y cyfnod gweithredu, bydd y rhaglenni presennol yn parhau i gael eu cyflawni'n effeithiol, a bydd ein trefniadau llywodraethu yn adlewyrchu hyn. Uned gyflawni'r gwasanaethau iechyd fydd yn goruchwylio'r gwaith gweithredu, a bydd yr uned yn dod yn rhan o waith gweithredu'r gwasanaeth iechyd yn 2023, gyda Llywodraeth Cymru yn symud i rôl oruchwylio. Rŷn ni wedi ymrwymo i barhau i weithio ar y cyd yn ystod y cyfnod gweithredu, a'r bwriad yw cyhoeddi diweddariad yn 2023 i roi gwybod am y cynnydd sy'n digwydd o ran y newidiadau a'r ymrwymiadau sydd wedi'u nodi yn y fframwaith imiwneiddio cenedlaethol. Diolch.136

The framework commits to building a core immunisation resource in health boards. It changes governance structures to ensure that there is appropriate, integrated oversight and management of all vaccination programmes and work streams to transform the digital infrastructure for vaccination, which presents huge opportunities for services and citizens.

Another significant commitment within the framework is a move to a central procurement process for the flu vaccine. We have seen unprecedented levels of uptake in our COVID-19 programme. I accept that some of this is about the context, but some of it is also due to the way that the system has engaged with and included groups that it has struggled to capture in the past. I want to apply this focus on health protection to the flu programme in the future. We cannot expect primary care providers to carry the risk of ordering more vaccines. We recognise that the risk must be borne at a national level, so we are exploring how we can move to a model of national procurement from 2024 onwards.

Primary care providers, including community pharmacies, will continue to play a really important role in the delivery of the flu vaccine and other vaccination programmes beyond 2024. They are a key element of the options that should be provided to citizens in order to maximise vaccination uptake. We are working closely with all those involved in the implementation of these changes.

Publication of the national immunisation framework is a key milestone that marks a move into the implementation phase of the transformation of vaccination, with a process of transition to the new arrangements expected during 2023 and 2024. Throughout the implementation period, existing programmes will continue to be delivered effectively and our governance arrangements will reflect that. The NHS Wales delivery unit will oversee the implementation, and that unit will become part of the NHS executive in 2023, with the Welsh Government moving into an oversight role. We remain committed to co-production during the implementation phase, and our intention is to publish an update in 2023 to share progress towards the transformational change and commitments set out in the national immunisation framework. Thank you.

15:05

Can I thank the Minister for her statement today? I know that the First Minister and you have stated on numerous occasions throughout the pandemic that your Government would be guided by the science. I agree, of course, with that approach as well, and the Government set up the technical advisory cell and has also taken on board the joint committee on vaccination and immunisation’s recommendations as well, on which groups should take COVID vaccinations. Now, in your framework, you note that you’re guided by the advice of the JCVI, but the framework also goes on to say,137

‘However, even with normally stable programmes, there will be times where an emergency response is required at pace.’138

So I just wanted to ask what does this mean in the context of when you are waiting for advice from JCVI. Of course, the JCVI is an incredibly important organisation, made up of clinicians and experts across the UK, and the UK health security agency. It also provides recommendations to all the UK health authorities on other vaccinations, not just COVID-19. So I’m just trying to ask you where you see the future for JCVI, for example, will its role be strengthened, or do you take a different view?139

I also read with interest, Minister, the section on digitally enabled vaccination, and it notes that you have commissioned Digital Health and Care Wales—previously NHS Wales Informatics Service—to review all vaccination systems, but that you’re looking for shorter term solutions. So, I’m aware that the current Welsh immunisation system was set up during the pandemic to log and manage COVID vaccine delivery, but I’m also told that NWIS is, or can be, burdensome and inflexible, so perhaps you could give a view on that. But, while the system has been, perhaps, adequate for logging COVID vaccines that were scheduled in advance, I’m just speculating that the system may not be likely to be appropriate in its current form for recording flu vaccines and other vaccinations that patients may need. So I wonder, Minister, whether, therefore, you expect NWIS to become the primary IT system for managing and recording vaccines in the future, and if so, how do you plan to improve the system so it’s more flexible, less bureaucratic and simpler to use?140

A quick update on the flu and COVID vaccinations among health and social care workers would be appreciated. I know that you, or I think your officials, wrote to health boards in that regard, so an update on that would be appreciated. And finally, Minister, I did read with delight that you’ve mentioned using the long-awaited NHS Wales app in the framework, but there’s no information on when this will happen. Will this be before the winter, within the next six months, next year? We’re waiting for something that will revolutionise patient access to appointments, prescriptions and more, so can you confirm when this will be introduced? Thanks, Minister.141

A gaf i ddiolch i'r Gweinidog am ei datganiad heddiw? Rwy'n gwybod bod y Prif Weinidog a chi wedi datgan droeon trwy gydol y pandemig y byddai'r wyddoniaeth yn arwain eich Llywodraeth. Rwy'n cytuno, wrth gwrs, gyda'r dull hwnnw hefyd, a sefydlodd y Llywodraeth y gell gynghori dechnegol sydd hefyd wedi derbyn argymhellion y cyd-bwyllgor ar imiwneiddio a brechu, o ran pa grwpiau ddylai gael brechiadau COVID. Nawr, yn eich fframwaith, rydych yn nodi eich bod yn cael eich tywys gan gyngor y cyd-bwyllgor, ond mae'r fframwaith hefyd yn mynd ymlaen i ddweud,

'Wedi dweud hynny, hyd yn oed mewn rhaglenni sydd fel arfer
yn sefydlog, bydd angen ymateb brys a chyflym weithiau'.

Felly dim ond eisiau gofyn oeddwn i beth mae hyn yn ei olygu yng nghyd-destun pryd rydych chi'n aros am gyngor gan y cyd-bwyllgor. Wrth gwrs, mae'r cyd-bwyllgor yn sefydliad hynod bwysig, sy'n cynnwys clinigwyr ac arbenigwyr ar draws y DU, ac asiantaeth diogelwch iechyd y DU. Mae hefyd yn rhoi argymhellion i holl awdurdodau iechyd y DU ar frechiadau eraill, nid dim ond COVID-19. Felly dim ond ceisio gofyn i chi ydw i pa ddyfodol ydych chi'n gweld sydd i'r cyd-bwyllgor, er enghraifft, a gaiff ei swyddogaeth ei gryfhau, neu ydych chi'n cymryd safbwynt gwahanol?

Darllenais hefyd gyda diddordeb, Gweinidog, yr adran ar frechu'n ddigidol, ac mae'n nodi eich bod wedi comisiynu Iechyd a Gofal Digidol Cymru—Gwasanaeth Gwybodeg GIG Cymru gynt—i adolygu'r holl systemau brechu, ond eich bod yn chwilio am atebion tymor byrrach. Felly, rwy'n ymwybodol bod y system imiwneiddio Gymreig bresennol wedi'i sefydlu yn ystod y pandemig i gofnodi a rheoli darparu brechlynnau COVID, ond rwyf hefyd wedi cael gwybod bod y gwasanaeth gwybodeg, neu y gall fod, yn feichus ac yn anhyblyg, felly efallai y gallech roi barn ar hynny. Ond, er y bu'r system, efallai, yn ddigonol i gofnodi brechlynnau COVID a drefnwyd ymlaen llaw, rwy'n dyfalu efallai na fydd y system yn debygol o fod yn briodol yn ei ffurf bresennol i gofnodi brechlynnau ffliw a brechiadau eraill y gallai fod eu hangen ar gleifion. Felly tybed, Gweinidog, p'un ai, felly, rydych chi'n disgwyl i'r gwasanaeth gwybodeg ddod y brif system TG ar gyfer rheoli a chofnodi brechlynnau yn y dyfodol, ac os felly, sut ydych chi'n bwriadu gwella'r system fel ei bod yn fwy hyblyg, llai biwrocrataidd a symlach i'w defnyddio?

Byddai diweddariad cyflym ynghylch brechiadau ffliw a COVID ymhlith gweithwyr iechyd a gofal cymdeithasol yn cael ei werthfawrogi. Rwy'n gwybod eich bod chi, neu rwy'n credu bod eich swyddogion, wedi ysgrifennu at fyrddau iechyd yn hynny o beth, felly byddai diweddariad ar hynny'n cael ei werthfawrogi. Ac yn olaf, Gweinidog, darllenais gyda hyfrydwch eich bod wedi sôn am ddefnyddio ap hir-ddisgwyliedig GIG Cymru yn y fframwaith, ond does dim gwybodaeth ynglŷn â phryd y bydd hyn yn digwydd. Fydd hyn cyn y gaeaf, o fewn y chwe mis nesaf, y flwyddyn nesaf? Rydym yn aros am rywbeth a fydd yn chwyldroi mynediad cleifion i apwyntiadau, presgripsiynau a mwy, felly allwch chi gadarnhau pryd y cyflwynir hynny? Diolch, Gweinidog.

Thank you very much, Russell. We have, throughout the pandemic, been following the advice of the JCVI, which, as you know, is embedded in science and a clinically led approach, and we will continue to do that. Obviously, if there are times when we need to work at pace, they have also demonstrated, during the pandemic, that they can also work at pace. I think we'd have to have quite a good reason to go away from JCVI advice, so that's certainly the model that we've followed so far. 142

When it comes to digitally enabled vaccination, we will develop a person-centred digital vaccination journey, and that will include an integrated vaccination record, digital consent and improved booking and communication and recording functionality. So, as you've noted, Digital Health and Care Wales are going to review all vaccination systems. At the moment, they don't speak to each other, so interoperability is absolutely key, and that's what they're working to do. So, while thinking about long-term digital solutions, we are going to need to have some shorter term fixes to make improvements with an immediate effect. There are existing digital improvement schemes that will link to things like our digital medicines transformation portfolio, the national data resource and the digital services for patients and public programme.143

The NHS Wales app—. Okay, I'm going to tell you quietly, Russell. It is actually being tested at the moment; it has been tested. What we want to do is to make sure that it works and that the functionality works. It's got to have three very key issues that make it work well. One is that the technical bits need to work well. The second is that you need the patient to be able to use it, and so make sure that it's a very simple process that everybody can access. And the third is that you need, for example, GPs to be able to link in with it. So, that is being tested at the moment in a real live operation; 1,000 people are using that as we speak. So, things are progressing, but what I don't want to do is to launch something, as they did in England, that then all the GPs switch off because it's just too overwhelming. We're just trying to make sure that we're taking things and not launching it formally until we are absolutely sure that the thing is going to work. 144

Diolch yn fawr, Russell. Rydym ni, trwy gydol y pandemig, wedi bod yn dilyn cyngor y cyd-bwyllgor ar imiwneiddio a brechu, sydd, fel y gwyddoch chi, wedi'i ymgorffori mewn gwyddoniaeth a dull gweithredu clinigol, a byddwn yn parhau i wneud hynny. Yn amlwg, os oes adegau pan fydd angen i ni weithio ar gyflymder, maen nhw hefyd wedi dangos, yn ystod y pandemig, y gallan nhw hefyd weithio ar gyflymder. Rwy'n credu y byddai'n rhaid i ni gael rheswm eithaf da i gefnu ar gyngor y cyd-bwyllgor, felly yn sicr dyna'r model rydym ni wedi'i ddilyn hyd yn hyn.

O ran brechu digidol, byddwn ni'n datblygu taith frechu ddigidol sy'n canolbwyntio ar yr unigolyn, a bydd hynny'n cynnwys cofnod brechu integredig, cydsyniad digidol ac ymarferoldeb archebu a chyfathrebu a chofnodi gwell. Felly, fel rydych chi wedi ei nodi, mae Iechyd a Gofal Digidol Cymru yn mynd i adolygu'r holl systemau brechu. Ar hyn o bryd, dydyn nhw ddim yn cyfathrebu â'i gilydd, felly mae rhyngweithrededd yn gwbl allweddol, a dyna beth maen nhw'n gweithio i'w wneud. Felly, wrth feddwl am atebion digidol tymor hir, bydd angen i ni gael rhai atebion tymor byrrach i wneud gwelliannau ar unwaith. Mae cynlluniau gwella digidol presennol a fydd yn cysylltu â phethau fel ein portffolio trawsnewid meddyginiaethau digidol, yr adnodd data cenedlaethol a'r gwasanaethau digidol i gleifion a rhaglen gyhoeddus.

Mae ap GIG Cymru—. Iawn, rwy'n mynd i ddweud wrthych chi'n dawel, Russell. Mewn gwirionedd mae'n cael ei brofi ar hyn o bryd; mae wedi cael ei brofi. Yr hyn mae arnom ni eisiau ei wneud yw sicrhau ei fod yn gweithio a bod y swyddogaeth yn gweithio. Mae'n rhaid cael tri mater allweddol iawn sy'n gwneud iddo weithio'n dda. Un yw bod angen i'r darnau technegol weithio'n dda. Yr ail yw eich bod angen i'r claf allu ei ddefnyddio, ac felly gwneud yn siŵr ei bod yn broses syml iawn y gall pawb ei ddefnyddio. A'r trydydd yw bod angen, er enghraifft, i feddygon teulu i allu cysylltu ag ef. Felly, mae hynny'n cael ei brofi ar hyn o bryd mewn gweithrediad byw go iawn; mae 1,000 o bobl yn ei ddefnyddio wrth i ni siarad. Felly, mae pethau'n dod yn eu blaen, ond yr hyn nad ydw i eisiau ei wneud yw lansio rhywbeth, fel y gwnaethon nhw yn Lloegr, y mae'r holl feddygon teulu wedyn yn ei ddiffodd oherwydd ei fod yn rhy llethol. Dim ond ceisio sicrhau ydym ni ein bod ni'n ystyried pethau a ddim yn ei lansio'n ffurfiol nes ein bod ni'n hollol sicr bod y peth yn mynd i weithio. 

15:10

Diolch am y datganiad. Dwi'n eiddgar, wrth gwrs, i gadarnhau cefnogaeth frwd y meinciau yma i raglenni brechu yn gyffredinol a'u cyfraniad nhw at iechyd y genedl. Mewn ffordd, mae'n od, tra'n croesawu'r fframwaith newydd, nad oedd gennym ni fframwaith ynghynt, mor bwysig ydy brechu fel rhan o'r tirwedd iechyd yng Nghymru. Ond, wrth gwrs, rydyn ni wedi bod drwy gyfnod lle mae yna fwy o sylw wedi cael ei roi i frechiadau nag ar unrhyw gyfnod yn ein hanes ni, debyg iawn, efo'r pandemig. Un cwestiwn ar raglen frechu'r pandemig. Mae'r Llywodraeth yn dweud bod rhaglen booster yr hydref yn mynd yn iawn, ond mae'r ffigurau yn awgrymu bod yr uptake yn llai nag y mae o wedi bod, yn enwedig pobl immunosuppressed. Tybed all y Gweinidog ymchwilio, neu roi ymrwymiad i ymchwilio i pam fod yr uptake wedi bod, mae'n ymddangos, gymaint llai yr hydref yma. 145

Ond yn ôl at y datganiad yn gyffredinol, dwi'n meddwl bod y chwe maes ffocws yn y fframwaith yn synhwyrol. Dwi'n croesawu'n arbennig, mae'n rhaid dweud, y sylw sydd yna ar anelu am system lle mae pawb yn gyfartal, lle mae pawb yn cael mynediad cyfartal at frechiadau, achos ar hyn o bryd, fel mae'r Gweinidog wedi'i ddweud, nid dyna yr achos.146

Dwi am roi sylw i un peth yn benodol yn fan hyn. Mae'r datganiad yn cyfeirio at y bwriad i greu system gaffael ganolog ar gyfer brechiad y ffliw o 2024 ymlaen. Ar hyn o bryd, wrth gwrs, mae meddygfeydd yn caffael brechiadau eu hunain yn uniongyrchol gan gyflenwyr. Mae'r Alban wedi dweud yn barod eu bod nhw'n troi at system gaffael ganolog, lle mae'r byrddau iechyd yn prynu'r holl frechlynnau ac yn eu dosbarthu nhw yn lleol. Rŵan, tra bod yna fanteision, dwi'n meddwl, i symud i system ganolog fel hyn ar gyfer yr hirdymor, mae'n bwysig, dwi'n meddwl, ar y pwynt cynnar yma yn y trafodaethau, i gadw mewn golwg yr heriau sy'n debyg iawn o godi, ac rydyn ni'n gwybod hynny o brofiad yr Alban. Pan wnaeth yr Alban gyflwyno'r system, mi wnaethon nhw sylweddoli (1) y byddai hi'n cymryd cyfnod o bosib tair blynedd i gyflwyno system fel hyn, ond (2) y byddai fo'n cael effaith negyddol ar y fferyllfeydd—ar y meddygfeydd, sori. Mi oedd angen ymateb i'r ansicrwydd yna; beth wnaethon nhw, fel Llywodraeth yr Alban, oedd rhoi £5 miliwn yn ychwanegol i wneud yn siŵr bod y broses nid yn unig yn cyflymu, yn digwydd yn effeithiol, ond, yn fwy na hynny, yn digolledi meddygfeydd yn ystod y cyfnod cychwynnol yna. Felly, gaf i ofyn a wnaiff y Gweinidog roi ymrwymiad i gydweithio'n agos iawn â meddygon a meddygfeydd i chwilio am ffyrdd o liniaru'r effeithiau negyddol posib yna, os bydd hwn yn cael ei gyflwyno? A hefyd a wnaiff hi gytuno i ystyried dilyn esiampl yr Alban a chynnig cymorth ariannol penodol lle bo angen gwneud hynny?147

Thank you for the statement. I'm eager to confirm the strong support of these benches to vaccination programmes in general and their contribution to the nation's health. In a way, it's strange, whilst welcoming the new framework, that we didn't have a framework previously, because vaccination is such an important a part of the health landscape in Wales. But, we have been through a period where more focus has been placed on vaccinations than at any other time in our history, given the pandemic. One question on the pandemic vaccination programme. The Government said that the autumn booster programme is progressing well, but the figures do suggest that the uptake is lower than it has been, particularly among the immunosuppressed. So, I wonder whether the Minister could look into or give a commitment to look into why the uptake seems to be so much lower this autumn. 

But to return to the statement in more general terms, I think the six focus areas are sensible. I particularly welcome the focus on aiming for a system where everyone has equal access to vaccination, because at the moment, as the Minister has said, that isn't the case.

I want to focus on one thing particularly here. The statement refers to the intention to create a central procurement system for flu vaccination from 2024 onwards. At the moment, surgeries procure their own vaccinations directly from suppliers. Scotland has already said that they will turn to a central procurement system, where health boards buy all of the vaccinations and distribute them locally. Now, whilst there are benefits to moving to a centralised system such as this one for the longer term, I think it is important, at this early stage in the discussions, to bear in mind the challenges that are very likely to arise, and we know that from the Scottish experience. When Scotland introduced the system, they realised that (1) it would take a period of around three years to introduce such a system, but, secondly, that it would have a negative impact on pharmacies—or, rather, surgeries. In responding to that uncertainty, what the Scottish Government did was to provide an additional £5 million to ensure that the process not only accelerated and happened effectively, but also compensated surgeries during that initial period. So, can I ask whether the Minister will give a commitment to work closely with GPs and surgeries to find ways of mitigating those possible negative impacts, if this is introduced? And also will she agree to consider following the Scottish example and providing particular financial support where required?

15:15

Diolch yn fawr. Wel, jest o ran y booster, felly, dwi'n falch o ddweud, ar yr ail ar bymtheg o'r mis yma, roedd 471,488 o bobl wedi cael y booster. Mae targed gyda ni o 75 y cant. Dwi'n falch o ddweud, os ydych chi mewn cartref gofal, rŷn ni lan at 74 y cant eisoes. Felly, mae hwnna ymhell o flaen ein targed ni. Rŷn ni yn poeni rhywfaint am staff sy'n gweithio mewn cartrefi gofal a staff yn y byrddau iechyd, felly dwi'n gwybod bod chief executive yr NHS wedi ysgrifennu nawr at y byrddau iechyd i ofyn iddyn nhw roi tipyn bach mwy o ymdrech i gael staff. Dwi'n gwybod eu bod nhw wedi blino a'u bod nhw'n gwneud ymdrech fawr, ac efallai mai pwysau gwaith sydd wedi'u stopio nhw rhag gwneud hynny, ond mae yn bwysig iddyn nhw ddiogelu eu hunain wrth inni fynd i mewn i beth rŷn ni'n gwybod fydd yn aeaf caled. Rŷch chi'n iawn ynglŷn â'r grŵp risg yna: felly, rŷn ni'n edrych ar tua 7 y cant o bobl o bump i 49, ond dyw'r ffocws ddim wedi bod ar hynny eto; rŷn ni yn ei gwneud hi mewn trefn blaenoriaeth, a dyna pam rŷn ni wedi sicrhau ein bod ni'n canolbwyntio'n gyntaf ar y cartrefi gofal yna.148

O ran y system caffael cenedlaethol, yn amlwg dyw hwn ddim yn mynd i ddigwydd yfory, ond mae hyd yn oed beth sydd wedi digwydd eleni, lle rŷn ni wedi gweld GPs, er enghraifft, yn prynu'r y flu vaccine—dydyn nhw ddim wedi ordro digon ac rŷn ni wedi gorfod camu mewn fel Llywodraeth. Felly, eisoes, rŷn ni'n camu i mewn, ac, wrth gwrs, mae hwnna'n golygu bod arian ychwanegol yn mynd mewn. Ond, os ydych chi'n mynd i system caffael cenedlaethol, rŷch chi'n fwy tebygol o gael gwell dêl hefyd, felly dwi yn gobeithio y bydd hwnna'n gwneud gwahaniaeth.149

Thank you very much. In terms of the booster, I'm pleased to say that, on the seventeenth of this month, 471,488 people had received the booster. We have a target of 75 per cent. I'm pleased to say that, if you're in a care home, we're up to 74 per cent already. So, that is well on the way to our target. We are somewhat concerned about staff working in care homes and staff working in the health boards, so I know that the chief executive of the NHS has written to the health boards to ask them to make a little bit more effort with the staff. I know that they're tired and that they're making a big effort, and maybe it's work pressure that's stopped them from doing that, but it is important for them to protect themselves as we go into what we know will be a very hard winter. You're right about the risk group: so, we are looking at about 7 per cent of people between five and 49, but the focus hasn't been placed on that yet; we're doing it in order of priority, and that's why we've ensured that we are focusing first on care homes.

In terms of the national procurement system, evidently this is not going to happen tomorrow, but even what's happened this year, where we've seen GPs, for example, procuring the flu vaccine—they haven't ordered enough and we've had to step in as the Government. So, we're already intervening, and that means that additional funding is being provided. But, if you're going to a procurement system on a national level, you're more likely to get a better deal, so I do hope that that will make a difference.

4. Datganiad gan Weinidog yr Economi: Banc Datblygu Cymru—Buddsoddi Uchelgeisiol
4. Statement by the Minister for Economy: Development Bank of Wales—Investing with ambition

We now move on to item 4, a statement by the Minister for Economy, Development Bank of Wales—investing with ambition. I call the Minister, Vaughan Gething.151

Fe symudwn ni ymlaen nawr at eitem 4, sef datganiad gan Weinidog yr Economi, Banc Datblygu Cymru—Buddsoddi Uchelgeisiol. Rwy'n galw ar y Gweinidog, Vaughan Gething.

Thank you, acting Presiding Officer. I know that businesses and workers are grappling with very real trauma all over again. From the many discussions that I have had with businesses in recent weeks, I recognise the enormous difficulties that they face. The Welsh Government is in no doubt about the gravity of the situation. Our economy is more reliant upon small businesses, so the risks that they face will of course hit our communities disproportionately. Many small businesses are the lifeblood of our communities and act as a meeting place, forming a part of the character of neighbourhoods across Wales. In the devolution era, I am proud that we have worked together to create support that is responsive to small and medium-sized businesses.152

I know that the Development Bank is taking a proactive role in facilitating help for businesses. That came across loud and clear in our recent economic summit. There are of course differing views on how we go about securing a stronger Welsh economy in the short term and long term, but all of us want to foster an environment where we are more resilient. For me, that means an economy where people have the skills and the protections that offer security through the tough times ahead.153

Diolch i chi, Llywydd dros dro. Rwy'n gwybod bod busnesau a gweithwyr yn ymgodymu o'r newydd ag ysgytwadau gwirioneddol unwaith eto. Yn dilyn llawer o drafodaethau a gefais i gyda busnesau yn ystod yr wythnosau diwethaf, rwy'n cydnabod yr anawsterau aruthrol y maen nhw'n eu hwynebu. Nid oes gan Lywodraeth Cymru unrhyw amheuaeth ynghylch difrifoldeb y sefyllfa. Mae ein heconomi ni'n fwy dibynnol ar fusnesau bach, felly fe fydd y risgiau y maen nhw'n eu hwynebu yn sicr o ergydio ein cymunedau ni'n anghymesur. Mae llawer o fusnesau bach yn anadl einioes i'n cymunedau ni ac yn cynnig man cyfarfod i bobl, gan lunio rhan o gymeriad y cymdogaethau ledled Cymru. Yn oes datganoli, rwy'n falch ein bod ni wedi cydweithio i estyn cefnogaeth sy'n ymateb i fusnesau bach a chanolig.

Rwy'n gwybod bod y Banc Datblygu â rhan ragweithiol wrth hwyluso cymorth i fusnesau. Cafodd hynny ei fynegi yn hyglyw ac eglur yn ein huwchgynhadledd economaidd ni'n ddiweddar. Fe geir safbwyntiau amrywiol wrth gwrs o ran ein dull ni o sicrhau economi gryfach yng Nghymru yn y tymor byr a'r tymor hir, ond mae pob un ohonom ni'n awyddus i feithrin amgylchedd sy'n rhoi mwy o gydnerthedd i ni. Yn fy marn i, mae hynny'n golygu economi lle ceir sgiliau ac amddiffyniadau sy'n rhoi diogelwch i bobl drwy'r cyfnodau anodd sydd i ddod.

Now, Wales possesses natural resilience. Welsh businesses have stepped up and developed a remarkable capacity to adapt to the toughest of challenges. It’s this spirit that has kept so many businesses afloat during the recent uncertainties. In stark contrast with the UK Government, Wales has a stable, mature Government and a network of social partners that help us to make the right calls. The summit earlier this month was a prime example of team Wales working together to quantify problems and to propose solutions.154

I will be meeting key stakeholders once more in early November to take their feedback on the UK Government’s attempts to stabilise the economy following the Halloween budget. Hopefully, we can then assess with more certainty the range of support required here in Wales and the practical levers available to us if the UK Government goes ahead and further cuts the Welsh Government budget.155

But, today, I want to mark the fifth anniversary of the Development Bank of Wales, the UK’s first regional development bank, and to speak to my ambitions for its future. The development bank has grown to manage funds in the order of £2 billion, and in so doing has become a key part of the economic development and finance ecosystem here in Wales. The bank plays a pivotal role in financing businesses who have sound business plans but struggle to access finance from the market.  It does this by working hand in glove alongside the advice and support provided by Business Wales and through very close ties with mainstream banks and other co-investors, where it often forms only part of the total investment package. By addressing market gaps, the bank allows businesses to access the finance that they need. Over its first five years, the bank has exceeded investment targets, delivering an economic impact of £1.2 billion. Overall debt and equity investment in 2021-22 reached £110 million against a target, set in 2017, to reach £80 million by that year.156

As a result of the UK Government taking direct control over the promised replacement for EU-funded programmes, the funding landscape is now far more complex than it was five years ago. The fact that we have our own now well-capitalised development bank here in Wales means we can maintain capability and stability to help drive economic development.157

In planning for the next five years, we have taken into account this changing funding landscape, which includes new funds from the Cardiff capital region and the British Business Bank. Together, these funds have the potential to bring around £35 million a year of additional capital into Wales. That is a welcome development, which, when combined with the targeted annual investments by the development bank, which will rise above £120 million a year over the same period, will help to ensure that more businesses in Wales will have access to finance. The development bank will work closely with them to ensure that their investment from the Cardiff capital region and the British Business Bank is complementary and supports businesses across our country.158

In our programme for government, we set out our ambition to increase the use of equity stakes in business support. Equity investment can support innovative businesses with growth potential, creating high-value jobs and driving exports. Equity stakes bring not only finance resource but also expertise to businesses, and can be a powerful catalyst for long-term economic growth.159

To date, our development bank has invested £78 million of equity into Welsh businesses, which, alongside other investors, has helped them to raise over £200 million. I have tasked the development bank to pursue a total equity investment target of at least £100 million, which, alongside private sector co-investment, can deliver over £250 million of capital to innovative businesses—an injection of capital that will help to create new jobs, expand new growth sectors in our economy, and help position Wales for the future.160

This new equity investment will be even more targeted, with other Welsh Government support, from business advice to innovation support, making it a complete and best-in-class offer. Going forward, businesses receiving equity investment will have unparalleled support through their investment journey. We believe that this will make a difference in supporting exciting new technology companies to take their product from early concept through to market, ambitious businesses to target high growth, and management teams wanting to buy existing businesses and keep them in Welsh ownership. And, in fact, only this lunchtime, before attending First Minister's questions, I attended an event chaired by Huw Irranca-Davies this lunchtime with the Centre for Local Economic Strategies. And for those who are interested, also in attendance was Huw Lewis, once of this parish, in his new role.161

Of immediate concern to businesses are the challenges driven by increasing costs for materials, wages and, of course, energy. To help businesses, the development bank will continue to offer flexibility to its customers through forbearance and, where appropriate, repayment holidays. Whilst interest rates on development bank loans are fixed at the point of issue—that protects those customers from the current volatility—we also know rates are not the only issue, and businesses can be confident that the bank is committed to working with them through these difficult times.162

The development bank has a major role in supporting business transition on an 'invest to save' principle and already has funding in place to support businesses on their journey to net zero. Right now, the bank is fast-tracking development of a new scheme that will allow businesses to take on borrowing to fund capital investment that delivers on decarbonisation. It will aim to offer more flexible repayment terms, attractive interest rates and other support, such as help towards consultancy costs, as part of this offer to enable businesses to take advantage of current generous capital allowances and to ensure that they are confident that the technologies and solutions being adopted are right for them. I am asking the development bank to do all they can to accelerate their plans so that delivery can begin this year, delivering a double win for eligible businesses by helping them cut future energy costs and progressing our shared ambition for decarbonisation.163

The Development Bank of Wales is a national asset. It continues to help businesses across Wales survive, grow and prosper. I am proud of what it has achieved to date and have confidence in the plans it has to deliver on my ambitions for the future of the Welsh economy.164

Nawr, mae gan Gymru gydnerthedd cynhenid. Mae busnesau Cymru wedi camu i'r adwy ac wedi datblygu gallu rhyfeddol i addasu i'r heriau anoddaf. Yr ysbryd hwn sydd wedi cynnal cymaint o fusnesau yn ystod ansicrwydd y cyfnod diweddar. Yn gwrthgyferbynu yn llwyr â Llywodraeth y DU, mae gan Gymru Lywodraeth sefydlog, aeddfed yn ogystal â rhwydwaith o bartneriaid cymdeithasol sy'n ein helpu i wneud y penderfyniadau cywir. Roedd yr uwchgynhadledd yn gynharach y mis hwn yn enghraifft ardderchog o dîm Cymru yn gweithio gyda'i gilydd i feintioli problemau a chynnig datrysiadau.

Fe fyddaf i'n cwrdd â rhanddeiliaid allweddol unwaith yn rhagor ar ddechrau mis Tachwedd i gael eu hadborth nhw ynglŷn ag ymdrechion Llywodraeth y DU i sefydlogi'r economi yn dilyn y gyllideb Calan Gaeaf. Y gobaith yw y gallwn ni asesu gyda mwy o sicrwydd wedyn o ran yr ystod o gymorth sydd ei angen yma yng Nghymru a'r ysgogiadau ymarferol sydd ar gael i ni os bydd Llywodraeth y DU yn bwrw ymlaen ac yn torri cyllideb Llywodraeth Cymru eto.

Ond, heddiw, fe hoffwn i nodi pum mlynedd ers sefydlu Banc Datblygu Cymru, banc datblygu rhanbarthol cyntaf y DU, a sôn am fy uchelgeisiau ar gyfer ei ddyfodol. Mae'r banc datblygu wedi tyfu i reoli arian gyda chyfanswm o tua £2 biliwn, ac wrth wneud hynny mae wedi dod yn rhan allweddol o'r ecosystem datblygu economaidd a chyllid yma yng Nghymru. Mae'r banc â rhan ganolog wrth ariannu busnesau sydd â chynlluniau busnes cadarn ond sy'n ei chael hi'n anodd cael gafael ar gyllid o'r farchnad. Mae'n gwneud hyn drwy weithio law yn llaw yn gyfochrog â'r cyngor a'r cymorth sy'n cael eu darparu gan Busnes Cymru a thrwy gysylltiadau clos iawn â banciau prif ffrwd a chyd-fuddsoddwyr eraill, lle mae'n llunio rhan yn unig o'r pecyn buddsoddiad yn ei gyfanrwydd. Drwy fynd i'r afael â bylchau yn y farchnad, mae'r banc yn caniatáu i fusnesau gael gafael ar y cyllid sydd ei angen arnyn nhw. Dros bum mlynedd gyntaf ei fodolaeth, mae'r banc wedi rhagori ar nodau buddsoddi, gan gyflawni effaith economaidd o £1.2 biliwn. Fe gyrhaeddodd buddsoddiad cyffredinol o ran dyled ac ecwiti £110 miliwn yn 2021-22 yn ôl bwriad, a bennwyd yn ôl yn 2017, i gyrraedd £80 miliwn erbyn y flwyddyn honno.

O ganlyniad i benderfyniad Llywodraeth y DU i gymryd rheolaeth uniongyrchol ar y rhaglenni a addawyd yn lle'r rhaglenni a oedd yn cael eu hariannu gan yr UE, mae'r dirwedd ariannu yn llawer mwy cymhleth erbyn hyn nag yr oedd hi bum mlynedd yn ôl. Mae'r ffaith bod ein banc datblygu ein hunain sydd â digon o gyfalaf gennym ni nawr yma yng Nghymru yn golygu y gallwn ni gynnal y gallu a'r sefydlogrwydd i helpu i ysgogi datblygiad economaidd.

Wrth gynllunio ar gyfer y pum mlynedd nesaf, rydym ni wedi ystyried y dirwedd newidiol hon o ran ariannu, sy'n cynnwys arian newydd gan brifddinas-ranbarth Caerdydd a Banc Busnes Prydain. Gyda'i gilydd, mae hi'n bosibl y bydd yr arian hwn yn dod â thua £35 miliwn y flwyddyn o gyfalaf ychwanegol i Gymru. Mae hwnnw'n ddatblygiad i'w groesawu, a fydd, o'i gyfuno â'r buddsoddiadau blynyddol a fwriedir gan y banc datblygu, sydd am godi i dros £120 miliwn y flwyddyn dros yr un cyfnod, yn helpu i sicrhau y bydd mwy o fusnesau yng Nghymru yn gallu manteisio ar gyllid. Fe fydd y banc datblygu yn cydweithio yn glos â nhw i sicrhau bod eu buddsoddiad oddi wrth brifddinas-ranbarth Caerdydd a Banc Busnes Prydain yn ategu ei gilydd ac yn cefnogi busnesau ledled ein cenedl ni.

Yn ein rhaglen lywodraethu ni, rydym ni'n amlinellu ein huchelgais i gynyddu'r defnydd o gyfran ecwiti mewn cymorth busnes. Fe all buddsoddi ecwiti gefnogi busnesau arloesol sydd â thwf dichonadwy, gan greu swyddi o werth mawr a rhoi hwb i allforion. Mae cyfran ecwiti nid yn unig yn dod ag adnodd y cyllid ond ag arbenigedd i fusnesau hefyd, ac fe all fod yn gatalydd pwerus ar gyfer twf economaidd hirdymor.

Hyd yn hyn, mae ein banc datblygu ni wedi buddsoddi £78 miliwn o ecwiti mewn busnesau yng Nghymru, sydd, ochr yn ochr â buddsoddwyr eraill, wedi eu helpu i godi dros £200 miliwn. Rwyf i wedi rhoi gorchwyl i'r banc datblygu i anelu at nod o £100 miliwn o leiaf o ran cyfanswm buddsoddi ecwiti, a all, ochr yn ochr â chyd-fuddsoddi'r sector preifat, gyflawni dros £250 miliwn o gyfalaf i fusnesau arloesol—chwistrelliad o gyfalaf a fydd yn helpu i greu swyddi newydd, ehangu sectorau twf newydd yn ein heconomi, a helpu i ddiogelu safle Cymru i'r dyfodol.

Bydd y buddsoddiad ecwiti newydd hwn yn cael ei gyfeirio yn fwy uniongyrchol eto hyd yn oed, gyda chefnogaeth arall gan Lywodraeth Cymru, o gyngor busnes hyd gymorth arloesi, sy'n ei wneud yn gynnig cyflawn a'r gorau o'r fath. Wrth symud ymlaen, fe fydd gan fusnesau sy'n cael buddsoddiad ecwiti gefnogaeth ddigyffelyb ar hyd eu taith fuddsoddi. Rydym ni o'r farn y bydd hyn yn gwneud gwahaniaeth o ran cefnogi cwmnïau technoleg newydd cyffrous i fynd â'u cynnyrch o fod yn gysyniad cynnar hyd at ei farchnata, a rhoi cymorth i fusnesau uchelgeisiol i anelu at fod â thwf cryf, a thimau rheoli sy'n awyddus i brynu busnesau presennol a'u cadw nhw yn eiddo Cymru. Ac yn wir, dim ond amser cinio heddiw, cyn bod yn bresennol yng nghwestiynau'r Prif Weinidog, bûm mewn digwyddiad dan gadeiryddiaeth Huw Irranca-Davies gyda'r Ganolfan Strategaethau Economaidd Lleol. Ac i'r rhai sydd â diddordeb, roedd Huw Lewis yn bresennol hefyd, gynt o'r parthau hyn, yn ei swydd newydd ef.

O bryder uniongyrchol i fusnesau yw'r heriau sy'n cael eu hachosi gan gostau cynyddol am ddeunyddiau, cyflogau ac, wrth gwrs, ynni. I helpu busnesau, fe fydd y banc datblygu yn parhau i gynnig hyblygrwydd i'w cwsmeriaid nhw drwy ymataliad a gwyliau ad-dalu lle bo hynny'n briodol. Er bod cyfraddau llog ar fenthyciadau'r banc datblygu wedi cael eu pennu wrth eu rhoi nhw—mae hynny'n amddiffyn y cwsmeriaid hyn rhag yr anwadalwch presennol—rydym ni'n gwybod hefyd nad y cyfraddau yw'r unig fater, ac fe all busnesau fod â ffydd fod y banc wedi ymrwymo i weithio gyda nhw drwy'r cyfnod anodd hwn.

Mae gan y banc datblygu swyddogaeth bwysig wrth gefnogi pontio busnes ar egwyddor 'buddsoddi i arbed' ac mae cyllid ganddo ar waith eisoes i gefnogi busnesau ar eu taith hyd at sero net. Ar hyn o bryd, mae'r banc yn datblygu cynllun newydd yn gyflym a fydd yn caniatáu i fusnesau ymgymryd â benthyca i ariannu buddsoddiad cyfalaf sy'n darparu ar gyfer datgarboneiddio. Ei nod fydd cynnig telerau ad-dalu sy'n fwy hyblyg, cyfraddau llog deniadol a chymorth fel arall, megis cymorth tuag at gostau ymgynghori, yn rhan o'r cynnig hwn i alluogi busnesau i fanteisio ar y lwfansau cyfalaf hael presennol a sicrhau eu bod nhw â ffydd fod y technolegau a'r datrysiadau sy'n cael eu mabwysiadu yn addas ar eu cyfer nhw. Rwy'n gofyn i'r banc datblygu wneud popeth yn ei allu i gyflymu ei gynlluniau er mwyn i'r gwaith cyflenwi ddechrau eleni, gan sicrhau buddugoliaeth ddwbl i fusnesau cymwys drwy eu helpu nhw i dorri costau ynni'r dyfodol a symud ymlaen â'n huchelgais gyffredin ni o ran datgarboneiddio.

Mae Banc Datblygu Cymru yn ased i'r genedl. Mae'n parhau i helpu busnesau ledled Cymru i oroesi, tyfu a ffynnu. Rwy'n falch o'r hyn a gyflawnodd hyd yn hyn ac mae gennyf i ffydd yn y cynlluniau sydd ganddo i gyflawni fy uchelgeisiau i o ran dyfodol yr economi yng Nghymru.

15:25

Can I thank the Minister for his statement this afternoon and congratulate the development bank on its fifth anniversary? Now, the Development Bank of Wales has been very open to scrutiny from the Economy, Trade, and Rural Affairs Committee, and I know Members welcome the ability to question the team on its investments and progress. Now, today's statement rightly recognises that the Welsh economy is more reliant upon small businesses, so it's crucial that the development bank is reaching out to small and medium-sized enterprises and offering support. The Minister has said that the development bank is taking a proactive role in facilitating help for businesses, but doesn't quite tell us how that work is taking place, and so perhaps the Minister could tell us exactly how the development bank is working with small businesses specifically, given the current financial climate.165

Today's statement rightly highlights some really good work by the development bank. It's great to hear that it has invested £78 million of equity into Welsh businesses. Of course, we need to ensure that funding is reaching businesses in all parts of Wales, and so perhaps the Minister could tell us more about how the Welsh Government will ensure that the bank is raising awareness of its services to businesses in all parts of the country.166

The Minister has already given the bank a total equity investment target of £100 million, which, alongside private sector co-investment, can deliver over £250 million of capital to businesses. Working with co-investors will be critical if the bank is to maximise the impact of its investment in Welsh businesses. Of course, to do so, the bank must continue to encourage the private sector to invest alongside itself, and so perhaps the Minister can tell us more on the work being done to increase that co-investment.167

Now, we know the COVID pandemic has had an enormous impact on businesses in Wales, and the development bank has an important role in supporting economic recovery and supporting businesses. It's vital that a one-size-fits-all approach is not blanketly adopted by the bank, and I'm pleased to hear the Minister talk about offering flexibility to its customers through forbearance and repayment holidays. Today’s statement acknowledges that businesses are facing challenges due to increasing costs for materials, wages and, of course, energy, and therefore perhaps the Minister could tell us a bit more about how the bank can provide tailored support to businesses in relation to these specific challenges.168

It's vital that we recognise the jobs that are being created by the development bank, and there has been some good work taking place to identify and measure productivity too. According to the bank's corporate plan, its baseline jobs target for 2022 to 2027 is 20,000 jobs, but it's vital that there is some measure of the quality of jobs. And, so, I'd be grateful if the Minister could tell us how the Welsh Government recognises success in terms of jobs, and what does success look like to the Welsh Government in this specific area.169

The Minister has made it clear today that, going forward, businesses receiving equity investment will have unparalleled support throughout their investment journey. Today's statement confirms that the bank will be supporting new technology companies to take their products from early concept through to market, as well as businesses targeting high growth, and management teams to buy existing businesses and keep them in Welsh ownership.170

I, of course, welcome this ambition, and perhaps the Minister can tell us more about how the bank is investing in new technology start-ups in particular. There has been some good work around the Wales technology seed fund, but more needs to be done, and so I'd be grateful for any further information the Minister can provide on this front.171

Equally, it's important that there is support for management teams that want to buy out existing businesses and keep them in Welsh ownership. To date, the Wales flexible investment fund, which is operated by the Development Bank of Wales, has been offering a potential debt-based funding route for employee buy-outs. And I know there is support for management buy-outs available through the Wales management succession fund, but perhaps the Minister could tell us a bit more about how those funds are being evaluated and monitored, so we can ensure that the right support is out there for businesses.172

And, finally, today's statement refers to the development bank's work to promote a transition in Wales to a significantly more decarbonised business environment. I'm particularly interested in the development of a new scheme that will allow businesses to take on borrowing to fund capital investment that delivers on decarbonisation. Indeed, the bank's annual report highlights that 41 per cent of its customers have indicated that they are motivated to act on climate change, but actually lack the expertise. And, so, I'd be grateful if the Minister could tell us a bit more about the new scheme that is being developed and when it's likely to become operational. 173

Therefore, in closing, acting Presiding Officer, we know that one of the key themes of the bank is investing in businesses that reflect the diversity in our communities, and we must remember that the bank, at its core, is an impact investor with a social purpose. And, so, can I thank the Minister for his statement this afternoon, and say that I look forward to hearing more about the development bank's work in the coming weeks and months? Thank you. 174

A gaf i ddiolch i'r Gweinidog am ei ddatganiad ef y prynhawn yma a llongyfarch y banc datblygu ar gyrraedd ei ben-blwydd yn bump oed? Nawr, mae Banc Datblygu Cymru wedi bod yn agored iawn i graffu gan Bwyllgor yr Economi, Masnach, a Materion Gwledig, ac rwy'n gwybod bod yr Aelodau yn croesawu'r gallu i holi'r tîm ynglŷn â'i fuddsoddiadau a'i gynnydd. Nawr, mae'r datganiad heddiw yn briodol yn cydnabod bod economi Cymru yn dibynnu mwy ar fusnesau bach, ac felly mae hi'n hollbwysig bod y banc datblygu yn ymestyn at fentrau bach a chanolig ac yn cynnig cefnogaeth. Mae'r Gweinidog wedi dweud bod y banc datblygu â swyddogaeth ragweithiol wrth hwyluso cymorth i fusnesau, ond nid yw yn dweud yn iawn wrthym ni sut mae'r gwaith hwnnw'n digwydd, ac felly efallai y gallai'r Gweinidog ddweud wrthym ni sut yn union y mae'r banc datblygu yn gweithio gyda busnesau bach yn benodol, o ystyried yr hinsawdd ariannol bresennol.

Mae datganiad heddiw yn tynnu sylw at waith da iawn gan y banc datblygu. Mae hi'n wych clywed ei fod wedi buddsoddi £78 miliwn o ecwiti i fusnesau yng Nghymru. Wrth gwrs, mae angen i ni sicrhau bod yr arian yn mynd i fusnesau ym mhob rhan o Gymru, ac felly fe allai'r Gweinidog ddweud mwy wrthym ni efallai ynglŷn â sut mae Llywodraeth Cymru am sicrhau bod y banc yn codi ymwybyddiaeth o'i wasanaethau i fusnesau ym mhob cwr o'r wlad.

Mae'r Gweinidog wedi rhoi nod i'r banc o gyfanswm o £100 miliwn o ran buddsoddi ecwiti, sydd, ochr yn ochr â chyd-fuddsoddiad y sector preifat, yn gallu darparu dros £250 miliwn o gyfalaf i fusnesau. Fe fydd gweithio gyda chyd-fuddsoddwyr yn hanfodol os yw'r banc yn dymuno i'w fuddsoddiad mewn busnesau yng Nghymru fod â'r effaith fwyaf. Wrth gwrs, ar gyfer gwneud hynny, mae'n rhaid i'r banc barhau i annog y sector preifat i fuddsoddi ochr yn ochr ag ef ei hun, ac felly efallai y gall y Gweinidog ddweud mwy wrthym ni am y gwaith sy'n cael ei wneud i gynyddu'r cyd-fuddsoddiad hwnnw.

Nawr, rydym ni'n gwybod am effaith aruthrol pandemig COVID ar fusnesau yng Nghymru, ac mae gan y banc datblygu swyddogaeth bwysig o ran cefnogi adferiad economaidd a chefnogi busnesau. Mae hi'n hanfodol nad yw dull sy'n trin pawb yr un fath trwy'r amser yn cael ei fabwysiadu gan y banc, ac rwy'n falch o glywed y Gweinidog yn siarad am gynnig hyblygrwydd i'w gwsmeriaid trwy ataliad a gwyliau ad-dalu. Mae datganiad heddiw yn cydnabod yr heriau oherwydd costau cynyddol am ddeunyddiau, cyflogau ac, wrth gwrs, ynni y mae busnesau yn eu hwynebu ac felly efallai gall y Gweinidog ddweud ychydig mwy wrthym ni ynglŷn â sut y gall y banc roi cefnogaeth wedi'i theilwra ar gyfer busnesau o ran yr heriau penodol hyn.

Mae hi'n hanfodol ein bod ni'n cydnabod y swyddi sy'n cael eu creu gan y banc datblygu, ac mae swm o waith da wedi bod yn mynd rhagddo i nodi a mesur cynhyrchiant hefyd. Yn ôl cynllun corfforaethol y banc, ei nod o ran swyddi sylfaenol ar gyfer 2022 i 2027 yw 20,000 o swyddi, ond mae hi'n hanfodol bod cyfran o feintioli ansawdd swyddi. Ac felly, fe fyddwn i'n ddiolchgar pe bai'r Gweinidog yn dweud wrthym sut mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn cydnabod llwyddiant o ran swyddi, a'r hyn y mae llwyddiant yn ei olygu i Lywodraeth Cymru yn y maes penodol hwn.

Mae'r Gweinidog wedi dweud yn eglur heddiw y bydd busnesau sy'n derbyn buddsoddiad ecwiti yn cael cefnogaeth ddigyffelyb ar hyd eu taith fuddsoddi nhw. Mae datganiad heddiw yn cadarnhau y bydd y banc yn cefnogi cwmnïau technoleg newydd i ddwyn eu cynnyrch nhw ymlaen o gysyniad cynnar hyd at y farchnad, yn ogystal â busnesau sy'n anelu at dwf mawr, a thimau rheoli i brynu busnesau presennol a'u cadw nhw ym mherchnogaeth Cymru.

Rydw i, wrth gwrs, yn croesawu'r uchelgais yma, ac fe wnaiff y Gweinidog ddweud mwy wrthym ni efallai ynglŷn â sut mae'r banc yn buddsoddi mewn busnesau newydd ym maes technoleg newydd yn benodol. Mae rhywfaint o waith da wedi digwydd ynghylch cronfa sbarduno technoleg Cymru, ond mae angen gwneud mwy, ac felly fe fyddwn i'n ddiolchgar am unrhyw wybodaeth bellach y gall y Gweinidog ei rhoi yn hyn o beth.

Yn yr un modd, mae hi'n bwysig fod yna gefnogaeth i dimau rheoli sy'n awyddus i brynu busnesau cyfredol a'u cadw nhw ym mherchnogaeth Cymru. Hyd yma, mae Cronfa Buddsoddi Hyblyg Cymru, sy'n cael ei gweithredu gan Fanc Datblygu Cymru, wedi bod yn cynnig llwybr ariannu posibl ar sail dyled i'r gweithwyr allu prynu eu busnesau. Ac rwy'n gwybod bod cefnogaeth ar gael i reolwyr brynu busnesau drwy gronfa olyniaeth rheoli Cymru, ond efallai y gwnaiff y Gweinidog ddweud ychydig mwy wrthym ni ynglŷn â sut mae'r cronfeydd hynny'n cael eu gwerthuso a'u monitro, er mwyn i ni sicrhau bod y gefnogaeth briodol ar gael i fusnesau.

Ac yn olaf, mae datganiad heddiw yn cyfeirio at waith y banc datblygu i hyrwyddo trawsnewid yng Nghymru i amgylchedd busnes sy'n cynnig cryn dipyn yn fwy o ran datgarboneiddio. Mae gennyf i ddiddordeb arbennig yn natblygiad cynllun newydd a fydd yn caniatáu i fusnesau ymgymryd â benthyca ar gyfer ariannu buddsoddiad cyfalaf sy'n cyflawni datgarboneiddio. Yn wir, mae adroddiad blynyddol y banc yn dangos bod 41 y cant o'i gwsmeriaid wedi mynegi eu bod yn cael eu hysgogi i weithredu ynglŷn â newid hinsawdd, ond nad yw'r arbenigedd hwnnw ganddyn nhw mewn gwirionedd. Ac felly, fe fyddwn i'n ddiolchgar pe bai'r Gweinidog yn gallu dweud ychydig mwy wrthym ni am y cynllun newydd sy'n cael ei ddatblygu a phryd mae hwnnw'n debygol o fod ar waith.

Felly, wrth gloi, Llywydd dros dro, rydym ni'n gwybod mai un o brif themâu'r banc yw buddsoddi mewn busnesau sy'n adlewyrchu'r amrywiaeth yn ein cymunedau ni, ac mae'n rhaid i ni gofio bod y banc, yn ei hanfod, yn fuddsoddwr sy'n ceisio creu effaith sydd â phwrpas cymdeithasol. Ac, felly, a gaf i ddiolch i'r Gweinidog am ei ddatganiad ef y prynhawn yma, a dweud fy mod i'n edrych ymlaen at glywed mwy am waith y banc datblygu yn yr wythnosau a'r misoedd nesaf? Diolch i chi. 

15:30

Thank you for the series of questions. It's a good place to be making a statement, five years after Ken Skates launched the development bank. It's fair to say that, at the time, not everyone was as optimistic that we'd be at this point celebrating its successful journey, with it overachieving its investment targets.175

On your point around small businesses and how aware they are, actually, the Federation of Small Businesses undertook their own survey, which was published in February of this year, and it found that two thirds of their members were already aware of the development bank, and, also, there had been a significant increase in brand perception of the development bank over that five years since it was introduced, and that, actually, 92 per cent of customers had stated that they would use the development bank for future funding needs, and, again, that nine in 10 associated the development bank with being honest and trustworthy. And, I think, actually, when you think about financial institutions, that does show that not only has it got a significant amount of penetration and awareness within just five years, but that it also has a good reputation among its existing customers as well. We're interested in getting more of those people in that final third more aware of what the bank does and taking advantage of the products that it has to offer.176

As I said in my statement, the investment that can take place from the development bank, whether loan or equity, or a combination of both, is often part of the package of investment support, and that, I think, goes into your point around co-investment. Recently, I met with high-street banks and the development bank to talk about some of the challenges for the economy in Wales, the challenges that we've been seeing with the rise in interest rates, and what the investment climate looked like. Now, there is always a challenge in that some businesses are retrenching and not making investment choices, which is understandable given what's happened in the last six or seven weeks. But there are still businesses that are looking to invest.177

What we're talking about today is the launch, or the indication that we're going to be able launch within the turn of this year—that's my target; if not, then early in the new year—a new product to help people to invest in their future, to decarbonise and help with energy costs as well. So, we are looking to acquire more people to come into that area. And that's also an area where lots of high-street banks say that they have funds available for further investment. So, the challenge will be on co-investment, what DBW can do, what businesses themselves often put up—they're often looking for someone to bridge the gap between their finance and someone else—but also other potential investors, not just high-street banks. It does include, as I have mentioned, other equity investors.178

Part of our challenge is that most of the equity investment that takes place across the UK is concentrated in London and the south-east. If you were having this conversation with the south-west of England or the north of England, they would be looking on and saying, 'The problem is, there's too much in the over-heating south-east corner of England.' And they themselves—and if you talk to the FSB—would say, 'We would like to have a regional development bank like the Development Bank of Wales.' It's a positive advantage that people and business recognise, but we also do need to make sure that other equity investors look at Wales, to add to what we're doing in the development bank.179

Now, I mentioned the Cardiff capital region and their investment, but also the British Business Bank. They're unlikely to have their funds ready until next year. When the investment was announced by the former Chancellor, who's now the Prime Minister, he announced there would be a fund in Wales. It's fair to say that, at that time, there wasn't a plan. There is now something that looks more like a plan, and the development bank, as I say, have been engaging and really constructing what that would look like. It will still take time for that to get up and running, so I'm looking forward to that extra investment coming in to add to the picture. And, in addition, there are also not just individual private investors, but a number of sovereign wealth investors—from Europe and beyond—who are looking at opportunities in Wales. And part of the balance that we have to strike is, where is that a real opportunity, and how can we make sure that we get a deal that doesn't mean that those assets are taken out of Wales, but are grown here as well.180

I think that it goes on to your point about the tech sector. Both fintech and cyber are really good examples of where we have a strong sector in Wales and the opportunity to grow more—certainly in parts of the conversations I've had with banking institutions, with other sovereign wealth funds, and indeed with the sectors themselves. We really do have a very positive group of sectors within Wales. I think that it's one of the things we under-appreciate, that the rest of the world is looking at what we're doing and is very positive about it, both in terms of learning how we've got here, but also looking at whether they can invest in helping to grow the sector here as well. And in each of those sectors, we're likely to see high-value employment.181

The offer from both DBW and Business Wales includes tailored support, which I've mentioned in my statement, so it won't just be you'll get money—you'll get some support and consultancy around that. We've indicated that, in the new fund on investing in decarbonisation, consultancy support could be part of what's created, to understand the specific needs of an individual business. I'm very pleased to reiterate what I said about employee ownership, not just the management buy-out funds, but what we're already doing with groups like Cwmpas Cymru and the funds that they are running, to try to increase the number of employee-owned businesses across Wales and meet our manifesto pledge to double the sector.182

And finally, on your point about how we'll make sure that this is well known around Wales, of course, the development bank has five offices, located in Cardiff, Llanelli, Llandudno Junction, Newtown, and the headquarters, of course, in Wrexham.183

Diolch am y gyfres o gwestiynau. Mae hon yn sefyllfa fanteisiol i fod yn gwneud datganiad ynddi hi, sef bum mlynedd ar ôl i Ken Skates lansio'r banc datblygu. Mae hi'n deg dweud, ar y pryd, nad oedd pawb mor obeithiol y byddem ni'n gallu dathlu ei daith lwyddiannus ef nawr, a'i gyflawniadau o ran ei nodau buddsoddi sydd wedi bod yn well na'r disgwyl.

O ran eich pwynt chi ynglŷn â busnesau bach a pha mor ymwybodol ydyn nhw o hyn, mewn gwirionedd, fe ymgymerodd Ffederasiwn y Busnesau Bach â'u harolwg eu hunain, a gyhoeddwyd ym mis Chwefror eleni, ac roedd hwnnw'n canfod bod dwy ran o dair o'u haelodau yn ymwybodol o'r banc datblygu eisoes, a bu cynnydd sylweddol hefyd mewn ymwybyddiaeth o frand y banc datblygu dros y pum mlynedd ers ei sefydlu, a bod 92 y cant o gwsmeriaid, mewn gwirionedd, wedi dweud y bydden nhw'n defnyddio'r banc datblygu ar gyfer anghenion cyllido yn y dyfodol, ac, unwaith eto, bod naw o bob 10 yn cysylltu'r banc datblygu gyda gonestrwydd a hygrededd. Ac, yn fy marn i, mewn gwirionedd, pan fyddwch chi'n meddwl am sefydliadau ariannol, mae hynny'n dangos nid yn unig ei fod wedi ennill ei blwyf ac wedi codi'r ymwybyddiaeth ohono i'r fath raddau mewn dim ond pum mlynedd, ond bod enw da iddo hefyd ymhlith ei gwsmeriaid cyfredol, yn ogystal â hynny. Fe fyddem ni'n hoffi gweld mwy o'r bobl hynny yn y traean olaf hwnnw yn fwy ymwybodol o'r hyn y mae'r banc yn ei wneud ac yn manteisio ar y cynhyrchion sydd ganddo i'w gynnig.

Fel y dywedais i yn fy natganiad, mae'r buddsoddiad a all ddigwydd gan y banc datblygu, boed yn fenthyciad neu'n ecwiti, neu'n gyfuniad o'r ddau, yn rhan o'r pecyn o gefnogaeth buddsoddi yn aml, ac mae hynny, rwy'n credu, yn cyffwrdd â'ch pwynt chi ynglŷn â chyd-fuddsoddi. Yn ddiweddar, fe wnes i gwrdd â banciau'r stryd fawr a'r banc datblygu i siarad am rai o'r heriau i'r economi yng Nghymru, yr heriau yr ydym ni wedi bod yn eu gweld nhw gyda'r cynnydd mewn cyfraddau llog, a sut olwg a oedd ar yr hinsawdd fuddsoddi. Nawr, mae yna her bob amser oherwydd bod rhai busnesau yn ceisio arbed arian ac yn peidio â gwneud dewisiadau o ran buddsoddi, sy'n ddealladwy o ystyried yr hyn sydd wedi digwydd yn ystod y chwech neu saith wythnos diwethaf. Ond mae yna fusnesau sy'n bwriadu buddsoddi o hyd.

Yr hyn yr ydym ni'n ei sôn amdano heddiw yw'r lansiad, neu'r arwydd ein bod ni'n mynd i allu lansio o fewn y flwyddyn eleni—dyna fy nod i; os nad felly, yna yn gynnar yn y flwyddyn newydd—gynnyrch newydd i helpu pobl i fuddsoddi yn eu dyfodol nhw, i ddatgarboneiddio a helpu gyda chostau ynni hefyd. Felly, rydym ni'n gobeithio cael mwy o bobl i ddod i mewn i'r maes hwnnw. A dyna faes hefyd lle mae llawer o fanciau ar y stryd fawr yn dweud bod ganddyn nhw arian ar gael i'w fuddsoddi ymhellach. Felly, fe fydd yr her o ran cyd-fuddsoddi, yr hyn y gall Banc Datblygu Cymru ei wneud, yr hyn y mae'r busnesau eu hunain yn ei godi yn aml—mae nhw'n aml yn chwilio am rywun i bontio'r bwlch rhwng eu cyllid nhw a rhywun arall—ond buddsoddwyr posibl eraill hefyd, nid banciau'r stryd fawr yn unig. Mae hynny'n cynnwys, fel dywedais i, fuddsoddwyr ecwiti eraill.

Rhan o'n her ni yw bod y rhan fwyaf o'r buddsoddiad ecwiti sy'n digwydd ledled y DU wedi ei ganoli yn Llundain a de-ddwyrain Lloegr. Os oeddech chi'n cael y sgwrs yma gyda de-orllewin Lloegr neu ogledd Lloegr, fe fydden nhw'n dweud fel hyn, 'Y broblem yw, mae gormod o arian yng nghornel de-ddwyrain Lloegr sy'n gorlifo.' Ac maen nhw eu hunain—ac os ydych chi'n siarad â'r Ffederasiwn Busnesau Bach—yn dweud, 'Fe hoffem ninnau gael banc datblygu rhanbarthol fel Banc Datblygu Cymru.' Mae hi'n fantais fawr y mae pobl a busnesau yn ei chydnabod, ond mae angen i ni sicrhau bod buddsoddwyr ecwiti eraill yn edrych ar Gymru hefyd, ar gyfer ychwanegu at yr hyn yr ydym ni'n ei wneud yn y banc datblygu.

Nawr, roeddwn i'n sôn am brifddinas-ranbarth Caerdydd a'u buddsoddiad nhw, ond am Fanc Busnes Prydain hefyd. Maen nhw'n annhebygol o fod â'u harian nhw'n barod tan y flwyddyn nesaf. Pan gyhoeddwyd y buddsoddiad gan y cyn-Ganghellor, sy'n Brif Weinidog y DU erbyn hyn, fe gyhoeddodd ef y byddai cronfa yng Nghymru. Mae hi'n deg dweud, bryd hynny, nad oedd yna unrhyw gynllun arbennig. Erbyn hyn mae yna rywbeth sy'n edrych yn fwy tebyg i gynllun, ac mae'r banc datblygu, fel rwy'n dweud, wedi bod yn ymgysylltu ac yn cynllunio yn wirioneddol sut wedd a fyddai ar hynny. Fe fydd rhoi hynny ar waith yn cymryd peth amser eto, ac felly rwy'n edrych ymlaen at y buddsoddiad ychwanegol hwnnw sy'n dod i mewn i ategu'r darlun hwnnw. Ac, yn ogystal â hynny, ac nid buddsoddwyr preifat unigol yn unig chwaith, mae nifer o fuddsoddwyr cyfoeth sofran—o Ewrop a thu hwnt—sy'n edrych ar gyfleoedd yng Nghymru. A rhan o'r cydbwysedd y mae'n rhaid i ni ei daro yw, pan fo hwnnw'n gyfle gwirioneddol, yw sut ydym ni am wneud yn siŵr ein bod ni'n cael cytundeb nad yw'n golygu y bydd yr asedau hynny'n cael eu diwreiddio o Gymru, ond eu bod nhw'n cael eu tyfu yma hefyd.

Rwy'n credu bod hyn yn cyffwrdd â'ch pwynt chi am y sector technoleg. Mae technoleg ariannol a seiber yn enghreifftiau da iawn o sector sy'n gryf yng Nghymru a'r cyfle i hwnnw dyfu eto—yn sicr mewn rhannau o'r sgyrsiau a gefais i gyda sefydliadau bancio, gyda chronfeydd cyfoeth sofran eraill, ac yn wir gyda'r sectorau eu hunain. Mae gennym ni grŵp cadarnhaol iawn o sectorau yng Nghymru. Rwyf i o'r farn ei fod yn un o'r pethau yr ydym ni'n ei werthfawrogi, a bod gweddill y byd yn edrych ar yr hyn yr ydym ni'n ei wneud ac yn gadarnhaol iawn ynglŷn â'r peth, o ran dysgu sut y daethom ni yma, ond ar gyfer ystyried hefyd a allen nhw fuddsoddi er mwyn helpu i dyfu'r sector yn y fan hon hefyd. Ac ym mhob un o'r sectorau hynny, rydym ni'n debygol o weld cyflogaeth o werth mawr.

Mae'r cynnig gan Fanc Datblygu Cymru a Busnes Cymru yn cynnwys cefnogaeth a deilwrwyd, fel crybwyllais i yn fy natganiad, felly nid yn unig y cewch chi arian—fe gewch chi rywfaint o gefnogaeth ac ymgynghoriaeth ynglŷn â hwnnw. Rydym ni wedi dweud, yn y gronfa newydd ar gyfer buddsoddi mewn datgarboneiddio, y gallai cymorth ymgynghori fod yn rhan o'r hyn a gaiff ei greu, i ddeall anghenion penodol busnes unigol. Rwy'n falch iawn o ailadrodd yr hyn a ddywedais i am berchnogaeth gweithwyr, nid yn unig y cronfeydd ar gyfer prynu busnesau gan eu rheolwyr nhw, ond yr hyn yr ydym ni'n ei wneud eisoes gyda grwpiau fel Cwmpas Cymru a'r cronfeydd y maen nhw'n eu gweinyddu, i geisio cynyddu nifer y busnesau sy'n perthyn i'w gweithwyr ledled Cymru a gwireddu ein haddewid maniffesto i ddyblu'r sector.

Ac yn olaf, ynglŷn â'ch pwynt chi am ein dull ni o sicrhau y bydd hyn yn hysbys o gwmpas Cymru, wrth gwrs, mae gan y banc datblygu bum swyddfa, a leolir yng Nghaerdydd, Llanelli, Cyffordd Llandudno, y Drenewydd, a'r pencadlys, wrth gwrs, sydd yn Wrecsam.

15:35

Diolch i'r Gweinidog am ei ddatganiad. Ac wrth gwrs, mae yna rôl bwysig gan y banc yn nyfodol economi Cymru.184

I thank the Minister for the statement. And of course, there is an important role for the bank to play in the future of the Welsh economy.

The Development Bank of Wales offers support to its customers through a number of organisations, including Business Wales. Business Wales offers a range of free services to Welsh companies and sole traders. Nearly a year ago now, there were discussions in committee and Plenary over funding concerns for Business Wales, much of which goes to supporting those businesses. On 11 December 2021, you, Minister, noted that over a third of Business Wales funding comes from European sources. A year on, how has this impacted the Development Bank of Wales and Business Wales, and has an impact assessment been done? Around the same time, I also asked the Minister about the courses on offer from Business Wales, and I was grateful for the follow-up meeting we had on this topic. Since then, has there been any growth in the number and availability of courses provided?185

Now, co-operatives and social partnerships allow the Welsh economy to grow in a more sustainable way, and will play a huge role in tackling the cost-of-living crisis. And I'll take this opportunity to plug the cross-party group on co-operatives and mutuals tomorrow, where we'll be looking at exactly this issue. In June 2021, the Welsh Government committed to doubling the number of employee-owned businesses in Wales. Earlier this year, I asked the Minister about funding available for co-operatives, to help reach the Welsh Government's target of doubling the number of employee-owned businesses in Wales. I'd be keen to know what progress has been made to reach that target. I did note that, in his statement, there was talk of supporting management buy-outs. Is that rather than worker buy-outs in that particular context? There is an important distinction to make between manager and worker buy-outs. Both groups will have different priorities and intentions going forward.186

Finally, the net-zero business incentive next year. The initiative hopes to incentivise businesses to lower their carbon footprint based on an invest-to-save principle that should reduce energy consumption and lower businesses' bills in the long term. That, of course, is to be welcomed. Businesses looking at investing in renewables or energy-efficiency measures will be offered more favourable terms. Businesses can take on borrowing to fund capital investment that delivers on decarbonisation through more flexible repayment terms, attractive interest rates and wider support, such as help towards consultancy costs. The Minister is also tasking the bank with pursuing an ambitious equity investment target of £100 million over the next five to seven years.187

While this announcement to help towards net-zero targets in Wales is welcome, it's something I recently questioned you and the First Minister on, and it has been called for by many in this Chamber. How does this increased investment fit in with the principle of the just transition? In my line of questioning, I referred to businesses, specifically small independent breweries, that have stretched their finances further than they thought possible during the pandemic, and now, during the cost-of-living crisis, they may be reluctant to take on more debt. What would you say to them as well as those who would not be potentially eligible for this scheme?188

Also, would the Development Bank of Wales, within this initiative, be able to operate a fabric-first approach to energy efficiency, with the most favourable terms prioritising it? The fabric-first approach to building energy efficiency looks at maximising the performance of components and materials that make up a building itself, before the use of mechanical or electrical systems. Diolch yn fawr.189

Mae Banc Datblygu Cymru yn estyn cymorth i'w gwsmeriaid trwy nifer o sefydliadau, gan gynnwys Busnes Cymru. Mae Busnes Cymru yn cynnig amrywiaeth o wasanaethau yn rhad ac am ddim i gwmnïau ac unig fasnachwyr o Gymru. Bron i flwyddyn yn ôl bellach, cafwyd trafodaethau mewn pwyllgorau a'r Cyfarfod Llawn hefyd am bryderon ynglŷn â chyllid i Fusnes Cymru, y mae llawer ohono'n mynd at gefnogi'r busnesau hynny. Ar 11 o fis Rhagfyr 2021, fe wnaethoch chi, Gweinidog, nodi bod dros draean o arian Busnes Cymru yn dod o ffynonellau Ewropeaidd. Flwyddyn yn ddiweddarach, sut mae hyn wedi effeithio ar Fanc Datblygu Cymru a Busnes Cymru, ac a oes asesiad effaith wedi cael ei wneud? Tua'r un pryd, fe ofynnais i'r Gweinidog hefyd am y cyrsiau a gynigir gan Fusnes Cymru, ac roeddwn i'n ddiolchgar am y cyfarfod dilynol a gawsom ni ynglŷn â'r pwnc hwnnw. Ers hynny, a oes unrhyw ehangu wedi bod o ran niferoedd y cyrsiau a faint sydd ar gael?

Nawr, mae cwmnïau cydweithredol a phartneriaethau cymdeithasol yn caniatáu i economi Cymru dyfu mewn ffordd fwy cynaliadwy, ac fe fydd rhan enfawr ganddyn nhw wrth fynd i'r afael â'r argyfwng costau byw. Ac rwyf i am achub ar y cyfle hwn i roi cyhoeddusrwydd i'r grŵp trawsbleidiol ar gwmnïau cydweithredol a chydfuddiannol sy'n cael ei gynnal yfory, pryd byddwn ni'n edrych ar yr union fater hwn. Ym mis Mehefin 2021, ymrwymodd Llywodraeth Cymru i ddyblu nifer y busnesau sy'n perthyn i'w gweithwyr yng Nghymru. Yn gynharach eleni, fe ofynnais i'r Gweinidog am y cyllid sydd ar gael ar gyfer cwmnïau cydweithredol, ar gyfer helpu i gyrraedd nod Llywodraeth Cymru o ddyblu nifer y busnesau sy'n eiddo i'w gweithwyr yng Nghymru. Fe fyddwn i'n awyddus i wybod pa gynnydd sydd wedi bod o ran cyrraedd y nod hwnnw. Fe wnes i nodi, yn ei ddatganiad ef, ei fod wedi sôn am gefnogi rheolwyr sy'n prynu busnesau. Ai hynny felly yn hytrach na gweithwyr yn prynu busnesau yn y cyd-destun penodol hwnnw? Mae gwahaniaeth pwysig i'w nodi rhwng rheolwyr yn prynu a gweithwyr yn prynu. Fe fydd gan y ddau grŵp flaenoriaethau a bwriadau gwahanol wrth symud ymlaen.

Yn olaf, cymhelliant sero net busnesau'r flwyddyn nesaf. Mae'r fenter honno'n gobeithio cymell busnesau i ostwng eu hôl troed carbon ar sail yr egwyddor o fuddsoddi i arbed ac fe ddylai hynny leihau'r defnydd o ynni a biliau busnesau is yn yr hirdymor. Mae hynny, wrth gwrs, i'w groesawu. Fe fydd busnesau sy'n ystyried buddsoddi mewn ynni adnewyddadwy neu fesurau effeithlonrwydd ynni yn cael cynnig o delerau mwy ffafriol. Fe all busnesau fenthyca i ariannu buddsoddiad cyfalaf sy'n cyflawni datgarboneiddio drwy delerau ad-dalu mwy hyblyg, cyfraddau llog deniadol a chefnogaeth yn fwy eang, fel cymorth tuag at gostau ymgynghoriaeth. Mae'r Gweinidog yn rhoi'r gorchwyl i'r banc hefyd i anelu at nod uchelgeisiol o fuddsoddi ecwiti o £100 miliwn dros y pump i saith mlynedd nesaf.

Er bod y cyhoeddiad hwn i helpu anelu at nodau sero net yng Nghymru i'w groesawu, mae hwn yn rhywbeth y gwnes i eich holi chi a'r Prif Weinidog ynglŷn ag ef yn ddiweddar, ac fe alwyd amdano gan lawer yn y Siambr hon. Sut mae'r cynnydd hwn mewn buddsoddi yn cyd-fynd ag egwyddor pontio teg? Wrth i mi holi, roeddwn i'n cyfeirio at fusnesau, bragdai annibynnol bychain yn benodol, sydd wedi ymestyn eu cyllid ymhellach nag yr oedden nhw'n credu ei bod hi'n bosibl yn ystod y pandemig, a nawr, yn ystod yr argyfwng costau byw, efallai eu bod nhw'n amharod i ysgwyddo mwy o ddyled. Beth fyddech chi'n ei ddweud wrthyn nhw yn ogystal â'r rhai na fydden nhw o bosibl yn gymwys ar gyfer y cynllun hwn?

Hefyd, a fyddai Banc Datblygu Cymru, yn sgil y fenter hon, yn gallu rhedeg dull gweithredu sy'n rhoi blaenoriaeth i ddeunyddiau adeiladu effeithlon o ran ynni, gyda'r telerau mwyaf ffafriol yn cael eu rhoi ar gyfer adeiladu â'r deunyddiau hynny? Mae'r dull o sicrhau effeithlonrwydd ynni sy'n rhoi blaenoriaeth i ddeunyddiau yn ceisio gwella perfformiad y darnau a'r deunyddiau yn lluniad yr adeilad ei hun, cyn defnyddio unrhyw systemau mecanyddol neu drydanol. Diolch yn fawr.

15:40

To start with, on your point about the individual courses available, I'm not in a position to answer that individual point now, but I will make sure I come back to you with the detail on that particular point.190

On your final point around net-zero investment and the announcement that we've made today on the new support that should be available to help with decarbonisation and energy efficiency and reducing energy costs, the last time we spoke I did indicate I'd have more to say in the coming weeks, and here we are. We've been working on this for a period of time. It isn't something that's been created in the last week or so.191

Part of this is about trying to generate a just transition, to make sure that, as we decarbonise, we don't simply keep the jobs we have, but we actually help to de-risk some of the future, not just from a broader climate perspective, but from the business costs that exist now. It's something that I think a number of businesses will want to look very closely at. And, as I say, on the point about the individual circumstances you mentioned for each business, well, they vary from one business to another. Individual businesses in the same sector will have different needs, they may have different opportunities to take advantage of that. That is, both looking at the fabric of their own institutions as they are now and their opportunities to maximise that. It's why I pointed out that the opportunity is to look at what's possible for that individual business. It's also possible we may end up being able to support district energy schemes as well, if you think about the number of businesses that may share a common broad footprint around a business park or an area and would want to have a look at whether it's possible to do more within a particular setting and not simply on each individual business. So, there'll be a range of circumstances that will be individual. 192

The other reality we have to confront is that, even with the support that is available, and this is from the bank and its lending, whether it's equity or loan finance individually or a combination thereof, the Welsh Government doesn't, as we've talked about today, have the firepower to provide a grants based scheme to reach into every area of the economy. I know there are more businesses with challenges that I do think would otherwise be viable businesses than we have the means to support. It's why we await so keenly the outcome of the Halloween budget. I don't know if you had an opportunity to listen to the finance Minister in today's Welsh Government press conference, but the reality of our budget is one where we simply don't have additional money that is being kept back in the hope that we can then invest it over the coming weeks and months. It's a very, very difficult financial picture that we face, and businesses themselves know that.193

In the conversations I've had with a variety of business groups of different sizes in different sectors, they all know that we don't have the money waiting for them. In fact, manufacturing businesses were very clear that they were anxious about the future, not because they didn't have full order books, but because they knew about the rising costs and prices for goods, the challenges in inflation, and they know that really it requires the UK Government to act like they are really on their side to help them through what's coming. We're all going to find out fairly soon what that really looks like. I'd be delighted to be proven wrong and that there is going to be a generous package available to help businesses to not just survive where they are, but to genuinely prosper in the future. Here in Wales, though, we will make the most of the advantages we do have, and DBW is one of those. But I can't tell you or anyone else that we can save every single business that we would otherwise want to.194

When it comes to DBW and Business Wales and the reality of where we are with post-European funding, as I've indicated—and I've been absolutely upfront from the outset—there is a real and significant impact from European funds disappearing and not being replaced on a like-for-like basis in terms of the value or, indeed, how they're then purposed. What it does mean, though, is that to maintain Business Wales, which is what I have done, I've had to make really difficult choices in the rest of my departmental budget. That means other areas I would otherwise have wanted to invest in to help support the future of the Welsh economy I haven't been able to, because I think the Business Wales service is really important across the whole of Wales, and you can see that from the outcomes and the numbers of businesses that have had help, support and advice from Business Wales. Again, the Federation of Small Businesses regularly tell their counterparts in the rest of the UK that what we have in Wales is really worthwhile. Actually, the FSB in England would like to see a service like Business Wales in regions across England. That explains why I protected the budgets for the future for the services they provide. If we did have the same amount of money to invest in different choices, it would mean I could do more, and, indeed, that DBW could grow more as well.195

Finally, when it comes to support practically for employee-owned businesses—and I recognise the point that management buy-outs aren't necessarily exactly the same—we're now up to 40 employee-owned businesses, and I've recently confirmed that extra £170,000 to Cwmpas Cymru to help with that practical support to move businesses from one ownership model into another. There are really good examples of new employee-owned businesses in Wales, and I look forward to announcing when we have, as I'm confident that we will do, achieved our manifesto goal of doubling the size of the sector.196

I ddechrau, ynglŷn â'ch pwynt chi am y cyrsiau unigol sydd ar gael, nid wyf i mewn sefyllfa i ateb y pwynt arbennig hwnnw nawr, ond fe fyddaf i'n gwneud yn siŵr fy mod yn dod yn ôl atoch chi gyda'r manylion o ran y pwynt arbennig hwnnw.

Ynglŷn â'ch pwynt olaf chi ynghylch buddsoddiad sero net a'r cyhoeddiad a wnaethom ni heddiw ynghylch y gefnogaeth newydd a ddylai fod ar gael i helpu gyda datgarboneiddio ac effeithlonrwydd ynni a lleihau costau ynni, y tro diwethaf i ni siarad fe fynegais i y byddai gennyf i fwy i'w ddweud yn ystod yr wythnosau nesaf, a dyma ni. Rydym ni wedi bod yn gweithio ar hynny ers cryn amser. Nid rhywbeth sydd wedi ei greu yn ystod yr wythnos diwethaf fwy neu lai mohono.

Ystyr hyn yn rhannol yw ceisio creu pontio teg, i sicrhau, wrth i ni ddatgarboneiddio, nad ydym ni dim ond yn cadw'r swyddi sydd gennym ni, ond ein bod ni mewn gwirionedd yn helpu i leihau risgiau'r dyfodol i raddau, nid yn unig o safbwynt ehangach o ran yr hinsawdd, ond o ran y costau sy'n bodoli nawr i fusnesau. Dyma rywbeth yn fy marn i y bydd nifer o fusnesau yn awyddus i'w ystyried yn fanwl iawn. Ac, fel dywedaf i, ar y pwynt ynglŷn ag amgylchiadau unigryw busnesau unigol fel roeddech chi'n sôn, wel, mae'r rhain yw amrywio yn fawr rhwng y naill fusnes a'r llall. Bydd anghenion busnesau unigol yn yr un sector yn wahanol, a chyfleoedd amrywiol ganddyn nhw, efallai, i fanteisio ar hynny. Hynny yw, edrych ar wead eu sefydliadau nhw ar hyn o bryd a'u cyfleoedd nhw i wneud y gorau o hynny. Dyna pam yr oeddwn i'n tynnu sylw at y ffaith mai'r cyfle sydd yma yw gallu edrych ar yr hyn sy'n bosibl i'r busnes unigol hwnnw. Yn ogystal â hynny, fe fydd hi'n bosibl y byddwn ni'n gallu cefnogi cynlluniau ynni ardal yn y pen draw hefyd, os ydych chi'n meddwl am nifer y busnesau a allai rannu ôl troed eang cyffredin yng nghyd-destun parc busnes neu ardal ac sy'n awyddus i ystyried a fyddai hi'n bosib gwneud mwy o fewn lleoliad arbennig ac nid yn unig yng nghyd-destun busnesau unigol. Felly, fe fydd yna amrywiaeth o wahanol amgylchiadau unigol.

Y gwirionedd arall y mae'n rhaid i ni ei wynebu yw, hyd yn oed gyda'r gefnogaeth sydd ar gael, ac mae hyn oddi wrth y banc a'r benthyciadau a gynigir ganddo, pa un a yw ar ffurf ecwiti neu'n gyllid benthyg unigol neu gyfuniad o'r pethau hyn, nid oes gan Lywodraeth Cymru, fel rydym ni wedi dweud heddiw, mo'r grym noeth i ddarparu cynllun ar sail grantiau a fydd yn ymestyn at bob maes yn yr economi. Fe wn i fod yna fwy o fusnesau â heriau a fyddai'n fusnesau hyfyw fel arall yn fy marn i ond nid oes gennym ni fodd i'w cefnogi nhw. Dyna pam yr ydym ni'n aros mor ddisgwylgar am ganlyniad y gyllideb Calan Gaeaf. 'Wn i ddim a gawsoch chi gyfle i wrando ar y Gweinidog cyllid yng nghynhadledd Llywodraeth Cymru i'r wasg heddiw, ond y sefyllfa wirioneddol o ran ein cyllideb ni'n syml yw nad oes gennym ni arian ychwanegol sy'n cael ei ddal yn ôl mewn gobaith y gallwn ni ei fuddsoddi eto dros yr wythnosau a'r misoedd nesaf. Mae hwn yn ddarlun ariannol dyrys tu hwnt sy'n ein hwynebu ni, ac mae'r busnesau eu hunain yn gwybod hynny hefyd.

Yn y sgyrsiau a gefais i ag amrywiaeth o grwpiau busnes o wahanol feintiau mewn gwahanol sectorau, roedden nhw i gyd yn gwybod nad yw'r arian gennym ni'n aros ar eu cyfer nhw. Mewn gwirionedd, roedd busnesau gweithgynhyrchu yn eglur iawn eu bod nhw'n bryderus ynglŷn â'r dyfodol, nid am nad oedd ganddyn nhw lyfrau'n llawn archebion, ond oherwydd eu bod nhw'n ymwybodol o'r costau a'r prisiau cynyddol ar gyfer nwyddau, yr heriau o ran chwyddiant, ac maen nhw'n gwybod mewn gwirionedd bod angen i Lywodraeth y DU weithio fel pe byddai hi ar eu hochr nhw i'w helpu nhw drwy'r hyn sydd i ddod. Fe fyddwn ni i gyd yn canfod yn weddol fuan sut wedd fydd ar bethau mewn gwirionedd. Fe fyddwn i'n falch iawn o gael fy nghywiro ac y bydd pecyn hael ar gael i helpu busnesau i oroesi yn eu sefyllfa bresennol, ond nid yn unig hynny, i ffynnu mewn gwirionedd yn y dyfodol. Yma yng Nghymru, serch hynny, fe fyddwn yn gwneud y gorau o'r manteision sydd gennym ni, ac mae Banc Datblygu Cymru yn un o'r rhain. Ond ni allaf i ddweud wrthych chi na neb arall y byddwn ni'n gallu achub pob busnes unigol y byddem ni fel arall yn awyddus i'w achub.

O ran Banc Datblygu Cymru a Busnes Cymru a'r sefyllfa bresennol wirioneddol gyda chyllid yn lle cyllid o Ewrop, fel nodais i—ac rwyf i wedi bod yn gwbl agored o'r cychwyn cyntaf—fe geir effaith wirioneddol ac arwyddocaol oherwydd y cronfeydd Ewropeaidd sy'n diflannu heb unrhyw beth tebyg o ran gwerth yn eu lle nhw neu, yn wir, o ran eu dibenion nhw. Yr hyn y mae'n yn ei olygu, er hynny, yw ar gyfer cynnal Busnes Cymru, sef yr hyn a wnes i, rwyf i wedi gorfod gwneud dewisiadau anodd iawn gyda gweddill fy nghyllideb adrannol i. Mae hynny'n golygu nad wyf i wedi gallu buddsoddi mewn meysydd eraill y byddwn i fel arall wedi bod yn awyddus i fuddsoddi ynddyn nhw i helpu i gefnogi dyfodol economi Cymru, am fy mod i o'r farn fod gwasanaeth Busnes Cymru yn wir bwysig ledled Cymru, ac fe allwch chi weld hynny o'r canlyniadau a'r niferoedd o fusnesau sydd wedi cael cefnogaeth, cymorth a chyngor gan Fusnes Cymru. Unwaith eto, mae Ffederasiwn y Busnesau Bach yn dweud wrth eu cymheiriaid yng ngweddill y DU yn rheolaidd fod yr hyn sydd gennym ni yng Nghymru mewn gwirionedd yn werthfawr iawn. Mewn gwirionedd, fe hoffai Ffederasiwn y Busnesau Bach yn Lloegr weld gwasanaeth fel Busnes Cymru mewn rhanbarthau ledled Lloegr. Mae hynny'n esbonio pam y bu i mi warchod y cyllidebau i'r dyfodol ar gyfer y gwasanaethau y maen nhw'n eu cynnig. Pe byddai swm tebyg o arian gennym ni i fuddsoddi mewn gwahanol ddewisiadau, fe fyddai'n golygu y byddem ni'n gallu gwneud mwy, ac, yn wir, fe allai Banc Datblygu Cymru ehangu eto hefyd.

Yn olaf, o ran cefnogaeth ymarferol i fusnesau sy'n eiddo i'w gweithwyr—ac rwy'n cydnabod y pwynt nad yw  rheolwyr yn prynu busnesau yn gwbl gyfystyr â hynny o reidrwydd—mae gennym ni hyd at 40 o fusnesau sy'n eiddo i'w gweithwyr erbyn hyn, ac yn ddiweddar rwyf i wedi cadarnhau bod £170,000 ychwanegol ar gael i Gwmpas Cymru i helpu gyda'r cymorth ymarferol hwnnw i symud busnesau o un dull o berchnogaeth i un arall. Fe geir enghreifftiau da iawn o fusnesau newydd sy'n eiddo i'w gweithwyr yng Nghymru, ac rwy'n edrych ymlaen at gyhoeddi pryd y byddwn ni, fel rwy'n ffyddiog y byddwn ni, wedi cyflawni ein nod maniffesto ni, sef dyblu maint y sector.

15:45

I very much welcome the statement. I agree with the Minister that the development bank here in Wales means we can maintain capability and stability to drive economic development. I, like Paul Davies, am pleased that the development bank is taking a proactive role in facilitating help for businesses. I have three questions. How is it intended to help businesses move from small to medium-sized enterprises, which is one of the weaknesses of the Welsh economy? Is it the Minister's intention to prioritise the three growth sectors of life sciences, ICT and financial services? And, perhaps, most importantly to me, from Swansea, will the bank further support the Swansea bay city region projects? 197

Rwy'n croesawu'r datganiad yn fawr iawn. Rwy'n cytuno â'r Gweinidog fod y banc datblygu yma yng Nghymru yn golygu y gallwn ni gynnal y gallu a'r sefydlogrwydd i ysgogi datblygiad economaidd. Rwyf i, fel Paul Davies, yn falch fod y banc datblygu am fod â rhan ragweithiol wrth hwyluso cymorth i fusnesau. Mae gennyf i dri chwestiwn. Ym mha ffordd y bwriedir iddyn nhw helpu busnesau i symud o fod yn fentrau bach i rai canolig, sef un o wendidau economi Cymru? Ai bwriad y Gweinidog yw blaenoriaethu tri o sectorau twf sef gwyddorau bywyd, TGCh a gwasanaethau ariannol? Ac, efallai, yn bwysicaf i gyd o fy safbwynt i, yn Abertawe, a fydd y banc yn rhoi mwy o  gefnogaeth i brosiectau dinas-ranbarth Bae Abertawe? 

Thank you for the questions. You're right; growth from small to medium and then from medium to large is one of our big challenges in the economy. Actually, it is exactly part of what DBW can do, because, often, it is the access to finance that holds people back. It's where high-street banks have seen a gap in what they do and DBW has been able to plug that gap. When it comes to the jobs and investment choices, it isn't just the funds that have helped to create about 2,600 jobs—to either safeguard or create those from the investment that's been made from the last financial year—but, actually, that adds to an increase in Welsh GVA of around £85.8 million within that year, and you expect that to carry on growing as we move forward. So, it is one of the things that I am genuinely concerned about.198

Yes, there is activity in life sciences, and there's activity in financial services, especially in the growing fintech sector we have. And on your broader point around the broader technology sector and what that looks like, actually these services go into most businesses now, and so there is something about what our broader tech sector is doing. On a recent trip, the trade mission that I led to the United Arab Emirates, we had lots and lots of tech businesses, small and medium-sized businesses, looking for investment and recognising that they had an opportunity, including businesses based in Swansea, you'll be very pleased to hear.199

And, yes, on your point around the Swansea bay city deal, we are looking at what DBW can do; how it can help to work with that and other growth deals in Wales to advance the projects they've got. I'm actually very positive about the practical progress that the Swansea bay city deal group is making on not just having a portfolio of projects, but on the investment that is already being made. 200

Diolch i chi am y cwestiynau. Rydych chi'n iawn; mae twf o fach i ganolig ac o ganolig i fawr wedyn yn un o'r heriau mawr i ni o ran yr economi. Mewn gwirionedd, dyma un o'r union bethau y gall Banc Datblygu Cymru ei wneud, oherwydd, yn aml, methu â chael gafael ar gyllid sy'n dal pobl yn ôl. Dyma pryd mae banciau ar y stryd fawr wedi gweld bwlch yn yr hyn y maen nhw'n ei wneud ac mae Banc Datblygu Cymru wedi gallu cau'r bwlch hwnnw. O ran y swyddi a'r dewisiadau o ran buddsoddi, nid arian yn unig sydd wedi helpu i greu tua 2,600 o swyddi—i naill ai ddiogelu neu greu rhai oherwydd y buddsoddiadau a fu yn ystod y flwyddyn ariannol ddiwethaf—ond, mewn gwirionedd, mae hynny'n ychwanegu at gynnydd yng ngwerth ychwanegol gros Cymru o tua £85.8 miliwn yn ystod y flwyddyn honno, ac rydych chi'n disgwyl i hynny barhau i dyfu wrth i ni symud ymlaen. Felly, dyna un o'r pethau yr wyf i'n wirioneddol bryderus yn ei gylch.

Oes, mae gweithgarwch mewn gwyddorau bywyd, ac fe geir gweithgarwch mewn gwasanaethau ariannol, yn enwedig yn y sector technoleg ariannol sy'n tyfu yma. Ac ynglŷn â'ch pwynt ehangach chi am y sector technoleg ehangach a sut olwg sydd ar hwnnw, mewn gwirionedd mae'r gwasanaethau hyn yn mynd i mewn i'r rhan fwyaf o fusnesau nawr, ac felly mae yna dipyn o ystyr i'r hyn y mae ein sector technoleg ehangach ni'n ei wneud. Ar daith ddiweddar, y daith fasnach a arweiniais i'r Emiradau Arabaidd Unedig, roedd gennym ni lawer iawn o fusnesau technoleg, busnesau bach a chanolig, yn chwilio am fuddsoddiad ac yn cydnabod bod cyfle iddyn nhw yn hyn o beth, gan gynnwys busnesau yn Abertawe, fe fyddwch chi'n falch iawn o'i glywed.

Ac ie, ynglŷn â'ch pwynt chi o ran bargen ddinesig Bae Abertawe, rydym ni'n edrych ar yr hyn y gall Banc Datblygu Cymru ei wneud; sut y gall helpu i weithio gyda honno a bargeinion twf eraill yng Nghymru i ddatblygu'r prosiectau sydd ganddyn nhw. Mewn gwirionedd rwy'n gadarnhaol iawn o ran y cynnydd ymarferol y mae grŵp bargen ddinesig Bae Abertawe yn ei wneud nid yn unig o ran bod â phortffolio o brosiectau, ond o ran y buddsoddiad sy'n cael ei wneud eisoes. 

Last week, Mervyn King, the former governor of the Bank of England, gave various interviews, including on the fact that we still haven't cracked the ongoing moral hazard of organisations that are too big to fail, which is why the Bank of England had to intervene in the markets following Liz Truss's disastrous mini-budget, to rescue pension funds that had dabbled in risky investments to increase the dividends they dish up. So, I very much welcome the role of the Development Bank of Wales, and we need many more organisations like that to provide a bit more stability in the financial markets. I very much welcome all the information you've provided about the equity investment that the development bank is providing for companies who want to decarbonise; that seems absolutely a win-win for those companies, as well as for our net-zero targets across the whole of Wales.201

Last week, I attended a conference organised by the Landworkers' Alliance and heard about the successful development of small-scale horticulture businesses that are profitable and require no subsidy. Both of them are based reasonably locally in south-east Wales, in both the Gower and the Vale of Glamorgan. You talk about wanting an economy where people have the skills and the protections that offer security through tough times. Did the recent economic summit discuss food security in the context of the fact that—202

Yr wythnos diwethaf, rhoddodd Mervyn King, cyn-lywodraethwr Banc Lloegr, gyfweliadau amrywiol, gan gynnwys rhai ynglŷn â'r ffaith nad ydym ni wedi datrys y broblem o berygl moesol parhaus sefydliadau sy'n rhy fawr i fethu, a dyna pam y bu'n rhaid i Fanc Lloegr ymyrryd yn y marchnadoedd yn dilyn cyllideb fechan drychinebus Liz Truss, i achub cronfeydd pensiwn a oedd wedi ymhél â buddsoddiadau llawn risg i gynyddu'r difidendau y maen nhw'n eu dosbarthu. Felly, rwy'n croesawu gwaith Banc Datblygu Cymru yn fawr iawn, ac mae angen llawer mwy o sefydliadau fel hyn i gynnig ychydig mwy o sefydlogrwydd yn y marchnadoedd ariannol. Rwy'n croesawu'r wybodaeth i gyd y gwnaethoch chi ei rhannu ynglŷn â'r buddsoddiad ecwiti y mae'r banc datblygu yn ei ddarparu ar gyfer cwmnïau sy'n dymuno datgarboneiddio; mae honno'n ymddangos yn fuddugoliaeth lwyr i'r cwmnïau hynny, yn ogystal ag o ran ein nodau sero net ni ledled Cymru.

Yr wythnos diwethaf, roeddwn i mewn cynhadledd a drefnwyd gan Gynghrair Gweithwyr y Tir ac fe glywais i am ddatblygiad llwyddiannus busnesau garddwriaeth bychain sy'n gwneud elw ac nad oes angen unrhyw gymhorthdal arnyn nhw. Mae'r ddau wedi eu lleoli yn weddol leol yn y de-ddwyrain, ym Mhenrhyn Gŵyr a Bro Morgannwg. Rydych chi'n sôn bod eisiau economi lle mae'r sgiliau a'r amddiffyniadau gan bobl i roi diogelwch iddyn nhw mewn cyfnodau anodd. A wnaeth yr uwchgynhadledd economaidd ddiweddar drafod diogelwch bwyd yng nghyd-destun y ffaith—

15:50

Could the Member ask her question, please?203

A wnaiff yr Aelod ofyn ei chwestiwn hi, os gwelwch hi'n dda?

—food is not coming into the wholesale market? And what investments are you aware of that the Development Bank of Wales may be investing in increasing the amount of food we are growing in Wales?204

—nad yw bwyd yn dod i mewn i'r farchnad gyfanwerthu? A pha fuddsoddiadau a ydych chi'n ymwybodol ohonyn nhw y gallai Banc Datblygu Cymru fod yn eu buddsoddi i gynyddu swm y bwyd yr ydym ni'n ei dyfu yng Nghymru?

It's not a specific objective of the development bank to increase food security in the country. It's not a specific objective that we've set. However, we have set objectives around helping to transition Wales to a more sustainable economy and plans around net zero. Lesley Griffiths, as you know, is the Minister who leads on the food sector. I mentioned this last week, and Alun Davies noted his lifetime's work in supporting the food and drink sector, sometimes personally—that actually we have seen a real growth in the sector from an export point of view. But there is something also about what we do need to do, and we recognise this within the Government, in broader food security for how food is produced, where it's produced, and how local it is as well.205

I'm not trying to avoid the issue; I just think that it's not the development bank that is the primary lever in doing that. It doesn't mean that projects that will help food security will not be supported. In fact, in the food and drink sector we have supported a number of projects to grow and to expand. At the economic summit it was much more about businesses in survival mode and wanting to understand what is likely to happen, and trade unions being interested in the terms and conditions of workers moving forward and what that means, but positively wanting to support businesses to have a good future. So, I think we're potentially talking at cross purposes about what the point and purpose of the summit was, because there wasn't a particular business that talked about food security in that event, and I wouldn't have necessarily expected there to be.206

I do take on board your point around pension funds, both the level of debt that they had and the level of risk they had. And of course what really changed and was very unexpected just a few weeks ago is actually that Government debt changed its profile as well. So, the value of that Government debt and that Government investment was a real factor for pension funds that were looking to provide a stable return for pension holders. I certainly hope, from the point of view of businesses, pensioners, and indeed householders, that we will see more stability from the UK market. It has a real impact not just on individual families but on individual businesses, because the terms of debt available are a real factor in holding off investment in the Welsh economy.207

Nid yw cynyddu diogelwch bwyd yn y wlad yn amcan penodol i'r banc datblygu. Nid yw'n amcan penodol y gwnaethom ni ei bennu. Er hynny, rydym ni wedi pennu amcanion ynghylch helpu Cymru i bontio i economi fwy cynaliadwy a chynlluniau ynghylch sero net. Lesley Griffiths, fel gwyddoch chi, yw'r Gweinidog sy'n arwain y sector fwyd. Fe soniais i am hynny'r wythnos diwethaf, ac fe nododd Alun Davies waith o ran cefnogi'r sector bwyd a diod ar hyd ei oes, mewn ffordd bersonol weithiau—ein bod ni mewn gwirionedd wedi gweld twf gwirioneddol yn y sector o safbwynt allforio. Ond mae yma rywbeth hefyd ynglŷn â'r hyn sydd ei angen i ni ei wneud, ac rydym ni'n cydnabod hynny yn y Llywodraeth, yng nghyd-destun diogelwch bwyd ehangach o ran sut caiff bwyd ei gynhyrchu, ymhle y caiff ei gynhyrchu, a pha mor lleol hefyd.

Nid wyf i'n ceisio osgoi'r mater; dim ond mai fy marn i yw nad y banc datblygu yw'r prif ysgogydd yn hyn o beth. Nid yw hynny'n golygu na fydd yna gefnogaeth i brosiectau sy'n cynnig diogelwch bwyd. Yn wir, yn y sector bwyd a diod rydym ni wedi cefnogi nifer o brosiectau i dyfu ac ehangu. Yn yr uwchgynhadledd economaidd roedd llawer mwy o sôn am fusnesau yn ceisio goroesi ac yn awyddus i ddeall yr hyn sy'n debyg o ddigwydd, ac undebau llafur â diddordeb yn nhelerau ac amodau gweithwyr sy'n symud ymlaen a'r hyn y mae hynny'n ei olygu, ond yn sicr yn dymuno cefnogi busnesau i fwynhau dyfodol llewyrchus. Felly, rwy'n credu ein bod ni'n siarad yn groes i'n gilydd o ran diben a phwrpas yr uwchgynhadledd, oherwydd ni wnaeth unrhyw fusnes arbennig sôn am ddiogelwch bwyd yn y digwyddiad hwnnw, ac ni fyddwn i wedi disgwyl hynny o reidrwydd.

Rwy'n deall eich pwynt chi ynglŷn â chronfeydd pensiynau, maint y ddyled a oedd ganddyn nhw a chyfradd y risg a oedden nhw'n ei hwynebu hefyd. Ac wrth gwrs yr hyn a newidiodd mewn gwirionedd ac a oedd yn annisgwyl iawn ychydig wythnosau yn ôl, yw bod dyled y Llywodraeth wedi newid ei phroffil. Felly, roedd gwerth dyled y Llywodraeth honno a buddsoddiad y Llywodraeth yn ffactor gwirioneddol ar gyfer cronfeydd pensiynau a oedd yn ceisio darparu elw sefydlog i ddeiliaid y pensiynau. Rwyf i'n sicr yn gobeithio, o safbwynt busnesau, pensiynwyr, a deiliaid tai, yn wir, y byddwn ni'n gweld mwy o sefydlogrwydd o du marchnad y DU. Mae ganddo effaith wirioneddol nid yn unig ar deuluoedd unigol ond ar fusnesau unigol, oherwydd mae amodau'r ddyled sydd ar gael yn ffactor gwirioneddol wrth rwystro buddsoddi yn economi Cymru.

I enjoy the Minister's statements and I enjoy the conversations that he embarks upon across the Chamber. In discussing a lot of his different priorities for the investment bank he's made it very clear that he wants to see the development bank acting in a very agile way, looking for opportunities, and also investing in a creative way, and I very much welcome what he said this afternoon about decarbonisation.208

What I worry sometimes, Minister, is that there are not very clear objectives and targets set for this activity. For example, one of the biggest issues facing us in the Welsh economy is that of productivity. What guidance or advice have you given the development bank to address issues of productivity in the economy, and how will you measure whether the development bank is having an impact on that?209

The constituency I represent in Blaenau Gwent, of course, is one of the areas where we need greater investment, not only in productivity but in economic activity. Do you give the development bank clear guidance on a spatial aspect to their investment, so that you look and you set targets for investment in the Heads of the Valleys, for example, to ensure that you actually are investing not simply in businesses to achieve global outcomes, which would drive investment to places like Cardiff and the M4 corridor, but to drive investment into some of the more difficult parts of Wales, which are suffering from significant market failure?210

Rwy'n mwynhau datganiadau'r Gweinidog ac yn mwynhau'r sgyrsiau y mae'n eu cychwyn ar draws y Siambr. Wrth drafod llawer o'i flaenoriaethau amrywiol ef ar gyfer y banc buddsoddi fe'i gwnaeth hi'n eglur ei fod ef yn awyddus i weld y banc datblygu yn gweithio mewn ffordd ystwyth iawn, yn chwilio am gyfleoedd, ac yn buddsoddi mewn ffordd greadigol hefyd, ac rwy'n croesawu'r hyn a ddywedodd ef brynhawn heddiw am ddatgarboneiddio yn fawr iawn.

Yr hyn sy'n fy mhoeni i weithiau, Gweinidog, yw na osodwyd amcanion na nodau eglur iawn ar gyfer y gweithgarwch hwn. Er enghraifft, un o'r materion mwyaf sy'n ein hwynebu ni yn economi Cymru yw cynhyrchiant. Pa ganllawiau neu gyngor a wnaethoch chi eu rhoi i'r banc datblygu ar gyfer mynd i'r afael â materion cynhyrchiant yn yr economi, a sut fyddwch chi'n mesur a yw'r banc datblygu yn cael effaith yn hynny o beth?

Mae'r etholaeth yr wyf i'n ei chynrychioli ym Mlaenau Gwent, wrth gwrs, yn un o'r ardaloedd lle mae angen mwy o fuddsoddiad arnom ni, nid yn unig o ran cynhyrchiant ond o ran gweithgarwch economaidd. A ydych chi'n rhoi canllawiau eglur i'r banc datblygu ynglŷn ag agwedd ofodol ei fuddsoddiad, fel eich bod chi'n edrych a'ch bod chi'n pennu nodau ar gyfer buddsoddi ym Mlaenau'r Cymoedd, er enghraifft, i sicrhau eich bod chi'n buddsoddi mewn gwirionedd nid yn unig mewn busnesau i sicrhau canlyniadau byd-eang, a fyddai'n ysgogi buddsoddiad i fannau fel Caerdydd a choridor yr M4, ond yn ysgogi buddsoddiad i rai o rannau llai breintiedig Cymru, sy'n dioddef o ran methiant sylweddol yn y farchnad?

15:55

There are two broad points there. The first is that, yes, when I do talk to the development bank I do take an interest in where that investment goes. If it was only going neatly in and around the centre of the Cardiff capital region, then that would not be what I think is appropriate, because it was partly set up to deal with the gap that has been mentioned about small to medium companies, as Mike Hedges mentioned, about access to capital for some of those businesses, which was often a problem from traditional lenders. Now, it doesn't mean that high-street lenders don't do anything for people on that growth journey, but actually it's where there's been a real call for further action. And also the different parts of the country that people are in, and I recognise with your own constituency it's a real factor. So, yes, we do look at that, but it's not just the development bank.211

I haven't set them a particular target or measure. I'm more than happy to discuss this with the Member and others—and we're due to have a broader meeting to talk about some of these points—about the remit that I set them and when and how we expect to see progress. But it is then also part of the conversation we have with the capital region, for example. What we're talking about with them and what we want to see and expect to see as the capital region invests more funds is to make sure that, again, it doesn't simply happen around Cardiff and Newport but that it's the whole capital region that needs to see the benefit—and not simply to get people quickly from other parts of the capital region into Cardiff or Newport or other major urban centres but actually to drive some growth in other parts of the region, too. It can't be all one way, taking people from the Valleys into Cardiff and Newport. 212

I think that's really important in terms of the metrics we set ourselves, and that goes into the productivity puzzle as well, because often a lot of that is the levers we have to invest in human capital, in the skills and in the people, and then to make sure we're getting people to invest in areas where those people themselves live and are able to work. So, it's part of the reason why we have the employability and skills plan, setting out what we will do. We'll need to look again to see if there's a different change in direction from the latest iteration of the UK Government, because that plan was set out when DWP were more active and people were closer to the market. We may well need to review again earlier than I thought we would do whether we're still doing enough and in the right place because, I'm afraid, we'll face a more difficult economic picture, with potentially more people out of work in the coming months.213

So, our interventions, like the ReAct+ programme—are they going to be doing enough to get people back into work rapidly, and are we doing enough to get people who have been in long-term economic inactivity back on a path to become active and to have the skills to not just get into work but then to succeed in work as well? It's also why we're looking at what we're doing in our skills policy place, not just in apprenticeships but also in in-work training as well. For the current workforce, the future of work is here already in very large number. In 10 years' time, most of the people in work will already be in work already. What we need to do is to make sure they have skills that are appropriate for the world of work in 10 years' time. So, much of this is going to be about investing in the current workforce, and that will definitely make a difference to productivity. 214

And the final point on this is investing in the quality of leadership and management within businesses. It isn't just workers on the shop floor, if you like, it is also about those leaders and managers who make a big difference to the effectiveness and productivity of a business as well. But, as I said, I'm very confident we'll talk about this more in the Chamber and outside it in the months ahead. 215

Fe geir dau bwynt bras yn y fan yna. Y cyntaf yw hyn, ydw, pan fyddaf i'n siarad â'r banc datblygu rwy'n hoffi gwybod i ble y bydd y buddsoddiad hwnnw'n mynd. Pe byddai hwnnw'n mynd i gyd yn ddestlus i ranbarth Caerdydd a'r cyffiniau yn unig, ni fyddai hynny'n briodol wedyn yn fy marn i, oherwydd fe gafodd ei sefydlu yn rhannol i ymdrin â'r bwlch y soniwyd amdano ynglŷn â chwmnïau bach i ganolig, fel roedd Mike Hedges yn dweud, am estyn cyfalaf i rai o'r busnesau hynny, a oedd yn broblem i fenthycwyr traddodiadol yn aml. Nawr, nid yw hynny'n golygu nad yw benthycwyr ar y stryd fawr yn gwneud unrhyw beth i helpu pobl ar y daith honno o ran twf, ond mewn gwirionedd dyma lle mae'r alwad wirioneddol wedi bod am weithredu pellach. A'r rhannau amrywiol o'r wlad y mae pobl ynddyn nhw hefyd, ac rwy'n cydnabod bod honno'n ffactor wirioneddol yn eich etholaeth chi. Felly, ydym, rydym ni'n ystyried hynny, ond nid yw'n ymwneud â'r banc datblygu yn unig.

Nid wyf i wedi pennu nod na mesur arbennig iddyn nhw. Rwy'n fwy na pharod i drafod hyn gyda'r Aelod ac eraill—ac mae cyfarfod ehangach i ddod ar gyfer trafod rhai o'r pwyntiau hyn—am y cylch gwaith a osodais i iddyn nhw a phryd a sut yr ydym ni'n disgwyl gweld cynnydd. Ond ystyr hyn wedyn hefyd yw cynnal rhan o'r sgwrs gyda'r brifddinas-ranbarth, er enghraifft. Yr hyn yr ydym ni'n ei siarad amdano gyda nhw a'r hyn yr ydym ni'n awyddus i'w weld ac yn disgwyl ei weld wrth i'r brifddinas-ranbarth fuddsoddi mwy o arian yw sicrhau, unwaith eto, nad yw'n digwydd o gwmpas Caerdydd a Chasnewydd yn unig ond bod angen i'r brifddinas-ranbarth yn ei chyfanrwydd weld y budd—ac nid yn unig i dynnu pobl yn gyflym o rannau eraill o'r brifddinas-ranbarth i Gaerdydd neu Gasnewydd neu ganolfannau trefol mawr eraill ond mewn gwirionedd i ysgogi rhywfaint o dwf mewn rhannau eraill o'r rhanbarth hefyd. Ni all fod i gyn i un cyfeiriad, tynnu pobl o'r Cymoedd i mewn i Gaerdydd a Chasnewydd.

Rwy'n credu bod hynny'n bwysig iawn o ran y metrigau yr ydym ni'n eu gosod i ni ein hunain, ac mae hynny'n cyffwrdd â'r penbleth o ran cynhyrchiant hefyd, oherwydd ystyr llawer o hynny'n aml yw'r ysgogiadau sydd ar gael i ni ar gyfer buddsoddi mewn cyfalaf dynol, mewn sgiliau a phobl, a gwneud yn siŵr ein bod ni'n cael pobl i fuddsoddi wedyn mewn ardaloedd lle mae'r bobl hynny eu hunain yn byw ac yn gallu gweithio ynddyn nhw. Felly, mae'n rhan o'r rheswm pam y mae'r cynllun cyflogadwyedd a sgiliau gennym ni, gan nodi'r hyn y byddwn ni'n ei wneud. Bydd angen i ni edrych eto i weld a oes unrhyw newid cyfeiriad sy'n wahanol yn yr ailadroddiad diweddaraf o Lywodraeth y DU, oherwydd fe nodwyd y cynllun hwnnw pan oedd yr Adran Gwaith a Phensiynau yn fwy gweithredol ac roedd pobl yn nes at y farchnad. Mae'n ddigon posibl y bydd angen i ni ystyried unwaith yn rhagor, yn gynt na'r disgwyl yn fy marn i, a ydym ni'n parhau i wneud digon a hynny yn y mannau priodol oherwydd, mae arna' i ofn, fe fyddwn ni'n wynebu darlun economaidd llymach, gyda mwy o bobl ar y clwt yn y misoedd nesaf o bosibl.

Felly, ein hymyriadau ni, fel rhaglen ReAct+—a ydyn nhw am wneud digon i gael pobl yn ôl i waith yn gyflym, ac a ydym ni'n gwneud digon i gael pobl sydd wedi bod mewn segurdod economaidd hirdymor yn ôl ar lwybr i fod yn gweithio a bod â'r sgiliau i wneud mwy na dim ond mynd i'r gwaith ond i lwyddo ym myd gwaith hefyd? Dyma pam yr ydym ni'n edrych ar yr hyn yr ydym ni'n ei wneud yn ein lle polisi sgiliau hefyd, nid yn unig o ran prentisiaethau ond mewn hyfforddiant mewn gwaith yn ogystal â hynny. O ran y gweithlu presennol, mae dyfodol gwaith yma eisoes mewn llu o wahanol ffyrdd. Ymhen 10 mlynedd, fe fydd y rhan fwyaf o'r bobl sydd mewn gwaith eisoes yn gweithio. Yr hyn sydd ei angen i ni ei wneud yw sicrhau bod y sgiliau ganddyn nhw a fydd yn addas ar gyfer y byd gwaith ymhen 10 mlynedd. Felly, ystyr hyn i raddau helaeth fydd buddsoddi yn y gweithlu presennol, ac fe fydd hynny'n bendant yn gwneud gwahaniaeth i gynhyrchiant.

A'r pwynt olaf yn hyn o beth yw buddsoddi yn ansawdd yr arweinyddiaeth a'r rheolaeth sydd gan fusnesau. Nid gweithwyr ar lawr gwaith yw hynny'n unig, os mynnwch chi, mae hynny'n ymwneud hefyd â'r arweinwyr a'r rheolwyr sydd hefyd yn gwneud gwahaniaeth mawr i effeithiolrwydd a chynhyrchiant busnesau. Ond, fel dywedais i, rwy'n ffyddiog iawn y byddwn ni'n siarad mwy am hynny yn y Siambr a'r tu allan iddi yn y misoedd i ddod. 

I'll allow one more question, if it's brief, and one more answer, if it's brief. Huw Irranca-Davies. 216

Rwyf i am ganiatáu un cwestiwn arall, os yw hwnnw'n un cryno, ac un ateb arall, os yw hwnnw'n un cryno. Huw Irranca-Davies. 

Thank you. Indeed, I will be brief. Minister, thank you for the statement and also for attending the lunchtime launch of the Centre for Local Economic Strategies report, 'Owning the workplace, securing the future', on how we increase the amount of employee ownership here in Wales. We're doing well already, we think we can go further. How can the Development Bank of Wales play a role within this, increasing employee ownership? Is there a role particularly for them to play when you have a problem of succession and changing over to employee ownership in the workplace, some sort of holding facility, some funding that would allow those discussions to happen with employees in the workplace so that it's not a rush of six months to all or bust, that we can actually pause and go through that process with them? What role does the Development Bank of Wales have in employee ownership?217

Diolch. Yn wir, fe fyddaf i'n gryno. Gweinidog, diolch am y datganiad a hefyd am ddod i lansiad adroddiad y Ganolfan Strategaethau Economaidd Lleol amser cinio, 'Owning the workplace, securing the future', ynglŷn â sut yr ydym ni'n cynyddu cyfradd perchnogaeth gan y gweithwyr mewn busnesau yma yng Nghymru. Rydym ni'n gwneud yn dda eisoes, rydym ni'n ystyried sut y gallwn ni fynd ymhellach. Sut all Banc Datblygu Cymru fod â rhan yn hyn o beth, gan gynyddu perchnogaeth gan y gweithwyr? A oes unrhyw ran arbennig iddyn nhw pan fo problem gennych chi o ran olyniaeth a throsglwyddo i berchnogaeth gan y gweithwyr yn y gweithle, rhyw fath o gyfleuster dal, rhywfaint o gyllid a fyddai'n caniatáu i'r trafodaethau hynny ddigwydd gyda gweithwyr yn y gweithle fel nad oes rhuthr gwyllt o chwe mis hyd at lwyddiant neu fethiant llwyr, ein bod ni mewn gwirionedd yn gallu pwyllo a mynd drwy'r broses honno gyda nhw? Pa swyddogaeth sydd gan Fanc Datblygu Cymru o ran perchnogaeth gan y gweithwyr?

The development bank is already active in this space, in supporting employee ownership, but it also has to work alongside others like Cwmpas Cymru, as you're aware. I'd be happy to have more of a conversation with you. As you know, at today's event, I committed to having a conversation with you and other actors in this space to not just look at the ideas from this lunchtime but to see how different institutions can play a part. I think it will be an interesting point to raise and to work through with the development bank itself. 218

Mae'r banc datblygu yn weithredol yn y maes hwn eisoes, yn cefnogi perchenogaeth gan y gweithwyr, ond mae'n rhaid iddo weithio ochr yn ochr ag eraill fel Cwmpas Cymru, fel gwyddoch chi. Fe fyddwn i'n hapus i gael sgwrs ehangach â chi. Fel gwyddoch chi, yn y digwyddiad heddiw, fe wnes i ymrwymo i gael sgwrs â chi a gweithredwyr eraill yn y maes hwn nid yn unig ar gyfer ystyried y syniadau a fynegwyd amser cinio heddiw ond i weld sut y gall gwahanol sefydliadau wneud eu rhan. Rwyf i o'r farn y bydd hwnnw'n bwynt diddorol i'w godi a gweithio drwyddo gyda'r banc datblygu ei hun. 

16:00
5. Datganiad gan y Gweinidog Newid Hinsawdd: Rôl y Sector Cyhoeddus yn System Ynni’r Dyfodol
5. Statement by the Minister for Climate Change: Public Sector Role in the Future Energy System

We'll move on now to item 5, a statement by the Minister for Climate Change on the public sector role in the future energy system, and I call on the Minister for Climate Change—Julie James.220

Symudwn ni ymlaen nawr i eitem 5, datganiad gan y Gweinidog Newid Hinsawdd ar rôl y sector cyhoeddus yn system ynni'r dyfodol, ac rwy'n galw ar y Gweinidog Newid Hinsawdd—Julie James.

Thank you, acting Presiding Officer.221

We have spent a great deal of time in this Chamber talking about the cost-of-living crisis, which is directly related to the major increase in the cost of energy. Keeping British people locked into the price of fossil fuels is bad for bill payers and disastrous for the action that we all know we need to take to tackle the climate emergency. The rising costs and lack of certainty of supply both strengthen the case for energy resilience and the need for control over our energy system. Our Government has championed the need for greater energy efficiency and more renewable energy, along with flexibility measures to make sure that we can always meet demand. These are the right long-term solutions to deliver on the current cost-of-living crisis and on the climate and nature crises. This much more local system requires us to be much more engaged with the energy system than previously. Government at all levels will need to take an active role in designing the net-zero energy system, one that enables people to live and move, yet has the lowest possible costs and impacts.222

I have been really pleased with the way that local authorities and regions have worked with us on energy plans that set out the changes that need to happen, and how those changes can deliver skilled jobs for people in their areas. Following the successful pilots in Conwy and Newport, I look forward to seeing the rest of our authorities developing detailed local energy plans, which will be the basis for the national energy plan in 2024. These plans don’t solve our immediate energy cost problems, but they do set a strong framework for us to collectively focus our action to protect ourselves in the medium term. In delivering these plans, we must think differently as a nation about how we manage public assets. We will only deliver net-zero obligations in ways that benefit communities by taking new and different approaches.223

We have already used the major public asset that is the Welsh Government woodland estate to deliver on our policy on renewables and local benefit. Natural Resources Wales has overseen the installation of four projects totalling 441 MW of onshore wind, with a further 134 MW still in development. This has delivered not just income to the public purse from lease payments and direct to communities from community benefit funds, but opportunities for communities to take ownership of part of these developments. The projects have also funded improvements in natural capital, such as restoring and expanding areas where peat was in danger of releasing greenhouse gases.224

It has been interesting to note that the companies winning lease competitions—those most prepared to deliver local benefits—are state-owned developers. We share the ambitions of these other nations, and we are determined to maximise the value that Wales receives from Welsh national assets used to generate energy. For the last two years, we have been working with NRW to assess the level of wind generation the woodland estate can support and to consider how to make sure that Wales keeps more of the benefits in a changing market. Public land presents a great opportunity, however, it is only fair to take a larger share in the risks if we wish to take more of the rewards for Wales.225

So, acting Presiding Officer, I am absolutely delighted to announce, as I set out in Net Zero Wales last year, that we are going to establish a Welsh state developer. We will take more risks where these are reasonable, and will earn the returns to benefit Welsh citizens. We will take forward projects on Welsh Government land and develop them commercially, whilst respecting the views of people and managing our natural resources sustainably. We will be delivering directly on our aims to have over a gigawatt of locally owned generation by 2030, and our manifesto commitment to at least an additional 100 MW of generation by 2026.226

This is a long-term approach, and we do not expect to see returns until towards the end of the decade. However, I expect significant returns compared to our investment. The income will help us support communities—as indeed we have already seen communities benefit during COVID and now the cost-of-living crisis—from the community funds from existing windfarms. But I am particularly keen to explore how we can link these developments with retrofitting homes nearby, using local businesses. This will involve working in a different way with the private sector. I hope that that sector will welcome another publicly owned member, working on an equal footing and returning profits to the public purse. We will be working with NRW to consider how, in future, we can offer up opportunities across the woodland estate that complement our own developments, opportunities for commercial and community developers to propose joint ventures with us.227

We also hope that our approach will help reshape the market elsewhere in Wales. Our deepening understanding of the economies of large-scale developments will help us set expectations about the level of local social and environmental benefit that it is reasonable to expect of other windfarms across Wales. We have a lot more work to do to set up a new company by April 2024. Alongside setting up the developer, we will develop a portfolio of projects, engaging at an early stage with communities and local authorities. We will also be looking in detail at the benefits that this approach will deliver. We will work with those who live near projects to define community benefit proposals that really make a difference to their lives. We will also work with Natural Resources Wales to make sure that those projects contribute to tackling both the climate and the nature emergencies.228

I'll keep the Siambr informed on progress as we work through the establishment of the developer. I hope that you will all welcome this announcement, as Wales becomes the first home nation to have a publicly owned Welsh renewables developer. Diolch.229

Diolch, Llywydd dros dro

Rydym wedi treulio llawer iawn o amser yn y Siambr hon yn siarad am yr argyfwng costau byw, sy'n uniongyrchol gysylltiedig â'r cynnydd mawr yng nghost ynni. Mae cadw pobl Prydain yn gaeth i bris tanwydd ffosil yn ddrwg i dalwyr biliau ac yn drychinebus i'r camau yr ydym ni i gyd yn gwybod y mae angen i ni eu cymryd i fynd i'r afael â'r argyfwng hinsawdd. Mae'r costau cynyddol a'r diffyg sicrwydd y bydd cyflenwad yn cryfhau'r achos dros gydnerthedd ynni a'r angen am reolaeth dros ein system ynni. Mae ein Llywodraeth wedi hyrwyddo'r angen am fwy o effeithlonrwydd ynni a mwy o ynni adnewyddadwy, ynghyd â mesurau hyblygrwydd i sicrhau y gallwn bob amser ateb y galw. Dyma'r atebion tymor hir cywir i gyflawni o ran yr argyfwng costau byw presennol a'r argyfyngau hinsawdd a natur. Mae'r system llawer mwy lleol hon yn gofyn i ni ymwneud llawer mwy â'r system ynni nag o'r blaen. Bydd angen i'r llywodraeth ar bob lefel fod â rôl weithredol wrth ddylunio'r system ynni sero-net, un sy'n galluogi pobl i fyw a symud, ond eto sydd â'r costau a'r effeithiau isaf posibl.

Rwyf wedi bod yn falch iawn o'r ffordd mae awdurdodau lleol a rhanbarthau wedi gweithio gyda ni ar gynlluniau ynni sy'n nodi'r newidiadau sydd angen digwydd, a sut y gall y newidiadau hynny sicrhau swyddi medrus i bobl yn eu hardaloedd. Wedi'r cynlluniau treialu llwyddiannus yng Nghonwy a Chasnewydd, edrychaf ymlaen at weld gweddill ein hawdurdodau yn datblygu cynlluniau ynni lleol manwl, a fydd yn sail i'r cynllun ynni cenedlaethol yn 2024. Nid yw'r cynlluniau hyn yn datrys ein problemau cost ynni ar unwaith, ond maent yn gosod fframwaith cryf i ni ganolbwyntio ar y cyd ein camau i amddiffyn ein hunain yn y tymor canolig. Wrth gyflawni'r cynlluniau hyn, rhaid i ni feddwl yn wahanol fel cenedl am sut rydyn ni'n rheoli asedau cyhoeddus. Byddwn ni'n cyflawni rhwymedigaethau sero-net yn unig mewn ffyrdd sydd o fudd i gymunedau trwy gymryd dulliau newydd a gwahanol.

Rydym eisoes wedi defnyddio'r prif ased cyhoeddus sef ystad goetir Llywodraeth Cymru i gyflawni ein polisi ar ynni adnewyddadwy a budd lleol. Mae Cyfoeth Naturiol Cymru wedi goruchwylio gwaith gosod pedwar prosiect gwerth 441 MW o wynt ar y tir, ac mae 134 MW arall yn dal i gael ei ddatblygu. Mae hyn wedi darparu nid yn unig incwm i'r pwrs cyhoeddus o daliadau prydles ac yn uniongyrchol i gymunedau o gronfeydd budd cymunedol, ond cyfleoedd i gymunedau gymryd perchnogaeth o ran o'r datblygiadau hyn. Mae'r prosiectau hefyd wedi ariannu gwelliannau mewn cyfalaf naturiol, fel adfer ac ehangu ardaloedd lle'r oedd mawn mewn perygl o ryddhau nwyon tŷ gwydr.

Mae wedi bod yn ddiddorol nodi bod y cwmnïau sy'n ennill cystadlaethau prydles—y rhai hynny sydd fwyaf parod i sicrhau buddion lleol—yn ddatblygwyr sy'n eiddo i'r wladwriaeth. Rydym yn rhannu uchelgais y cenhedloedd eraill hyn, ac rydym yn benderfynol o sicrhau cymaint â phosibl y gwerth y mae Cymru yn ei dderbyn gan asedau cenedlaethol Cymru a ddefnyddir i gynhyrchu ynni. Dros y ddwy flynedd ddiwethaf, rydym wedi bod yn gweithio gyda CNC i asesu lefel y cynhyrchu gan wynt y gall yr ystad goetir ei chynnal ac ystyried sut i sicrhau bod Cymru'n cadw mwy o'r manteision mewn marchnad sy'n newid. Mae tir cyhoeddus yn gyfle gwych, fodd bynnag, nid yw ond yn deg cymryd cyfran fwy o ran y risgiau os ydym yn dymuno cymryd mwy o'r enillion i Gymru.

Felly, Llywydd dros dro, rwy'n falch iawn o gyhoeddi, fel y nodais yn Cymru Sero Net y llynedd, ein bod ni'n mynd i sefydlu datblygwr gwladol Cymru. Byddwn ni'n cymryd mwy o risgiau pan fydd y rhain yn rhesymol, ac yn cael yr enillion er budd dinasyddion Cymru. Byddwn ni'n bwrw ymlaen â phrosiectau ar dir Llywodraeth Cymru ac yn eu datblygu'n fasnachol, gan barchu barn pobl a rheoli ein hadnoddau naturiol mewn ffordd gynaliadwy ar yr un pryd. Byddwn yn cyflawni'n uniongyrchol ar ein nodau i gael dros gigawat o gynhyrchiant dan berchnogaeth leol erbyn 2030, a'n hymrwymiad maniffesto i gynhyrchu o leiaf 100 MW ychwanegol erbyn 2026.

Mae hwn yn ddull hirdymor, ac nid ydym yn disgwyl gweld enillion tan tua diwedd y ddegawd. Fodd bynnag, rwy'n disgwyl enillion sylweddol o'u cymharu â'n buddsoddiad. Bydd yr incwm yn ein helpu i gefnogi cymunedau—fel yn wir yr ydym eisoes wedi gweld cymunedau'n elwa yn ystod COVID ac erbyn hyn yr argyfwng costau byw—o'r cronfeydd cymunedol o ffermydd gwynt presennol. Ond rwy'n arbennig o awyddus i archwilio sut y gallwn gysylltu'r datblygiadau hyn â ôl-osod cartrefi gerllaw, gan ddefnyddio busnesau lleol. Bydd hyn yn golygu gweithio mewn ffordd wahanol gyda'r sector preifat. Gobeithio y bydd y sector hwnnw'n croesawu aelod arall dan berchnogaeth gyhoeddus, gan weithio ar sail gyfartal a dychwelyd elw i'r pwrs cyhoeddus. Byddwn yn gweithio gyda CNC i ystyried sut, yn y dyfodol, y gallwn gynnig cyfleoedd ar draws yr ystad coetir sy'n ategu ein datblygiadau ni, cyfleoedd i ddatblygwyr masnachol a chymunedol gynnig mentrau ar y cyd gyda ni.

Rydym hefyd yn gobeithio y bydd ein dull ni o weithredu yn helpu i ailffurfio'r farchnad mewn mannau eraill yng Nghymru. Bydd ein dealltwriaeth ddyfnach o arbedion yn sgil datblygiadau mawr yn ein helpu i bennu disgwyliadau ynglŷn â faint o fudd cymdeithasol ac amgylcheddol lleol y mae'n rhesymol ei ddisgwyl gan ffermydd gwynt eraill ledled Cymru. Mae gennym lawer iawn mwy o waith i'w wneud i sefydlu cwmni newydd erbyn mis Ebrill 2024. Ochr yn ochr â sefydlu'r datblygwr, byddwn ni'n datblygu portffolio o brosiectau, gan ymgysylltu yn gynnar â chymunedau ac awdurdodau lleol. Byddwn hefyd yn edrych yn fanwl ar y buddion y bydd y dull hwn yn eu cyflawni. Byddwn yn gweithio gyda'r rhai sy'n byw ger prosiectau i ddiffinio cynigion budd cymunedol sydd wir yn gwneud gwahaniaeth i'w bywydau. Byddwn hefyd yn gweithio gyda Cyfoeth Naturiol Cymru i wneud yn siŵr bod y prosiectau hynny'n cyfrannu at fynd i'r afael â'r argyfyngau hinsawdd a natur.

Byddaf yn rhoi gwybod i'r Siambr ar y cynnydd wrth i ni weithio trwy sefydlu'r datblygwr. Gobeithio y byddwch i gyd yn croesawu'r cyhoeddiad hwn, wrth i Gymru fod y genedl gartref gyntaf i fod â datblygwr ynni adnewyddadwy dan berchnogaeth gyhoeddus yng Nghymru. Diolch.

16:05

Thank you, Minister, for your statement. It's really good to see that you're going forward in terms of looking at projects that can actually help us towards our ambitions of carbon zero, as well as putting more money back into the local economy. Now, currently, you do have a Welsh Government energy service. This has supported 242 projects, saving 716,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide from being emitted, whilst generating £322 million in local income and savings. From your statement, that is the bit that really stood out for me about an announcement of a Welsh state developer and new projects on Welsh Government land that will be then commercially developed in 2024. I suppose, going back to the current Welsh Government energy service, how will this work with the new one that you're setting up, because, in 2021, only five renewable energy projects were supported by the service? So, do you agree with me that, this service, if that's going to keep running, should be challenged to increase the numbers of renewable energy projects that it supports?230

Also, £5.34 million-worth of projects are being discontinued after securing finance, so the report actually states that the schemes were not built, but there is no clarity as to what has happened to the millions that were invested. So, maybe you could just elaborate on that further. Will you liaise with the service to establish what has happened to that? The auditor general published a report on the public sector's readiness to meet the net-zero 2030 target in August 2022, so there is uncertainty within the sector as to whether they can meet the net-zero target.231

Now just 10.4 per cent of our public sector bodies in Wales are confident that they're going to meet the 2030 target, and a further 40 per cent of public bodies neither agreed or disagreed with this statement. So, how are you confident that they're going to meet the sector's target? And another question: two months have passed since the warning shot that 90 per cent of public bodies could miss the 2030 net-zero target, so what steps are you taking to address this?232

Interestingly, the health sector are accounting for approximately a third of public sector emissions in Wales. The NHS Wales decarbonisation strategy delivery plan has set a target of 34 per cent reduction in carbon emissions, but the reality is that, if only a 34 per cent reduction from them is achieved, it will then be difficult for the public sector to deliver on its overall net-zero target. So, what steps will you do, how will you work with the Minister for health and social care to see a more challenging target set by NHS Wales? Others have warned that reaching the target will require additional financial resources, and, of course, the absence of these funds will be a barrier to progress. The main thrust of your statement was about this new development company, so how will that work with the energy service you had, and how will it actually deliver? How confident—?And, I suppose, my final question is: you say in 2024; we've got the climate crisis now, is there any way at all that that might be brought forward? Thank you.233

Diolch, Gweinidog, am eich datganiad. Mae'n dda iawn gweld eich bod chi'n bwrw ymlaen o ran edrych ar brosiectau a all ein helpu ni mewn gwirionedd tuag at ein huchelgeisiau o ran sero carbon, yn ogystal â rhoi mwy o arian yn ôl i'r economi leol. Nawr, ar hyn o bryd, mae gennych chi gwasanaeth ynni Llywodraeth Cymru. Mae hwn wedi cefnogi 242 o brosiectau, gan arbed 716,000 tunnell o garbon deuocsid rhag cael ei allyrru, gan gynhyrchu £322 miliwn mewn incwm a chynilion lleol. O'ch datganiad, dyna'r darn wnaeth wir sefyll allan i mi ynglŷn â chyhoeddi datblygwr gwladol Cymru a phrosiectau newydd ar dir Llywodraeth Cymru a fydd wedyn yn cael eu datblygu'n fasnachol yn 2024. Am wn i, gan fynd yn ôl at wasanaeth ynni Llywodraeth Cymru, sut fydd hwn yn gweithio gyda'r un newydd yr ydych chi'n ei sefydlu, oherwydd, yn 2021, dim ond pum prosiect ynni adnewyddadwy gafodd eu cefnogi gan y gwasanaeth? Felly, a ydych chi'n cytuno â mi, y dylid herio'r gwasanaeth hwn, os yw'n mynd i barhau i weithredu, i gynyddu niferoedd y prosiectau ynni adnewyddadwy y mae'n eu cefnogi?

Hefyd, mae gwerth £5.34 miliwn o brosiectau yn dod i ben ar ôl sicrhau cyllid, felly mae'r adroddiad mewn gwirionedd yn nodi na chafodd y cynlluniau eu hadeiladu, ond nid oes eglurder o ran yr hyn sydd wedi digwydd i'r miliynau a gafodd eu buddsoddi. Felly, efallai y gwnewch chi ymhelaethu ar hynny ymhellach. A fyddwch chi'n gydgysylltu â'r gwasanaeth i ganfod beth sydd wedi digwydd i'r rheini? Cyhoeddodd yr archwilydd cyffredinol adroddiad ar barodrwydd y sector cyhoeddus i gyrraedd targed sero-net 2030 ym mis Awst 2022, felly mae ansicrwydd o fewn y sector ynghylch a allan nhw gyrraedd y targed sero-net.

Nawr, dim ond 10.4 y cant o'n cyrff sector cyhoeddus yng Nghymru sy'n hyderus eu bod nhw'n mynd i gyrraedd targed 2030, ac nid oedd 40 y cant arall o gyrff cyhoeddus yn cytuno nac yn anghytuno â'r datganiad hwn. Felly, sut ydych chi'n ffyddiog eu bod nhw'n mynd i gyrraedd targed y sector? A chwestiwn arall: mae dau fis wedi mynd heibio ers i'r rhybudd y gallai 90 y cant o gyrff cyhoeddus fethu targed sero-net 2030, felly pa gamau rydych chi'n eu cymryd i fynd i'r afael â hyn?

Yn ddiddorol, mae'r sector iechyd yn gyfrifol am oddeutu traean o allyriadau'r sector cyhoeddus yng Nghymru. Mae cynllun cyflawni strategaeth ddatgarboneiddio GIG Cymru wedi gosod targed o ostyngiad o 34 y cant mewn allyriadau carbon, ond y gwir amdani yw, os mai dim ond gostyngiad o 34 y cant ohonynt a gyflawnir, yna bydd yn anodd i'r sector cyhoeddus gyflawni ei darged sero-net cyffredinol. Felly, pa gamau fyddwch chi'n eu cymryd, sut fyddwch chi'n gweithio gyda'r Gweinidog iechyd a gofal cymdeithasol i weld targed mwy heriol yn cael ei osod gan GIG Cymru? Mae eraill wedi rhybuddio y bydd cyrraedd y targed yn gofyn am adnoddau ariannol ychwanegol, ac, wrth gwrs, bydd absenoldeb yr arian hwn yn rhwystr i symud ymlaen. Prif bwnc eich datganiad oedd y cwmni datblygu newydd hwn, felly sut fydd hwnnw'n gweithio gyda'r gwasanaeth ynni a oedd gennych, a sut y bydd yn cyflawni mewn gwirionedd? Pa mor ffyddiog—? Ac, am wn i, fy nghwestiwn olaf yw: rydych chi'n dweud yn 2024; mae gennym ni'r argyfwng hinsawdd nawr, a oes unrhyw ffordd o gwbl y gallai hynny gael ei gyflwyno'n gynt? Diolch.

Thank you, Janet. I think most of the thrust of your contribution there was around the energy efficiency service, which is obviously not what this statement is primarily about. We obviously work with the energy efficiency service to make sure that we can get energy efficiency. You quoted some of the very good stats that we've actually had by way of results there. I'm very pleased to be working with them.234

We will also be developing a community energy developer, as part of our co-operation agreement with Plaid Cymru, who will pull together the community-level energy schemes that we need right around Wales—the small-scale schemes that we need right around Wales. And they will also be a combination of generation of electricity—so from your solar panels, from your small-scale hydro and so on, which I know you're interested in—but also work on the energy efficiency of the buildings that are part of that community project. So, obviously, what we also need to do is reduce demand for the generation of electricity.235

What this statement is about, though, is a very large-scale developer owned by the Welsh Government, starting off on Welsh Government land, to take its place in a number of companies already working throughout Wales. Scottish Power, for example, provides, as I know you know, the grid in north Wales. This, acting Presiding Officer, is one of the old cliches come to life: so, the best time to do this was probably about 40 years ago, and the next best time is now. So, here we are—we are doing it. What we are doing as well is inviting a joint venture with private sector companies—I say 'private sector' with inverted commas around it, because most of them are the Swedish national power company, the Scottish national power company, the German national power company, the Danish, you know, these are companies that are already there, so they're not really private sector; they're state-owned operators—to work alongside us to make sure that, in generating the kind of energy that we need right across Wales from all kinds of renewables, although starting on the Welsh Government estate with wind, we return the investment in that, not just in community benefits but the actual investment back to the people of Wales, as those other companies are able to do to their national citizenry. In doing that, we will, of course, be able to redeploy that investment back into energy resilience and into energy efficiency, which are two sides of the same coin—I completely agree with you.236

So, I'm glad that you welcome this. It will take us a year to set the company up properly, because this is a major investment strategy, which we must do in order to get our just transition agenda really running. I know that you share our ambition that the people of Wales, in transitioning to a green economy, should not suffer the problems that we suffered in previous industrial revolutions. So, this is the first major step forward in making sure that we secure the wealth of our renewable industry for the people of Wales.237

Diolch, Janet. Rwy'n credu bod y rhan fwyaf o'ch cyfraniad yn y fan yna ynghylch y gwasanaeth effeithlonrwydd ynni, ac yn amlwg nid dyna yw prif bwrpas y datganiad hwn. Yn amlwg, rydym yn gweithio gyda'r gwasanaeth effeithlonrwydd ynni i sicrhau y gallwn gael effeithlonrwydd ynni. Fe wnaethoch chi ddyfynnu rhai o'r ystadegau da iawn yr ydym ni wedi'u cael mewn gwirionedd o ran canlyniadau yn y fan yna. Rwy'n falch iawn o fod yn gweithio gyda nhw.

Byddwn ni hefyd yn datblygu datblygwr ynni cymunedol, fel rhan o'n cytundeb cydweithredu â Phlaid Cymru, a fydd yn tynnu'r cynlluniau ynni lefel gymunedol sydd eu hangen arnom yn y gymuned at ei gilydd ledled Cymru—y cynlluniau ar raddfa fach sydd eu hangen arnom ledled Cymru. A byddan nhw hefyd yn gyfuniad o gynhyrchu trydan—felly o'ch paneli solar, o'ch hydro ar raddfa fach ac yn y blaen, yr wyf yn gwybod bod gennych ddiddordeb ynddyn nhw—ond hefyd yn gweithio ar effeithlonrwydd ynni'r adeiladau sy'n rhan o'r prosiect cymunedol hwnnw. Felly, yn amlwg, yr hyn sydd angen i ni ei wneud hefyd yw lleihau'r galw am gynhyrchu trydan.

Mae'r datganiad hwn, er hynny, am datblygwr ar raddfa fawr iawn sy'n eiddo i Lywodraeth Cymru, gan ddechrau ar dir Llywodraeth Cymru, i gymryd ei le gyda nifer o gwmnïau sydd eisoes yn gweithio ledled Cymru. Mae Scottish Power, er enghraifft, yn darparu, fel y gwn eich bod chi'n gwybod, y grid yn y gogledd. Mae hyn, Llywydd Dros Dro, yn un o'r hen ystrydebau wedi ei wireddu: felly, mae'n debyg mai'r amser gorau i wneud hyn oedd tua 40 mlynedd yn ôl, a'r amser gorau wedi hynny yw nawr. Felly, dyma ni—rydym ni'n ei wneud. Yr hyn yr ydym ni'n ei wneud hefyd yw gwahodd menter ar y cyd â chwmnïau'r sector preifat—rwy'n dweud 'sector preifat' gyda dyfynodau o'i amgylch, oherwydd  cwmni pŵer cenedlaethol o Sweden, cwmni pŵer cenedlaethol yr Alban, cwmni pŵer cenedlaethol yr Almaen, Denmarc yw'r rhan fwyaf ohonyn nhw, wyddoch chi, mae'r rhain yn gwmnïau sydd yno'n barod, felly dydyn nhw ddim yn rai sector preifat mewn gwirionedd; maen nhw'n weithredwyr sy'n eiddo i'r wladwriaeth—i weithio ochr yn ochr â ni i wneud yn siŵr, wrth gynhyrchu'r math o ynni sydd ei angen arnom ledled Cymru o bob math o ynni adnewyddadwy, er ein bod yn dechrau ar ystad Llywodraeth Cymru gyda gwynt, rydym yn dychwelyd y buddsoddiad yn hwnnw, nid yn unig mewn buddion cymunedol ond y buddsoddiad gwirioneddol yn ôl i bobl Cymru, ac mae'r cwmnïau eraill hynny'n gallu gwneud hynny i'w dinasyddion cenedlaethol nhw. Wrth wneud hynny, fe fyddwn ni, wrth gwrs, yn gallu ailfuddsoddi mewn cydnerthedd ynni a effeithlonrwydd ynni, sef dwy ochr o'r un geiniog—rwy'n cytuno'n llwyr â chi.

Felly, rwy'n falch eich bod chi'n croesawu hyn. Bydd yn cymryd blwyddyn i ni sefydlu'r cwmni yn iawn, oherwydd mae hon yn strategaeth fuddsoddi fawr, y mae'n rhaid i ni ei gwneud er mwyn cael ein hagenda pontio teg yn weithredol mewn gwirionedd. Gwn eich bod yn rhannu ein huchelgais na ddylai pobl Cymru, wrth bontio i economi werdd, ddioddef y problemau y gwnaethom eu dioddef mewn chwyldroadau diwydiannol blaenorol. Felly, dyma'r cam mawr cyntaf ymlaen wneud yn siŵr ein bod ni'n sicrhau cyfoeth ein diwydiant adnewyddadwy ar gyfer pobl Cymru.

16:10

Diolch, Gadeirydd dros dro, a diolch, Weinidog, am eich datganiad. Mae’n dda clywed mwy am fel y gall y sector cyhoeddus chwarae rôl bwysig wrth inni fynd i’r afael â’r argyfyngau hinsawdd a natur.  238

Mae hyn wedi codi yn barod, ond rwy'n meddwl ei bod hi'n werth i ni siarad ychydig am hyn. Roedd hi'n peri pryder clywed bod Audit Wales wedi dweud dros yr haf ei bod hi'n glir y byddai'r sector yma yn gorfod—er mwyn iddyn nhw gyrraedd y nod o net sero gydag allyriadau carbon erbyn 2030, dywedodd yr archwilydd fod angen i gyrff cyhoeddus gwneud mwy yn gyflymach. Gwnaethon ni glywed fod heriau mawr yn eu ffordd nhw, a bod angen i Lywodraeth Cymru eu helpu nhw i ddod dros yr heriau hyn.239

Fel rydyn ni wedi clywed, o'r 48 corff cyhoeddus yr oedd Audit Wales wedi siarad â nhw, dim ond dau oedd wedi asesu goblygiadau ariannol cyrraedd y nod yma yn llawn. Dywedodd y cyrff cyhoeddus fod angen arnynt fwy o fuddsoddiad, a bod angen iddyn nhw ffeindio ffyrdd fwy agile neu wahanol, newydd o ddefnyddio’u harian. A gaf i ofyn i chi yn gyntaf, Weinidog, ymateb i’r pryderon ariannol a dweud sut y bydd Llywodraeth Cymru yn cefnogi datgarboneiddio yn y sector cyhoeddus, efallai’n ffocysu ar ein system ynni? Hefyd, datgelwyd problemau gyda chapasiti a bylchau yn y sgiliau sydd yn y sector. Dywedodd y cyrff fod eu hadnoddau nhw’n cael eu defnyddio ar gapasiti llawn yn barod wrth iddyn nhw ddelio â gwasanaethau craidd, ac nad oes ganddyn nhw wastad y sgiliau arbenigol i ddelio â natur gymhleth datgarboneiddio.240

Rwy’n siŵr y byddech chi’n cytuno, Weinidog, fod angen gweithlu gyda’r sgiliau gwyrdd hyn er mwyn inni wneud yn siŵr ein bod ni'n gweld y newid sydd ei angen. Felly, a gaf i ofyn i chi osod allan eich vision chi ar gyfer y gweithlu? Ymhellach i hynny, sut ydy’r Llywodraeth yn annog cydweithrediad yn y sector cyhoeddus yn y materion hyn? Mae adroddiad yr archwilydd yn sôn am bwysigrwydd rhannu gwybodaeth, capasiti ac arbenigedd, felly buaswn i’n hoffi clywed eich persbectif chi ar hynny.241

Yn olaf ond un, mae data yn her sylweddol yn hyn. Mae’n glir bod dyfodol ein system ynni, a rôl ddatgarboneiddio'r sector cyhoeddus, yn dibynnu ar ddata sydd yn ddibynadwy. Galwodd yr archwilydd ar gyrff cyhoeddus i wella’u dealltwriaeth nhw o allyriadau carbon. Beth ydy’r Llywodraeth yn gwneud i gefnogi hynny a beth sy’n cael ei wneud i wella casglu data gan y Llywodraeth ei hun wrth ystyried hyn? Yn olaf, Weinidog, hoffwn i ofyn: beth oeddech chi’n ei olygu wrth 'returns'? Roeddech chi'n dweud242

Thank you, temporary Chair, and thank you, Minister, for your statement. It’s good to hear more about how the public sector can play an important role as we all tackle the climate and nature emergencies.

This has already arisen, but I think it's worth us discussing this. It did cause concern that Audit Wales said over the summer that it was not clear whether the sector would reach the goal of net-zero carbon emissions by 2030. The auditor general said that the public bodies needed do more, faster, and we heard that there are major challenges on the way for them, and that the Welsh Government needed to help them to overcome those challenges.

As we've heard, of the 48 public bodies that Audit Wales spoke to, only two had fully assessed the financial implications of meeting the 2030 goal. The public bodies said that they needed more investment, and that they needed to find new ways—agile ways—of using their funding. So, could I ask you, Minister, first, to respond to these financial concerns and say how the Welsh Government will support decarbonisation in the public sector, perhaps focusing on our energy system? Also, problems were revealed in terms of capacity and skills gaps in the sector. The bodies said that their resources were already being used at full capacity while they were dealing with core services, and that they didn't always have the specialist skills to deal with the complex nature of decarbonisation.

I'm sure that you would agree, Minister, that we need a workforce with these green skills so that we can see the change that is needed. So, could I ask you to set out your vision for the workforce? Further to that, how is the Government encouraging collaboration in the public sector on these issues? The auditor's report talks about the importance of sharing information, capacity and expertise, and I would like to hear your perspective on that.

Last but one, data is a significant challenge here. It's clear that the future of our energy system, and the role of the public sector in decarbonisation, depends on having reliable data. The auditor called on public bodies to improve their intelligence on carbon emissions. So, what is the Government doing to support that and what's being done to improve the Government's data collection in considering this issue? Finally, Minister, I’d like to ask: what did you mean by 'returns'? You said

'we do not expect to see returns until...the end of the decade'.243

'nid ydym yn disgwyl gweld enillion tan...diwedd y degawd'.

16:15

Daeth y Llywydd i’r Gadair.

The Llywydd took the Chair.

Ai prosiectau oeddech chi’n golygu wrth hwnna, neu returns on investment? Ac yn olaf, o ran yr amserlen, 'the end of the decade', roeddech chi’n dweud. Ydych chi’n cytuno, yn sicr o ran prosiectau ynni cymunedol, fod angen mwy o frys na hynny?244

Diolch yn fawr. Sori os oedd hwnna bach yn gyflym ar gyfer y cyfieithwyr.245

Are you talking about projects through that, or returns on investment? And finally, in terms of the timescales, 'the end of the decade' is what you said. Now, do you agree that, certainly in terms of community energy projects, we need to act more urgently than that?

Thank you very much. I’m sorry if that was a bit quick for the translator.

Does dim angen ymddiheuro i’r cyfieithwyr. Maen nhw’n fwy na ddigon abl i gyfieithu popeth sy’n cael ei ddweud yn y Siambr yma.246

There’s no need to apologise to our interpreters. They are more than able in interpreting everything said in this Chamber.

And I for one am very grateful to them indeed, Llywydd, because I’m afraid my Welsh isn’t up to discussing renewable deep-dives at the moment, much as I wish it was.247

So, Delyth, I’m very grateful indeed for those remarks. You covered quite a big area in quite a small amount of time there, so I’ll just do my best to answer some of it, but I’ll start from the premise of the statement, which is that this is the announcement of us making a state-owned, large-scale energy developer. So, this is a scale hitherto unknown in the projects that are owned by communities across Wales. This is a major developer. That’s why the returns will take a decade to come in, because it will take that long to build the first windfarm, which we have a plot already allocated for, but we will have to go through the whole development of that, including all the planning consent and the community engagement and all the things that we expect other developers to go through. So, obviously, we have to invest upfront to enable the developer to do that, and we won’t have a working windfarm producing its profits back for some time. So, that’s what the lag in this particular thing is.248

The other thing to say is that unless we decarbonise our grid rapidly—and, frankly, I’ve given up on the UK Government’s ability to act in this space; I hope I’m wrong and that they sort themselves out, but, at the moment, it’s not looking great. It remains to be seen who the new Secretary of State is. But unless we decarbonise the grid, of course public sector bodies right across Wales will struggle, including the health service, because decarbonising the grid from which they get their energy in the first place is one of the big steps forward, and that’s the same for housing and for commercial operators right across Wales. I think I’ve said in this Chamber before, Llywydd, that we were having a good discussion with the then Minister about having a planned grid for Wales, a network development arrangement that allowed us to plan out the grid and not react to market forces all the time. I really hope that survives the current turmoil in the UK Government, because of course that allows us not only to put our big renewable generators in place, but much, much more importantly, Delyth, it allows all the little community schemes across Wales to connect into the grid, both to pull energy out when they need it, but, much more importantly, to feed energy in when they have surpluses, thus helping with the whole cost-of-living crisis and with decarbonisation.249

Clearly, as I said in response to Janet, this is one side of a two-pronged approach. You’ll know that, under the co-operation agreement, we’re looking to make Ynni Cymru. Ynni Cymru will be the community energy developer across Wales for all the small projects, pulling them together. It’s under discussion at the moment but probably—well, I hope—it will have a relationship with or even take over the Welsh energy service in order to get both sides of that—the decarbonisation, insulation, retrofit side and the energy generation side—coming together, because we both have to reduce the demand on our generation and make sure that we use that that we have generated very efficiently in order to get anywhere near net zero.250

In terms of skills, we work very closely with both my colleague Jeremy Miles and my colleague Vaughan Gething to make sure that we have both the economic development opportunities highlighted and we have the skills production there, so we take on the right apprentices, we make sure that we work with our further education colleges to be producing the right kinds of apprentices to work on these projects, but actually we’ll also be working, of course, with our universities as well, because one of the big benefits of having a state-owned developer is that it will be designed and run here in Wales. We will not be importing something that has most of the big jobs back in whichever state operator you care to mention. So, I’m really excited by this prospect. This is a big step forward in a patchwork of things that we need to do together in order to get the greener and much better green economy for Wales that we all want.251

Ac rydw i, o'm rhan fy hun, yn ddiolchgar iawn iddyn nhw yn wir, Llywydd, oherwydd mae arna i ofn nad yw fy Nghymraeg i yn ddigon da i drafod ynni adnewyddadwy yn fanwl ar hyn o bryd, er cymaint yr hoffwn iddi fod.

Felly, Delyth, rwy'n ddiolchgar iawn yn wir am y sylwadau hynny. Fe wnaethoch chi gwmpasu cryn dipyn mewn ychydig iawn o amser yn y fan yna, felly mi wnaf i fy ngorau i ateb rhywfaint o'r cwestiynau hynny, ond mi fyddaf i'n dechrau o gynsail y datganiad, sef mai dyma'r cyhoeddiad amdanom ni'n ffurfio datblygwr ynni sylweddol gwladol. Felly, mae hyn yn raddfa lawer mwy na'r prosiectau cymunedol ledled Cymru. Mae hwn yn ddatblygwr o bwys. Dyna pam mae'n cymryd degawd i weld unrhyw enillion, oherwydd bydd yn cymryd mor hir â hynny i adeiladu'r fferm wynt gyntaf, y mae gennym ni blot eisoes wedi'i neilltuo ar ei chyfer, ond bydd yn rhaid i ni ymdrin â phob agwedd o ddatblygu hynny, gan gynnwys yr holl ganiatâd cynllunio a'r ymgysylltu cymunedol a'r holl bethau yr ydym ni'n disgwyl i ddatblygwyr eraill ei wneud. Felly, yn amlwg, mae'n rhaid i ni fuddsoddi o flaen llaw i alluogi'r datblygwr i wneud hynny, ac ni fydd gennym ni fferm wynt weithredol yn cynhyrchu ei helw am beth amser. Felly, dyna yw'r oedi yn y peth arbennig yma.

Y peth arall i'w ddweud yw, oni bai ein bod ni'n datgarboneiddio ein grid yn gyflym—ac, a dweud y gwir, rwyf wedi colli pob ffydd yng ngallu Llywodraeth y DU i weithredu yn hyn o beth; rwy'n gobeithio fy mod i'n anghywir a'u bod nhw'n rhoi trefn ar eu hunain, ond, ar hyn o bryd, nid yw pethau'n edrych yn wych. Wyddon ni ddim eto pwy yw'r Ysgrifennydd Gwladol newydd. Ond oni bai ein bod ni'n datgarboneiddio'r grid, wrth gwrs bydd cyrff yn y sector cyhoeddus ym mhob rhan o Gymru yn ei chael hi'n anodd, gan gynnwys y gwasanaeth iechyd, oherwydd datgarboneiddio'r grid y maen nhw'n cael eu hynni ohono yn y lle cyntaf yw un o'r camau mawr ymlaen, ac mae hynny'r un peth ar gyfer tai ac i weithredwyr masnachol ledled Cymru. Rwy'n credu fy mod i wedi dweud yn y Siambr hon o'r blaen, Llywydd, y buom ni'n cael trafodaeth dda gyda'r Gweinidog ar y pryd am gael grid wedi'i gynllunio i Gymru, trefniant datblygu rhwydwaith a oedd yn caniatáu inni gynllunio'r grid a pheidio ag ymateb i rymoedd y farchnad drwy'r amser. Rwy'n gobeithio'n fawr y bydd hynny'n goroesi'r cynnwrf presennol yn Llywodraeth y DU, oherwydd wrth gwrs mae hynny'n ein galluogi nid yn unig i roi ein generaduron adnewyddadwy mawr ar waith, ond yn bwysicach o lawer, Delyth, mae'n caniatáu i'r holl gynlluniau cymunedol bach ledled Cymru gysylltu â'r grid, i ddefnyddio ynni pan fydd ei angen arnynt, ond, yn bwysicach o lawer, i gyfrannu ynni pan fydd ganddyn nhw ynni dros ben, ac felly'n helpu gyda'r holl argyfwng costau byw a gyda datgarboneiddio.

Yn amlwg, fel y dywedais i mewn ymateb i Janet, dyma un ochr i ddull deublyg. Fe wyddoch chi, o dan y cytundeb cydweithio, ein bod ni'n bwriadu creu Ynni Cymru. Ynni Cymru fydd y datblygwr ynni cymunedol ledled Cymru ar gyfer yr holl brosiectau bach, gan eu tynnu at ei gilydd. Mae'n cael ei drafod ar hyn o bryd ond mae'n debyg—wel, rwy'n gobeithio—y bydd ganddo berthynas â gwasanaeth ynni Cymru, neu hyd yn oed yn disodli hynny, er mwyn dod a'r ddwy agwedd ar hynny—y datgarboneiddio, insiwleiddio, yr ôl-osod a'r agwedd cynhyrchu ynni—at ein gilydd, oherwydd mae'n rhaid inni ddefnyddio llai a sicrhau ein bod yn defnyddio'r hyn y gwnaethom ni ei gynhyrchu yn effeithlon iawn er mwyn cyflawni unrhyw beth yn agos at sero net.

O ran sgiliau, rydym ni'n gweithio'n agos iawn gyda fy nghyd-Aelod Jeremy Miles, a fy nghyd-Aelod Vaughan Gething, i sicrhau bod gennym ni'r cyfle datblygu economaidd wedi'i amlygu a bod gennym ni'r sgiliau cynhyrchu, fel ein bod ni'n penodi'r prentisiaid cywir, yn sicrhau ein bod ni'n gweithio gyda'n colegau addysg bellach i fod yn cynhyrchu'r mathau cywir o brentisiaid i weithio ar y prosiectau hyn, ond mewn gwirionedd, byddwn ni hefyd yn gweithio, wrth gwrs, gyda'n prifysgolion hefyd, oherwydd un o'r manteision mawr o gael datblygwr gwladol yw y caiff ei gynllunio a'i redeg yma yng Nghymru. Ni fyddwn yn mewnforio rhywbeth sydd â'r rhan fwyaf o'r swyddi mawr yn ôl ym mha bynnag wladwriaeth weithredu yr ydych yn sôn amdani. Felly, mae'r gobaith yma wedi fy nghyffroi'n fawr. Mae hwn yn gam mawr ymlaen mewn clytwaith o bethau sydd angen i ni eu gwneud gyda'n gilydd er mwyn cael yr economi werdd llawer gwell a llawer mwy gwyrdd i Gymru y mae arnom ni i gyd ei heisiau.

Faced with the incredible scale of the climate change emergency that we face and the need to hit net zero, this is a very welcome statement today, and particularly the proposals around a Welsh state developer. What I want to ask you, Minister, is: you'll know that right on my doorstep—I'm not asking you to comment on the individual application, don't worry, and it's not to come to you until, I think, in 2023—we have the proposal for the Bryn development. This will be one of the largest in Wales, if not in Europe. It will also be some of the tallest wind turbines. I've been a consistent advocate, by the way, of wind power all these years. These are directly opposite my house; I remain a consistent advocate of them because of that challenge that we have. But it's really interesting that it just overlaps; the timing is just wrong. This could have been one of the state developer ones. Okay, so if it's wrong, you also put in your statement: 252

'Our deepening understanding of the economies of large-scale developments will help us set expectations about the level of local social and environmental benefit that it is reasonable to expect of other windfarms across Wales.'253

Well, this is one of those other ones. What shall I say to them when I next meet them on behalf of my constituents about the level of community engagement, interest, shareholding, payback, retrofitting, whatever, that we should expect of them if this is going to be one of the biggest onshore wind developments not just in Wales but in Europe? What should we be demanding of them? 254

Yn wyneb graddfa anhygoel yr argyfwng newid hinsawdd sy'n ein hwynebu a'r angen i gyrraedd sero net, mae hwn yn ddatganiad i'w groesawu heddiw ac yn enwedig y cynigion ynghylch datblygwr gwladol Cymreig. Yr hyn yr hoffwn i ei ofyn i chi, Gweinidog, yw: fe wyddoch chi ar garreg fy nrws—dydw i ddim yn gofyn i chi wneud sylw ar y cais unigol, peidiwch â phoeni, ac ni fydd yn dod atoch chi tan, rwy'n credu, 2023—mae gennym y cynnig ar gyfer datblygiad Bryn. Dyma fydd un o'r mwyaf yng Nghymru, os nad yn Ewrop. Rhain hefyd fydd rhai o'r tyrbinau gwynt talaf. Rwyf wedi eiriol yn gyson, gyda llaw, dros bŵer gwynt yr holl flynyddoedd yma. Mae'r rhain yn union gyferbyn â fy nhŷ i; rwy'n parhau'n eiriolwr cyson ohonynt oherwydd yr her honno sydd gennym ni. Ond mae'n ddiddorol iawn ei fod yn gorgyffwrdd; mae'r amseru yn anghywir. Gallai'r cynllun hwn fod wedi bod yn un o rai'r datblygwr gwladol. Iawn, felly os yw'n anghywir, fe ddywedasoch chi hefyd yn eich datganiad: 

'Bydd ein dealltwriaeth ddyfnach o arbedion yn sgil datblygiadau mawr yn ein helpu i bennu disgwyliadau ynglŷn â faint o fudd cymdeithasol ac amgylcheddol lleol y mae'n rhesymol ei ddisgwyl gan ffermydd gwynt eraill ledled Cymru.'

Wel, dyma un o'r rhai eraill hynny. Beth ddywedaf i wrthyn nhw pan fyddaf yn eu cyfarfod nesaf ar ran fy etholwyr am faint o ymgysylltu cymunedol, llog, cyfranddaliadau, enillion, ôl-osod, beth bynnag, y dylem ni ddisgwyl ganddyn nhw os yw hyn yn mynd i fod yn un o'r datblygiadau gwynt mwyaf ar y tir nid yn unig yng Nghymru ond yn Ewrop? Beth ddylem ni fod yn ei fynnu ganddyn nhw? 

16:20

Thank you very much, Huw. So, obviously, I'm not going to comment on that particular one, but just in general, one of the reasons we want a state player owned by us, the citizens of Wales, is to put pressure on all the other developments across Wales to show what can be done in a joint venture between a state-owned developer and community engagement and the joint venture partner. We've done a really good job with the community benefits, but community benefits are limited; you're not getting direct profit back from that. It's a profit share of sorts, but it's not a direct profit. What we're looking to do is have windfarms across Wales—and I absolutely emphasise I'm not talking about any particular one here—we want windfarms across Wales to seriously engage with us in making sure that, in building whatever windfarm they're building, some of the turbines are directly owned by the local community. So, they get the community benefit from the entire windfarm, but they actually directly own some of the turbines—so, they're put up on behalf of the community.255

What we want to do, in development with Plaid Cymru and our co-operation agreement plans—and this is, I emphasise, under development, this is not agreed, but it's one of the discussions we're having—is to see whether that company—so, not this one I'm talking about here, but that other company—will be able to facilitate that ownership on behalf of local people, because one of the big issues for us is that local people are unlikely to be able to buy into stocks in those companies. So, to facilitate that ownership. So, a much more direct relationship, and, of course, therefore, a much more direct relationship throughout the whole process—so, in engagement, in design, in build, in skills, in delivery of energy projects and retrofitting of homes, in upskilling whole communities. 256

One of the things I often say in conversations with the renewables—and this is why the grid part of this is so important—is that all over Wales there are homes that can look out of a window and see a windfarm but who are on off-grid oil, who cannot upgrade their houses in order to be able take advantage of things like air-source heat pumps because the investment is too much for them. Those windfarms can make a direct contribution to that. We need to upskill our communities to be able to ask for the right thing in community benefits. We need to get them the direct profit from owning some of the turbines, and this large-scale developer will be a big player in helping that conversation go along the joint venture lines.257

I hasten to say again I'm not discussing any particular application here, but, clearly, what we're trying to do is put pressure into the whole system to make it behave in a particular way, and I hope this will not only be for onshore wind, but will also be for offshore wind. We've had very good conversations with the Crown Estate so far. We are very much hoping to have a similar conversation about the ownership and operation of offshore wind as well, because then we are talking serious amounts of energy being generated. 258

Diolch yn fawr, Huw. Felly, yn amlwg, dydw i ddim yn mynd i wneud sylw ar yr agwedd benodol yna, ond yn gyffredinol, un o'r rhesymau mae arnom ni eisiau cwmni gwladol sy'n eiddo i ni, ddinasyddion Cymru, yw i roi pwysau ar yr holl ddatblygiadau eraill ledled Cymru i ddangos beth y gellir ei wneud mewn menter ar y cyd rhwng datblygwr gwladol ac ymgysylltu â'r gymuned a'r partner cyd-fentro. Rydym ni wedi gwneud gwaith da iawn gyda'r buddion cymunedol, ond mae buddion cymunedol yn gyfyngedig; dydych chi ddim yn cael elw uniongyrchol yn ôl o hynny. Mae'n gyfran elw o fath, ond nid yw'n elw uniongyrchol. Yr hyn rydym ni'n bwriadu ei wneud yw cael ffermydd gwynt ledled Cymru—ac rwy'n pwysleisio'n llwyr nad ydw i'n siarad am unrhyw un penodol yma—hoffem i ffermydd gwynt ledled Cymru ymgysylltu â ni o ddifrif wrth sicrhau, wrth adeiladu pa bynnag fferm wynt maen nhw'n ei hadeiladu, fod rhai o'r tyrbinau yn eiddo uniongyrchol i'r gymuned leol. Felly, maen nhw'n cael budd cymunedol o'r fferm wynt gyfan, ond maen nhw mewn gwirionedd yn berchen ar rai o'r tyrbinau—felly, fe gânt eu codi ar ran y gymuned.

Yr hyn y mae arnom ni eisiau ei wneud, wrth ddatblygu gyda Phlaid Cymru a'n cynlluniau o dan y cytundeb cydweithio—ac mae hyn, rwy'n pwysleisio, yn cael ei ddatblygu, nid yw hyn wedi'i gytuno, ond mae'n un o'r trafodaethau rydym ni'n eu cael—yw gweld a yw'r cwmni hwnnw—felly, nid yr un yma yr wyf yn siarad amdano yn y fan yma, ond y bydd y cwmni arall hwnnw—yn gallu hwyluso'r berchnogaeth honno ar ran pobl leol, oherwydd un o'r materion mawr i ni yw nad yw pobl leol yn debygol o allu prynu stociau yn y cwmnïau hynny. Felly, i hwyluso'r berchnogaeth honno. Felly, perthynas lawer mwy uniongyrchol, ac, wrth gwrs, felly, perthynas lawer mwy uniongyrchol drwy gydol yr holl broses—felly, wrth ymgysylltu, wrth ddylunio, wrth adeiladu, gyda sgiliau, wrth ddarparu prosiectau ynni ac ôl-osod cartrefi, wrth uwchsgilio cymunedau cyfan.

Un o'r pethau rwy'n ei ddweud yn aml mewn sgyrsiau gyda chwmnïau ynni adnewyddadwy—a dyma pam mae'r agwedd grid o hyn mor bwysig—yw bod yna gartrefi drwy Gymru benbaladr sy'n gallu edrych allan o ffenest a gweld fferm wynt ond sydd ar olew nad yw'n rhan o'r grid, sydd ddim yn gallu uwchraddio eu tai er mwyn gallu manteisio ar bethau fel pympiau gwres ffynhonnell aer oherwydd bod y buddsoddiad yn ormod iddyn nhw. Gall y ffermydd gwynt hynny gyfrannu'n uniongyrchol at hynny. Mae angen i ni uwchsgilio ein cymunedau i allu gofyn am y peth cywir mewn buddion cymunedol. Mae angen i ni gael yr elw uniongyrchol iddyn nhw o fod yn berchen ar rai o'r tyrbinau, a bydd i'r datblygwr sylweddol hwn ran allweddol yn llywio'r sgwrs honno i gyfeiriad cyd-fentro.

Rwy'n prysuro i ddweud eto nad ydw i'n trafod unrhyw gais penodol yma, ond, yn amlwg, yr hyn rydym ni'n ceisio ei wneud yw rhoi pwysau ar yr holl system fel ei fod yn ymddwyn mewn ffordd benodol, a gobeithio y bydd hyn nid yn unig ar gyfer gwynt ar y tir, ond hefyd ar gyfer gwynt ar y môr. Rydym ni wedi cael sgyrsiau da iawn gyda Ystad y Goron hyd yn hyn. Rydym ni'n gobeithio'n fawr cael sgwrs debyg am berchnogaeth a gweithrediad cynlluniau gwynt ar y môr hefyd, oherwydd rydym ni'n siarad yn y fan yna am gynhyrchu symiau sylweddol iawn o ynni. 

Thank you, Minister, for your statement. As I'm sure you will remember, Minister, Monmouthshire County Council, back when I was leader, took the initiative to establish its own solar farm on council-owned ground in Crick. The intention was to generate renewable power for around 1,400 homes and to reduce carbon emissions. The council asked the then Welsh Government to join the project as a partner, and we received welcome support and funding via the invest-to-save green growth fund to help deliver that. I'm sure there are many other great examples across all authorities and you pointed out a couple I know, and I hope that local government will bring forward very detailed energy plans, and I welcome the initiatives you have announced today so that we can scale up energy projects and deliver them at a greater pace at local level. 259

The renewable energy deep-dive carried out last year recommended that we needed to look at ways of improving access to public land and local energy projects, as well as building additional capacity within the community enterprises, to help kick start those new schemes. Minister, I just wanted to know roughly how you are working with the Minister for local government to develop additional knowledge and capacity within local authorities and regional structures to help scale up existing and new renewable energy schemes, so that we can create a larger, more sustainable sector. Thank you.260

Diolch, Gweinidog, am eich datganiad. Fel rwy'n siŵr y byddwch yn cofio, Gweinidog, mentrodd Cyngor Sir Fynwy, yn ôl pan oeddwn i'n arweinydd, sefydlu ei fferm solar ei hun ar dir sy'n eiddo i'r cyngor yn y Crug. Y bwriad oedd cynhyrchu ynni adnewyddadwy ar gyfer tua 1,400 o gartrefi a lleihau allyriadau carbon. Gofynnodd y cyngor i Lywodraeth Cymru ar y pryd ymuno â'r prosiect fel partner, a chawsom gefnogaeth a chyllid derbyniol drwy'r gronfa twf gwyrdd buddsoddi i arbed er mwyn helpu i gyflawni hynny. Rwy'n siŵr bod llawer o enghreifftiau gwych eraill ar draws yr holl awdurdodau ac fe wnaethoch chi dynnu sylw at ddau rwy'n gwybod amdanynt, ac rwy'n gobeithio y bydd llywodraeth leol yn cyflwyno cynlluniau ynni manwl iawn, ac rwy'n croesawu'r mentrau rydych chi wedi'u cyhoeddi heddiw fel y gallwn ni gynyddu prosiectau ynni a'u darparu'n gynt yn lleol.

Roedd yr archwiliad manwl i gynlluniau ynni adnewyddadwy a gynhaliwyd y llynedd yn argymell bod angen i ni edrych ar ffyrdd o wella mynediad at dir cyhoeddus a phrosiectau ynni lleol, yn ogystal â meithrin gallu ychwanegol yn y mentrau cymunedol, er mwyn helpu i gychwyn y cynlluniau newydd hynny. Gweinidog, roedd arna i eisiau gwybod yn fras sut rydych chi'n gweithio gyda'r Gweinidog llywodraeth leol i ddatblygu gwybodaeth a gallu ychwanegol mewn awdurdodau lleol a strwythurau rhanbarthol i helpu i gynyddu cynlluniau ynni adnewyddadwy presennol a newydd, fel y gallwn ni greu sector mwy, a mwy cynaliadwy. Diolch.

16:25

Thank you very much, Peter. I very much do remember that, with great pleasure as well. And one of the things we want to do is to assist councils to bring forward renewable energy schemes that do a number of other things as well—so, for example, enhance biodiversity, encourage tree planting around the edge and so on, all the things we discussed in Monmouthshire's bid, and, actually, with a large number of other authorities across Wales.261

So, we have a regional energy strategy—I'm sure you remember this; it was a subject of much conversation—and we've supported each region to identify the scale of change needed to reach a low-carbon energy system for its region. The regional strategy set that ambition. They don't have enough detail in them at the moment to inform the actual delivery stage, but they will form the basis of our energy plan for Wales. We'll then be doing a lot more detail through the local area energy planning—we've piloted with Conwy and Newport, I think I mentioned already—and then we'll be rolling that out for similar support to all local authorities, delivering on our commitment for all areas of Wales to have a detailed local energy plan by March 2024. That will help us talk to the grid operator, who we hope will now be a planned grid operator, about what the energy requirement in each of those areas is and what the energy efficiency requirement in each of those areas is, through the energy service and through the area plans, done with our local authority partners, without whom we wouldn't be able to do any of this, of course. And then that will provide the skeleton plan for the national energy plan for Wales, which will be the blueprint to guide a coherent grid—hallelujah, the holy grail of a coherent grid—planned for now and for the future, with both upgrading for the grid lines along north and south Wales, but also to fill in what is effectively no grid right across very large parts of central Wales.262

So, we are putting in place those plans, with our local authority partners, and Rebecca and I have had many conversations about this with local authority leaders. In fact, it's a standing item in the partnership council to address net zero and the climate and nature emergencies. So, we are absolutely reliant on them to do this, but they are very happy to do it with us, to get that coherent planned system in place, so we understand what we need, we understand what our ambition is, we can deliver it both locally and at this new, big national level in order to get the best return for the people of Wales out of our abundant natural resources.263

Diolch yn fawr, Peter. Rwy'n cofio hynny'n iawn, gyda phleser mawr hefyd. Ac un o'r pethau mae arnom ni eisiau ei wneud yw cynorthwyo cynghorau i gyflwyno cynlluniau ynni adnewyddadwy sy'n gwneud nifer o bethau eraill hefyd—felly, er enghraifft, gwella bioamrywiaeth, annog plannu coed o gwmpas yr ymylon ac ati, yr holl bethau y gwnaethom ni eu trafod yng nghais sir Fynwy, ac, mewn gwirionedd, gyda nifer fawr o awdurdodau eraill ledled Cymru.

Felly, mae gennym ni strategaeth ynni rhanbarthol—rwy'n siŵr eich bod yn cofio hyn; roedd yn destun cryn sgwrsio—ac rydym ni wedi cefnogi pob rhanbarth i adnabod faint o newid sydd ei angen i gyrraedd system ynni carbon isel ar gyfer ei ranbarth. Roedd y strategaeth ranbarthol yn gosod yr uchelgais honno. Nid oes ganddyn nhw ddigon o fanylion ynddyn nhw ar hyn o bryd i lywio'r cam cyflawni gwirioneddol, ond byddant yn sail i'n cynllun ynni ar gyfer Cymru. Byddwn ni wedyn yn mynd i lawer mwy o fanylion drwy'r cynlluniau ynni ar gyfer ardaloedd lleol—rydym ni wedi arbrofi gyda Chonwy a Chasnewydd, y credaf i mi grybwyll yn barod—ac yna byddwn yn cyflwyno hynny i bob awdurdod lleol ar gyfer cefnogaeth debyg, gan gyflawni ein hymrwymiad i bob ardal yng Nghymru gael cynllun ynni lleol manwl erbyn mis Mawrth 2024. Bydd hynny'n ein helpu i siarad â gweithredwr y grid, a fydd, gobeithio, nawr yn weithredwr grid wedi'i gynllunio, am beth yw'r gofyniad ynni ym mhob un o'r meysydd hynny a beth yw'r gofyniad effeithlonrwydd ynni ym mhob un o'r meysydd hynny, drwy'r gwasanaeth ynni a thrwy'r cynlluniau ardal, a wneir gyda'n partneriaid awdurdod lleol, na fydden ni hebddyn nhw yn gallu gwneud dim o hyn, wrth gwrs. Ac yna bydd hynny'n rhoi'r cynllun sgerbwd ar gyfer cynllun ynni cenedlaethol Cymru, sef y glasbrint i arwain grid cydlynol—haleliwia, greal sanctaidd grid cydlynol—wedi ei gynllunio am y tro ac at y dyfodol, gyda'r llinellau grid ar hyd y gogledd a'r de yn cael eu huwchraddio, ond hefyd i lenwi'r hyn sydd i bob pwrpas yn ddim grid ar draws rhannau helaeth iawn o ganolbarth Cymru.

Felly, rydym ni'n rhoi'r cynlluniau hynny ar waith, gyda'n partneriaid awdurdod lleol, ac mae Rebecca a minnau wedi cael llawer o sgyrsiau am hyn gydag arweinwyr awdurdodau lleol. Mewn gwirionedd, mae'n eitem sefydlog yn y cyngor partneriaeth i fynd i'r afael â sero net a'r argyfyngau hinsawdd a natur. Felly, rydym ni'n gwbl ddibynnol arnyn nhw i wneud hyn, ond maen nhw'n hapus iawn i'w wneud gyda ni, i gael y system arfaethedig gydlynol honno ar waith, felly rydym ni'n deall yr hyn sydd ei angen arnom ni, rydym ni'n deall beth yw ein huchelgais, gallwn ei gyflawni'n lleol ac ar y lefel genedlaethol newydd, fawr hon er mwyn cael yr elw gorau i bobl Cymru o'n hadnoddau naturiol toreithiog.

I very much welcome the initiative to set up a new state-owned company. We need to learn from the experience of Norway, which, when they discovered oil there, they set up what is now the largest sovereign wealth fund in the world. And what were we left with? Nothing; it's all gone up in a puff of smoke and the private companies have gone off with all the money.264

So, I've long been frustrated that NRW hasn't been able to develop renewables itself, rather than giving concessions to foreign companies of one sort or another, because the communities who reside in the areas where we have such potential do not understand the value of the renewable activity that is going to go on in their area and, frankly, these companies have been allowed to get away with offering peanuts. There are so few renewable energy schemes that have actually directly benefited the local communities themselves. The Bethesda hydro scheme, which was supported by the National Trust, is one where there is direct benefit to communities, and Awel Aman Tawe, which I'm an investor in, has also benefited local communities directly. But it's a complicated story, is it not, to try and invest in new energy. But we've got so many possibilities of developing renewable energy in Wales and we know that we can sell it to any number of countries abroad, once we've satisfied our own needs. So, I suppose I want to understand a bit more about the timescales, because I appreciate that caution is required to get the terms of any joint venture project right, but, in the meantime, we have this raging energy crisis. How quickly can we be, in parallel, developing potential schemes that are going to be oven-ready once you've got the financial terms right with whoever your joint venture partner is going to be?265

Rwy'n croesawu'r fenter yn fawr i sefydlu cwmni gwladol newydd. Mae angen i ni ddysgu o brofiad Norwy, y gwnaethon nhw, ar ôl darganfod olew yno, sefydlu'r hyn sydd bellach yn gronfa cyfoeth sofran fwyaf y byd. A beth gawsom ni? Dim; mae'r cyfan wedi diflannu mewn pwff o fwg ac mae'r cwmnïau preifat wedi mynd â'r arian i gyd.

Felly, rwyf wedi bod yn rhwystredig ers tro nad yw Cyfoeth Naturiol Cymru wedi gallu datblygu ynni adnewyddadwy ei hun, yn hytrach na rhoi consesiynau i gwmnïau tramor o ryw fath neu'i gilydd, oherwydd nid yw'r cymunedau sy'n byw yn yr ardaloedd lle mae gennym ni'r fath botensial yn deall gwerth y gweithgarwch adnewyddadwy a fydd yn digwydd yn eu hardal ac, a bod yn onest, mae'r cwmnïau hyn wedi cael dianc gan gynnig dim byd ond arian mân. Mae cyn lleied o gynlluniau ynni adnewyddadwy sydd wedi bod o fudd uniongyrchol i'r cymunedau lleol eu hunain mewn gwirionedd. Mae cynllun hydro Bethesda, a gefnogwyd gan yr Ymddiriedolaeth Genedlaethol, yn un lle mae budd uniongyrchol i gymunedau, ac mae Awel Aman Tawe, yr ydw i'n fuddsoddwr ynddo, hefyd wedi bod o fudd uniongyrchol i gymunedau lleol. Ond mae'n stori gymhleth, onid yw, i geisio buddsoddi mewn ynni newydd. Ond mae gennym ni gymaint o bosibiliadau o ddatblygu ynni adnewyddadwy yng Nghymru ac rydym ni'n gwybod y gallwn ni ei werthu i unrhyw nifer o wledydd tramor, wedi i ni fodloni ein hanghenion ein hunain. Felly, mae'n debyg fod arna i eisiau deall ychydig mwy am yr amserlenni, oherwydd rwy'n sylweddoli bod angen pwyll i gael telerau unrhyw brosiect cyd-fentro yn iawn, ond, yn y cyfamser, mae gennym ni'r argyfwng ynni ofnadwy yma. Pa mor gyflym allwn ni fod, ochr yn ochr, yn datblygu cynlluniau posibl a fydd yn barod i'w gweithredu unwaith y bydd gennych chi'r telerau ariannol cywir gyda phwy bynnag fydd eich partner cyd-fentro?

16:30

Yes, thank you, Jenny. Absolutely right. I completely agree with all of that. There are some really good examples, though, around Wales, that we direct people to. So, Pen y Cymoedd, I don't know if you've managed to go up there, but it's well worth a visit. The increasing biodiversity around what they call the 'spotting' of the turbines has been exponential. It's actually quite astonishing. The engagement with local people who are now using the forest, where they didn't before, has been extraordinary, and the community benefits package has delivered real benefit to that community. That's a state-owned operator, of course, and that's the point, isn't it? But the real profit is going back to the state operator and that's the bit that we want to get our hands on, if you like.266

This is just one strand of a large number of things that I've been trying to set out today. So, this is the large energy generator that we have had missing so far. But, that will not work unless we have the holistic network design—to use the jargon—so, the planned grid, as I describe it, so that we can feed it in properly, so that we can get the grid that we need to deliver people's needs and we can get people off off-grid oil, for example. We also need community engagement to make sure that the communities understand what is necessary for them. And that's not being paternalistic; I would have not the faintest idea unless somebody was able to help me understand what is possible in my particular home and my particular area for energy efficiency and so on. So, that's the area plans I was talking about; that's holistic planning for the future needs of the community, for its energy generation and for its efficiency—we need to do all of those things.267

We need to have the small renewables right across Wales at the moment, very particularly, because they can sometimes avoid the problems of the energy market. Just to be really clear, right at the moment, with the ridiculous way that the energy market works at the moment, even if we had a state-owned renewable operator, it would still be charging its energy at the marginal price of gas, which is clearly nonsensical. The UK Government needs to move to change the market and it's been sadly very lacking in doing so. And, in the new Bill going through Parliament, which I brought an LCM on very recently, I was very clear that although we needed that to make sure that the people of Wales got some of the benefit, it does not do to the energy market what is required to be done to make it work. So, just to be clear, community renewables can deliver that because they can do it off grid, but we have to do that in a way that's both resilient and capable of joining the grid once we get a more sensible energy market running. So, sorry to be really technical about the different strands of it, but it is important that we try to operate in what we've got now in the best way, but also plan for the future, so that when we do have a better market system we're able to benefit from it in a way that makes the most difference to the people of Wales.268

Ie, diolch i chi, Jenny. Rydych chi'n hollol gywir. Rwy'n cytuno'n llwyr â hynny i gyd. Er hynny, mae rhai enghreifftiau da iawn, o amgylch Cymru, yr ydym ni'n cyfeirio pobl atyn nhw. Felly, Pen y Cymoedd, wn i ddim a ydych chi wedi llwyddo i fynd yno, ond mae'n werth mynd yno. Mae'r fioamrywiaeth gynyddol o gwmpas yr hyn y maen nhw'n ei alw'n 'sbotio' y tyrbinau wedi bod yn rhyfeddol. Mae'n eithaf syfrdanol mewn gwirionedd. Mae'r ymgysylltu â phobl leol sydd bellach yn defnyddio'r goedwig, lle nad oedden nhw o'r blaen, wedi bod yn rhyfeddol, ac mae'r pecyn buddiannau cymunedol wedi darparu budd gwirioneddol i'r gymuned honno. Mae'r cwmni yna'n weithredwr gwladol, wrth gwrs, a dyna'r pwynt, ynte? Ond mae'r elw go iawn yn mynd yn ôl i'r gweithredwr gwladol a dyna'r darn yr ydym ni am gael ein dwylo arno, os mynnwch chi.

Dim ond un elfen o nifer fawr o bethau rwyf wedi bod yn ceisio eu hamlinellu heddiw yw hyn. Felly, dyma'r cynhyrchydd ynni sylweddol a fu ar goll o'r cynllun hyd yma. Ond, ni fydd hynny'n gweithio oni bai bod gennym ni ddyluniad y rhwydwaith cyfannol—i ddefnyddio'r jargon—felly, y grid arfaethedig, fel yr wyf yn ei ddisgrifio, fel y gallwn ni ei gyflenwi'n iawn, fel y gallwn ni gael y grid angenrheidiol i ni ddiwallu anghenion pobl ac y gallwn ni gael pobl oddi ar olew y tu allan i'r grid, er enghraifft. Mae angen ymgysylltu â'r gymuned hefyd er mwyn sicrhau bod y cymunedau yn deall yr hyn sy'n angenrheidiol iddyn nhw. Ac nid bod yn llyffetheiriol yw hynny; fyddai gen i ddim y syniad lleiaf oni bai bod rhywun yn gallu fy helpu i ddeall beth sy'n bosib yn fy nghartref penodol i ac yn fy ardal benodol i ar gyfer effeithlonrwydd ynni ac yn y blaen. Felly, dyna'r cynlluniau ardal yr oeddwn yn sôn amdanynt; dyna gynllunio cyfannol ar gyfer anghenion y gymuned yn y dyfodol, ar gyfer creu ei hynni ac o ran ei effeithlonrwydd—mae angen i ni wneud yr holl bethau hynny.

Mae angen i ni gael cynlluniau ynni adnewyddadwy bach ar draws Cymru ar hyn o bryd, yn benodol iawn, oherwydd gallan nhw weithiau osgoi problemau'r farchnad ynni. Dim ond i fod yn glir iawn, ar hyn o bryd, gyda'r ffordd hurt y mae'r farchnad ynni'n gweithio ar hyn o bryd, hyd yn oed pe bai gennym ni weithredwr adnewyddadwy gwladol, byddai'n dal i godi pris ymylol nwy am ei ynni, sy'n amlwg yn hurt bost. Mae angen i Lywodraeth y DU weithredu i newid y farchnad ac mae hi wedi bod yn ddiffygiol iawn yn gwneud hynny yn anffodus. Ac, yn y Bil newydd sy'n mynd trwy Senedd y DU, y cyflwynais i gynnig cydsyniad deddfwriaethol yn ei gylch yn ddiweddar iawn, roeddwn i'n glir iawn, er bod angen hynny i wneud yn siŵr bod pobl Cymru yn cael rhywfaint o'r budd, nad yw'n gwneud i'r farchnad ynni yr hyn sy'n ofynnol i wneud iddo weithio. Felly, dim ond i fod yn glir, gall cynlluniau ynni adnewyddadwy cymunedol gyflawni hynny oherwydd y gallan nhw wneud hynny oddi ar y grid, ond mae'n rhaid i ni wneud hynny mewn ffordd sy'n gydnerth ac yn gallu ymuno â'r grid unwaith y cawn ni farchnad ynni mwy synhwyrol. Felly, mae'n ddrwg gennyf am fod yn dechnegol iawn am y gwahanol elfennau o hynny, ond mae'n bwysig ein bod yn ceisio gweithredu gyda'r hyn sydd gennym ni nawr yn y ffordd orau, ond hefyd yn cynllunio ar gyfer y dyfodol, fel y gallwn ni elwa ohono mewn ffordd sy'n gwneud y gwahaniaeth mwyaf i bobl Cymru.

Good afternoon, Minister. This sounds amazing. Thank you so much for the statement—a real, long-term vision of where we see our energy going, when it's so tempting for political parties to just look at the short term. So, thank you so much.269

Just two really quick points, if I may. Just looking at small renewable community energy projects, just trying to understand how this new renewable developer for Wales will actually support and help those people who want to develop their community energy. How will it support them? We know that the Scottish Government has a really good scheme, and I'm just wondering if there will be parallels.270

Secondly, this week, I'm sure we all know, is Wind Week. So, great to hear all the commitment to wind energy, which I also totally support, and I've been hearing a lot about the potential for offshore wind in the port of Milford Haven. But, one of the issues they raise is speeding up our commitment and our ability to get those wind platforms in, and the issues around planning. So, I just wondered if you could just help a little bit more with that. Thank you very much. Diolch yn fawr iawn.271

Prynhawn da, Gweinidog. Mae hyn yn swnio'n anhygoel. Diolch o galon am y datganiad—gweledigaeth go iawn, hirdymor o'r hyn a dybiwn fydd dyfodol ein hynni, pan fo yna demtasiwn i bleidiau gwleidyddol ddim ond edrych ar y tymor byr. Felly, diolch o galon.

Dim ond dau sylw cyflym iawn, os caf i. Dim ond o ran edrych ar brosiectau ynni bach adnewyddadwy yn y gymuned, dim ond o ran ceisio deall sut y bydd y datblygwr adnewyddadwy newydd hwn i Gymru mewn gwirionedd yn cefnogi ac yn helpu'r bobl hynny sydd eisiau datblygu eu hynni cymunedol. Sut bydd yn eu cefnogi? Rydym ni'n gwybod bod gan Lywodraeth yr Alban gynllun da iawn, a dim ond meddwl ydw i tybed a fydd yna gynlluniau tebyg. 

Yn ail, yr wythnos hon, fel y gwyddom ni i gyd, rwy'n siŵr, yw Wythnos y Gwynt. Felly, gwych clywed yr holl ymrwymiad i ynni gwynt, yr wyf hefyd yn ei gefnogi'n llwyr, ac rwyf wedi bod yn clywed llawer am y potensial am wynt ar y môr ym mhorthladd Aberdaugleddau. Ond, un o'r materion maen nhw'n eu codi yw cyflymu ein hymrwymiad a'n gallu i osod y llwyfannau gwynt hynny, a'r materion yn ymwneud â chynllunio. Felly, dim ond meddwl oeddwn i tybed allech chi helpu ychydig bach mwy gyda hynny. Diolch yn fawr iawn.

Thank you very much, Jane, for that. I'm very pleased, as I say, delighted, to be announcing this, what is a really long-term investment for the people of Wales. I'm sure it won't be controversial, no matter who comes after us as the Government, because we should have done this a long time ago, but the next best time is now. So, here we are, going for it.272

This is complementary to community energy. So, it won't feed directly into community energy. But, we need large-scale renewables as well, and, as I've been talking, the way that we see this working is that the profit from this will directly come back to the people of Wales. It's not just community benefits like it is elsewhere. And then, that profit can be reinvested into a large number of projects, other large-scale renewables, but, of course, community renewables as well. It also gives us a real foot in the planning for the grid, which is very important, and I keep emphasising that. And it gives us an exemplar project, effectively, for how this could be done across Wales. So, in answer to Huw Irranca, I was saying that this will be about the best kind of engagement, the best kind of joint venture with private sector partners, and the best kind of shared community ownership, even on a large renewable project. So, we've a lot of ambition for this project before it's even got off the ground.273

And then, on the other part of your question, we've done an end-to-end review, as the deep-dive recommended, of marine licensing in Wales, with NRW. That's just coming to a conclusion now. We will be informing our infrastructure consenting Bill, which will be coming to the Senedd by the end of this Senedd year—so, 'summer term' in normal parlance. That will, of course, inform our consenting process, but it is essential that we have a continuation of the habitats regulations because the whole point here is to hit the sweet spot between speed of deployment, so that we act on a global stage, and protection of the environment, so that we do not have unintended consequences. So, the next piece of work will be making sure we get that sweet spot just right.274

Diolch yn fawr iawn, Jane, am hynny. Rwy'n falch iawn, fel y dywedaf, wrth fy modd, yn cyhoeddi hyn, yr hyn sy'n fuddsoddiad tymor hir iawn i bobl Cymru. Rwy'n siŵr na fydd hi'n ddadleuol, dim ots pwy fydd y Llywodraeth ar ein holau, oherwydd dylen ni fod wedi gwneud hyn amser maith yn ôl, ond yr ail adeg orau yw nawr. Felly, dyma ni, yn mynd amdani.

Mae hyn yn ychwanegol i ynni cymunedol. Felly, ni fydd yn cyfrannu'n uniongyrchol at ynni cymunedol. Ond, mae angen ynni adnewyddadwy ar raddfa fawr arnom ni hefyd, ac, fel rwyf wedi bod yn dweud, y ffordd rydym ni'n gweld hyn yn gweithio yw y bydd yr elw o hyn yn dod yn ôl yn uniongyrchol i bobl Cymru. Nid buddion cymunedol yn unig fel a geir mewn mannau eraill. Ac yna, gellir ail-fuddsoddi'r elw hwnnw i nifer fawr o brosiectau, cynlluniau ynni adnewyddadwy eraill sylweddol, ond, wrth gwrs, ynni adnewyddadwy cymunedol hefyd. Mae hefyd yn rhoi troedle go iawn i ni yn y cynllunio ar gyfer y grid, sy'n bwysig iawn, ac rwy'n pwysleisio hynny o hyd. Ac mae'n rhoi prosiect enghreifftiol i ni, i bob diben, o sut y gellid gwneud hyn ledled Cymru. Felly, wrth ateb Huw Irranca, roeddwn i'n dweud y bydd hyn yn ymwneud â'r math gorau o ymgysylltu, y math gorau o gyd-fentro â phartneriaid yn y sector preifat, a'r math gorau o gydberchnogaeth gymunedol, hyd yn oed ar brosiect adnewyddadwy mawr. Felly, mae gennym ni lawer o uchelgais ar gyfer y prosiect hwn cyn iddo ddechrau hyd yn oed.

Ac yna, ynghylch rhan arall eich cwestiwn, rydym ni wedi cynnal adolygiad trwyadl fel yr argymhellodd yr archwiliad manwl, ynglŷn â thrwyddedu morol yng Nghymru, gyda Cyfoeth Naturiol Cymru. Mae hynny'n dod i gasgliad nawr. Byddwn yn addasu'n Bil Cydsynio Seilwaith, fydd yn dod i'r Senedd erbyn diwedd eleni—felly, 'tymor yr haf' mewn ffordd o siarad. Bydd hynny, wrth gwrs, yn llywio ein proses gydsynio, ond mae'n hanfodol bod gennym ni barhad o'r rheoliadau cynefinoedd oherwydd holl ddiben hyn yw cael y cydbwysedd cywir rhwng cyflymder y darparu, fel ein bod yn gweithredu ar lwyfan byd-eang, ac amddiffyn yr amgylchedd, fel nad oes gennym ni ganlyniadau anfwriadol. Felly, bydd y darn nesaf o waith yn gwneud yn siŵr ein bod yn cael y cydbwysedd hwnnw'n iawn.

16:35

I'm grateful, Presiding Officer. Like others, Minister, I very much welcome the statement you've made this afternoon. I very much welcome the initiative that you're taking. I'd like to follow on from other Members in the approach this afternoon, and perhaps take a different view to you. The statement you've made has outlined that this state-owned entity will be focusing on larger scale initiatives, and I welcome that—it's an important part of the overall mix. But, my real interest is on a somewhat different scale. The public estate is huge across Wales, and owns a variety of different facilities, buildings and land, and my interest is in how do we, in an urban environment, deliver renewable energy generation. We've seen examples in Germany and France, for example, where the state has intervened to ensure that there's a mixed economy of delivery of different generation opportunities. Do you see this wholly owned company delivering in a more agile way, if you like—delivering for an urban environment as well as for a larger scale, more rural environment?276

And how do you see the energy company, Ynni Cymru, delivering the finance required for small-scale community development, the expertise that will be required to provide the advice to people on how they do it, and then the investment that you've already described in the grid? Because it seems to me that those are the blockages, and if we are to overcome the blockages and deliver the sort of distributed energy generation that I think we would all agree on, then we need to be able to unblock those issues. I think the announcement you're making this afternoon is very much designed to, and I think it will, deliver the sort of approach to energy policy that I think all of us would want to see.277

Rwy'n ddiolchgar, Llywydd. Fel eraill, Gweinidog, rwy'n croesawu'r datganiad rydych chi wedi'i wneud y prynhawn yma. Rwy'n croesawu'r fenter rydych chi'n ei chymryd yn fawr. Hoffwn barhau â'r hyn a ddywedodd Aelodau eraill yn yr un ysbryd y prynhawn yma, ac efallai cymryd golwg wahanol i chi. Mae'r datganiad rydych chi wedi'i wneud wedi amlinellu y bydd yr endid gwladol hwn yn canolbwyntio ar fentrau ar raddfa fwy, ac rwy'n croesawu hynny—mae'n rhan bwysig o'r cyfuniad cyffredinol. Ond, mae fy niddordeb go iawn ar raddfa ychydig yn wahanol. Mae'r ystad gyhoeddus yn enfawr ledled Cymru, ac yn berchen ar amrywiaeth o gyfleusterau, adeiladau a thir gwahanol, a fy niddordeb i yw sut ydym ni, mewn amgylchedd trefol, yn darparu dulliau adnewyddadwy o gynhyrchu ynni. Rydym ni wedi gweld enghreifftiau yn yr Almaen a Ffrainc, er enghraifft, lle mae'r wladwriaeth wedi ymyrryd i sicrhau bod yna economi gyflenwi gymysg gyda gwahanol ffyrdd o gynhyrchu. Ydych chi'n gweld y cwmni gwladol hwn yn cyflawni mewn ffordd fwy ystwyth, os mynnwch chi—cyflawni ar gyfer amgylchedd trefol yn ogystal ag ar gyfer amgylchedd ehangach a mwy gwledig?

A sut ydych chi'n gweld y cwmni ynni, Ynni Cymru, yn darparu'r cyllid sydd ei angen ar gyfer datblygiad cymunedol ar raddfa fach, yr arbenigedd y bydd ei angen er mwyn darparu'r cyngor i bobl ynghylch sut i fynd ati, ac yna'r buddsoddiad rydych chi eisoes wedi'i ddisgrifio yn y grid? Oherwydd mae'n ymddangos i mi mai dyna'r rhwystrau, ac os ydym ni am oresgyn y rhwystrau a chyflawni'r math o gynhyrchu ynni gwasgaredig y credaf y byddem ni i gyd yn cytuno arno, yna mae angen i ni allu gwireddu'r materion hynny. Rwy'n credu bod y cyhoeddiad rydych chi'n ei wneud y prynhawn yma wedi'i gynllunio i raddau helaeth i fynd i'r afael â pholisi ynni mewn ffordd y credaf yr hoffai pob un ohonom ei weld, ac rwy'n credu y bydd yn gwneud hynny. 

Yes, absolutely, Alun. So, as I say, this is one of the strands of things that we need to do to come together to be able to deliver the kind of energy grid across Wales that we want. So, the urban initiatives are really interesting. We expect a large-scale renewables developer to have a look at whether there are large-scale opportunities in some of our urban environments, for example, the utilisation of roofs on buildings and so on, as you’ve seen elsewhere. There are some real issues around solar, which I won't go into now—the Llywydd will be telling me off for the amount of time I'm taking—but it would be really interesting to make sure that we can exploit technologies being developed in our universities here in Wales at the moment to have home-grown solar panels, manufactured here in Wales, in a much better and more carbon-neutral way than is often the case. I'm very interested to make sure that some of the roofs that are being generated with the photovoltaics already in them in steel plants around Wales will be utilised in those kinds of builds. There is, perhaps, a role for this large-scale developer in that. I actually think it's much more likely to be part of Ynni Cymru, the co-operation agreement developer, which is likely to be pulling together community effort to do that kind of thing with small groupings. For example, a bid district in a city would be perfect for pulling that kind of stuff together. But we would expect them to co-operate, of course, and to cross-fertilise and to make sure that the profits are properly reinvested in the right kinds of projects. We have a project in mind to start us off, and then one of the big tasks for us will be to make sure that we have a pipeline of projects going forward that are probably a mix of all of those things.278

Ydy, yn hollol, Alun. Felly, fel rwy'n dweud, dyma un o'r amryw bethau y mae angen i ni eu gwneud i ddod at ein gilydd i allu cyflawni'r math o grid ynni ar draws Cymru mae arnom ni ei eisiau. Felly, mae'r mentrau trefol yn ddiddorol iawn. Rydym yn disgwyl i ddatblygwr adnewyddadwy sylweddol gloriannu a oes cyfleoedd sylweddol yn rhai o'n mannau trefol, er enghraifft, defnyddio toeau ar adeiladau ac yn y blaen, fel y gwelwch chi mewn mannau eraill. Mae rhai materion gwirioneddol yn ymwneud â solar, na fydda i'n ymhelaethu arnyn nhw nawr—bydd y Llywydd yn dweud y drefn wrthyf am faint o amser rwy'n ei gymryd—ond byddai'n ddiddorol iawn sicrhau y gallwn ni fanteisio ar dechnolegau sy'n cael eu datblygu yn ein prifysgolion yma yng Nghymru ar hyn o bryd i gael paneli solar a wnaed yma, a weithgynhyrchwyd yma yng Nghymru, mewn ffordd lawer gwell a mwy carbon-niwtral nag sy'n digwydd yn aml. Mae gen i ddiddordeb mawr sicrhau y bydd rhai o'r toeau sy'n cael eu cynhyrchu gyda elfennau ffotofoltäig eisoes ynddyn nhw mewn gweithfeydd dur o amgylch Cymru'n cael eu defnyddio yn y mathau hynny o adeiladau. Mae yna, efallai, swyddogaeth i'r datblygwr sylweddol hwn yn hynny. Credaf mewn gwirionedd ei bod hi'n llawer mwy tebygol o fod yn rhan o Ynni Cymru, datblygwr y cytundeb cydweithio, sy'n debygol o fod yn cydlynu ymdrech gymunedol i wneud y math yna o beth gyda grwpiau bach. Er enghraifft, byddai ardal gais mewn dinas yn berffaith ar gyfer tynnu'r math yna o beth at ei gilydd. Ond bydden ni'n disgwyl iddyn nhw gydweithredu, wrth gwrs, a chroesffrwythloni a gwneud yn siŵr bod yr elw yn cael ei ail-fuddsoddi'n iawn yn y mathau cywir o brosiectau. Mae gennym ni brosiect mewn golwg i ddechrau arni, ac yna un o'r tasgau mawr i ni fydd sicrhau bod gennym ni gyfres o brosiectau yn y dyfodol sy'n gyfuniad o'r holl bethau hynny mae'n debyg.

16:40
6. Datganiad gan y Gweinidog Cyfiawnder Cymdeithasol: Diweddariad ar Wcráin
6. Statement by the Minister for Social Justice: Update on Ukraine

Yr eitem nesaf, felly, yw'r datganiad gan y Gweinidog Cyfiawnder Cymdeithasol ar y diweddariad ar Wcráin. Dwi'n galw ar y Gweinidog i wneud y datganiad. Jane Hutt.280

The next item, therefore, is a statement by the Minister for Social Justice, an update on Ukraine. I call on the Minister to make the statement. Jane Hutt.

Diolch yn fawr, Llywydd. Thank you for providing an opportunity for me to give an update to Members about our ongoing work to support people from Ukraine seeking sanctuary in Wales. When I last updated you in September, Wales had welcomed just over 5,600 Ukrainians in Wales under the Homes for Ukraine scheme, including under our supersponsor route.281

Arrivals have continued, but at a much slower pace in recent weeks. Just under 6,000 Ukrainians sponsored by the Welsh Government and Welsh households had arrived in Wales by 18 October, and there have been additional arrivals under the Ukraine family scheme, but we are not given that data by the UK Government. More than 8,300 visas have now been granted to people from the Ukraine who have sponsors in Wales, so we can expect the number of arrivals to continue to grow steadily in the coming weeks, and we are mindful that events in Ukraine can have a direct impact on the number of Ukrainians who may arrive in Wales. We deplore the latest attempts by Putin to try to break the will of the Ukrainian people. We are continuing to work with the Home Office to ascertain the likelihood of the additional 1,600 individuals we have sponsored arriving in Wales, so that we can properly plan for providing accommodation and wraparound support.282

In recent weeks, we have been considering the offer that we make to Ukrainians who we support in our accommodation under the supersponsor route. I and other ministerial colleagues have visited many of our accommodation sites and received feedback directly from Ukrainian guests and the dedicated staff who are helping us to provide assistance. We want to help people to transition from a supportive welcome to active integration as quickly as possible.283

We believe that we can enhance personal independence and support people to move on to the next stage of their lives in Wales by revisiting our wraparound support offer. We will be aligning our initial accommodation offer much more closely to the support that would be received in other forms of temporary accommodation, and this will encourage guests to contribute to costs via earnings or universal credit wherever possible, after an initial short period. I have also engaged with my Scottish Government counterpart, Minister Neil Gray MSP, and I understand that they will be taking a very similar approach, as we learn from each others' experiences in our response as supersponsors.284

Our supersponsor route is a key part of Wales's response to the Europe-wide humanitarian crisis. We must ensure that we are steadfast in our commitment to supporting Ukraine and displaced Ukrainians living in Wales, despite the increased cost pressures we're all experiencing. The support we provide here will have an impact on the family and friends still defending Ukraine. The changes we make will carefully balance helping people to be more independent, to move on to alternative accommodation more quickly, and to ensure that we have the finances we need to fulfil our commitment to the Ukrainians we have sponsored.285

As well as my visits to welcome centres, I recently attended the Ukraine arts festival and the new Cardiff Ukraine centre. In each case, I have been struck by the desire and ability of Ukrainians, with a wide range of skills and experience, to integrate and join the workforce as quickly as possible. Many Ukrainians are already working, including a sizeable proportion of those in our initial accommodation.286

We need to be conscious that initial accommodation should be a short-term provision, with our guests supported to move on to longer term accommodation as soon as practicable. We understand that our welcome centres, which are funded by the Welsh Government, are of a good quality—and we are proud of that—but they are not a long-term option for people, not least because roots cannot be properly established in communities in such temporary accommodation.287

Last time I updated you, I remarked upon the good working relationship we had with the previous UK Minister for Refugees, Lord Harrington, and my hopes for a similar relationship with his successor. I am sorry to have to report that we have had no engagement from UK Ministers on these issues since Lord Harrington's resignation.288

But we are at a critical juncture in the UK Government Homes for Ukraine scheme. Welsh households who signed up as sponsors are at, or near, the six-month hosting milestone that represents the commitment they made to their guests at the point of application. These households have done an inspiring thing and embodied the nation of sanctuary vision in its truest sense. We know many did not plan to continue beyond six months, but we urge as many hosts as possible to consider hosting for a longer period if at all possible. Where that isn't possible, we thank you for everything you have done for your guests and for us as a nation. For those that can continue, we have funded Housing Justice Cymru to provide advice, training, peer support and mediation services for hosts in Wales. More information can be found by calling 01654 550 550 or emailing UkraineHostSupport@housingjustice.org.uk.289

We know that hosts in Wales are struggling with cost-of-living pressures, and this is a major factor in deciding if they can continue. This is why I wrote to UK Ministers, with my Scottish ministerial counterpart, to urge a quick decision on increasing the 'thank you' host payment to at least £500 per month from the current level of £350. We are still waiting for an update on this. We do need an urgent decision to avert a wave of homelessness presentations as we move into November, and I again call upon the UK Government to act on this, as well as providing financial certainty for year 2 of the programme, supporting the unfunded English for speakers of other languages provision and ensuring funding parity across the three Ukraine visa schemes.290

We are now communicating regularly with hosts and Ukrainian guests, with a monthly newsletter being sent from the Welsh Government, and we'll build upon this with additional information sessions and participation opportunities. Alongside our funded third sector partners, we recently held an open information session, which I was glad to see around 180 people attended to hear more about our work; we are mobilising a Ukraine peer support group through Displaced People in Action; and we'll also soon survey our Ukrainian guests to better understand their unmet skills and employment needs. Ukrainians are clearly integrating very well indeed, but we will continue to consider any action we can take to make this as effective and supportive as possible. Diolch.291

Diolch yn fawr, Llywydd. Diolch i chi am roi cyfle i mi roi'r wybodaeth ddiweddaraf i Aelodau am ein gwaith parhaus i gefnogi pobl o Wcráin sy'n chwilio am noddfa yng Nghymru. Pan wnes i roi'r wybodaeth ddiweddaraf i chi ddiwethaf ym mis Medi, roedd Cymru wedi croesawu ychydig dros 5,600 o Wcreiniaid i Gymru o dan gynllun Cartrefi i Wcráin, gan gynnwys o dan ein llwybr uwch-noddwr.

Mae rhai yn dal i gyrraedd, ond ar gyflymder llawer arafach yn ystod yr wythnosau diwethaf. Roedd ychydig dan 6,000 o Wcreiniaid a noddwyd gan Lywodraeth Cymru ac aelwydydd Cymru wedi cyrraedd Cymru erbyn 18 Hydref, a daeth rhai ychwanegol o dan y cynllun teuluoedd o Wcráin, ond ni roddir y data hwnnw i ni gan Lywodraeth y DU. Mae mwy na 8,300 o fisâu bellach wedi'u rhoi i bobl o Wcráin sydd â noddwyr yng Nghymru, felly gallwn ddisgwyl i nifer y bobl sy'n cyrraedd barhau i dyfu'n raddol yn ystod yr wythnosau nesaf, ac rydym yn ymwybodol y gall digwyddiadau yn Wcráin gael effaith uniongyrchol ar nifer yr Wcreiniaid a allai gyrraedd Cymru. Rydym yn gresynu at ymdrechion diweddaraf Putin i geisio torri ysbryd pobl Wcráin. Rydym yn parhau i weithio gyda'r Swyddfa Gartref i ganfod pa mor debygol yw hi y bydd yr 1,600 o unigolion ychwanegol yr ydym wedi eu noddi yn cyrraedd Cymru, fel y gallwn gynllunio'n iawn ar gyfer darparu llety a chefnogaeth gofleidiol.

Yn ystod yr wythnosau diwethaf, rydym wedi bod yn ystyried y cynnig a wnawn i Wcreiniaid yr ydym yn eu cefnogi yn ein llety o dan y llwybr uwch-noddwr. Rwyf i a chyd-Weinidogion eraill wedi ymweld â nifer o'n safleoedd llety ac wedi cael adborth yn uniongyrchol gan westeion o Wcráin a'r staff ymroddedig sy'n ein helpu i roi'r cymorth. Rydym eisiau helpu pobl i symud o sefyllfa o groeso cefnogol i sefyllfa o integreiddio gweithredol cyn gynted â phosibl.

Rydym yn credu y gallwn wella annibyniaeth bersonol a chefnogi pobl i symud ymlaen i gam nesaf eu bywydau yng Nghymru drwy ailedrych ar ein cynnig cefnogaeth gofleidiol. Byddwn ni'n alinio ein cynnig llety cychwynnol yn llawer agosach â'r gefnogaeth a geid mewn mathau eraill o lety dros dro, a bydd hyn yn annog gwesteion i gyfrannu at gostau drwy enillion neu gredyd cynhwysol pryd bynnag y bo modd, ar ôl cyfnod byr cychwynnol. Rwyf hefyd wedi ymgysylltu â fy Ngweinidog cyfatebol yn Llywodraeth yr Alban, y Gweinidog Neil Gray ASA, ac rwy'n deall y byddan nhw'n cymryd agwedd debyg iawn, wrth i ni ddysgu o brofiadau ein gilydd yn ein hymateb fel uwch-noddwyr.

Mae ein llwybr uwch-noddwr yn rhan allweddol o ymateb Cymru i argyfwng dyngarol Ewrop gyfan. Rhaid i ni sicrhau ein bod ni'n ddiwyro yn ein hymrwymiad i gefnogi Wcráin ac Wcreiniaid dadleoledig sy'n byw yng Nghymru, er gwaethaf y pwysau cynyddol o ran costau yr ydym ni i gyd yn ei brofi. Bydd y gefnogaeth yr ydym ni'n ei darparu yma yn cael effaith ar y teulu a ffrindiau sy'n dal i amddiffyn Wcráin. Bydd y newidiadau a wnawn yn cydbwyso'n ofalus y cymorth i bobl i fod yn fwy annibynnol, er mwyn symud ymlaen i lety arall yn gyflymach, a sicrhau bod gennym y cyllid sydd ei angen arnom i gyflawni ein hymrwymiad i'r Wcreiniaid yr ydym wedi eu noddi.

Yn ogystal â fy ymweliadau â chanolfannau croeso, bûm yn ddiweddar yng ngŵyl gelfyddydau Wcráin a chanolfan newydd Wcráin yng Nghaerdydd. Ym mhob achos, rwyf wedi cael fy nharo gan awydd a gallu Wcreiniaid, gydag ystod eang o sgiliau a phrofiad, i integreiddio ac ymuno â'r gweithlu cyn gynted â phosibl. Mae llawer o Wcreiniaid eisoes yn gweithio, gan gynnwys cyfran sylweddol o'r rhai yn ein llety cychwynnol.

Mae angen i ni fod yn ymwybodol y dylai llety cychwynnol fod yn ddarpariaeth tymor byr, gyda'n gwesteion yn cael cymorth i symud ymlaen i lety mwy hirdymor cyn gynted ag y bo'n ymarferol. Deallwn fod ein canolfannau croeso, sydd wedi eu hariannu gan Lywodraeth Cymru, o ansawdd da—ac rydym ni'n falch o hynny—ond dydyn nhw ddim yn ddewis hirdymor i bobl, yn bennaf oherwydd na ellir sefydlu gwreiddiau'n iawn mewn cymunedau mewn llety dros dro o'r fath.

Y tro diwethaf i mi roi'r wybodaeth ddiweddaraf i chi, soniais am y berthynas waith dda a gawsom gyda Gweinidog blaenorol y DU dros Ffoaduriaid, yr Arglwydd Harrington, a fy ngobeithion am berthynas debyg gyda'i olynydd. Mae'n ddrwg gen i orfod adrodd nad ydym wedi cael unrhyw ymgysylltiad gan Weinidogion y DU ar y materion hyn ers ymddiswyddiad yr Arglwydd Harrington.

Ond rydym mewn cyfnod tyngedfennol yng nghynllun Cartrefi i Wcráin Llywodraeth y DU. Mae aelwydydd Cymru a gofrestrodd yn noddwyr yn agos at gyrraedd y garreg filltir chwe mis sy'n cynrychioli'r ymrwymiad a wnaethant i'w gwesteion ar adeg y cais. Mae'r aelwydydd hyn wedi gwneud peth ysbrydoledig ac wedi ymgorffori gweledigaeth cenedl o noddfa yn ei gwir ystyr. Rydym yn gwybod nad oedd llawer yn bwriadu parhau y tu hwnt i chwe mis, ond rydym yn annog cymaint â phosibl o'r rhai sy'n cynnig llety i ystyried cynnig llety am gyfnod hirach os yw'n bosibl o gwbl. Pan nad yw hynny'n bosib, diolchwn am bopeth yr ydych chi wedi'i wneud i'ch gwesteion ac i ni fel cenedl. I'r rhai sy'n gallu parhau, rydym wedi ariannu Cyfiawnder Tai Cymru i ddarparu cyngor, hyfforddiant, cefnogaeth gan gymheiriaid a gwasanaethau cyfryngu i'r rhai sy'n cynnig llety yng Nghymru. Ceir mwy o wybodaeth drwy ffonio 01654 550 550 neu drwy anfon neges e-bost i UkraineHostSupport@housingjustice.org.uk.

Rydym yn gwybod bod y rhai sy'n cynnig llety yng Nghymru yn ei chael hi'n anodd gyda phwysau costau byw, ac mae hyn yn ffactor pwysig wrth benderfynu a oes modd iddyn nhw barhau. Dyma pam yr ysgrifennais at Weinidogion y DU, gyda fy Ngweinidog cyfatebol yn yr Alban, i annog penderfyniad cyflym ar gynyddu'r taliad 'diolch' i'r rhai sy'n cynnig llety i o leiaf £500 y mis o'r lefel bresennol o £350. Rydym yn dal i aros am ddiweddariad ar hyn. Mae angen penderfyniad brys arnom i osgoi ton o achosion o ddigartrefedd wrth i ni symud i fis Tachwedd, ac rwy'n galw eto ar Lywodraeth y DU i weithredu ar hyn, yn ogystal â rhoi sicrwydd ariannol i flwyddyn 2 y rhaglen, gan gefnogi'r ddarpariaeth Saesneg ar gyfer siaradwyr ieithoedd eraill heb ei ariannu a sicrhau cydraddoldeb cyllido ar draws tri chynllun fisa Wcráin.

Rydym bellach yn cyfathrebu'n rheolaidd gyda'r rhai sy'n cynnig llety a gwesteion o Wcráin, gyda chylchlythyr misol yn cael ei anfon o Lywodraeth Cymru, a byddwn yn adeiladu ar hyn gyda sesiynau gwybodaeth ychwanegol a chyfleoedd i gymryd rhan. Ochr yn ochr â'n partneriaid trydydd sector a ariennir, fe wnaethom gynnal sesiwn wybodaeth agored yn ddiweddar, yr oeddwn yn falch o weld tua 180 o bobl yn bresennol i glywed mwy am ein gwaith; rydym yn rhoi grŵp cymorth gan gymheiriaid Wcráin ar waith drwy Displaced People in Action; a byddwn hefyd yn arolygu ein gwesteion o Wcráin yn fuan er mwyn deall yn well eu sgiliau a'u hanghenion cyflogaeth sydd heb eu diwallu. Mae Wcreiniaid yn amlwg yn integreiddio'n dda iawn yn wir, ond byddwn yn parhau i ystyried unrhyw gamau y gallwn eu cymryd i wneud hyn mor effeithiol a chefnogol â phosibl. Diolch.

16:45

Thank you for your statement and for our short meeting earlier, which was very helpful.292

Responding to your update on Ukraine statement here four weeks ago, I referred to your constructive relationship, which you've referred to again, with the former UK Government Minister for refugees, Lord Harrington, and asked how, based upon practical inter-governmental working relationships in Wales, you responded to his statement on resignation last month that the role was always meant to be temporary and that his work was essentially complete. I also asked what discussions you had had or were planning to have with the UK Government regarding a possible uplift to the monthly £350 payment to people hosting Ukrainians in their own homes, and again you've referred to that in your statement today. In your response then, you said that the job certainly wasn't done. Referring to the joint letter regarding these matters you had sent with your Scottish ministerial counterpart to the then new Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities and the then new Home Secretary, you stated that you would be, and I quote,293

'very interested to see what reply we get'.294

Thank you for subsequently copying me into that letter. What, if any, reply did you receive? And if, given events elsewhere, you've not yet received a reply, how will you be following up on this once Prime Minister Rishi Sunak announces his Cabinet?295

In your reply to me, you stated that local leadership is crucially important in the provision of devolved service for which the Welsh Government is responsible. Following my reference to, for example, the need for English for speakers of other languages, or ESOL, lessons in person and online and for action to support skill and qualification transferability, something we also discussed earlier, what update can you provide on these matters, given your response then that you have fortnightly meetings on Ukraine, chaired by the Minister for Finance and Local Government? 296

I refer to the document that I sent to you, produced by the Polish Integration Support Centre, or PISC, in Wrexham, detailing their humanitarian efforts to help Ukrainian refugees and the proposal for consolidated and sustainable support for Ukrainian people, including the construction of temporary housing. What engagement have you or your officials therefore subsequently had with them regarding this? 297

More broadly, given that the latest figures show that 4,833 visa applications by people from Ukraine have been submitted with the Welsh Government as a supersponsor, that 4,564 have been issued with the Welsh Government as a supersponsor, and that 2,904 of the people who've arrived in the UK had the Welsh Government as a supersponsor, what is the current position regarding the pause to new applications for the Welsh Government supersponsor scheme announced in June?298

Both my colleague Russell George and I have received an e-mail saying, and I quote, 'I ask for Welsh Government help with a pilot project to use long-term empty housing units to provide short-term accommodation for Ukrainian refugees, using a short-life housing model of the kind implemented elsewhere since the 1980s.' Who is the best person to refer the sender to regarding this?299

Finally, I've previously referred you to the role played by faith groups in the Ukrainian link programme to support Ukrainians arriving in north Wales. In this context, what engagement have you had with the Catholic community regarding its response to the illegal and inhumane invasion of Ukraine, including the Catholic international development charity CAFOD's Ukrainian humanitarian appeal and dedicated emergency response team to reach people most in need, and the bishops’ conference domestic social action agency, Caritas Social Action Network, or CSAN, which, with its partners, is supporting the relocation of refugees across the UK with the diocese and agencies of the church assisting the co-ordination efforts? Diolch.300

Diolch am eich datganiad ac am ein cyfarfod byr yn gynharach, a oedd yn ddefnyddiol iawn.

Wrth ymateb i'ch diweddariad ar ddatganiad Wcráin yma bedair wythnos yn ôl, cyfeiriais at eich perthynas adeiladol, yr ydych chi wedi cyfeirio ati eto, gyda Gweinidog blaenorol Llywodraeth y DU dros ffoaduriaid, yr Arglwydd Harrington, a gofyn sut, ar sail perthnasoedd gweithio ymarferol rhyng-lywodraethol yng Nghymru, wnaethoch chi ymateb i'w ddatganiad adeg ei ymddiswyddiad fis diwethaf sef bod y swyddogaeth i fod yn un dros dro a bod ei waith yn ei hanfod yn gyflawn. Gofynnais hefyd pa drafodaethau yr oeddech wedi'u cael neu'n bwriadu eu cael gyda Llywodraeth y DU ynghylch cynnydd posibl i'r taliad misol o £350 i bobl sy'n lletya Wcreiniaid yn eu cartrefi eu hunain, ac unwaith eto rydych chi wedi cyfeirio at hynny yn eich datganiad heddiw. Yn eich ymateb chi bryd hynny, fe ddywedoch chi nad oedd y gwaith wedi ei gyflawni. Gan gyfeirio at y llythyr ynglŷn â'r materion hyn yr oeddech wedi'i anfon ar y cyd gyda'ch Gweinidog cyfatebol yn yr Alban at yr Ysgrifennydd Gwladol dros Ffyniant Bro, Tai a Chymunedau ar y pryd a'r Ysgrifennydd Cartref newydd ar y pryd, fe ddywedoch chi y byddech chi, ac rwy'n dyfynnu,

'â diddordeb mawr mewn gweld pa ateb a gawn'.

Diolch am fy nghopïo i mewn i'r llythyr hwnnw wedyn. Pa ateb, os o gwbl, gawsoch chi? Ac os, o ystyried digwyddiadau mewn mannau eraill, nad ydych chi wedi cael ateb eto, sut fyddwch chi'n ymateb ar ôl i'r Prif Weinidog Rishi Sunak gyhoeddi ei Gabinet?

Yn eich ateb i mi, fe ddywedoch fod arweinyddiaeth leol yn hanfodol bwysig yn narpariaeth y gwasanaeth datganoledig y mae Llywodraeth Cymru yn gyfrifol amdano. Yn dilyn fy nghyfeiriad at, er enghraifft, yr angen am Saesneg i siaradwyr ieithoedd eraill, neu ESOL, gwersi personol ac ar-lein ac am weithredu i gefnogi trosglwyddo sgiliau a chymwysterau, rhywbeth a drafodwyd gennym hefyd yn gynharach, pa ddiweddariad gallwch ei ddarparu ar y materion hyn, o ystyried eich ymateb yna bod gennych gyfarfodydd bob pythefnos ar Wcráin, wedi'u cadeirio gan y Gweinidog Cyllid a Llywodraeth Leol?

Rwy'n cyfeirio at y ddogfen a anfonais atoch, a gynhyrchwyd gan y Ganolfan Cefnogi Integreiddio Pwylaidd, neu PISC, yn Wrecsam, yn manylu ar eu hymdrechion dyngarol i helpu ffoaduriaid o Wcráin a'r cynnig am gefnogaeth gyfunol a chynaliadwy i bobl Wcráin, gan gynnwys adeiladu tai dros dro. Pa ymgysylltu fu rhyngoch chi neu eich swyddogion felly wedi hynny â nhw ynglŷn â hyn?

Yn ehangach, o ystyried bod y ffigyrau diweddaraf yn dangos bod 4,833 o geisiadau fisa gan bobl o Wcráin wedi cael eu cyflwyno gyda Llywodraeth Cymru fel uwch-noddwr, bod 4,564 wedi eu cyhoeddi gyda Llywodraeth Cymru fel uwch-noddwr, a bod 2,904 o'r bobl sydd wedi cyrraedd y DU wedi cael Llywodraeth Cymru fel uwch-noddwr, beth yw'r sefyllfa bresennol o ran saib ceisiadau newydd yng Nghynllun uwch-noddwr Llywodraeth Cymru a gafodd ei gyhoeddi ym mis Mehefin?

Mae fy nghyd-Aelod Russell George a minnau wedi cael e-bost yn dweud, ac rwy'n dyfynnu, 'Rwy'n gofyn am gymorth gan Lywodraeth Cymru gyda phrosiect treialu i ddefnyddio unedau tai gwag hirdymor i ddarparu llety tymor byr i ffoaduriaid o Wcráin, gan ddefnyddio model tai oes fer o'r math a weithredwyd mewn mannau eraill ers y 1980au.' Pwy yw'r person gorau y dylid cyfeirio'r anfonwr ato ynghylch hyn?

Yn olaf, rwyf wedi eich cyfeirio chi o'r blaen at y rhan a chwaraewyd gan grwpiau ffydd yn rhaglen gyswllt Wcráin i gefnogi Wcreiniaid sy'n cyrraedd y gogledd. Yn y cyd-destun hwn, pa ymgysylltu ydych chi wedi'i gael â'r gymuned Gatholig ynglŷn â'i hymateb i'r ymosodiad anghyfreithlon ac annynol ar Wcráin, gan gynnwys apêl ddyngarol a thîm ymateb brys pwrpasol elusen yr Asiantaeth Gatholig ar gyfer Datblygu Tramor i gyrraedd pobl sydd fwyaf anghenus, ac asiantaeth gweithredu cymdeithasol domestig cynhadledd yr esgobion, Caritas Social Action Network, neu CSAN, sydd, gyda'i bartneriaid, yn cefnogi adleoli ffoaduriaid ar draws y DU gydag esgobaethau ac asiantaethau'r eglwys yn cynorthwyo'r ymdrechion cydlynu? Diolch.

16:50

Thank you very much, Mark, and thank you for also always giving me updates and insights of the work that’s been carried out in north Wales, particularly in relation to the third-sector engagements and local authorities.301

I do hope that we can establish good new working relationships with the new Government, the new Cabinet that’ll be announced over the next few days. You referred to the joint letter that I sent to Andrew Stephenson, who had been named as Minister for refugees by the previous Prime Minister in the department of housing and levelling up, but I have to say, no reply was received to that letter. I asked my officials, and indeed the Scottish Minister asked his officials, to request an urgent meeting with the new Minister, but there was no response. So, I am, in a positive and constructive way, looking towards immediately welcoming a new announcement, which I hope will be made, that we will have a Minister for refugees who we can follow up with. Because we urgently need responses to the questions that we’ve asked, particularly about the uplift to the £350 monthly payment to those hosts for the Homes for Ukraine scheme.302

I’m interested as well that in England, a number of charities have come together. I think they wrote to the former Prime Minister to actually say very much what we’ve been saying, actually echoing, in fact, Lord Harrington’s call for an increased payment to hosts to help them through the winter. I think the generosity of hosts at a time of economic strain and cost-of-living pressures is extraordinary; the generosity of hosts across Wales with very different socioeconomic and financial means themselves. So, can I ask you and your colleagues in Westminster to ensure that we do get a positive response?303

Local leadership is vital, so myself and the Minister for Finance and Local Government, and indeed the Minister for Climate Change, are meeting every fortnight with the leaders of local government. Our officials are working very closely, particularly around a framework for accommodation in terms of move-on opportunities. But that local leadership is robust, it’s positive. In fact, Ukraine is on the agenda as a standing item as we meet every fortnight. The response that we get from local leadership is about not just the support they’re giving to their welcome centres, if they have them in their county areas, but also ways in which they're supporting hosts as well, the hosts who are providing that important support for so many of our Ukrainian guests in Wales.304

It's very important in terms of the move-on accommodation that's being provided that we look to, as the Minister for Climate Change was able to do last week, the £65 million transitional accommodation capital programme. This is something that will help us increase accommodation to support existing housing pressures, together with the Ukraine response. Local authorities are coming forward and working with registered social landlords to provide this type of accommodation. Of course, there's huge pressure on our capital programme, which you are well aware of, but this is transitional accommodation that can also meet a wide range of housing need in Wales. So, we hope that we will get the support, and that includes support in terms of UK Government's forthcoming announcements. We're very concerned about what this will mean for capital, because this will be a really important way to help those who are in housing need move forward. We have to remember that we've got more than 8,000 people in temporary accommodation already, and these are housing pressures that our local leaders are supporting.305

Thank you, again, for raising the work and the support of the Polish integration society, and I will make sure that there is a response to them. And also, just in terms of any suggestion about other use of accommodation—I think you mentioned Russell George as well who had received an approach about possible use of short-life accommodation—they should go to the local authority in which that accommodation is provided.306

Of course, it is a challenge regarding our supersponsor scheme. We are committed to it, it provides a safe way to welcome people, Ukrainians fleeing from that terrible conflict. They come here and they are given that support, that wraparound support that we have provided. Remember that the original commitment we made was for 1,000 Ukrainian people being supported; now we're four and five times the number of Ukrainian people that we're supporting through our supersponsor route. Our welcome centres are now running at full capacity, but we're working quickly to ensure there's a reliable pathway to longer term accommodation for everyone we accommodate.307

Diolch yn fawr iawn, Mark, a diolch i chi hefyd am roi diweddariadau a mewnwelediadau i mi bob amser o'r gwaith sydd wedi'i wneud yn y gogledd, yn enwedig mewn cysylltiad â'r ymgysylltiadau trydydd sector a'r awdurdodau lleol.

Rwy'n gobeithio y gallwn sefydlu perthynas waith newydd dda gyda'r Llywodraeth newydd, y Cabinet newydd a fydd yn cael ei gyhoeddi dros y dyddiau nesaf. Fe gyfeirioch at y llythyr ar y cyd a anfonais at Andrew Stephenson, a oedd wedi'i enwi'n Weinidog dros ffoaduriaid gan y Prif Weinidog blaenorol yn yr adran dai a ffyniant bro, ond mae'n rhaid i mi ddweud, ni chafwyd ateb i'r llythyr hwnnw. Gofynnais i fy swyddogion, ac yn wir gofynnodd Gweinidog yr Alban i'w swyddogion ofyn am gyfarfod brys gyda'r Gweinidog newydd, ond ni chafwyd ymateb. Felly, rydw i, mewn ffordd gadarnhaol ac adeiladol, yn edrych ymlaen at groesawu cyhoeddiad newydd yn syth, a fydd, gobeithio, yn cael ei wneud, y bydd gennym Weinidog dros ffoaduriaid y gallwn godi'r mater hwn gydag ef. Oherwydd y mae angen ymatebion ar frys i'r cwestiynau yr ydym wedi'u gofyn, yn enwedig am y codiad i'r taliad misol o £350 i'r rhai sy'n lletya ar gyfer y cynllun Cartrefi i Wcráin.

Mae gennyf ddiddordeb hefyd yn y ffaith bod nifer o elusennau wedi dod at ei gilydd yn Lloegr. Rwy'n credu eu bod wedi ysgrifennu at y cyn Brif Weinidog i ddweud fwy neu lai yr hyn a ddywedom ni, gan adleisio mewn gwirionedd, alwad yr Arglwydd Harrington am daliad cynyddol i helpu'r rhai a oedd yn lletya drwy'r gaeaf. Rwy'n credu bod haelioni y rhai a oedd yn lletya ar adeg o straen economaidd a phwysau costau byw yn rhyfeddol; haelioni'r rhai oedd yn lletya ledled Cymru sydd mewn sefyllfaoedd economaidd-gymdeithasol ac ariannol gwahanol iawn eu hunain. Felly, a gaf i ofyn i chi a'ch cyd-Weinidogion yn San Steffan sicrhau ein bod ni'n cael ymateb cadarnhaol?

Mae arweinyddiaeth leol yn hanfodol, felly rydw i a'r Gweinidog Cyllid a Llywodraeth Leol, ac yn wir y Gweinidog Newid Hinsawdd, yn cwrdd bob pythefnos gydag arweinwyr llywodraeth leol. Mae ein swyddogion yn gweithio'n agos iawn, yn enwedig ynghylch fframwaith ar gyfer llety o ran cyfleoedd i symud ymlaen. Cyn belled â bod arweinyddiaeth leol yn gadarn, bydd yn bositif. Mewn gwirionedd, mae Wcráin ar yr agenda fel eitem sefydlog wrth i ni gwrdd bob pythefnos. Mae'r ymateb yr ydym ni'n ei gael oddi wrth arweinyddiaeth leol yn ymwneud â nid yn unig y gefnogaeth y maen nhw'n ei rhoi i'w canolfannau croeso, os oes ganddyn nhw rai yn eu hardaloedd sirol, ond hefyd y ffyrdd y maen nhw'n cefnogi y rhai sy'n lletya hefyd, y rhai sy'n darparu'r gefnogaeth bwysig honno i gynifer o'n gwesteion o Wcráin yng Nghymru.

Mae'n bwysig iawn o ran llety symud ymlaen sy'n cael ei ddarparu ein bod ni'n edrych, fel yr oedd y Gweinidog Newid Hinsawdd yn gallu ei wneud yr wythnos diwethaf, ar y rhaglen gyfalaf llety dros dro gwerth £65 miliwn. Mae hyn yn rhywbeth a fydd yn ein helpu ni i gynyddu llety i gefnogi'r pwysau tai presennol, ynghyd ag ymateb Wcráin. Mae awdurdodau lleol yn dod ymlaen ac yn gweithio gyda landlordiaid cymdeithasol cofrestredig i ddarparu'r math hwn o lety. Wrth gwrs, mae pwysau enfawr ar ein rhaglen gyfalaf yr ydych yn ymwybodol iawn ohono, ond llety dros dro yw hwn a all hefyd ddiwallu ystod eang o anghenion tai yng Nghymru. Felly, rydym yn gobeithio y cawn ni'r gefnogaeth, ac mae hynny'n cynnwys cefnogaeth o ran cyhoeddiadau sydd i ddod gan Lywodraeth y DU. Rydym ni'n bryderus iawn ynghylch beth fydd hyn yn ei olygu i gyfalaf, oherwydd bydd hyn yn ffordd bwysig iawn o helpu'r rhai sydd angen tai i symud ymlaen. Mae'n rhaid i ni gofio bod gennym ni dros 8,000 o bobl mewn llety dros dro yn barod, a dyma bwysau tai y mae ein harweinwyr lleol yn eu cefnogi.

Diolch, eto, am nodi gwaith a chefnogaeth y gymdeithas integreiddio Pwylaidd, a gwnaf yn siŵr bod ymateb iddynt. A hefyd, dim ond o ran unrhyw awgrym am ddefnydd arall o lety—rwy'n credu eich bod chi wedi sôn bod rhywun wedi cysylltu â Russell George hefyd ynghylch y defnydd posibl o lety oes fer—dylen nhw fynd at yr awdurdod lleol lle darperir y llety hwnnw.

Wrth gwrs, mae'n her o ran ein cynllun uwch-noddwr. Rydym wedi ymrwymo iddo, mae'n darparu ffordd ddiogel o groesawu pobl o Wcráin sy'n ffoi rhag y gwrthdaro ofnadwy hwnnw. Maen nhw'n dod yma ac maen nhw'n cael y gefnogaeth honno, y gefnogaeth gofleidiol yna yr ydym ni wedi'i darparu. Cofiwch mai'r ymrwymiad gwreiddiol a wnaethom oedd i 1,000 o bobl o Wcráin gael eu cefnogi; nawr rydym yn cefnogi pedair a phum gwaith y nifer gwreiddiol o bobl drwy ein llwybr uwch-noddwr. Mae ein canolfannau croeso bellach yn gweithredu gyda chapasiti llawn, ond rydym yn gweithio'n gyflym i sicrhau bod llwybr dibynadwy at lety tymor hwy i bawb yr ydym yn cynnig llety iddyn nhw.

16:55

Diolch am y datganiad, Weinidog. Mae'n wir bod yr adroddiadau am y rhyfela yn Wcráin a'r dwysáu sydd o ran tactegau ac agwedd cwbl annynol Rwsia yn peri gofid ofnadwy i'r bobl sydd wedi cael lloches yng Nghymru, ac yn debyg, wrth gwrs, o gael effaith ar y niferoedd o ffoaduriaid.308

Mae'r newidiadau rŷch chi wedi sôn amdanyn nhw o ran y gefnogaeth fydd ar gael i bobl dan nawdd Llywodraeth Cymru, sydd, wrth gwrs, wedi gorfod gadael popeth, wedi profi trawma a cholled, yn peri peth pryder. Tra'n cydnabod bod angen annog pobl i symud ymlaen, integreiddio i gymdeithas a thalu eu ffordd ble'n bosib, oni ddylid gwneud hynny mor gyflym â sy'n briodol yn hytrach na mor gyflym â phosib? Felly, beth yw llais y ffoadur yn hyn? Pwy sy'n penderfynu pa gostau sy'n cael eu talu a beth yw'r meini prawf? A fyddai tapr o ryw fath o ran y cymorth sydd ar gael gan y Llywodraeth yn briodol os yw pobl yn ennill cyflog neu o ran eu taliadau credyd cynhwysol?309

Ers i'r Gweinidog gyflwyno ei diweddariad diwethaf ar Wcráin, mae mwy a mwy o sefydliadau'r trydydd sector yn pryderu am y bygythiad gwirioneddol o ddigartrefedd sy'n wynebu ffoaduriaid o Wcráin. Yn ôl adroddiad yn The Guardian, gallai 50,000 o ffoaduriaid o Wcráin ledled y Deyrnas Gyfunol fod yn ddigartref y flwyddyn nesaf. Eisoes ers mis Chwefror rydym ni'n gwybod bod 1,335 o aelwydydd o Wcráin, gan gynnwys 945 â phlant, wedi eu cofrestru'n ddigartref. Felly, Weinidog, a yw hi'n adeg ddoeth i wneud y newid yma nawr a ninnau yn wynebu'r gaeaf caletaf ers degawdau a gwyntoedd main y storm economaidd yn arbennig o fygythiol i'r rhai sydd wedi gorfod ffoi, gan adael popeth ar ôl yn eu mamwlad? 310

Thank you for the statement, Minister. It is true that the reports of the war in Ukraine and the intensification in terms of tactics and the inhuman response of Russia are very concerning to those people who have sought shelter in Wales, and likely, of course, to have an impact on the number of refugees.

The changes that you've mentioned in terms of the support available to the people sponsored by Welsh Government, who, of course, left everything behind, who've experienced trauma and loss, do cause some concern. While recognising that we need to encourage people to move on, to integrate into society and to pay their way wherever possible, we should do that as quickly as is appropriate, rather than as quickly as possible. So, what's the voice of the refugee here? Who decides which costs are to be paid, and what are the criteria for that? Would a taper of some sort in terms of the support available from Government be appropriate if people are earning a salary or receiving universal credit, for example?

Since the Minister presented her latest update on Ukraine, more and more third sector organisations are very concerned about the very real threat of homelessness facing refugees from Ukraine. According to a report in The Guardian, up to 50,000 Ukrainian refugees across the UK could be homeless next year. Already since February, we know that 1,335 Ukrainian households, including 945 with children, have registered as homeless. So, Minister, is now the right time to be making this change, given that we are facing the hardest winter for decades and with the harsh winds of the economic storm particularly threatening those who've had to flee, leaving everything behind in their home country?

Welsh councils are warning us already that they're going to be facing huge shortfalls in their budgets as a result of the COVID pandemic, market reactions to Westminster chaos, the energy crisis and inflationary pressures because of this cost-of-living crisis. The Welsh Local Government Association has warned that councils are at risk of being forced to make significant cuts to key services. So, how is the Welsh Government supporting and working with local authorities now to ensure that there is local support and housing available for those who need it, especially given the change in support announced today?311

I asked you this after your last update to the Senedd, but you didn't answer me, so I'm asking you again whether we could potentially allow our local authorities to become guarantors for Ukrainians faced with having to enter the rental market, which is, as we know, at the moment extremely competitive and costly.312

Mae cynghorau Cymru yn ein rhybuddio eisoes eu bod yn mynd i fod yn wynebu diffygion enfawr yn eu cyllidebau o ganlyniad i bandemig COVID, adweithiau'r farchnad i anhrefn San Steffan, yr argyfwng ynni a phwysau chwyddiant oherwydd yr argyfwng costau byw hwn. Mae Cymdeithas Llywodraeth Leol Cymru wedi rhybuddio bod cynghorau mewn perygl o gael eu gorfodi i wneud toriadau sylweddol i wasanaethau allweddol. Felly, sut mae Llywodraeth Cymru'n cefnogi ac yn gweithio gydag awdurdodau lleol nawr i sicrhau bod cefnogaeth a thai lleol ar gael i'r rhai sydd eu hangen, yn enwedig o ystyried y newid mewn cefnogaeth a gyhoeddwyd heddiw?

Gofynnais hyn i chi ar ôl eich diweddariad diwethaf i'r Senedd, ond ni wnaethoch fy ateb, felly rwy'n gofyn i chi eto a allem o bosibl ganiatáu i'n hawdurdodau lleol fod yn warantwyr i Wcreiniaid sy'n wynebu sefyllfa lle maen nhw'n gorfod mynd i mewn i'r farchnad rentu, sydd, fel y gwyddom, ar hyn o bryd yn hynod gystadleuol a chostus.

Yn olaf, rŷch chi'n cyfeirio yn eich datganiad nad ydych chi wedi cael unrhyw ymgysylltiad ag olynydd yr Arglwydd Harrington, a oedd yn Weinidog ffoaduriaid yn Llywodraeth San Steffan, ac rwyf am roi ar gofnod farn Plaid Cymru fod hyn yn gwbl warthus ac yn gwbl anfaddeuol yng ngolau'r argyfwng sydd yn wynebu'r miloedd o ffoaduriaid yng Nghymru sydd mewn sefyllfa mor anodd wrth geisio ymgartrefu mewn gwlad newydd. Mae nifer ar ymyl dibyn brawychus yn sgil y ffaith fod nifer fawr iawn o'r rhai sydd wedi dod yma drwy gynllun Cartrefi i Wcráin yn agos nawr at ddiwedd y cytundeb chwe mis â'r rhai sydd wedi rhoi llety iddynt.313

Gyda'r argyfwng costau byw a heb gynnydd yn y taliad misol o £350, bydd hi'n anodd iawn nawr i nifer o bobl ymestyn y croeso hwnnw. Mae'n warthus fod Torïaid San Steffan yn poeni cyn lleied am gefnogi pobl Wcráin. Weinidog, gan ein bod ni yma yng Nghymru yn genedl noddfa, a oes modd defnyddio taliadau costau byw eraill i gefnogi'r cytundebau hyn er mwyn atal embaras, straen, caledi a digartrefedd? Diolch.314

Finally, you refer in your statement that you've had no engagement with Lord Harrington's successor, and he was the Minister for refugees in Westminster, and I want to put on record the Plaid Cymru view that this is entirely disgraceful and unforgivable in light of the crisis facing thousands of refugees in Wales, who are in such a difficult situation in making their homes in a new country. Now, many are on the edge of a precipice, given the fact that many of those who have come here through the Homes for Ukraine scheme are close to the end of that six-month period with their hosts.

With the cost-of-living crisis and without an increase in the monthly payment of £350, it'll be very difficult now for many people to extend that welcome. It is disgraceful that the Tories in Westminster care so little about supporting the people of Ukraine. Minister, as we in Wales, here, are a nation of sanctuary, can we use other cost-of-living payments to support these costs of living to prevent homelessness, stress and poverty?  

17:00

Diolch yn fawr, Sioned Williams, and thank you for those important questions. I think that, what I'm signaling, I suppose, is that we're working with not only our Ukrainian guests but our local authority partners to find a way in which we can ensure that we can provide that initial support through our supersponsor scheme in our welcome centres across Wales, and, also, help them with their engagement, because this is about working together in collaboration to move, as you say, in an appropriate way to enable them to move forward into more independent living.315

So, some of our guests who come, they've said, 'Can we contribute?', because they see that there's been this welcome. They've come, they haven't had to be matched—they've literally come and they've been welcomed into a welcome centre or, indeed, other temporary initial accommodation, and they're saying, 'We want to become independent'. If, of course, they then get into work, into jobs, they're using their skills and, also, beginning then—because we have every agency at hand to help them access benefits like universal credit, they are willing and wish to make a contribution. But, also, we consider the fact that they would, perhaps, prefer to be more self-catering in terms of diet and access to appropriate food and provision for their lives, rather than, perhaps, depending on a set arrangement or a menu that has been provided in a welcome centre.316

Of course, when we started along this route, and that's why we work very closely with our Scottish Government colleagues, we were supersponsors to provide that welcome, that wraparound support. That includes the support that, obviously, is crucial, in assessing health needs, educational needs of the children, and I've talked about access to benefits and also to skills and jobs. So, you know that, through our website and through our work, we have free personalised careers advice, coaching and employment support from Working Wales for every—of course, they come to every welcome centre, so people are encouraged and supported into work.317

Many of our Ukrainian guests have independently moved on, but there's a real pressure in terms of availability of housing, in terms of that move-on opportunity. So, we want to avert any threat of homelessness—we want to avert that. We know that every Ukrainian guest who comes through the supersponsor route, or, indeed, supporting hosts, and funding—substantially funding Housing Justice Cymru, Asylum Justice Cymru, the Welsh Refugee Council and the British Red Cross to ensure that they're all engaged in supporting the refugees who are either with hosts or in our welcome centres.318

What I would say is to thank you for your recognition that we need to have a response from the UK Government, not just in terms of the £350, and lifting that up for hosts, but also the fact that we've called on them to give more support for discretionary housing payments and for local housing allowances, so that local authorities can use their discretion to help people move on into the private rented sector. Indeed, as I've mentioned, this letter from refugee charities in England, they are actually saying help refugee families find homes—this is the letter to the Prime Minister—a rental scheme for refugees arriving through a Government-backed scheme. Of course, local authorities are using their discretion, their powers, in order to try and help people get into long-term accommodation.319

Diolch yn fawr, Sioned Williams, a diolch am y cwestiynau pwysig yna. Rwy'n credu, yr hyn rwy'n ceisio ei amlygu, am wn i, yw ein bod ni'n gweithio, nid yn unig gyda ein gwesteion Wcreinaidd ond ein partneriaid awdurdod lleol i ddod o hyd i ffordd y gallwn ni sicrhau y gallwn ddarparu'r gefnogaeth gychwynnol honno drwy ein cynllun arch-noddwr yn ein canolfannau croeso ledled Cymru, a hefyd, eu helpu gyda'u hymgysylltiad, oherwydd bod hyn yn ymwneud â chydweithio mewn cydweithrediad i symud, fel y dywedwch chi, mewn ffordd briodol i'w galluogi nhw i symud ymlaen i fyw'n fwy annibynnol.

Felly, mae rhai o'n gwesteion yn dweud, 'Gawn ni gyfrannu?', oherwydd maen nhw'n gweld y croeso yma. Maen nhw wedi dod, nid oedden nhw'n gorfod cael eu paru—maen nhw wedi dod yn llythrennol ac wedi cael eu croesawu i ganolfan groeso neu, yn wir, i lety cychwynnol dros dro arall, ac maen nhw'n dweud, 'Rydym ni eisiau bod yn annibynnol'. Os gallan nhw, wrth gwrs, wedyn gael gwaith, swyddi, maen nhw'n defnyddio eu sgiliau ac, hefyd, yn dechrau—oherwydd bod gennym ni bob asiantaeth wrth law i'w helpu i gael mynediad at fudd-daliadau fel credyd cynhwysol, maen nhw'n barod ac yn dymuno gwneud cyfraniad. Ond, hefyd, rydym ni'n ystyried y ffaith y byddai'n well ganddyn nhw, efallai, droi at hunan-arlwyo o ran deiet a mynediad at fwyd a darpariaeth briodol ar gyfer eu bywydau, yn hytrach na dibynnu ar drefniant penodol neu fwydlen sydd wedi ei darparu mewn canolfan groeso efallai.

Wrth gwrs, pan gychwynnom ni ar hyd y llwybr hwn, a dyna pam yr ydym ni'n gweithio'n agos iawn gyda'n cyd-Weinidogion yn Llywodraeth yr Alban, roeddem ni'n arch-noddwr i ddarparu'r croeso hwnnw, y gefnogaeth gofleidiol honno. Mae hynny'n cynnwys y gefnogaeth sydd, yn amlwg, yn hollbwysig, wrth asesu anghenion iechyd, anghenion addysgol y plant, ac rwyf wedi siarad am y gallu i gael budd-daliadau a hefyd sgiliau a swyddi. Felly, rydych chi'n gwybod, drwy ein gwefan a thrwy ein gwaith, fod gennym gyngor gyrfaoedd, hyfforddiant a chymorth cyflogaeth personol am ddim gan Cymru'n Gweithio ar gyfer pob—wrth gwrs, maen nhw'n dod i bob canolfan groeso, felly mae pobl yn cael eu hannog a'u cefnogi i mewn i fyd gwaith.

Mae llawer o'n gwesteion Wcreinaidd wedi symud ymlaen yn annibynnol, ond mae pwysau gwirioneddol o ran faint o dai sydd ar gael, o ran y cyfle i symud ymlaen hwnnw. Felly, rydym ni eisiau osgoi unrhyw fygythiad o ddigartrefedd—rydym ni eisiau osgoi hynny. Gwyddom fod pob gwestai Wcreinaidd sy'n dod drwy'r llwybr uwch-noddwr, neu, yn wir, y rhai sy'n lletya ac yn cefnogi, a chyllid—ariannu Cyfiawnder Tai Cymru, Asylum Justice Cymru, Cyngor Ffoaduriaid Cymru a'r Groes Goch Brydeinig i sicrhau eu bod nhw i gyd yn cymryd rhan i gefnogi'r ffoaduriaid sydd naill ai gyda'r rhai sy'n lletya neu yn ein canolfannau croeso.

Yr hyn y byddwn i'n ei ddweud yw diolch am eich cydnabyddiaeth bod angen i ni gael ymateb gan Lywodraeth y DU, nid yn unig o ran y £350, a chynyddu hwnnw ar gyfer y rhai sy'n lletya, ond hefyd y ffaith ein bod ni wedi galw arnyn nhw i roi mwy o gymorth ar gyfer taliadau disgresiwn at gostau tai ac am lwfansau tai lleol, fel bod awdurdodau lleol yn gallu defnyddio'u disgresiwn i helpu pobl i symud ymlaen i'r sector rhentu preifat. Yn wir, fel yr wyf wedi sôn, mae'r llythyr hwn gan elusennau ffoaduriaid yn Lloegr, mewn gwirionedd yn dweud eu bod yn helpu teuluoedd sy'n ffoaduriaid i ddod o hyd i gartrefi—dyma'r llythyr at Brif Weinidog y DU—cynllun rhentu ar gyfer ffoaduriaid sy'n cyrraedd drwy gynllun sy'n cael ei gefnogi gan y Llywodraeth. Wrth gwrs, mae awdurdodau lleol yn defnyddio eu disgresiwn, eu pwerau, er mwyn ceisio helpu pobl i gael llety hirdymor.

17:05

Good afternoon, Minister. On Thursday last week, I was actually on a stall with the Brecon, Hay and Talgarth refugee support group, and I met a refugee there, a young woman, who has three children, the youngest of whom was actually born in a bomb shelter in Kyiv. She's an amazingly entrepreneurial person and is trying to set up a business making jewellery. But she wanted me to pass on her thanks and her family's thanks to the Welsh Government for all of the support that they've received. 320

One of the issues raised by the group is around access to dental care for refugees. Many arrive needing support and then their host families find out that they actually need dental care. I know one family who've had to pay around £2,000 for the refugee from Ukraine who was staying with them, so I just wonder, Minister, if you could just let us know what your understanding is of the situation with regard to the health authorities responding to requests for dental check-ups and dental care for refugees, not just those from Ukraine. Thank you so much.321

Prynhawn da, Gweinidog. Dydd Iau yr wythnos diwethaf, roeddwn i mewn gwirionedd ar stondin gyda grŵp cefnogi ffoaduriaid Aberhonddu, Y Gelli a Thalgarth, ac fe gwrddais â ffoadur yno, merch ifanc, sydd â thri o blant, yr ieuengaf ohonyn nhw wedi'i eni mewn lloches fomiau yn Kyiv. Mae hi'n unigolyn entrepreneuraidd dros ben ac yn ceisio sefydlu busnes yn gwneud gemwaith. Ond roedd hi eisiau i mi gyfleu ei diolch a diolch ei theulu i Lywodraeth Cymru am yr holl gefnogaeth y maen nhw wedi ei chael. 

Mae un o'r materion a godir gan y grŵp yn ymwneud â mynediad at ofal deintyddol i ffoaduriaid. Mae llawer o'r rhai sy'n cyrraedd angen cymorth ac yna mae'r teuluoedd sy'n cynnig llety iddyn nhw yn canfod eu bod angen gofal deintyddol mewn gwirionedd. Rwy'n adnabod un teulu sydd wedi gorfod talu tua £2,000 ar ran y ffoadur o Wcráin oedd yn aros gyda nhw, felly tybed, Gweinidog, a wnewch chi roi gwybod i ni beth yw eich dealltwriaeth chi o'r sefyllfa o ran yr awdurdodau iechyd yn ymateb i geisiadau am archwiliadau deintyddol a gofal deintyddol i ffoaduriaid, nid dim ond y rhai o Wcráin. Diolch yn fawr iawn.

Thank you very much, Jane Dodds. Also, it's really good to hear of the progress of that refugee you met at the stall so recently, and what she's come from—giving birth in a bomb shelter in Kyiv—just shows how important it is that we continue with our support as a supersponsor and as a nation of sanctuary. And so many of us across this Chamber have met people who have had the same experience, and also who want to get on and set up businesses, get into work, be independent, become citizens of Wales. Many wouldn't have imagined that they were going to come and stay as long as they have; they would have hoped that the war would be over and that they would be back with their loved ones. We must think, always, of the fact that their loved ones are back, so many of them are back in Ukraine, fighting, defending their country. But we must make sure that we give them the support that they need to set up in business, to get housing, to help make their contribution, which is part of what I'm saying in my statement, but also get the UK Government to play their part. This is not just an issue for Wales, this is an issue not just for the UK—it's the whole European humanitarian response that has been so important.322

Just in terms of access to dental services, obviously we need to make sure that those who are with hosts—. Perhaps again, it's so much up to the host to access the information. We are funding organisations to support hosts, which I think is very important, so that they can look to the information they can get so that they—. Hosts shouldn't, themselves, have to be paying for that kind of access to services, and we need to make sure that they know where to go, and signpost them. So, it is advisable for Ukrainians to register with a dentist as soon as possible, but there may not be a dental practice opening capacity for accepting new NHS patients. But the local health board has got that list of practices, and also, if it's a dental emergency, then NHS Direct Wales should facilitate access to community dental services. So, if I can just say that today and put it on the record: NHS 111 for the local health board to get a list of NHS practices and 0845 46 47 for NHS Direct Wales, leading them to a community dental service.323

Diolch yn fawr, Jane Dodds. Hefyd, mae'n dda iawn clywed am gynnydd y ffoadures honno y gwnaethoch chi ei chyfarfod ar y stondin mor ddiweddar, a'r hyn a fu ei phrofiad—rhoi genedigaeth mewn lloches fomiau yn Kyiv—sy'n pwysleisio pa mor bwysig yw hi ein bod ni'n parhau gyda'n cefnogaeth fel uwch-noddwr ac fel cenedl noddfa. Ac mae cymaint ohonom ar draws y Siambr hon wedi cwrdd â phobl sydd wedi cael yr un profiad, a hefyd sydd eisiau bwrw ymlaen a sefydlu busnesau, mynd i mewn i waith, bod yn annibynnol, dod yn ddinasyddion Cymru. Ni fyddai llawer wedi dychmygu eu bod nhw'n mynd i aros cyhyd; bydden nhw wedi gobeithio y byddai'r rhyfel drosodd ac y bydden nhw'n ôl gyda'u hanwyliaid. Mae'n rhaid i ni ystyried, bob amser, y ffaith bod eu hanwyliaid yn ôl, mae llawer ohonyn nhw yn ôl yn Wcráin, yn ymladd, yn amddiffyn eu gwlad. Ond mae'n rhaid i ni wneud yn siŵr ein bod ni'n rhoi'r gefnogaeth sydd ei hangen arnyn nhw i sefydlu busnes, i gael tai, i helpu i wneud eu cyfraniad, sy'n rhan o'r hyn yr wyf yn ei ddweud yn fy natganiad, ond hefyd cael Llywodraeth y DU i chwarae ei rhan. Nid mater i Gymru yn unig yw hwn, nid mater i'r DU yn unig—mae'n ymwneud â'r ymateb dyngarol Ewropeaidd cyfan sydd wedi bod mor bwysig.

Ond o ran mynediad at wasanaethau deintyddol, yn amlwg mae angen i ni sicrhau bod y rhai sydd gyda rhai sy'n lletya—. Efallai eto, mai cyfrifoldeb y rhai sy'n lletya yw cael yr wybodaeth. Rydym ni'n ariannu sefydliadau i gefnogi'r rhai sy'n lletya, sy'n bwysig iawn yn fy marn i, fel eu bod nhw'n gallu edrych ar yr wybodaeth y maen nhw'n ei chael fel eu bod nhw—. Ni ddylai'r rhai sy'n lletya eu hunain dalu am y math yna o wasanaethau, ac mae angen i ni sicrhau eu bod yn gwybod lle i fynd, a'u cyfeirio nhw. Felly, fe fyddai'n ddoeth i Wcreiniaid gofrestru gyda deintydd cyn gynted â phosibl, ond efallai na fydd practis deintyddol yn cynyddu capasiti er mwyn derbyn cleifion newydd y GIG. Ond mae'r bwrdd iechyd lleol wedi cael y rhestr honno o feddygfeydd, a hefyd, os yw'n argyfwng deintyddol, yna dylai Galw Iechyd Cymru hwyluso mynediad at wasanaethau deintyddol cymunedol. Felly, os caf i ddweud hynny heddiw a'i roi ar gofnod: GIG 111 ar gyfer y bwrdd iechyd lleol er mwyn cael rhestr o feddygfeydd y GIG a 0845 46 47 ar gyfer Galw Iechyd Cymru, i'w cyfeirio nhw at wasanaeth deintyddol cymunedol.

17:10
7. Datganiad gan y Dirprwy Weinidog Newid Hinsawdd: Cau Pont Menai
7. Statement by the Deputy Minister for Climate Change: Closure of the Menai Bridge

Yr eitem nesaf felly yw'r datganiad gan y Diprwy Weinidog Newid Hinsawdd ar gau Pont Menai, a dwi'n galw ar y Gweinidog i wneud y datganiad hynny—Lee Waters. 325

The next item is a statement by the Deputy Minister for Climate Change on the closure of the Menai Bridge, and I call on the Deputy Minister to make the statement—Lee Waters. 

Diolch yn fawr iawn, Llywydd, and thank you for the opportunity to provide Members with an update on the Menai bridge. As Members will know, at 2 p.m. on Friday 21 October, the Welsh Government made the decision to close the Menai bridge to all traffic with immediate effect. The decision was not made lightly; it was made on safety grounds after clear advice from structural engineers and conversations with the police.326

The Menai bridge is managed by a private company, UK Highways A55 Ltd, as part of a private finance initiative so-called design-build-finance-operate contract, or DBFO, for the A55 on Ynys Môn and the Menai loop. As part of their maintenance responsibility, UK Highways have been carrying out inspections on the bridge. They do this to an industry standard at two and six-year intervals. The general inspections every two years are visual inspections where all parts of the structure are examined, typically using binoculars or aerial drone surveys. The principal inspection occurs every six years, and involves close examination of all inspectable parts of the bridge within touching distance. The in-depth survey includes visual inspections, as well as specialist techniques such as hammer tap surveys of concrete, or corrosion measurement.327

As part of the last principal inspection in 2019, a concern about the resilience of hangers that support the suspension bridge were identified, and led to a weight restriction being imposed on the bridge while further studies were carried out. The latest inspection was reported to the Welsh Government last Wednesday, and it unexpectedly highlighted an immediate concern around the brittle failure mechanism of the hangers. As is standard practice, officials reviewed and challenged the findings. However, based on very clear advice from structural engineers, it was considered that there was no other option but to close the bridge while further checks on the analysis are undertaken by an independent consultant.328

As I say, this was not a decision that was taken lightly, and I fully appreciate the implications that this has for local people, especially without any advanced warnings. We did initially plan a communications campaign in advance to give people warning, but on further conversations with the police and based on the advice, we decided that it was prudent to close the bridge with immediate effect. The safety of our network and the travelling public is paramount, and the decision has been based upon the safety recommendations from numerous structural engineers, amongst the best in the world. The findings that led to the recommendation to close the bridge are currently being reviewed, as is standard. The initial review will take up to two weeks. Officials, along with stakeholders, are assessing all available options to reopen the bridge as soon as possible. Temporary hanger-strengthening works may need to be installed to ensure the safety and integrity of the Menai bridge, and this programme could take between 14 and 16 weeks, with the bridge reopening to vehicles up to 7.5 tonnes, again in early 2023. 329

Now, I am acutely aware of the inconvenience that this is causing. Clearly, the Menai bridge is a vital link for the people of north Wales and beyond, and I’d like to thank local people for their patience and understanding whilst this urgent work takes place. And I want to reassure them that the Welsh Government is working with UK Highways and all stakeholders, including emergency services, to ensure that this can be done as quickly and safely as possible. All vehicular traffic is now being diverted to the Britannia bridge, and Welsh Government officials are urgently working on further contingency plans in the area, and will continue to monitor the congestion to inform future changes. They are also developing further strategies to increase resilience on the Britannia bridge to mitigate the risk of both bridges being closed in exceptional circumstances.330

I can confirm that, following discussions with UK Highways and their structural experts, it's been agreed that the footway across the bridge can be reopened for pedestrians and dismounted cyclists. Pedestrians must remain on the footways, and numbers will be limited, with monitoring taking place. Officials are working with UK Highways to help limit the impact on emergency services and allow their vehicles, which weigh less than 7.5 tonnes, across the Menai bridge, if the A55 Britannia bridge is closed. This will be subject to the emergency services meeting certain criteria and the traffic management, put in place by UK Highways, is safe to allow this to happen.331

The effects of the closure are in their infancy. Officials are already considering the impacts and will continue to monitor the road network to see what can be done to ease congestion further. I'll be providing further updates as things progress, and I would like to invite the local Members to a technical briefing with Welsh Government officials, so they can ask detailed questions of their own to satisfy themselves of the decision making and the next steps. I'd encourage local people to visit the Welsh Government and Traffic Wales websites and social media channels to keep up to date with the latest information. Once again, I'm extremely grateful to everyone this will affect. We'll do everything within our power to reopen the bridge as soon as it is safe to do so. Diolch.332

Diolch yn fawr iawn, Llywydd, a diolch i chi am y cyfle i roi diweddariad i'r Aelodau ar bont Menai. Fel y bydd Aelodau yn gwybod, am 2 p.m. ddydd Gwener 21 Hydref, penderfynodd Llywodraeth Cymru gau pont Menai i'r holl draffig ar unwaith. Ni wnaed y penderfyniad ar chwarae bach; cafodd ei wneud ar sail diogelwch ar ôl cyngor clir gan beirianwyr strwythurol a sgyrsiau gyda'r heddlu.

Mae pont Menai yn cael ei rheoli gan gwmni preifat, UK Highways A55 Ltd, fel rhan o fenter cyllid preifat sy’n cael ei alw yn gontract dylunio-adeiladu-ariannu-gweithredu, neu DBFO, ar gyfer yr A55 ar Ynys Môn a dolen Menai. Fel rhan o'u cyfrifoldeb cynnal a chadw, mae UK Highways wedi bod yn cynnal archwiliadau ar y bont. Maen nhw'n gwneud hyn i safon diwydiant bob dwy a chwe blynedd. Mae'r archwiliadau cyffredinol bob dwy flynedd yn archwiliadau gweledol lle archwilir pob rhan o'r strwythur, gan ddefnyddio binocwlars neu arolygon drôn o'r awyr fel arfer. Mae'r prif archwiliad yn digwydd bob chwe blynedd, ac mae'n cynnwys archwilio'r holl rannau y gellir eu harolygu o'r bont sydd o fewn pellter cyffwrdd. Mae'r arolwg manwl yn cynnwys archwiliadau gweledol, yn ogystal â thechnegau arbenigol megis arolygon tapio gyda morthwyl ar goncrit, neu fesur rhwd.

Fel rhan o'r prif arolygiad diwethaf yn 2019, nodwyd pryder am gadernid hongwyr sy'n cefnogi'r bont grog, ac arweiniodd at gyfyngiad pwysau yn cael ei osod ar y bont tra bod astudiaethau pellach yn cael eu cynnal. Adroddwyd yr arolygiad diweddaraf i Lywodraeth Cymru ddydd Mercher diwethaf, ac yn annisgwyl fe dynnodd sylw at bryder ar unwaith ynghylch mecanwaith methiant bregus yr hongwyr. Fel sy'n arfer safonol, fe wnaeth swyddogion adolygu’r canfyddiadau a’u herio. Fodd bynnag, yn seiliedig ar gyngor clir iawn gan beirianwyr strwythurol, ystyriwyd nad oedd opsiwn arall ond cau'r bont tra bod gwiriadau pellach ar y dadansoddiad yn cael eu cynnal gan ymgynghorydd annibynnol.

Fel rydw i’n ei ddweud, nid yw hyn yn benderfyniad a wnaed ar chwarae bach, ac rwy'n llwyr werthfawrogi goblygiadau i bobl leol, yn enwedig heb unrhyw rybuddion ymlaen llaw. Yn wreiddiol, fe wnaethom gynllunio ymgyrch gyfathrebu o flaen llaw i roi rhybudd i bobl, ond yn dilyn sgyrsiau pellach gyda'r heddlu ac yn seiliedig ar y cyngor, fe wnaethom ni benderfynu ei bod hi'n ddoeth cau'r bont ar unwaith. Mae diogelwch ein rhwydwaith a'r cyhoedd sy'n teithio yn hollbwysig, ac mae'r penderfyniad wedi bod yn seiliedig ar yr argymhellion diogelwch gan nifer o beirianwyr strwythurol, ymhlith y gorau yn y byd. Mae'r canfyddiadau a arweiniodd at yr argymhelliad i gau'r bont yn cael eu hadolygu ar hyn o bryd, fel sy'n safonol. Bydd yr adolygiad cychwynnol yn cymryd hyd at bythefnos. Mae swyddogion, ynghyd â rhanddeiliaid, yn asesu'r holl opsiynau sydd ar gael i ailagor y bont cyn gynted â phosib. Efallai y bydd angen gosod gwaith i gryfhau'r hongwyr dros dro er mwyn sicrhau diogelwch ac uniondeb pont Menai, a gallai'r rhaglen hon gymryd rhwng 14 ac 16 wythnos, gyda'r bont yn ailagor i gerbydau hyd at 7.5 tunnell, eto ar ddechrau 2023.

Nawr, rwy'n ymwybodol iawn o'r anghyfleustra mae hyn yn ei achosi. Yn amlwg, mae pont Menai yn gyswllt hanfodol i bobl y gogledd a thu hwnt, a hoffwn ddiolch i bobl leol am eu hamynedd a'u dealltwriaeth tra bod y gwaith brys hwn yn digwydd. Ac rwyf i am eu sicrhau bod Llywodraeth Cymru yn gweithio gyda UK Highways a'r holl randdeiliaid, gan gynnwys y gwasanaethau brys, i sicrhau y gellir gwneud hyn mor gyflym a diogel â phosibl. Mae'r holl draffig cerbydau bellach yn cael ei ddargyfeirio i bont Britannia, ac mae swyddogion Llywodraeth Cymru wrthi'n gweithio ar frys ar gynlluniau wrth gefn pellach yn yr ardal, a byddant yn parhau i fonitro'r tagfeydd i lywio newidiadau yn y dyfodol. Maen nhw hefyd yn datblygu strategaethau pellach i gynyddu cadernid ar bont Britannia i liniaru'r risg y bydd y ddwy bont yn cau mewn amgylchiadau eithriadol.

Gallaf gadarnhau, yn dilyn trafodaethau gyda UK Highways a'u harbenigwyr strwythurol, cytunwyd bod modd ailagor y llwybr troed ar draws y bont ar gyfer cerddwyr a beicwyr oddi ar eu beiciau. Rhaid i gerddwyr aros ar y llwybr troed, a bydd y niferoedd yn gyfyngedig, a monitro'n digwydd. Mae swyddogion yn gweithio gyda UK Highways i helpu i gyfyngu’r effaith ar y gwasanaethau brys ac i ganiatáu eu cerbydau, sy'n pwyso llai na 7.5 tunnell, ar draws pont Menai, os bydd A55 pont Britannia yn cau. Bydd hyn yn amodol ar y gwasanaethau brys yn bodloni meini prawf penodol a’r rheolaeth traffig, sy’n cael ei roi ar waith gan UK Highways, ei bod hi’n ddiogel i ganiatáu i hyn ddigwydd.

Mae effeithiau'r cau yn newydd iawn. Mae swyddogion eisoes yn ystyried yr effeithiau a byddant yn parhau i fonitro'r rhwydwaith ffyrdd i weld beth y gellir ei wneud er mwyn lleddfu tagfeydd ymhellach. Byddaf yn rhoi diweddariadau pellach wrth i bethau fynd yn eu blaen, a hoffwn wahodd yr Aelodau lleol i sesiwn friffio technegol gyda swyddogion Llywodraeth Cymru, fel y gallant ofyn eu cwestiynau manwl eu hunain i fodloni eu hunain gyda’r penderfyniadau a'r camau nesaf. Byddwn i'n annog pobl leol i ymweld â gwefannau Llywodraeth Cymru a Traffig Cymru a sianeli cyfryngau cymdeithasol i gael y wybodaeth ddiweddaraf. Unwaith eto, rwy'n hynod ddiolchgar i bawb fydd yn cael eu heffeithio gan hyn. Byddwn yn gwneud popeth o fewn ein gallu i ailagor y bont cyn gynted ag y bydd yn ddiogel i wneud hynny. Diolch.

17:15

Deputy Minister, the scenes we've been seeing play out in Anglesey over the last few days are completely unacceptable and, dare I say it, avoidable. I must say, from the moment the bridge suddenly closed late on Friday afternoon, there has been complete chaos in the area, with drivers, pedestrians and cyclists left stranded. My inbox has been inundated with messages over it, and I'm based in south-east Wales. Closing the bridge at the last minute without prior warning for what could be potentially four months will not only hit residents, visitors and commuters, but also hard-working businesses in the area. Of course, Deputy Minister, safety is paramount—I'm not going to deny it for a single second—but how on earth are we only now aware of structural weaknesses here today? A 200-year-old bridge, which is used by nearly 50,000 vehicles every day, should be regularly inspected, not every six years. If this problem had been picked up sooner, advance warning could have been given and the people of Anglesey would have been able to make alternative arrangements. Motorists are now expected to use the Britannia bridge while the Menai is closed. This is simply not going to work, Deputy Minister, especially now as we're heading into winter, when the Britannia bridge is regularly closed due to high winds. What happens if the Britannia bridge is forced to close while the Menai is closed? Some of my colleagues here, and my honourable colleague Virginia Crosbie in Westminster, have indeed been getting attacks on social media by your Labour Party over this sorry saga. The Labour Party, which clearly doesn't have true understanding of the situation, has been claiming this is a UK Government problem, because it involves a company called UK Highways A55 Limited—[Interruption.]333

Dirprwy Weinidog, mae'r golygfeydd rydyn ni wedi bod yn eu gweld yn digwydd yn Ynys Môn dros y dyddiau diwethaf yn gwbl annerbyniol ac, os caf fentro dweud, y gellid bod wedi eu hosgoi. Mae'n rhaid i mi ddweud, o'r eiliad y caeodd y bont yn sydyn yn hwyr brynhawn Gwener, mae anhrefn llwyr wedi bod yn yr ardal, gyda gyrwyr, cerddwyr a seiclwyr wedi'u gadael yn sownd. Mae fy mewnflwch wedi bod yn llawn negeseuon, ac rydw i wedi fy lleoli yn y de-ddwyrain. Bydd cau'r bont ar y funud olaf heb rybudd ymlaen llaw am yr hyn a allai fod yn bedwar mis nid yn unig yn taro trigolion, ymwelwyr a chymudwyr, ond hefyd busnesau gweithgar yn yr ardal. Wrth gwrs, Dirprwy Weinidog, mae diogelwch yn hollbwysig—dydw i ddim yn mynd i'w wadu am un eiliad—ond sut ar y ddaear ydyn ni ond bellach yn ymwybodol o wendidau strwythurol yma heddiw? Dylai pont 200 mlwydd oed, sy'n cael ei defnyddio gan bron i 50,000 o gerbydau bob dydd, gael ei harchwilio'n rheolaidd, nid bob chwe blynedd. Pe bai'r broblem hon wedi cael ei chodi ynghynt, gellid bod wedi rhoi rhybudd o flaen llaw a byddai pobl Ynys Môn wedi gallu gwneud trefniadau amgen. Bellach mae disgwyl i fodurwyr ddefnyddio pont Britannia tra bod Pont Menai ar gau. Yn syml, nid yw hyn yn mynd i weithio, Dirprwy Weinidog, yn enwedig nawr wrth i ni fynd i'r gaeaf, pan fydd pont Britannia ar gau yn rheolaidd oherwydd gwyntoedd cryfion. Beth sy'n digwydd os bydd pont Britannia yn gorfod cau tra bod Pont Menai ar gau? Mae rhai o fy nghydweithwyr yma, a fy nghydweithiwr anrhydeddus Virginia Crosbie yn San Steffan, wedi bod yn cael ymosodiadau ar y cyfryngau cymdeithasol gan eich Plaid Lafur chi dros y saga wael hon. Mae'r Blaid Lafur, sy'n amlwg heb wir ddealltwriaeth o'r sefyllfa, wedi bod yn honni bod hyn yn broblem i Lywodraeth y DU, oherwydd ei fod yn cynnwys cwmni o'r enw UK Highways A55 Limited—[Torri ar draws.]

This is a statement, Janet Finch-Saunders. [Interruption.] How long have you been here, Janet?334

Datganiad yw hwn, Janet Finch-Saunders. [Torri ar draws.] Ers pryd ydych chi wedi bod yma, Janet?

I am pleased you have laid these wrong claims to rest—[Interruption.] I am pleased that you have laid these wrong claims to rest by confirming UK Highways A55 Limited is a private company, and responsibility lies with your Government, not Westminster. However, you should have made this abundantly clear from the outset, because it's led to a lot of confusion with the public, politicians and your own party. Let me be clear from the outset: I firmly believe that this fiasco further highlights the Welsh Government's neglect of north Wales and shows there is still a major divide between the north and the south. It's vital the Menai bridge, which is a vital artery, is reopened as soon as possible, and your Government must do all it can to make sure situations like this are avoided in the future. Will you now commit that, going forward, the Menai bridge will be inspected regularly and thoroughly to nip any future problems in the bud? Because the people and businesses of Anglesey deserve better than this, Deputy Minister.336

Rwy'n falch eich bod chi wedi rhoi diwedd ar yr honiadau anghywir hyn—[Torri ar draws.] Rwy'n falch eich bod chi wedi rhoi diwedd ar yr honiadau anghywir hyn trwy gadarnhau bod UK Highways A55 Limited yn gwmni preifat, a bod y cyfrifoldeb yn nwylo eich Llywodraeth chi, nid San Steffan. Fodd bynnag, dylech chi fod wedi gwneud hyn yn gwbl glir o'r cychwyn cyntaf, oherwydd mae wedi arwain at lawer o ddryswch gyda'r cyhoedd, gwleidyddion a'ch plaid chi eich hun. Gadewch i mi fod yn glir o'r cychwyn cyntaf: rwy'n credu'n gryf fod y ffiasgo hwn yn amlygu esgeulustod Llywodraeth Cymru o'r gogledd ymhellach ac yn dangos bod rhaniad mawr yn dal i fodoli rhwng y gogledd a'r de. Mae'n hanfodol ailagor pont Menai, sydd yn wythïen hanfodol, cyn gynted â phosibl, a rhaid i'ch Llywodraeth wneud popeth o fewn ei gallu i sicrhau bod sefyllfaoedd fel hyn yn cael eu hosgoi yn y dyfodol. A fyddwch chi'n ymrwymo nawr, wrth symud ymlaen, y bydd pont Menai yn cael ei harchwilio'n rheolaidd ac yn drylwyr fynd i'r afael ag unrhyw broblemau yn y dyfodol cyn iddyn nhw waethygu? Oherwydd mae pobl a busnesau Ynys Môn yn haeddu gwell na hyn, Dirprwy Weinidog.

Well, as tempting as it is, Llywydd, to engage in that contribution in the same tone as it was offered, I shall not do that. I think that was a very poorly judged intervention on what is a very serious subject.337

There are regular inspections of the bridge to industry standard, far higher than to the normal highway network, which is a risk-based approach. Inspections of the bridge are not risk-based, they are regularly held, and I mentioned the process for that, and it's through that regular inspection that the initial problem was highlighted. Ongoing monitoring work has been going on since then, and it's that ongoing monitoring that has highlighted the potential for further failure, which led us to take immediate action. And as I explained, we could have waited till the end of the weekend and given advance notice that the bridge would be closing on Monday, but, on reflection, we thought that would be imprudent; had something happened, that would have been unforgivable. And given the weight of the advice we were getting from the structural engineers, it was clearly the right thing to do to act immediately, in the full knowledge this would cause distress and inconvenience, which we deeply regret, but we felt this was the responsible thing to do. And if the Member has time to reread the statement I gave, I believe it fairly answers the questions that have been raised, and I regret the way in which she has made her intervention today.338

Wel, er ei fod yn gymaint o demtasiwn, Llywydd, i ymgysylltu â'r cyfraniad hwnnw yn yr un cywair ag y'i cynigiwyd, dydw i ddim am wneud hynny. Rwy'n credu bod hwnnw'n ymyrraeth annoeth iawn ar yr hyn sy'n bwnc difrifol iawn.

Mae archwiliadau rheolaidd o'r bont i safon y diwydiant, sy'n llawer uwch nag i'r rhwydwaith priffyrdd arferol, sy'n ddull sy'n seiliedig ar risg. Nid yw archwiliadau o'r bont yn seiliedig ar risg, maen nhw'n cael eu cynnal yn rheolaidd, ac fe wnes i sôn am y broses ar gyfer hynny, a thrwy'r archwiliad rheolaidd hwnnw y tynnwyd sylw at y broblem gychwynnol. Mae gwaith monitro parhaus wedi bod yn digwydd ers hynny, a'r monitro parhaus hwnnw sydd wedi amlygu'r potensial am fethiant pellach, a'n harweiniodd ni i weithredu ar unwaith. Ac fel yr eglurais, gallem fod wedi aros tan ddiwedd y penwythnos a rhoi rhybudd ymlaen llaw y byddai'r bont yn cau ddydd Llun, ond, wrth fyfyrio, roedden ni'n meddwl y byddai hynny'n anymarferol; petai rhywbeth wedi digwydd, byddai hynny wedi bod yn anfaddeuol. Ac o ystyried pwysau'r cyngor yr oeddem ni'n ei gael gan y peirianwyr strwythurol, roedd yn amlwg mai'r peth iawn i'w wneud oedd gweithredu ar unwaith, gan wybod yn iawn y byddai hyn yn achosi gofid ac anghyfleustra, yr ydym ni'n gresynu'n arw yn ei gylch, ond roeddem ni'n teimlo mai dyma'r peth cyfrifol i'w wneud. Ac os oes gan yr Aelod amser i ailddarllen y datganiad a roddais, rwy'n credu ei fod yn ateb yn deg y cwestiynau sydd wedi eu codi, ac rwy'n gresynu'r ffordd y mae wedi gwneud ei hymyrraeth heddiw.

17:20

Diolch am y datganiad. Mae'n rhaid dweud wrth y Gweinidog: mae hyn yn llawer mwy nag anghyfleustra, ac mae'n rhaid i mi ddweud hefyd fod y sefyllfa'n llawer mwy difrifol nag yr oedd llefarydd y Ceidwadwyr wedi'i drin o. Dwi'n meddwl bod yna dri chwestiwn sylfaenol yn codi rŵan. Yn gyntaf, y flaenoriaeth: beth ydy'r camau sy'n cael eu cymryd i ymateb i hyn, cadw traffig i lifo, lliniaru risgiau? Yn ail, cyflwr y bont: sut adawyd i hyn ddigwydd yn y lle cyntaf? Sut mae dod o hyd i'r ffordd gyntaf i ailagor yn ddiogel? Ac yn drydydd, beth fydd yr ymateb er mwyn sicrhau gwytnwch yn yr hir dymor?339

O ran yr ymateb rŵan, te, mae yna gymaint o haenau i hyn: sicrhau does dim rhwystrau i gerbydau brys; sut i gael staff allweddol i'w gwaith—staff Ysbyty Gwynedd yn arbennig, ond llawer mwy na hynny—sut i gael pobl allan o'u ceir—mwy o drenau'n stopio mewn mwy o orsafoedd, mwy o fysus, annog mwy o ddefnydd o park and rides, bysus gwennol ac ati. A fydd y llwybr cerdded ar agor drwy'r cyfnod yma? Dydy hynny dal ddim yn hollol glir. Oes modd defnyddio'r llwybr wrth ymyl y rheilffordd ar ddec isaf pont Britannia i ryw bwrpas? Mae hynny'n rywbeth dwi wedi'i godi o'r blaen. 340

Mae yna bwysau ar wasanaethau iechyd. Pa gamau fydd yna i wella darpariaeth ar yr ynys yn Ysbyty Penrhos Stanley, er enghraifft? Beth am gynlluniau i leihau'r angen i gau pont Britannia mewn gwynt, a'r cynlluniau brys wedyn, parcio loris ac ati, os oes rhaid cau? Beth am gynlluniau i liniaru ym mhorthladd Caergybi? Fel dwi'n dweud, mae yna gymaint o elfennau i hyn—gormod o restr yn fanna i ddisgwyl ymateb ar bob un ohonyn nhw gan y Gweinidog—ond does yna brin ddim mesurau cadarn wedi cael eu hamlinellu hyd yma. Mae'n rhaid inni glywed am fesurau pendant ar frys. A hefyd, os caf i ddweud, mi fydd angen buddsoddiad. Felly, a allwn ni gael ymrwymiad o adnoddau ychwanegol i'r cyngor sir, fydd yn gorfod delifro sawl elfen o'r mesurau yma?341

Gadewch i ni ddod at yr ail elfen, te: sut ddigwyddodd hyn? Rydyn ni wedi cael disgrifiad o'r rhaglen archwilio ac ati a wnaeth arwain at y datganiad ddydd Gwener, ond mae yna gwestiynau'n parhau i fi. Sut mae pethau wedi gallu gwaethygu mor gyflym, yn cyrraedd pwynt mor gritigol, mae'n ymddangos, mewn cyfnod mor fyr? Mae'n lot o waith edrych ar ôl pont o'r math yma—yn sicr dyw e ddim mor hawdd ag roedd Lewis Carroll yn ei awgrymu yn Through the Looking-Glass:342

Thank you for the statement. I have to tell the Minister that this is far more than an inconvenience, and I also have to say that the situation is far more serious than the way the Conservative spokesperson dealt with it. I think there are three fundamental questions. First of all, the priority: what steps are being taken to respond to this, to keep traffic flowing, to mitigate risk? Secondly, the state of the bridge: how was this allowed to happen in the first instance? How can we find the best way to reopen safely? And thirdly, what will the response be in order to ensure long-term resilience?

In terms of the response now, there are so many layers to this: ensuring that there are no barriers to emergency vehicles; how to get key workers to work—Ysbyty Gwynedd staff particularly, but far more than that—how to get people out of their cars—more trains stopping in more stations, more buses, encouraging more use of park and rides, shuttle buses and so on. Will the walkway be open throughout this period? That's not entirely clear. Can the path near the railway line on the Britannia bridge be used for some purpose? That's something I've raised in the past.

There is pressure on health services. What steps will be taken to improve provision on the island at Penrhos Stanley Hospital, for example? What about plans to reduce the need to close Britannia bridge in high winds, and the emergency plans, lorry parks and so on if closure is necessary? What about plans for mitigation in the port of Holyhead? As I said, there are so many elements to this—too long a list to expect a response on all of them from the Minister—but there are hardly any robust measures set out to date. We must hear about those measures as a matter of urgency. And also, if I may say, we will need investment. So, can we have a commitment of additional resources to the local authority, who will have to deliver many elements of this? 

Let's return to the second element: how did this happen? We've had a description of the inspection programme that led to Friday's statement, but there are still questions for me. How could things have deteriorated so quickly, getting to such a critical point, it would appear, in such a brief period of time? It's a lot of work to look after a bridge of this kind—it's certainly not as easy as Lewis Carroll suggested in Through the Looking-Glass:

'I had just / Completed my design / To keep the Menai bridge from rust / By boiling it in wine.'343

'Roeddwn i newydd / gwblhau fy nyluniad / i gadw Pont Menai rhag rhwd / Trwy ei berwi mewn gwin.'

Nid felly mae gwneud. Ond a oedd y gwaith cynnal a chadw, y gwaith paentio ac amddiffyn, wedi bod yn ddigon da? Yn sicr, dwi wedi bod yn gweld rhwd. Mwy nag arfer? Dwn i ddim; dwi ddim yn beiriannydd. Ond oedd Llywodraeth Cymru'n monitro'n ddigon da'r modd yr oedd UK Highways yn gwneud eu gwaith? Ac ai gwaith UK Highways oedd adnabod problemau'n gynnar—preventative maintenance schedule—neu ymateb i broblemau wrth iddyn nhw godi? Buaswn i'n mawr obeithio mai bod yn rhagweithiol oedd gofynion y cytundeb. 344

Mae'n rhaid rhoi diogelwch yn gyntaf, wrth gwrs, ond hefyd mae angen asesu'n drylwyr ai cau oedd yr unig opsiwn. Oes modd symud yn gynt, yn ddiogel—hynny ydy, i ailagor? Ydw i'n iawn i ddeall mai asesu bydd yn digwydd am y tri neu bedwar mis nesaf, ac y gallai gwaith trwsio gymryd mwy na hynny?345

A gadewch i mi droi at y pwynt olaf. Dwi ac eraill wedi rhybuddio'n hir am hyn. Rydyn ni angen croesiad newydd. Mi oedd Llywodraeth Cymru wedi addo croesiad, a dydy o dal ddim wedi digwydd. Mae yna bris i'w dalu am oedi—pris mewn punnoedd, pan fo chwyddiant mor fawr ag ydy o rŵan, ond pris cymunedol hefyd. Y ffaith bod cynllun Wylfa wedi dod i stop sy'n cael y bai yn aml, ond gadewch inni fod yn glir: nid ymateb i broblem traffig ydy'r angen am groesiad dual carriageway lle mae'r Britannia. Ydy, mae hi'n boen aros mewn ciw i groesi, ond, mewn difrif, gwytnwch—resilience—sydd dan sylw yn fan hyn. Dau groesiad sydd yna, ac mae un ohonyn nhw'n bont grog 200 mlwydd oed.346

Mi fu ond y dim i mi gael cytundeb Llywodraeth Cymru rai blynyddoedd yn ôl i gael system tair lôn, system peak flow, ond bod peirianwyr y Llywodraeth wedi penderfynu yn y pen draw bod y bont yn rhy gul i hynny, yn enwedig o ystyried bod traffig yn ymuno efo pont Britannia ar gyflymder uchel. Efallai fod modd edrych ar weithredu rhywbeth felly dros dro rŵan. Ond y gwir amdani ydy bod angen ateb parhaol, gwydn. Un peth ydy bod yn ynys, peth arall ydy cael ein hynysu, a dyna'r realiti sydd wedi cael ei amlygu rŵan. Dwi'n edrych ymlaen at ymrwymiad o'r newydd i ailgydio, ar frys, yn y gwaith o ddatblygu croesiad newydd. 347

That's not how you do it. But was the maintenance done, the painting and so on, robust enough? Certainly, I've seen rust. More than usual? I don't know; I'm not an engineer. But was the Welsh Government sufficiently monitoring how UK Highways was carrying out its work? And is it the job of UK Highways to identify problems earlier—a preventative maintenance schedule—or to respond to problems as they arose? I would very much hope that the requirements of the contract required proactivity.

We must put safety first, of course, but we also need a thorough assessment as to whether closure was the only option. Could we move more quickly, safely, to reopen? Am I right in understanding that it's assessment that will happen over the next three or four months, and that the maintenance work could take longer than that? 

Let's turn to the final point. I and others have warned on this for a long time. We need a new crossing. The Welsh Government had pledged to deliver a new crossing, and it still hasn't happened. There's a price to pay for delay—a price in pounds, when inflation is so high, but also a community price too. The fact that the Wylfa programme came to an end is often blamed, but let's be clear: it wasn't a response to a traffic problem; that's not why we need a dual carriageway where the Britannia bridge is. Yes, it's annoying to wait in a queue to cross, but, in reality, it is resilience that we're talking about here. There are two crossings, and one of them is a 200-year-old suspension bridge.

I almost got the Welsh Government's agreement to get a three-lane peak-flow system, but Government engineers ultimately decided that the bridge was too narrow for that, particularly given that traffic joins the Britannia bridge at a high speed. Perhaps we could look at implementing something like that on a temporarily basis now. But the reality is that we need a permanent solution, a resilient solution. It's one thing to be an island, it's another thing to be isolated, and that is the reality that's been highlighted now. I look forward to hearing a renewed commitment to restart, as a matter of urgency, the work of developing a new crossing. 

17:25

Well, I'd like to thank the Member for the way in which he has engaged with this issue, and I understand his concerns, and those questions are fair. I will try and answer some of them now. I will write to him with those I haven't answered, and, as I say, we will set up a meeting for him and others to speak with the Welsh Government chief engineer to talk through the detailed questions and concerns he has.348

I think the overall questions, 'Was enough done?' 'Are there lessons learned?', are fair questions, and those are questions we're asking ourselves, and we shall be reviewing what has happened to get us to this stage. I think it's fair to say that our officials were surprised when we had the report last Wednesday that urgent work needed to be done. I was told about it Wednesday and initially told that it is not unusual for concerns to be raised, but the process is to challenge and to test them, given the consequences of closing, to make sure we were absolutely certain. I was then told on Thursday, having had further testing and further conversations—. As I say, the firm of engineers who've been doing this work are world-renowned for this work. They also work on the Clifton suspension bridge, so are familiar with the type of engineering involved. And given that their advice was so clear, it was felt that this had to be done right away, but it wasn't something we anticipated. So, obviously, something had changed since the previous inspection to require this work. But, in a sense, the system worked. The system is one of checks—regular checks, follow-up work, analysis—and that's what happened. It was first identified as a problem in 2019, there was a restriction on heavy vehicles crossing, further follow-up and testing work was done, and that has resulted in today's decision and discussion. So, in a sense, the safety measures we had in place have proven effective.349

The risk of a catastrophic event happening to the bridge is still low, but it is too high for us to be able to risk it. And as the Member rightly pointed out, this is a very old bridge. Some 40 of the hangers were replaced in 1990s, but there are over 200 remaining that are much older, and a much older technology. And that also creates a degree of uncertainty, because the newer technology is able to be tested and able to be monitored in a far more reliable way. There's a degree of uncertainty that we have with the much older hangers. That is one of the reasons why we've been cautious in making the decisions that we have. It's possible that the checks that will happen over the next two weeks will find that this has been an overreaction and that we'll be able to open the bridge, with a weight restriction, much, much sooner. My officials advise me that they think that's unlikely, but it is certainly a possibility, and we won't keep this closed any longer than we feel is justified by the balance of risks.350

To try and answer some of the questions about the traffic flowing, well, there are plans being developed with the local authority and with UK Highways to monitor that and to put in place any mitigation measures, and I'm happy to give you more detail of those. In terms, then, of the contingencies for what should happen if both bridges are closed—. And just some reassurance on this—this has tended to happen something like no more than twice a year. So, it's a rare event and, when it happens, it generally happens for a matter of hours. It clearly causes huge disruption, and I'm not minimising it; I'm just putting it into context of how often. I think it's closed 10 times since 1987, the Britannia bridge.351

Now, as it happens, there are high winds predicted for tomorrow, so it allows us to immediately put in place plans to inform drivers of the conditions and to urge those with vulnerable vehicles, like caravans and motorbikes, not to travel while those high-wind conditions are in place, and those that do so do so at their own risk. The officials are working with the north Wales trunk road agency on a new high-winds strategy for the A55 Britannia bridge to review wind gusts against the speed of vehicles, and the option to reduce the speed limit to 30 mph could assist with allowing the most vulnerable vehicles to cross at high-wind gusts. There are also contingency plans being drafted, and initial options in this plan would include the options to increase park-and-ride facilities, create potential stacking site options, and review the rail use to and from the island. So, there is a lot of thought, as you might imagine, going into looking at a whole range of possibilities, given the importance of this link.352

In terms of the long-term resilience of the bridge, as Rhun ap Iorwerth mentioned, work has been going on to look into a third crossing. That has now gone through WelTAG stage 2. It would cost somewhere in the order of £400 million. That's the current estimate. So, it's a significant decision to make and investment to make. As you know, it's been reviewed as part of the roads review panel, along with all other schemes in Wales, and we'll also be asking the Burns review in north Wales to look at what contingencies could be put in place in the short term. Even were we to start to build it now, the process takes somewhere around seven years. These things are expensive and slow. So, we will be asking Burns to address the issue of resilience in the longer term, and that report will be available next year.353

So, I think, as I've set out, we're doing some short-term things. If that inspection in two weeks' time shows that the decision was the right one, then some detailed modelling will be done by an entirely separate firm, who also are highly experienced in these structures, to make sure that it is independent, and then further modelling will be done. So, we will make sure that we do this right and we will make sure that we do it with safety in mind, and we will do all we can in the meantime to help the people of Ynys Môn and beyond who are inconvenienced by the congestion this causes at peak times.354

Wel, hoffwn ddiolch i'r Aelod am y ffordd mae wedi ymgysylltu â'r mater hwn, ac rwy'n deall ei bryderon, ac mae'r cwestiynau hynny'n deg. Fe wnaf i geisio ateb rhai ohonyn nhw nawr. Byddaf yn ysgrifennu ato gyda'r rhai nad wyf wedi eu hateb, ac fel y dywedais i, byddwn yn sefydlu cyfarfod iddo ef ac eraill siarad â phrif beiriannydd Llywodraeth Cymru i siarad drwy'r cwestiynau a'r pryderon manwl sydd ganddo.

Rwy'n credu bod y cwestiynau cyffredinol, 'A gafodd digon ei wneud?' 'Oes yna wersi wedi eu dysgu?', yn gwestiynau teg, ac mae'r rheiny'n gwestiynau rydyn ni'n eu gofyn i ni'n hunain, a byddwn ni'n adolygu'r hyn sydd wedi digwydd i'n cael ni i'r cam hwn. Rwy'n credu ei bod hi’n deg dweud bod ein swyddogion wedi synnu pan gawsom yr adroddiad ddydd Mercher diwethaf bod angen gwneud gwaith brys. Cefais wybod amdano ddydd Mercher a chefais wybod i ddechrau nad yw'n anarferol i bryderon gael eu codi, ond y broses yw eu herio a'u profi, o ystyried canlyniadau cau, i wneud yn siŵr ein bod ni’n gwbl sicr. Cefais wybod wedyn ddydd Iau, ar ôl cael profion pellach a sgyrsiau pellach—. Fel y dywedais i, mae’r cwmni o beirianwyr sydd wedi bod yn gwneud y gwaith hwn yn fyd-enwog am y gwaith hwn. Maen nhw hefyd yn gweithio ar bont grog Clifton, felly maen nhw'n gyfarwydd â'r math o beirianneg dan sylw. Ac o ystyried bod eu cyngor mor glir, teimlwyd bod yn rhaid gwneud hyn yn syth, ond nid oedd yn rhywbeth yr oeddem ni wedi’i ragweld. Felly, yn amlwg, roedd rhywbeth wedi newid ers yr archwiliad blaenorol i fod angen y gwaith hwn. Ond, ar un ystyr, roedd y system yn gweithio. Mae'r system yn un sy’n cynnwys gwiriadau—gwiriadau rheolaidd, gwaith dilynol, dadansoddiad—a dyna ddigwyddodd. Cafodd ei nodi am y tro cyntaf fel problem yn 2019, roedd cyfyngiad ar gerbydau trwm yn croesi, gwnaed gwaith dilynol a phrofi pellach, ac mae hynny wedi arwain at benderfyniad a thrafodaeth heddiw. Felly, ar un ystyr, mae'r mesurau diogelwch a oedd gennym ni ar waith wedi profi eu bod yn effeithiol.

Mae'r risg o ddigwyddiad trychinebus yn digwydd i'r bont yn dal i fod yn isel, ond mae'n rhy uchel i ni allu mentro. Ac fel y nododd yr Aelod yn gywir, mae hon yn bont hen iawn. Gosodwyd tua 40 o hongwyr newydd yn lle hen rai yn yr 1990au, ond mae dros 200 yn weddill sy'n llawer hŷn, a thechnoleg llawer hŷn. Ac mae hynny hefyd yn creu rhywfaint o ansicrwydd, oherwydd mae'r dechnoleg fwy newydd yn gallu cael ei phrofi ac yn gallu cael ei monitro mewn ffordd llawer mwy dibynadwy. Mae gennym ni rywfaint o ansicrwydd gyda'r hongwyr llawer hŷn. Dyna un o'r rhesymau pam rydyn ni wedi bod yn ofalus wrth wneud y penderfyniadau rydym ni wedi’u gwneud. Mae'n bosib y bydd y gwiriadau fydd yn digwydd dros y pythefnos nesaf yn canfod ein bod ni wedi gorymateb ac y byddwn ni’n gallu agor y bont, gyda chyfyngiad pwysau, llawer, llawer cynt. Mae fy swyddogion yn fy nghynghori eu bod nhw’n credu bod hynny'n annhebygol, ond mae'n sicr yn bosibilrwydd, ac ni fyddwn ni’n cadw hon ar gau yn hirach nag yr ydym ni’n credu sydd wedi ei gyfiawnhau drwy bwyso a mesur risgiau.

Er mwyn ceisio ateb rhai o'r cwestiynau am lif y traffig, wel, mae cynlluniau yn cael eu datblygu gyda'r awdurdod lleol a gyda UK Highways i fonitro hynny ac i roi unrhyw fesurau lliniaru ar waith, ac rwy'n hapus i roi mwy o fanylion i chi am y rheini. O ran, wedyn, y cynlluniau wrth gefn o ran beth ddylai ddigwydd os yw'r ddwy bont ar gau—. A dim ond rhywfaint o sicrwydd ar hyn—mae hyn wedi tueddu i ddigwydd rhywbeth fel dim mwy na dwywaith y flwyddyn. Felly, mae'n ddigwyddiad prin, a phan mae'n digwydd, mae'n digwydd yn gyffredinol am fater o oriau. Mae'n amlwg yn achosi aflonyddwch enfawr, ac nid wyf i'n ei leihau; rydw i yn ei roi mewn cyd-destun o ran pa mor aml. Rydw i’n meddwl ei bod wedi'i chau 10 gwaith ers 1987, pont Britannia.

Nawr, fel mae'n digwydd, mae yna wyntoedd cryfion yn cael eu rhagweld ar gyfer yfory, felly mae'n caniatáu i ni roi cynlluniau ar waith ar unwaith i hysbysu gyrwyr o'r amodau ac annog y rhai sydd â cherbydau agored i niwed, fel carafanau a beiciau modur, i beidio â theithio tra bod yr amodau gwynt uchel hynny’n mynd rhagddynt, ac mae'r rhai sy'n gwneud hynny yn gwneud hynny ar eu risg eu hunain. Mae'r swyddogion yn gweithio gydag asiantaeth cefnffyrdd y gogledd ar strategaeth wyntoedd uchel newydd ar gyfer yr A55 Britannia i adolygu hyrddiadau gwynt yn erbyn cyflymder cerbydau, a gallai'r opsiwn i leihau'r terfyn cyflymder i 30 mya gynorthwyo gyda chaniatáu i'r cerbydau mwyaf agored i niwed groesi pan fydd hyrddiadau gwynt uchel. Mae cynlluniau wrth gefn hefyd yn cael eu drafftio, a byddai opsiynau cychwynnol yn y cynllun hwn yn cynnwys yr opsiynau i gynyddu cyfleusterau parcio a theithio, creu opsiynau safle pentyrru posibl, ac adolygu'r defnydd o'r rheilffyrdd i'r ynys ac oddi yno. Felly, mae llawer o feddwl, fel y gallech chi ddychmygu, yn mynd i edrych ar ystod gyfan o bosibiliadau, o ystyried pwysigrwydd y ddolen hon.

O ran cadernid y bont yn yr hirdymor, fel soniodd Rhun ap Iorwerth, mae gwaith wedi bod yn mynd ymlaen i edrych ar drydydd croesiad. Mae hynny bellach wedi mynd trwy gam 2 WelTAG. Byddai'n costio rhywle yn agos i £400 miliwn. Dyna'r amcangyfrif presennol. Felly, mae'n benderfyniad sylweddol i'w wneud a buddsoddiad i'w wneud. Fel y gwyddoch chi, mae wedi cael ei adolygu fel rhan o'r panel adolygu ffyrdd, ynghyd â'r holl gynlluniau eraill yng Nghymru, a byddwn ni hefyd yn gofyn i adolygiad Burns yn y gogledd edrych ar ba gynlluniau wrth gefn y gellid eu rhoi ar waith yn y tymor byr. Hyd yn oed pe byddem ni’n ddechrau ei hadeiladu nawr, mae'r broses yn cymryd tua saith mlynedd. Mae'r pethau yma'n ddrud ac yn araf. Felly, byddwn ni’n gofyn i Burns fynd i'r afael â'r broblem o ran cadernid yn y tymor hwy, a bydd yr adroddiad hwnnw ar gael y flwyddyn nesaf.

Felly, rwy'n credu, fel rydw i wedi’i nodi, rydyn ni’n gwneud rhai pethau tymor byr. Os yw'r archwiliad hwnnw ymhen pythefnos yn dangos mai'r penderfyniad oedd yr un cywir, yna bydd rhywfaint o fodelu manwl yn cael ei wneud gan gwmni cwbl ar wahân, sydd hefyd yn brofiadol iawn yn y strwythurau hyn, i wneud yn siŵr ei fod yn annibynnol, ac yna bydd modelu pellach yn cael ei wneud. Felly, byddwn ni’n sicrhau ein bod ni’n gwneud hyn yn iawn a byddwn ni’n sicrhau ein bod ni’n ei wneud gyda diogelwch mewn golwg, a byddwn ni’n gwneud popeth o fewn ein gallu yn y cyfamser i helpu pobl Ynys Môn a thu hwnt sy'n profi anghyfleustra oherwydd y tagfeydd mae hyn yn ei achosi ar adegau prysur.

17:30

I've got a few suggestions as well from residents. Some of them have probably already been covered, if that's okay. As I said before, Britannia is a permanent bottleneck and there are two carriageways on the bridge, but there's also space for another lane, which has been discussed in the past and was raised earlier. So, would the Minister request an urgent re-evaluation of the third central lane across the Britannia bridge, with traffic management to suit the direction of flow at peak times?355

And also, as was mentioned as well, there's a lower deck on the Britannia bridge, and I know cyclists have been asking for a long time if that could be reopened again as a cycle route. That could happen now. The railway is fenced off, so that could really happen now, if there were cameras there. That could be an option. They've also suggested maybe minibuses for staff and more frequent trains to be timetabled, but they do know that's quite difficult as well, to fit that in. 356

Safety is paramount, so thank you to the engineers for spotting this. It is really inconvenient, but we appreciate that it is checked regularly.357

And could I also ask you for an update on the A494 River Dee crossing? I know, quite a few years ago, there was possibly an issue there about it deteriorating, and it might have to go to one carriageway. This is all part of the same route in and out of Wales. So, could you give me an update on that, please, as well? Thank you.358

Mae gen i ambell i awgrym hefyd gan drigolion. Mae'n debyg bod rhai ohonyn nhw eisoes wedi cael sylw, os yw hynny'n iawn. Fel y dywedais i o'r blaen, mae Britannia yn dagfa barhaol ac mae'n ffordd ddeuol ar y bont, ond mae lle hefyd i lôn arall, sydd wedi cael ei thrafod yn y gorffennol ac a godwyd yn gynharach. Felly, a fyddai'r Gweinidog yn gofyn am ail-werthuso'r drydedd lôn ganolog ar frys ar draws pont Britannia, gyda rheolaeth traffig yn gweddu i gyfeiriad y llif ar yr adegau prysuraf?

A hefyd, fel y soniwyd hefyd, mae dec is ar bont Britannia, ac rwy'n gwybod bod beicwyr wedi bod yn gofyn ers talwm os byddai modd ailagor hwnnw eto fel llwybr beicio. Gallai hynny ddigwydd nawr. Mae'r rheilffordd wedi'i ffensio, felly gallai hynny ddigwydd mewn gwirionedd nawr, pe bai camerâu yno. Gallai hynny fod yn opsiwn. Maen nhw hefyd wedi awgrymu efallai bod bysiau mini i staff a threnau amlach yn cael eu hamserlennu, ond maen nhw'n gwybod ei bod hi'n eithaf anodd hefyd, i ffitio hynny i mewn. 

Mae diogelwch yn hollbwysig, felly diolch i'r peirianwyr am sylwi ar hyn. Mae'n anghyfleus iawn, ond rydym ni'n gwerthfawrogi ei fod yn cael ei wirio'n rheolaidd.

Ac allai ofyn i chi hefyd am y diweddaraf am groesfan Afon Dyfrdwy yr A494? Rwy'n gwybod, dipyn o flynyddoedd yn ôl, roedd problem yno o bosib ynglŷn â dirywio, ac efallai y byddai'n rhaid iddo fynd yn un lôn. Mae hyn i gyd yn rhan o'r un llwybr i mewn ac allan o Gymru. Felly, allech chi roi diweddariad i mi ar hynny, os gwelwch yn dda, hefyd? Diolch.

Certainly. In terms of the points the Member made about alternative suggestions, that is something that the Britannia bridge contingency plans—which I mentioned and which I've currently been drafting, looking at options—would look at, to look at the whole range of things that we could do. In terms of cycling access, one of the things that's being looked at now as part of this two-week review is whether or not the restriction on cyclists having to dismount and push their bicycles across the bridge is proportional, and whether or not cyclists will be able to cross. That's being tested, as well as, as I said, the access for emergency vehicles going slowly over the bridge when the Britannia bridge isn't available.359

In terms of the Dee bridge, which is obviously a separate point and we shouldn't link them as they are different issues, but as you've asked for clarification, I am happy to confirm that a preferred option of a new river crossing for westbound traffic and the partial reuse of the existing bridge for eastbound traffic has been identified. Draft orders are planned for this winter, with a public inquiry pencilled in for next summer, and, providing all that is approved, construction could begin in 2024. Those plans are not subject to the roads review, because they were already under way, and those are in train.360

Yn sicr. O ran y pwyntiau a wnaeth yr Aelod am awgrymiadau amgen, mae hynny'n rhywbeth y byddai cynlluniau wrth gefn pont Britannia—y soniais amdano ac yr wyf wedi bod yn eu drafftio, gan edrych ar opsiynau—yn edrych arno, i edrych ar yr holl ystod o bethau y gallem ni eu gwneud. O ran mynediad seiclo, un o'r pethau sy'n cael ei edrych arno nawr fel rhan o'r adolygiad pythefnos hwn yw p'un a yw'r cyfyngiad ar feicwyr yn gorfod dod oddi ar eu beiciau a'u gwthio nhw ar draws y bont yn gymesur ai peidio, ac a fydd beicwyr yn gallu croesi ai peidio. Mae hynny'n cael ei brofi, yn ogystal â, fel y dywedais i, y mynediad i gerbydau brys yn mynd yn araf dros y bont pan nad yw pont Britannia ar gael.

O ran pont Dyfrdwy, sy'n amlwg yn bwynt ar wahân ac ni ddylem eu cysylltu gan eu bod nhw'n faterion gwahanol, ond gan eich bod chi wedi gofyn am eglurhad, rwy'n hapus i gadarnhau bod opsiwn sy'n cael ei ffafrio o groesfan afon newydd ar gyfer traffig tua'r gorllewin ac ailddefnyddio'r bont bresennol yn rhannol ar gyfer traffig tua'r dwyrain wedi'i nodi. Mae gorchmynion drafft wedi'u cynllunio ar gyfer y gaeaf hwn, gydag ymchwiliad cyhoeddus wedi'i nodi ar gyfer yr haf nesaf, a, gan dybio y bydd y cyfan yn cael ei gymeradwyo, gallai'r gwaith adeiladu ddechrau yn 2024. Nid yw'r cynlluniau hynny'n destun yr adolygiad ffyrdd, oherwydd eu bod eisoes ar y gweill, ac mae'r rheiny wedi dechrau.

Diolch, Llywydd. As you'll be aware, I did submit an emergency question on this issue, but clearly withdrew it as this statement was announced, and I'm grateful to the Welsh Government and the Deputy Minister for bringing forward today's statement. It's appreciated. I'm also grateful, Deputy Minister, that you made it clear in your statement as to the decision making around the closure of the Menai bridge and understanding who is responsible for what within that. As has already been mentioned here today, the immediate closure of the Menai bridge, which sees thousands of vehicles crossing per day, is really concerning, and I appreciate, Deputy Minister, your acknowledgement of the importance of this crossing to the island and to the mainland equally.361

I'll just raise a couple of points, Llywydd. I appreciate that time is very short, but you've already mentioned, Deputy Minister, the point around the contingency plans when high winds are likely to close Britannia bridge. I would ask that you share those contingency plans, if they're not already shared, as quickly as possible, so that businesses and locals know how that will work. I think that's a very important point.362

Secondly, looking at the longer term, the programme of work is going to take around 16 weeks to complete, and then only looking to reopen for vehicles up to 7.5 tonnes. I would be interested to know when you envisage vehicles heavier than 7.5 tonnes being able to cross the Menai bridge in the future, to create that wider capacity that's needed to cross on and off the island.363

And then thirdly, Deputy Minister, you alluded to this, and it was mentioned in the statement, the fact that this problem was highlighted initially in 2019, so clearly there has been a pattern of concern over a series of years and months. It's still not clear to me why, even though there has been a pattern of concern over a long time—we're looking at three years plus here—there was an immediate and sudden decision that had to be made without warning for locals and for businesses alike. So, I'd appreciate perhaps a bit more clarity as to why that pattern of concern wasn't properly considered.364

And very finally, Llywydd, just really a plea for regular and quality communication, please, to local residents and businesses in the area. Diolch yn fawr iawn.365

Diolch, Llywydd. Fel y gwyddoch chi, fe wnes i gyflwyno cwestiwn brys ar y mater hwn, ond yn amlwg fe wnes i ei dynnu'n ôl wrth i'r datganiad hwn gael ei gyhoeddi, ac rwy'n ddiolchgar i Lywodraeth Cymru a'r Dirprwy Weinidog am gyflwyno'r datganiad heddiw. Mae'n cael ei werthfawrogi. Rydw i hefyd yn ddiolchgar, Dirprwy Weinidog, eich bod chi wedi ei gwneud yn glir yn eich datganiad ynglŷn â'r penderfyniadau ynghylch cau pont Menai a deall pwy sy'n gyfrifol am beth o fewn hynny. Fel sydd eisoes wedi ei grybwyll yma heddiw, mae cau pont Menai yn syth, sy'n gweld miloedd o gerbydau yn croesi bob dydd, yn peri pryder gwirioneddol, ac rwy'n gwerthfawrogi, Dirprwy Weinidog, eich cydnabyddiaeth o bwysigrwydd y croesiad hwn i'r ynys ac i'r tir mawr fel ei gilydd.

Rydw i am godi cwpwl o bwyntiau, Llywydd. Rwy'n gwerthfawrogi bod amser yn fyr iawn, ond rydych chi eisoes wedi sôn, Dirprwy Weinidog, am y pwynt ynghylch y cynlluniau wrth gefn pan fydd gwyntoedd cryfion yn debygol o gau pont Britannia. Byddwn yn gofyn i chi rannu'r cynlluniau wrth gefn hynny, os nad ydyn nhw eisoes wedi cael eu rhannu, cyn gynted â phosib, fel bod busnesau a phobl leol yn gwybod sut y bydd hynny'n gweithio. Rwy'n credu bod hynny'n bwynt pwysig iawn.

Yn ail, o edrych ar y tymor hwy, mae'r rhaglen waith yn mynd i gymryd tua 16 wythnos i'w chwblhau, ac yna dim ond yn edrych i ailagor ar gyfer cerbydau hyd at 7.5 tunnell. Byddai'n ddiddorol cael gwybod pryd rydych chi'n rhagweld cerbydau trymach na 7.5 tunnell yn gallu croesi pont Menai yn y dyfodol, er mwyn creu'r capasiti ehangach yna sydd angen i groesi i'r ynys ac oddi arni.

Ac yna'n drydydd, Dirprwy Weinidog, fe wnaethoch chi gyfeirio at hyn, a soniwyd amdano yn y datganiad, y ffaith i'r broblem hon gael ei hamlygu i ddechrau yn 2019, felly mae'n amlwg bod patrwm o bryder wedi bod dros gyfres o flynyddoedd a misoedd. Dydy hi dal ddim yn glir i mi pam, er bod patrwm o bryder wedi bod dros amser hir—rydyn ni'n edrych ar dair blynedd a mwy yma—bod penderfyniad uniongyrchol a sydyn y bu'n rhaid ei wneud heb rybudd i bobl leol ac i fusnesau fel ei gilydd. Felly, byddwn i'n gwerthfawrogi efallai ychydig mwy o eglurder pam nad chafodd y patrwm hwnnw o bryder ei ystyried yn iawn.

Ac yn olaf, Llywydd, dim ond apêl ar gyfer cyfathrebu rheolaidd ac o safon, os gwelwch yn dda, i drigolion a busnesau lleol yn yr ardal. Diolch yn fawr iawn.

17:35

Thank you. Well, certainly, on your last point, I'd appreciate the help of all Members to make sure that we're able to communicate these messages with honesty and subtlety to constituents. There has been a somewhat hysterical tone amongst some political parties over the weekend to try to create some point-scoring, which I think is deeply inappropriate and doesn't help people to understand the nature of the problems that we are dealing with. So, I hope we won't see any more of that, and I'd be very happy to engage with all Members who are interested in a full and frank conversation about what's happening and the options as we go through them. This is something where party politics should have no place, in my view.366

In terms of the contingency plans, I'm happy to set them out for you by letter, but they are as they already stand: to warn and inform drivers of our advisory restrictions when they are required. As I said, they are required infrequently and, generally, for relatively short periods of time. And, as I said, we are working on a new contingency strategy to look at other options, which I'll keep Members fully updated about.367

In terms of when the bridge is likely to reopen without restrictions, well, I think that really does depend on the analysis of the state of the hangers. It's not for me to second guess the results of the engineering report, but in the event that all or many of the hangers need to be replaced, then clearly that's going to be a considerable piece of work. The 7.5 tonne restriction, I'd imagine, wouldn't be able to be lifted until the engineers were convinced that was safe. And given that there is concern about the brittle nature of the hangers, it would seem to me that it's premature to think about lifting restrictions altogether until that full assessment and work is carried out. 368

I think I've answered the question about the lack of warning and the state of the bridge. There have been regular inspections, and these are industry standards. This is not something peculiar to the Menai bridge; this is what happens with other similar bridges. It is a higher standard of inspection than normal roads, and as well as being of a greater frequency, the checks taking place within the process are to a much higher and more thorough level, and the checking involved within the different agencies responsible and the companies and, separate to them, independent peer reviews is quite considerable. That's one of the reasons why it has taken so long, since the identification of the first problem in 2019, because this is a very thorough and methodical approach, done at arm's length from each other to make sure that it is robust. So, I think it would be unfair to represent this as a slow response to evidence of concern. I think this has been a thorough and methodical approach, in line with industry standard around the world, and that is the process that has shown us that there are problems that justify closing the bridge, so I think we've acted prudently and responsibly. But as I said in answer to Rhun ap Iorwerth, we will of course be conducting a lessons-learned exercise, to see if any mistakes were made that would have prevented us from getting to this position today. But I'm not aware of any that have come to light so far.369

Diolch. Wel, yn sicr, ar eich pwynt olaf, byddwn i'n gwerthfawrogi help pob Aelod i wneud yn siŵr ein bod ni'n gallu cyfathrebu'r negeseuon hyn gyda gonestrwydd a chynildeb i etholwyr. Mae naws gwyllt braidd wedi bod ymysg rhai pleidiau gwleidyddol dros y penwythnos i geisio creu rhywfaint o sgorio pwyntiau, sydd, yn fy marn i, yn amhriodol iawn ac nid yw'n helpu pobl i ddeall natur y problemau yr ydym ni'n delio â nhw. Felly, rwy'n gobeithio na fyddwn ni'n gweld mwy o hynny, a byddwn i'n hapus iawn i ymgysylltu â'r holl Aelodau sydd â diddordeb mewn sgwrs lawn a gonest am yr hyn sy'n digwydd a'r opsiynau wrth i ni fynd drwyddyn nhw. Mae hyn yn rhywbeth lle na ddylai fod unrhyw le i wleidyddiaeth bleidiol, yn fy marn i.  

O ran y cynlluniau wrth gefn, rwy'n hapus i'w cyflwyno nhw i chi drwy lythyr, ond maen nhw fel maen nhw'n sefyll eisoes: rhybuddio a hysbysu gyrwyr o'n cyfyngiadau cynghori pan fydd eu hangen. Fel y dywedais i, anaml mae eu hangen nhw a hynny, yn gyffredinol, am gyfnodau cymharol fyr. Ac, fel y dywedais i, rydym ni'n gweithio ar strategaeth wrth gefn newydd i edrych ar opsiynau eraill, a byddaf yn sicrhau bod yr Aelodau yn cael y wybodaeth ddiweddaraf amdanyn nhw.

O ran pryd mae'r bont yn debygol o ailagor heb gyfyngiadau, wel, rwy'n credu bod hynny wir yn dibynnu ar y dadansoddiad o gyflwr yr hongwyr. Nid fy lle i yw dyfalu canlyniadau'r adroddiad peirianyddol, ond pa bai angen disodli pob un neu lawer o'r hongwyr, yna'n amlwg mae hynny'n mynd i fod yn ddarn sylweddol o waith. Ni fyddai'r cyfyngiad 7.5 tunnell, byddwn i'n dychmygu, yn gallu cael ei godi nes bod y peirianwyr yn argyhoeddedig bod hynny'n ddiogel. Ac o ystyried bod pryder am natur bregus yr hongwyr, mae'n ymddangos i mi ei bod hi'n rhy gynnar i feddwl am godi cyfyngiadau yn gyfan gwbl nes bod yr asesiad llawn a'r gwaith hwnnw'n cael ei wneud. 

Rwy'n meddwl mod i wedi ateb y cwestiwn am y diffyg rhybudd a chyflwr y bont. Mae archwiliadau rheolaidd wedi bod, ac mae'r rhain yn cyd-fynd â safonau'r diwydiant. Nid yw hyn yn rhywbeth arbennig i bont Menai; dyma sy'n digwydd gyda phontydd eraill tebyg. Mae'n safon arolygu uwch na ffyrdd arferol, ac yn ogystal â bod yn amlach, mae'r gwiriadau sy'n digwydd o fewn y broses i lefel llawer uwch a mwy trylwyr, ac mae'r gwirio sy'n gysylltiedig â'r gwahanol asiantaethau sy'n gyfrifol a'r cwmnïau ac, ar wahân iddyn nhw, adolygiadau annibynnol gan gymheiriaid yn eithaf sylweddol. Dyna un o'r rhesymau pam ei bod wedi cymryd cyhyd, ers nodi'r broblem gyntaf yn 2019, oherwydd mae hwn yn ddull trylwyr a threfnus iawn, wedi'i wneud hyd braich oddi wrth ei gilydd i wneud yn siŵr ei fod yn gadarn. Felly, rwy'n credu y byddai'n annheg cynrychioli hyn fel ymateb araf i dystiolaeth o bryder. Rwy'n credu bod hwn wedi bod yn ddull trylwyr a threfnus, yn unol â safon y diwydiant ledled y byd, a dyna'r broses sydd wedi dangos i ni fod yna broblemau sy'n cyfiawnhau cau'r bont, felly rwy'n credu ein bod ni wedi gweithredu'n ddoeth ac yn gyfrifol. Ond fel y dywedais i mewn ateb i Rhun ap Iorwerth, byddwn ni wrth gwrs yn cynnal ymarfer dysgu gwersi, i weld a wnaed unrhyw gamgymeriadau a fyddai wedi ein hatal rhag cyrraedd y sefyllfa hon heddiw. Ond dydw i ddim yn ymwybodol o unrhyw un sydd wedi dod i'r amlwg hyd yn hyn.

17:40

Diolch am y datganiad a chyfle i drafod y mater pwysig yma. Fel rydych chi'n gwybod, dwi'n cynrychioli'r etholaeth ar y tir mawr sydd agosaf at bont Menai a phont Britannia. Mae hi'n ardal ddinesig brysur iawn, yn cynnwys busnesau a siopau, meysydd chwarae, parc busnes, gwesty, ysgolion a channoedd o dai, a hefyd, dyma lle mae Ysbyty Gwynedd. Fe gafwyd ciwiau o bron i dair awr jest i adael maes parcio'r ysbyty, a hyd yn oed cyn i'r ceir ymuno â'r ciw i groesi pont Britannia. Erbyn hyn, mae staff yr ysbyty sy'n byw ond ychydig filltiroedd i ffwrdd ar Ynys Môn yn wynebu dwy awr o siwrnai bob ffordd bob diwrnod, felly pa ystyriaeth ydych chi wedi ei rhoi i sefyllfa benodol Ysbyty Gwynedd o safbwynt y staff, y gwasanaeth ambiwlans, y rhai sy'n mynychu clinigau, a'r cleifion a'u teuluoedd?370

Dwi yn cytuno: mi oedd yn rhaid cau pont Menai am resymau diogelwch er gwaethaf yr hafoc mae hynny wedi ei greu. Dwi yn gallu gweld hynny. Mi fyddai unrhyw un synhwyrol yn gallu gweld hynny. Mi ddaeth y problemau diogelwch i sylw'r swyddogion ddydd Mercher diwethaf—dyna rydych chi'n ei ddweud yn eich datganiad. Mi fyddwn i yn tybio erbyn hyn fod yna ddigon o amser wedi pasio er mwyn cytuno o leiaf ar gynllun traffig amgen dros dro ar gyfer yr ardal. Pryd ydyn ni am weld y cynllun traffig amgen yma o ran y llif traffig, ac yn bwysicach, pryd ydyn ni'n mynd i weld hwnnw'n cael ei roi ar waith yn yr ardal?371

Yn amlwg, dydy’r sefyllfa fel y mae hi ar hyn o bryd, efo pobl yn cymryd dwy awr i gyrraedd Ysbyty Gwynedd o Ynys Môn, jest ddim yn gynaliadwy, felly mae'n rhaid dod â chynllun arall ymlaen i wella'r llif traffig yn yr ardal, a dwi eisiau gwybod pryd fydd hynny'n digwydd. Rydyn ni ar yr ochr yma o'r Siambr am weld datrysiadau ymarferol er budd pobl leol tra bod y bont yn cael ei diogelu, ac mae yna lot o etholwyr yn dod ymlaen efo syniadau sydd yn swnio’n synhwyrol i mi—rhai ymarferol am sut i wella'r llif traffig yn yr ardal. Ydych chi'n barod i wrando ar rai o'r syniadau rheini?372

Rydyn ni wedi rhannu ambell un yma y prynhawn yma. Mae Rhun ap Iorwerth a Carolyn Thomas wedi sôn am y syniad yma o greu tair lôn ar bont Britannia dros dro, efo dwy ar agor i gludo'r traffig i'r tir mawr yn y bore, a dwy i gludo traffig yn ôl i Fôn gyda'r nos—rhywbeth sydd yn swnio'n synhwyrol. Os nad ydy hynny'n bosib, oes modd cael esboniad, achos mae lot o bobl yn gofyn pan nad ydyn ni ddim yn gallu gwneud y math yna o beth? 373

Felly, fe fyddwn ni jest eisiau cael sicrwydd gennych chi eich bod chi yn barod i wrando ar syniadau fel hwnna. Mae yna rai eraill hefyd yn cael eu crybwyll o gwmpas gwneud rhywbeth yn wahanol o gwmpas rhai o'r rowndabowts yn yr ardal er mwyn gwella'r llif dros dro. Felly, gobeithio eich bod chi yn fodlon gwrando ar y syniadau yna ac yn gwerthfawrogi ein bod ni yn troi helpu i gael datrysiad sydd yn mynd i helpu pobl i gyrraedd i lle maen nhw'n trio mynd yn gynt nag y maen nhw ar hyn o bryd.374

Thank you for the statement and an opportunity to discuss this important issue. As you know, I represent the constituency on the mainland closest to the Menai bridge and the Britannia bridge. It’s a very busy civic area, including businesses and shops, playing fields, a business park, a hotel, schools and hundreds of homes, and also this is where Ysbyty Gwynedd is. We had queues of nearly three hours just to leave the car park at the hospital, even before the cars joined the queues to cross the Britannia bridge. By now, hospital staff who live only a few miles away on Anglesey face a two-hour journey in each direction every day. So, what consideration are you giving to the specific situation that Ysbyty Gwynedd faces, in terms of the staff, the ambulance service, those who attend the clinics, and the patients and their families?

I agree that the Menai bridge had to be closed for safety reasons, despite the havoc that that has caused. I can see that. And anybody sensible would be able to see that. The safety problems came to the attention of officials last Wednesday—that’s what you said in your statement. I would suspect that, by now, enough time has passed in order to at least agree an alternative traffic plan, a temporary plan, for the area. When can we see the alternative traffic plan in terms of traffic flow, and, more importantly, when are we going to see that being implemented in the area?

Evidently, the situation as it is at present, with people taking two hours to reach Ysbyty Gwynedd from Anglesey, is not sustainable, so we have to bring forward another plan in order to improve traffic flow in the area, and I want to know when that will happen. We, on this side of the Chamber, want to see practical solutions for the benefit of local people while the bridge is being secured, and many constituents are bringing ideas forward that sound very sensible to me—practical ideas about how to improve traffic flow in the area. Are you willing to listen to some of those ideas?

We’ve shared a few this afternoon. Rhun ap Iorwerth and Carolyn Thomas have talked about the idea of creating three lanes on the Britannia bridge temporarily, with two open for traffic to the mainland in the morning, and two lanes open in the other direction in the evening. That sounds very sensible. If that isn’t possible, can we have an explanation as to why, because many people are asking why we can’t do that kind of thing?

So, I would just like to have some assurance from you that you’re willing to listen to such ideas. There are other ideas that are being postulated as well, in terms of doing things differently around some of the roundabouts in the area in order to improve the traffic flow temporarily. So, I hope that you are willing to listen to those ideas and appreciate the fact that we are trying to obtain solutions that will help people to reach the places they’re trying to get to more quickly than they're able to at present.

Thank you again for the tone of that contribution, because I fully recognise that people are distressed and annoyed and concerned about the fallout from this decision. I'm particularly aware of the situation of the hospital. I think we've seen, obviously, because of the sudden nature of the announcement, and the inability for people to plan and think ahead, and I hope that will settle down as people realise that they need to allow longer to get to appointments and be able to plan far more. I guess in truth there are limits to what we can do within the confines of the options available to us.375

Certainly in terms of the Member's point about whether we are willing to listen to ideas the public have for improving traffic flow: of course we are. And certainly, as I said, I'll make our officials available to the local Members who wish to meet with them, and you can discuss and test some of the ideas, the practicality of them, with those engineering experts to see what can and cannot be done. But I certainly, as the Minister, am very open to looking at any option we possibly can to open this as quickly as possible when it is safe to do so and to try and mitigate the congestion that is inevitably caused by it, both now and in the future. So, you have my commitment to do that.376

In terms of when we'll have a final traffic plan finalised, 'I'm not certain' is the honest answer. It's something we're actively working on. We will be able to update you when you meet the officials, and I'll be able to give you more information as soon as I am able.377

Diolch eto am dôn y cyfraniad hwnnw, oherwydd rwy'n cydnabod yn llwyr fod pobl yn ofidus ac wedi cythruddo ac yn pryderu am ganlyniadau'r penderfyniad hwn. Rwy'n arbennig o ymwybodol o sefyllfa'r ysbyty. Rwy'n meddwl ein bod ni wedi gweld, yn amlwg, oherwydd natur sydyn y cyhoeddiad, a'r anallu i bobl gynllunio a meddwl ymlaen llaw, a gobeithio y bydd hynny'n setlo wrth i bobl sylweddoli bod angen iddyn nhw ganiatáu mwy o amser i gyrraedd apwyntiadau a gallu cynllunio llawer mwy. Rwy'n tybio mewn gwirionedd fod cyfyngiadau ar yr hyn y gallwn ni ei wneud o fewn cyfyngiadau'r opsiynau sydd ar gael i ni.

Yn sicr o ran pwynt yr Aelod a ydym ni'n fodlon gwrando ar syniadau gan y cyhoedd ar gyfer gwella llif y traffig: wrth gwrs ein bod ni. Ac yn sicr, fel y dywedais i, byddaf yn sicrhau bod ein swyddogion ar gael i'r Aelodau lleol sy'n dymuno cwrdd â nhw, a gallwch chi drafod a phrofi rhai o'r syniadau, ymarferoldeb y rhain, gyda'r arbenigwyr peirianneg hynny i weld beth y gellir ei wneud a beth na ellir ei wneud. Ond rwy'n sicr, fel y Gweinidog, yn agored iawn i edrych ar unrhyw opsiwn posibl i agor cyn gynted â phosibl pan fydd yn ddiogel i wneud hynny ac i geisio lliniaru'r tagfeydd sy'n anochel yn cael ei achosi ganddo, nawr ac yn y dyfodol. Felly, fe gewch chi fy ymrwymiad i wneud hynny.

O ran pryd y bydd gennym ni gynllun traffig terfynol wedi'i gwblhau, 'Dydw i ddim yn sicr' yw'r ateb gonest. Mae'n rhywbeth rydyn ni'n gweithio arno'n rhagweithiol. Byddwn yn gallu eich diweddaru pan fyddwch chi'n cwrdd â'r swyddogion, a byddaf yn gallu rhoi mwy o wybodaeth i chi cyn gynted ag y gallaf.

17:45

Diolch i'r Dirprwy Weinidog. Mae gweddill yr eitemau ar yr agenda wedi eu gohirio am y tro, ac felly dyna ddod â'n gwaith ni am heddiw i ben.378

I thank the Deputy Minister. The other items on the agenda have been postponed, so that brings our proceedings to a close.

Daeth y cyfarfod i ben am 17:46.

The meeting ended at 17:46.